Bio
I write Stirrup Queens when I'm not reading other people's blogs, cooking, or chasing after my twins. I'm the author of two books: Life from Scratch,...
 
 
 

 

 
 

Most Popular

My Son Bought Lunch at School, and I Cried

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

On Thursday morning, my son announces that he wants to buy lunch at school. They are serving pizza -- one of the 6 foods he currently eats -- which he claims "looked good" when he saw it on someone else's tray earlier this month. I suspect the real reason he wants to buy lunch has to do with the fact that his kindergarten teacher has a song she sings each morning for the lunch buyers that includes their name (it really is a catchy song -- I sing it all the time in the house) whereas she says the names of the lunch bringers. I am sure this is a matter of time constraints since there are more bringers than buyers, and the song is used to work teaching moments even into the mundane classroom business tasks, but the song has a strong pull. Most kids ask to buy at some point just to hear their name sung out to the class.

I could lie and say that I have nothing against school lunch, but I have a lot against school lunches, even though I remember the joy I felt the few times I bought lunch when I was little. I mean, come on, it's a rite of passage. Not just the eating the strange and plastic-y food stuffs (because you can get that at home with a bag of Doritos), but the standing in line, the smell, the pride in having your own money to spend. He wants to show me that he's responsible. That he can go to the kindergarteners' version of a restaurant, order his meal, and pay for it (with money I gave him) ... ALL BY HIMSELF.

I should want to encourage this because it certainly saves me time to not have to make food or pack the lunchbox or wash the reusable lunch equipment -- even if it's just for a day. It's a responsibility thing for him, but it's a break for me. A cheap break at that -- lunch only costs $2.50 per meal.

So those are the good parts about buying lunch -- responsibility for him, a break for me -- so why does his request to purchase lunch strike such fear in my heart?

When we were taking a tour of the school last year, we swung by the lunch room and the guide told us about the lunch routine. She started ticking off some of the things kids can buy and when she mentioned the pizza, she touched my arm with concern and said, "I don't want you to worry, but the cheese isn't real cheese. It isn't dairy."

I'm not sure why I would be worried about cheese being made from milk. Frankly, I was worried about why it wasn't made from milk. I inquired what the cheese was if not dairy, and she shrugged her shoulders and said, "I don't know." And while I was fairly calm over the idea of pizza, THAT was what freaked me out.

Because I think we've all seen enough of Jamie Oliver's tears to know that there is very little food in school lunches these days. There is food stuff. There are chemicals and strange preservatives. There are schools that have started making healthful choices, but even with those healthful choices, you simply can't provide meals to that many kids that match the quality of what can be made in small batches at home.

Canned or frozen vegetables are used because the school staff doesn't have time to individually shell peas. My pizza at home has homemade, high-protein dough, homemade tomato sauce, and real cheese. Their pizza at school comes shrink wrapped in plastic. And I can't expect more than that because it's a small staff who need to put out many meals. And they do it well and they do it within a small budget, they just can't compete with homemade food.

A friend who has a first grader was over this summer and she warned me about school lunches. "I ate there once," she said. "The menu said it was serving mac-n-cheese and green beans. Then the food came out on the tray. The mac-n-cheese was inexplicably smothered in an additional layer of sour cream and shredded cheese. The grey, canned green beans were covered by a pool of cream of mushroom soup and another layer of shredded cheese.

  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
nestbliss 5 pts

omgosh they let him take the choc milk ... oh it is so hard to send a new kindergartner to school all day!

saywithlove 5 pts

I work at the same elementary school that I went to as a child. They have some items that are great choices but some I wish they didn't have as options. Sure they still basically serve the same items but they do have better options like a salad plate. Despite whatever the main meals that are served the children always have the option for a salad meal. Sometimes it comes without meat (plain) but which is also sometimes served with grilled chicken, turkey, or ham. There is even a yogurt plate that includes yogurt, a cheese stick, and an orange. I love when I go through the line with the children and see them making good choices as their sides like fruits and vegetables. Some even get spinach!

I do wish that our school did not sell junk food though. They have cookies as a side option on some days and ice cream on Friday's. I think it's great when I see children bring their own lunches from home but a lot of what I see is a bunch of unhealthy lunches. Sometimes mom is too busy to pack their lunch so the child does it themselves and they bring a bag of hot cheetos and a coke. Sometimes parents are confused on nutrition. No joke I have a kindergarten child who every day brings their own lunch and it's pure junk food. A bag of cheeze-its, a snack cake, a banana, another type of sweet snack cake, a capri sun. We we need more education on a healthy nutrition going home to parents as well because not everyone who's sending lunches with their kids provides nutritional meals.

Momofacrew 5 pts

You could have written this post just for me...as I read your fears and thoughts, I nodded in agreement. Like your children also, one of my children has a gluten allergy, though it is not life threatening, it is an allergy that creates a complication.

Each, in their own time approached me to buy lunch and I was reluctant. And in time I learned to let go...easier the second time around with my non-allergy child. ;-)

Our school system allows me to see what they purchased, they know the rules, snacks are ONLY allowed on Friday...and only one of them. They are to purchase healthy options that include actual fruits and vegetables. Milk, only if it is skim, otherwise water. If there is something coming up on the menu that isn't a standard agreed upon option, we need to chat about it. If they violate these rules, they will have a time period where they cannot buy lunch. My oldest is a tween and came to me recently and stated he no longer wanted to buy, even if all of his friends do. Not because of the 'rules', etc, he just likes what I make better...upon hearing this, my younger child agreed. Music to my ears...so we allowed the buying w/rules that satisfied our belief structure, and eventually they outgrew the novelty. Maybe you will have the same experience once your twins age a little...good luck and thank you for the great posts!

CroMom 5 pts

There is a certain joy in buying your frozen cardboard pizza as a child. To this day I can still remember what our square pizzas looked like, and I didn't buy lunch much.
My husband now works in a school and we talked about lunches the other day. They always have a salad bar for the kids and he says he is always surprised by how many kids get salad for lunch. It is really a habit and what they enjoy to eat. Sure they have the occassionaly mac n cheese, pizza day, or whatever. I'd like to think that my 3 year old will take his own lunch from home with the occasional school lunch for a treat. I'm a firm believer that everything in moderation is ok.
For those who still have unhealthy lunch programs...start making noise! The more noise you make the quicker things will change. You'd be surprised how many parents are thinking the same thing as you.

Randa 5 pts

The system can change. The county that my mother is in was NOTHING like it is now. Less than five years ago, it was disgusting - she wouldn't even let me and my siblings eat there and she WORKED there. However, people complained and, eventually, the school board hired a new head nutritionist and she did a complete re-haul of the system. It's been tough - a lot of trial and error - but it's slowly becoming so much better. I don't know how big your county is but this county is comprised of six high schools, six middle schools, twenty elementary schools, and two or three "academies." The SES of this county is all over the board - one school is comprised of mostly high income families while another is Title I.

I was just pointing out about the ice cream because I'm in a school system where students can buy ice cream, junk food, etc., in the cafeteria but it was set in place by the PTO - not the actual nutrition program. A lot of parents became upset about it and complained to the school but it was their own board that set it up as a fundraising tool. I should have mentioned that it may not be something that happens in every system. :0]]

Sincerely,

Randa from About Life* ( http://aboutlifestar.blogspot.com/ )

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I wish the system would change, but it would take a lot of dedicated parents and staff to change it. And in the end, I think the healthful eating -- and what constitutes healthful eating -- supporters are in the minority. The fact is that this will never be my cause because there is a solution for me -- bring lunch.

Our school sells ice cream and cookies in the cafeteria -- it's sold by the school. And I think the problem is also that we have a county-wide system, meaning, every school needs to adhere by the same rules. Sometimes, it's a bit ridiculous -- if there is snow in one part of the county but not the other (and it can take over an hour to drive across the county), every school needs to close. But it's also a great thing. I've seen too many places where the affluent areas have beautiful schools and the impoverished areas don't, and our system means that it's equal(ish) across the board. It means that impoverished areas have the means to run their schools and implement new technology, etc. But it also means that you need to get hundreds of schools on-board for a change of the school lunch program.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I think most of it comes down to whether you laid a good foundation of knowledge, did you make junk food taboo (making it more enticing), and each kid is different. One of my twins loves to follow the rules. The other one, not so much.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

LucindaA 6 pts

about that particular lunch program. I am planning to start making some noise.

My kids actually don't eat the school lunches because they are gluten-intolerant. But before we knew that they were allowed to eat only 2 times a month. The rest of the time I packed them lunches. The choices were always crap and I feel for kids who eat school lunch every day. Ugh.

Randa 5 pts

It's these kind of articles that make me see how unequal schools are. In the program that my mother is in, only the dishes that require too much time to cook are shipped in and heated up, which is very rare. They make their own rolls, their own pizzas, their own tomato sauces, etc. The meat is real, though they tend to just serve chicken because it's a more cost efficient option and it's better for you. They only use whole grains and make sure that kids have at least two servings of vegetables and one serving of fruit during every lunch. On Thanksgiving, one elementary school cooked a dozen turkeys and prepared three homemade sides plus desserts to feed all the kids and their parents.

Oh, and before anyone asks - this is part of a public school system in a working-class neighborhood. Most of the kids are on free or reduced lunch and for those that aren't, lunch is only $1.25.

If you have a problem with the nutritional value of your child's lunch, complain to the school board! Let them know that you want something better because it is possible. If enough families go to the head of the nutrition department [which is in the school board, not the individual school], things should be changed.

[Also - cookies, ice cream, soda, etc., are usually not apart of the school nutrition plan. Most of the time, it is offered as a fundraising tool by the school.]

Sincerely,

Randa from About Life* ( http://aboutlifestar.blogspot.com/ )

mrsmuffins 5 pts

My daughter is vegetarian too and even though she's only a year and a half old, it's topics like this that keep me up at night. I hope with the knowledge we have now, it will only be a matter of time before junk food becomes less accessible. We have so much more to worry about, we shouldn't have to fear a school lunch like we do now.

Melissa Ford 5 pts

They can't even use the excuse that the water comes in a disposable bottle because the chocolate milk also comes in a disposable bottle. It also sucks because my son can't drink any milk, so he'll always have to pay more for his drink.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

ms_lorelei 5 pts

...is that the water costs extra.

My kids bought food on the rare occasion that they forgot their lunch (which I always heard about on the back end - "By the way, you owe us $11 for lunches this semester." Huh??)

But it drives me batty that we penalize the healthier choices with cost.

If fresh produce costs more than a bag of cheetos at the supermarket, I get it.

But at someplace like a school...that just needs to not happen. We can't simultaneously teach nutrition in health class and penalize them for acting on that education in the cafeteria.

Lori, speech pathologist, writer, and business owner, blogs home-family-working-mom drama at In Pursuit of Martha Points. ( http://inpursuitofmarthapoints.com )

Melissa Ford 5 pts

That's the part that really scares me -- the junk food offered and the fact they can buy ice cream, cookies and such. How can they make a decision between carrots and cookies?

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

The Bake-Off Flunkie 5 pts

School lunches make me cry because they are so horrific. Luckily (lol) my 2nd grader eats about 10 things and doesn't want to buy lunch, but my oldest gained 15 pounds her 7th grade year; too much crap to choose from and no supervision :(

Tiffiny blogs at The Bake-Off Flunkie ( http://bakeoff-flunkie.blogspot.com ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

No explanation why. Chocolate milk comes in a disposable bottle and is free. Water comes in a disposable bottle and is not.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Melissa Ford 5 pts

My son talked about buying again this weekend. I'm thinking about setting it up so he can do it once a month. And he can pick the date and stick to his budget.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Shannon LC Cate 9 pts

Water costs extra????
Gah!

"All that you have is your soul." Tracy Chapman

texasebeth 7 pts

My son is also in Kindergarten. He normally takes his lunch becasue we just don't have the budget to buy lunch every single day. Bringing from home is healthier and less expensive for the most part.

But the day of the Thanksgiving Feast at school parents were invited so I went. We both had bought lunches and ever since then Charlie has wanted to buy his lunch.

I don't have his account set up yet at school. Regardless of my various arguments for bringing a lunch, part of it is totally the letting go of my little boy, just the same as you.

Elizabeth

@texasebeth ( http://twitter.com/texasebeth )  and My Life, such as it is.... ( http://texasebeth.blogspot.com )