Bio
I'm a scientist turned stay-at-home mom turned cancer survivor turned survivor survivor, who packs each day with fun with her children, learning oppor...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

In the name of awareness (the FB color meme)

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 45
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

If you're on Facebook, you've seen the meme going around the past couple of days. Women the world over are posting colors to their status updates. Lots of black, some pink, some white, a virtual rainbow. It's a game that several of my circles (high school, local friends, blogging friends) are playing right now, and it looked cute if harmless. I wanted to play.

I tracked the game back a couple hours and figured it out -- they were writing their bra colors! I put hands to keyboard and wrote ... nothing. Truth is, I didn't know what to write. I wanted to frivilously play along -- the boys had gone to bed, and this was MY time, after all -- but I couldn't. And why couldn't I? If you know me, you don't have to ask. But if you're new here, I couldn't play along by posting the color of my bra because I don't have one. I don't own one.

Two years ago this month, I underwent surgery, you see. I had a double mastectomy to remove the cancer that was trying to kill me. In my right breast, Stage III inflammatory breast cancer, a fast-moving, deadly cancer that kills more than 60% of women in the first five years. (Statistics have improved somewhat since my diagnosis, but it's still the second-deadliest cancer, second only to prostate cancer.) In my left breast, potential. Potential that the same cancer would recur, as it was in my lymph system, coursing through my body, even as we tried to kill it with six months of tri-weekly, then weekly chemotherapy.

We had been through hell. First the cancer, then the chemo tried to kill me, and both of them almost succeeded. I was in bed for months, too tired to move. I couldn't leave the house for fear of infection during flu season -- and we had to take my oldest out of preschool, to keep those germs at bay. At one point, the taxol had ravaged my nervous system so much that I lost the use of my legs.

After all that, we had to wait for my body to rally after the last chemotherapy treatment and become strong enough to survive the surgery. As each day went by, I would grow stronger -- but so would the cancer. and if it grew faster than my white blood cells rebounded, then the surgery might not happen, and the tumor would be inoperable again.

It was terrible.

But eventually the day came, January 23, 2007, and I was able to have my breasts removed. I've never felt so relieved in all my life. This was my one big shot at getting rid of (most of) the cancer in my body, and starting life anew. This was it. This HAD to work.

And it did. I made it through surgery just fine (twittering when I woke up, and blogging about it the same day). I went through the gory aftermath of breast removal, and the difficulty of explaining it to my children. We found out that the second breast was not innocent at all, but fostering its own little type of cancer, Paget's disease. If I had not removed it preventatively, I could have been back in chemo within the year -- if it were found in time.

So I have some history here.

But I tried to shrug it off and play along. I wrote "None -- In fact, I don't even OWN one! :-)" and watched my friends play along in their own way, hoping I didn't make anyone uncomfortable.

But what I saw was nothing short of amazing. I'd forgotten for an instant that this wasn't about my story. This was about our story, and the Mothers With Cancer were coming out to play too. Here's what they wrote:

"Nude."

"Nothing."

"White, with pockets."

And then, in the comments, some amazing things began to happen. Their friends came out to support them, cheering them on. Friends engaged me on FB and twitter too, talking about it, asking why I felt left out, and letting me know that the whole meme was staged by some women in the midwest urging awareness of breast cancer.

Really?

Awareness?

Aren't we aware by now, people? Don't we know that we

  • 45
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
EncinitasMom 5 pts

First, I can help but feel a little angry at the comment above "don't feel sorry for yourself for what you have lost." I know this comment comes from someone who admits she has had brain damage but she seems cognizant enough to subscribe to this blog and write in complete sentences. Really??? I just want to say that even though my breasts were small, I loved my breasts. They were small but they had sensation, they provided nourishment for my children and they were mine.  They served me well. To compare the trials and tribulations of  small breasts to a person who agonized over months of chemo, radiation, and physical pain (both physical and emtional) from a bilateral mastectomy, is just plain ridiculous. I have no nipples and no sensation in my entire chest - except pain. Yes, I have had reconstruction so, yes, I can fill out a bra now days but what I wouldn't do to have my small, natural breasts back. Appreciate what you have!!!

Now, getting to the meme. I actually did respond to the FB meme with "no bra, don't need one, mine are gone." It made me feel a little sad but they way I see it, if it did make even one of my "friends" stop and check her breasts and if even one woman on Facebook became "aware" of something that shouldn't be there in her breast - well, the meme was worth it. I too can be overwhelmed with all the PINK but I feel very fortunate that there has been so much emphasis on "awareness" and believe it does lead to "action".  I actually walked all 60 miles of the Breast Cancer 3 Day just months after finishing my treatment and our team raised over $136,000 for breast cancer research. I felt incredibly supported and empowered. Yes, there was a lot of PINK and men walking around with bras filled with watermelons, etc.. But it was fun. And, no, the little girl who stood at the side of the road playing her violin for us walkers, no, she wasn't actively putting an end to breast cancer but she in her small way was supporting the cause. We were all parading pink throughout the city to bring about "AWARENESS" which leads to "ACTION". Breast cancer sucks, no doubt about it but there is nothing wrong in finding a way to celebrate "LIFE" and create more AWARENESS in fundraising functions such as these walks and, so be it, t-shirts with pink pancakes.  I know that the research made possible by all the dollars donated - even if the awareness came from a shirt with pink pancakes, well, these dollars helped to save my life. I have officially met NED and am happy to say so. If wearing pink or posting about bra color leads to action, any action at all, well, I am grateful. Grateful that I will hopefully now get to see my sons make it to kindergarten and 2nd grade, and hopefully graduate and dance with them at their weddings. 

Twenty years ago, I may not have been so lucky. Yes, I say LUCKY to be alive!! There may not have been pink ribbons plastered all over the place and walks and racers draped in pink but I also wouldn't have had a very good life expectancy. I realize that even a simple meme, even one that made me feel a little sad,  can cause AWARENESS that could help save a life. Even if its just one woman is reminded to check her breasts who then realizes there is a lump or even one extra dollar is donated for research that contributes to someone's life saving treatments, it is worth it. Awareness is better than nothing. Of course action is better but there first needs to be awareness. 

rosiesmom1120 5 pts

I am 34 years old, I had a double mastectomy in Nov and have tissue expanders. I was diagnosed with DCIS, in the end in both breasts and it was rampant, with a micro invasion. The mastectomy saved me from tamoxifen and possibly from developing a later stage breast cancer. It was not taken lightly and I wanted to the decision that would put an end fo the situation.

I appreciate your blog, because I did feel really uncomfortable the two days that meme ran rampant on facebook. I appreciate the solidarity and it if caused one women to get checked out, it was worth it.

However, I would love to see the same kind of action, sending emails to Senators and Congressmen to keep those new regulations from coming to fruition.

usmousie 5 pts

I truly hope no one is offended by this post.  I just want to say that it isn't only cancer survivors who have flat chests.  Some of us women never develop anything beyond what might be normal for a 13 year old.  We spend our lives in the same place-- not feeling like women.  As you say, blouses don't fit us. Other women bond over breast issues and we don't belong.  Men know that it is a tender issue and complete strangers make mean comments about being flat chested if they want to hurt us because their advances were rejected.  I would love to have cleavage.  A man, intending to make me feel better, will say "more than a handful is wasted" and there is an embarrassed silence because- oops-- I don't have a handful.  I don't even have a mouthful.  You may not have much to be thankful for when it comes to your breasts, but at least you had them when it was most important-- in your teens and early adulthood.  What am I saying? Maybe, don't feel sorry for yourself for what you have lost.  Some of us never had it.  I hope that isn't offensive.  Let me add that I have experienced a loss as well-- a budding genius as a child and student, I have suffered brain damage which renders me far less intelligent. I graduated summa cum laude from Yale; now I get lost in the subway on a route I have taken 100 times.  I felt sorry for myself for about 5 years.  Then I decided, there are people who are born less able to think than others.  At least I had it once.  Now I'm like one of them.  I have to deal with who I am, not as less than I could be, but as as good as I can be.  I don't feel sorry for myself anymore, and I try not to let reminders hurt me.  

Oh-- I just wrote "none."  That's sexy, isn't it?

stephaniedelger 5 pts

Thanks for the insight.  I never thought of it like that, having never been through or even witnessing a loved one go through what you've been through.  You opened my eyes.  I wish you blessings and good health!

laurie 5 pts

I am a fierce opponent of all the pink crap that litters our world every October. And I will never promote a blender or a lock just because it happens to be pink and a tiny percentage of profits goes to "breast cancer research."

So I hear you Susan, on awareness and action.

But I thought this meme was light-hearted and fun. I know it made some of us feel a bit sad but it also gave some of us the chance to interject a little education. One mother we both know said, "White. With pockets." I was "Vermilion. Worn Asymmetrically."

My world right now could use a little more fun. I think there is more room for education when people aren't scared to death of speaking out - yes cancer is a scary thing but we all need to talk about it a little more and maybe even laugh in its face.

And, as someone who has been struggling lately, I think a day where the status updates named all those we have loved and lost to cancer would have pushed me right over the edge.

I do really think that you have added something really important to the discussion with this post. I guess I also feel that those who participated need not feel bad or apologize.

Laurie

www.notjustaboutcancer.blogspot.com ( http://www.notjustaboutcancer.blogspot.com )

Jory Des Jardins 5 pts

You put awareness on a whole new level. I don't live on FB the same way I live on blogs and hadn't really noticed it. This connection would have gone over my head. There are some other ways to raise it, like share your story, as you do. With all this legislation around changing the screening requirements it's so important to understand all of the possibilities. As you've shown, we don't all find lumps and get them checked out. I prefer to be serious about this, not frivolous, but I feel unqualified to speak, not being a survivor.

The meme disturbed me for completely different reasons: Bad memory as a pre-teen of my first training bra (a hand-me-down, which makes it even worse): No underwire, of course, the right cup was red, the left blue. Why, to help me know my right from my left? Try wearing that in the girls locker room.

Jory Des Jardins writes on business and career topics at BlogHer, and on her personal blog From Here to Autonomy ( http://www.jorydesjardins.com )

dizpinfreak 5 pts

Please ignore this if you feel my gender has impacted my ability to weigh in on this -  but speaking solely for myself (though I am among the 1 in 1000 men diagnosed and treated annually for breast cancer in America) I found the posts fun - and the cause of a few bright moments during a particularly trying day. I am saving my fight for my disease. Maybe this frivolity will lead to a few more research dollars, a few more scheduled mammograms, or a few more connections rekindled between those friends that never seem to know just what to say. This "awareness effort" was certainly not intended to be at my - or your - expense. I kind of enjoyed the mainstream moment and frank dialogue it generated. I may go "commando" but I don't feel the need to be one combatting a facebook meme! I choose to see the potential in it and move on. I have much better things to do with the time I have left. 

clh523 5 pts

Your story accomplished what no "expert" could do: explain why this sort of so-called awareness campaign is meaningless--or worse. At ForbesWoman, we put the question to our community: Approve or disapprove of this social networking campaign to take cancer "awareness" viral? The response was fast and furious. While some said, "It's fun" or "What's the harm," the majority agreed (with you and your moving comments) that the bra color ripple will have little impact adequate health care for women, lack of attention paid to other diseases that kill women and the millions in spending in breast cancer marketing and advertising, among other important issues. Thank you, thank you, Susan, for sharing. Caroline

http://www.forbes.com/2010/01/08/breast-cancer-awa... ( http://www.forbes.com/2010/01/08/breast-cancer-awa... )

Serena_farhat 5 pts

I just wanted to say i'm really very sorry  that i posted my bra color on facebook Satatus !!.

I just thought it would remind us girls or women to remember breast cancer awareness in a new way . Seriously , i never new anything about breast cancer until i have read your article and i just thought that these facebook msgs were helping but not hurting other people's feelings ... 

. But you are completly right i'm truly sorry again and when i read your article it was very touching and i hope every women with breast cancer will be cured .... it's really a shame how sometimes we might forget to consider or rethink our actions. I hope we can really raise breast cancer awareness all over the world with better ways in order to open up the eyes of people that aren't aware of it.  Thank you ,

Best Regards,

Serena Farhat

agolston 5 pts

I just posted a link to this blog and the following on my FB page.  We may raise awareness yet! "In the spirit of truly raising awareness (and not just posting our bra colors), please read this inspiring blog from a breast cancer survivor." 

barbarabaker 5 pts

I don't know what to say. I've read every single comment as well as the lovely, yet inspirational heart-felt post (thank you) and I am speechless.

I have lost family to cancer. My husband lost his mother to cancer 13 years ago this past November (and still grieves). It hurts to hear the stories.

I just want to say; I commend every one of you for sharing your stories. That, to me, is awareness.

KJKae 5 pts

Thank you for this post. I played along with the meme, embracing it while I can, knowing someday I may not. My great grandmother and grandmother both had breast cancer, back before women survived it. It's hanging out there in my future, waiting for me. I look for it, I wait, I wonder when it will flip our lives upsidedown. I hope when it finds me I can be half as strong as you.

whymommy 5 pts

Wow.  Thank you for speaking out.

I slept on it too, and I just couldn't let it stand out there.  Thanks for letting me know that it was ok to speak up.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

mls322 5 pts

Hi Susan-

You are truly a remarkable woman. Thank you for your honest and heartfelt posting. You struck a passionate chord in me! And helped me find a voice. My family is full of cancer losses and survivors, and this past fall, I joined the ranks. Only Basal Cell Carcinoma, so nothing compared to the bone, prostate, breast, and uterine cancers of my family members. I understand your feelings of wanting action not more awareness.

Your insight prompted action, so this morning I posted this on my facebook page:

"No color will be posted, no video shared. But I will post this very heartfelt explanation from a survivor. I hope you will possibly take a look at the non-funny side of the share-your-bra-color postings that have resulted in some pretty painful reminders for survivors who would rather see action. Visit the ACS Cancer Action Network http://www.acscan.org/ ( http://www.acscan.org/ ) and consider joining or contacting your representatives in Washington.

Susan, I only know you from your post. But you have certainly touched this woman's heart today. Thank you."

And I posted your link.

But, crazy me. In the hopes of not losing friends, but instead, enlightening them, I also stepped out on a limb. Let me explain. I was very sad about a male friend's posting that turned the share-your-bra-color into one of those serious URGENT! FACEBOOK VIRUS ALERT postings, where he then proceeded to try to get a good laugh from friends by offering the fix which was to go to Settings> Enable Webcam> Hit Record> remove your bra, and Post Movie. I sat in disbelief and in tears as I realized that some folks don't get that cancer isn't funny. Ever. But instead of offering a comment, I walked away. Thought that it'd be better left unsaid. What a chicken I was!

Sleeping on it, I decided this morning that I did need to speak. I probably couldn't have forgiven myself if I hadn't. So I posted my comments to his posting and included your link. I hope the other 12 folks on his posting get my point and see that I was trying to only enlighten, not further offend.

Thank you for so many things... sharing your story, empowering folks, raising this issue, taking action, and for SURVIVING! I appreciate you.

Please take good care.

Michele

whymommy 5 pts

"Cancer isn't pretty and it isn't a sexy piece of lingerie."

Now that's an important message.  Thank you for saying that.  And for talking about it, on FB and elsewhere.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

Excellent point.  As a matter of fact, my breast cancer is a type that practically no one's heard of -- inflammatory breast cancer, the cancer that forms without a lump.  And while I would LOVE to see more awareness of this, as far as breast cancer itself, I think it's time to turn awareness into action.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

Excellent point.  As a matter of fact, my breast cancer is a type that practically no one's heard of -- inflammatory breast cancer, the cancer that forms without a lump.  And while I would LOVE to see more awareness of this, as far as breast cancer itself, I think it's time to turn awareness into action.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

I agree.  And I don't see how posting your bra color -- without any other explanation or action -- cures or prevents cancer.

Thanks for commenting.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

Bingo.

I'm getting a lot of these accusations at my personal blog, and I'm just dumbfounded.

Oh well, I suppose it means that I'm "out of the woods" health-wise. This is the first time I've ever had such a negative reaction to a post!

Thanks for sharing your hard-won experience.  You're not alone.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

What a terrible idea that pancake shirt was.  The truth is (and people may not want to hear this either) that VERY FEW MASTECTOMY SURVIVORS have nipples.

Yes, it's possible to make new ones from puckered skin and tattoos, if you're lucky enough to even be able to have reconstruction, but the truth is, they're never the same.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

You know, I think a lot of people did, and I know you all did it with the best of intentions..  Thanks for listening to how it affected me.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

Jennifer_Paradis 5 pts

Your story made me cry. Thank you so much for sharing it.

I've posted a link here on my Facebook page. I hope that all of my friends come and read your entry too.

ashleytoronto 5 pts

Thank you for having the courage to share your experience. I did not share my bra colour because I too felt it was tip-toeing around the real issue. I spoke about this in my facebook status and instead of posting a colour or pattern, I posted a link to this blog entry and am happy to say it has since inspired a dialogue (something the colours didn't do on many of my friends' profiles).

Cancer isn't pretty and it isn't a sexy piece of lingerie. We all know this - why do we continue to consider it taboo? I've lost many people in my family to cancer and I know most of us are affected by it in some way. Thank you again for sharing your story - this is the step we need to take.

Ashley

Toronto, Canada

KitchenTherapy 5 pts

I admit, I posted my bra color. And it was pink.

I am continually amazed at the marketing machine that is breast cancer awarenes. Pink bathroom rugs, pink silicone spatulas. You name it, it comes in breast cancer pink. The Susan B. Komen Foundation sure gets around.

But there are other cancers, I have had 2. My dad had 2 different cancers. I held his hand as he died of one.

Most of the time I ignore pink cancer campaigns, with a sigh. Thanks you for sharing your experiences and thoughts.

midgetinvasion 5 pts

My dad brought up the fact yesterday that the meme that should be brought back is the "*uck Cancer" one.

I lost my grandmother to multiple cancers, my grandfather to non-hodgkin's lymphoma, and my mother to cervical cancer.

And now we've had a close friend fight breast cancer, and my step mother's dad is currently battling prostate cancer.  To top it off, I've had melanoma scares in both my husband and the grandfather I have left.

I'm tired, pissed off, and fed up with cancer.  All of it.

GeorgieL 5 pts

I was told yesterday that it's like women who've lost their mother or child and have to endure Mother's Day. No. Not really. OCTOBER is like that. All day, every day, for a month.... dripping in pink ooze. This invaded my computer. I had a bilateral mastectomy at age 33, 10 years ago this month. Mind you, my replacement parts are "better" than the originals. I wear a variety of bras that now fit since the originals were almost non-existent and the new ones are lovely. But I don't HAVE to wear a bra. That's what happens when you have replacements.... they don't need support. Yesterday I just didn't feel like strapping one on. While I appear to all the world as having a lovely pair, the fact is they aren't. For those who BSE and the annual mammogram is just a matter of routine and perhaps a bit of bother... it WAS fun. It was a lark. But even with a stellar reconstruction, buying a bra is still about what it will hide, not what it will enhance. Because while I don't NEED a bra, I dare not leave the house without one. Even a stellar reconstruction job doesn't make them look natural or "right". God willing, I will live more of my life with my fake boobies than I did with the real ones. 99.9% of the time it just isn't a big deal. But then there comes the day that I am pounded with the message "you don't have real boobies" all dang day. Charming.

girlvaughn 5 pts

wow, this was so beautifully written. I love mcalison's idea

Big Girl Bombshell 5 pts

What a moving story and it is just an important reminder that we can never know just how our actions can affect others.  I have deleted my post and posted the link to this!  You are absolutely RIGHT! about it being time to take action.   It's not just about being aware because awareness often is only in the moment. I just want to publicly apologize for not thinking this all the way through.  I honestly believed until reading your side of the story, that I was supporting a cause that I have long supported.   I need to look at it through a different lens now!

It's about the attitude, not the scale!

MissyDiggs 5 pts

I just became aware of the FB meme today and joined in a couple of discussions about it but haven't put anything on my page. I did create a bit of a stir in October when I got upset about a local cafe putting out pink t-shirts with pictures of pancakes (complete with butter pat nipples) where the breasts would be.... in the name of awareness, of course, but when I ate there with my family I spent the meal with burning cheeks and a pain in my gut, feeling totally humiliated because I kept imagining how I would look with no breasts in that shirt, and I didn't think I would look "cute." I was pretty sure I would look sad at best.

Thanks for posting about this. I don't know if it's worse when the topic is breasts (the most culturally-charged body part I can think of), and the bike ride for MS example is a good one, but it is definitely true that there can be unintended consequences. Alienating the very people you are trying to support is a tricky one. Many of my friends have posted their bra colors today and I know they are doing it with the very best intentions. Those of us who have gone through this have so much grieving to do and it is hard to approach the idea of awareness with a light heart.

whymommy 5 pts

Wouldn't it be nice to remember these women and men this way?  I like to hear about women and men who have passed, as it lets me know that no matter what happens, we will not be so easily forgotten.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

Thanks, Lucretia. Although we may not be the "norm" we sure do have loud voices.  Thanks for passing this along -- and anything that you do to raise awareness, clearly, especially when the awareness is linked with information or action.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

OMG, Darryle, I love that post!

Go read it, y'all, and find out what she lost at the Great Barrier Reef....

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

Suebob,

Great!  Wonderful!  I'm glad it helped.  Yes, awareness is good, and I'm all for it, as you know.  I just needed to point out an unintended consequence.

The MS bike ride analogy is so, so true.  I always wondered about that.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

Thanks for the note, Maggielmcg.  I am sorry that she had to hurt, and I hope that we can all pick ourselves up and move past it, doing SOMETHING to improve awareness of a particular cancer, joining a cancer action network, or going to get that test we've been putting off.

The American Cancer Society has a Cancer Action Network that you can join, by the way: http://www.acscan.org/

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

Yes, awareness!  But not just bra color. 

My heart aches for your loss.  I have lost friends too this year, and when I think of how much Jen, Andrea, Lisa, and Katie would have loved to be on FB today, it makes me sad AND angry.

Thank you for telling us about Fran.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

Thanks, Kayrbear!  Here's one simple way that people reading this post can take action.  Visit the ACS Cancer Action Network http://www.acscan.org/ and consider joining or contacting your representatives in Washington.  Screening is important.  Paying for screening is an important first step.

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

whymommy 5 pts

Kgirl,

You're never alone.  With the incredible reach of the internet, there is always a community.  Since writing this a couple hours ago, I've received so many comments and emails from others who felt the same way, for various reasons.

Those who had a breast removed.  Or two.  Those who lost their mother to breast cancer.  Those who lost their father to prostate cancer.  Those fighting hard to make it through, and those who have lost a friend.  And even those who were born without breasts.  There are hundreds of thousands of women out there without breasts, I'm told, and they feel this way a lot.

Hugs to them, and to you, and if there's anything I can do to help you find others in your situation, please let me know...

Susan

http://toddlerplanet.wordpress.com & http://motherswithcancer.com

kgirl 5 pts

I have a tough, potentially life-altering decision to make soon, and this post has not only nudged me a little bit closer to maiking that decision, but has reminded me that I won't be alone, whatever the outcome. Thank you.

mcalison 5 pts

An option that wouldn't remind us of our missing breasts would be for people to simply change their status to the number of women they know who have or have had breast cancer.

GeekMommy 5 pts

Thank you.

I'm sitting here in tears. Not because I'm a survivor, but because I've never had it put quite so eloquently to me before.

When I found out what the meme was for - breast cancer awareness - I joined in.  Feeling a little silly at 43 to be playing "secret lingerie color memes" but still - even a little bit of awareness is a good thing right?

Apparently, there is such a thing as too much awareness.  It didn't occur to me that someone on my list might read that and think "I only wish this were just a silly meme instead of a reminder of something painful."

I agree that awareness without action is useless.  But awareness is the first step.  Yes, most of us are more than aware of all of the "pink ribbon events" and promotion - but I don't tend to think that we're the norm.  By us, I mean BlogHers.

We're certainly not the norm on FB - where there are many teenage & twenty-something students who could use the awareness.

But I'm now passing THIS along.  So much better than a one word "secret bra meme".  Thank you for taking the time to write it.  You touched my heart.

Lucretia (aka GeekMommy) Raising a child in a digital world, still a digital girl

suebob 7 pts

It actually did remind me to do a BSE, and I hope it reminded other people, too. I don't think it is designed to hurt breast cancer survivors any more than bike rides for MS are meant to remind people with MS they can't walk anymore...but sometimes consequences are unintended.

DarryleP 5 pts

Susan--I, too, just stared at my status box wondering what to put in it. 

Thank you for telling your story, which is so similar to mine:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/darryle-pollack/burn... ( http://www.huffingtonpost.com/darryle-pollack/burn... )

Thank you for your exquisite words--and for so perfectly expressing the passion I feel too---about action vs. awareness.

http://blog.darrylepollack.com/

kmkane123 5 pts

I saw this on Facebook, too, and ironically on the same day Facebook suggested I "say hello" to someone I hadn't talked to for a while. Why haven't I? Well, she died of breast cancer in May. (Hello Fern - we're all thinking of you and we miss you! xox You know, Fern always loved an audience - so here ya go, gal) I've had breast cancer myself, and while I'm sick of "pepto bismol pink" (as Fern would call it), I believe that awareness AND action are equally important. Heck, my husband just had a mammogram and needle biopsy for a lump in his chest, so yes, awareness is important no matter how it comes to you. Sad fact is that we'll all have a sad moment when breast cancer is mentioned, it's a sad story.

maggielmcg 5 pts

My best friend, who also underwent a double mastectomy, reconstruction, grueling chemo for 6 months then radiation...then more surgery...feels this same way about the Facebook meme. Thanks for a beautiful post that expresses so well what so many women who've survived breast cancer are feeling when they are bombarded by these seemingly frivolous Facebook status updates.

kayrbear 5 pts

I wholeheartedly agree with you that action, more than awareness, is what is important now. Not to say that awareness isn't important, but alone it is not enough. And while the bra color game is fun/funny for those who participate, is it really making them think more about getting screened and self-checking, and reminding loved ones to do the same? Most people have been saying, "what is this?" or doing as you did and scrolling back through the feed to figure out what's going on. There have to be more effective ways to spur people to action -- an effort that in itself will raise awareness (two birds!) -- than posting a (pretty intimate) detail about clothing on Facebook.

Kudos to you for your courage. Best wishes for continued good health.