Bio
I have been writing about family, parenting, politics and religion since 2000. My work has appeared on Babble.com, Literary Mama.com, in Adoptive Fam...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

National Adoption Month: 10 Common Misconceptions about Adoption

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 26
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

November is National Adoption Month in the United States, and although the main purpose of the month is to encourage adoption of children in foster care, all things adoption seem to make the Internet rounds each November. This seems as good a time as any to clear up some of the most common misconceptions people outside of adoption tend to have about it. Here are the ten that came instantly to mind, based on my own experience of talking to people about adoption

1. Birth mothers are all teenagers.

Birth mothers (sometimes called “natural” or “first” mothers) — international and domestic — come in all ages and from all walks of life. Some are teens, but the mythical “unwed teen mother” that many people think of when they imagine adoption is a hold-over from the 1950s and 1960s when single and teen motherhood were less acceptable in certain areas of society than they are now. These days, the reasons for placing children in adoptive families tend to be more diverse than mere age or marital status.

2. Open adoption is confusing to kids.

Most international adoptions are “closed” by default, because the first parents are unknown and perhaps untraceable. But there is a growing trend in domestic adoption to open the process and maintain some connection between birth and adoptive families. While this idea is often hard to grasp at first thought, the fact is that closing adoption records is a fairly recent phenomenon and fairly limited to industrialized societies. Even in the United States where formal, legal adoptions have been closed for the past few decades, there are subcultures in which informal and open “adoptions” have always been the norm. These might include extended families, neighbors or close friends raising each other’s children in times of need, temporarily or permanently. Such practices have been common throughout human history. Research is starting to show that adopted people who at least know a little bit about their first families have a better chance of adjusting healthily throughout their adolescent years of identity formation and on into later life.

3. They hate girls in China.

The circumstances that lead to so many girls being available for adoption in China are complex. But, in short, it is more the tradition of wives being absorbed by their husbands’ families that is the root of the problem in China. When you combine this with an economy that relies on adult children’s care of aged parents and a law restricting most families to either one son or two children (when the first is a daughter), the problem is seriously exacerbated. Some families — by far the small minority — with a first-born daughter feel pressured enough to have a boy on their second try, that a second daughter is sometimes abandoned so they can try again for a boy.

4. Black babies are the latest trend among celebrities.

If a celebrity does something, we hear much more about it than when Bill Smith from Peoria does it, right? When two celebrities do the same thing, we hear enough about it to make it feel like a “trend” simply by virtue of the percentage of space it takes up in the media. The fact is, African American babies are still the last to be placed in adoption in the United States. African American boy babies are at the very bottom of the demand pyramid for healthy newborns. Perhaps the reasons more than one white celebrity has a Black adopted son is because celebrities live such cosmopolitan lives that when the social worker doing their home study asks “are you open to adopting a Black boy?” they say yes more often than other people. And if you say yes to a Black baby boy, you will probably get one — and fast — because not many people say yes.

5. Adoptive parents are saintly for adopting.

Adoptive parents are always hearing how great they are for having adopted. People always mean well when they say this, but the fact is, most adoptive parents adopted because they wanted to be parents. Period. Not because they are special saints. This also sometimes sounds to adoptive parents

  • 26
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Carrie Anne Hudson 5 pts

These are all spot on. We live in China and we get frustrated at the "Chinese hate girls," mantra we hear. It's a deep seeded cultural issue and for most, the one child policy leaves them feeling strangled by the realities of culture. Thank you for addressing so many of the misconceptions out there. 

Natsters 5 pts

Wow this is great! As an adopted child, I have run into a LOT of strange conceptions about adoption over the years. I remember time and time again as a child being asked what orphanage I came from... and how confused I was by anyone who asked me that. Haha! Thanks for your blog.

stephanieburrage 5 pts

great article. I shared it on my blog.

Kerri L 5 pts

I just came across your post and enjoyed it very much. Two years ago I witnessed the pain that my in-laws went through when their son (my brother-in-law)reunited with his birth mother. The reality was that they had nothing to worry about. As much as my brother-in-law felt more "complete" having met his birth mother, my in-laws were, and will always be, his parents. He got married this fall and his birth mother (and three 1/2 siblings) were at the wedding. He made a point of recognizing his parents, including giving a speech about his dad being his hero. He then came and took my mother-in-law's hand for the newlywed's dance with their parent. It was really special.

Response provided by blog: www.bornforbrilliance.com ( http://www.bornforbrilliance.com )

Kristen Howerton 9 pts

As an adoptive mom, I LOVE this post. So true. All of it.

www.rageagainsttheminivan.com ( http://www.rageagainsttheminivan.com )

( http://www.%3C/div )

blesstheirheartsmom 5 pts

Wonderful post!

As an adoptive parent, let me say open adoptions CAN work well for everyone, if everyone keeps the best of intentions for the child. My daughter gets to see her grandmother, great aunt and great great grandmother 3-4 times a year and she adores them and thinks of them as just more family. We have a great bond over my daughter and as mu husband and i come from families of divorce and remarriage, we have alot of extended family members around, so it works for us.

She does NOT see her bio mom, due to bio mom's psychological issues. But we send photos via grandma and she gets updates from family members. This works for her and us, so everyone is happy.

s palmer bennett 5 pts

From one Carolina girl to another...do it! You don't know what awaits if you don't try. You may find rejection and hurt but you may also find acceptance and love. I found my siblings and there were mixed emotions, but now I know and they know and right now, that's enough.
www.palmerbennett.wordpress.com ( http://www.palmerbennett.wordpress.com )

s palmer bennett 5 pts

I used to have the fear of the unknown when it came to medical history and genetic abnormalities but the medical advancements and technology of today are of such that we don't really need our history. Yes, it's nice to have, but I found that I used it as a crutch to keep from hurting my adopted parents feelings. I found my biologicals and I have to admit that the medical history I found was better off unknown. Good luck to you...
www.palmerbennett.wordpress.com ( http://www.palmerbennett.wordpress.com )

s palmer bennett 5 pts

From one Shannon to another...I am so feeling you on this. Thank you.
www.palmerbennett.wordpress.com ( http://www.palmerbennett.wordpress.com )

BarnMaven 10 pts

When a child grows into an adult, they are no longer a "child." One of the things I often hear is adoptees of any age being called "adopted children." I'm sorry. I'm 45 years old. I'm not a child. I'm a grownup.

Mary a/k/a BarnMaven blogs at http://www.barnmaven.typepad.com about single parenting, living with ADHD, too many animals to count and dealing with ADHD/Bipolar kids.

BarnMaven 10 pts

Illinois new records bill is a travesty that splits adoptees down a date line. Adoptees born after 1946 are the ONLY ones who can get their birth certificate on request. The rest are subject to state and birthparent consent laws that are ridiculously infantilizing. They even criminalized an adoptee utilizing information from the medical information exchange to identify birth family members.

Mary a/k/a BarnMaven blogs at http://www.barnmaven.typepad.com about single parenting, living with ADHD, too many animals to count and dealing with ADHD/Bipolar kids.

Breeann Ashton 5 pts

Thank you for publicizing all these. I wish everyone had more consideration for birthmothers and that everyone could understand THAT I AM the lucky one, not my son.

lorrie callison watson 5 pts

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHA!!!! Saintly!!! I only wish!! I'm about as evil as they come. Ahem. I mean, ah, yes, I beg to differ. I am a saint for adopting two kids, I'm just modest.

As an adult adoptee, I do want to say that some birth mothers do not have the slightest desire to be in contact with their children. Conceived and born in a time where birth mothers were regarded as whores and fallen women, I understand. But I'm sad. I have reached out and been rejected.

I found my half brother & sister on Facebook and I'm too terrified to contact them.

Great piece, Shannon!!!

Lorrie http://cluelessincarolina.blogspot.com

Shannon LC Cate 46 pts

Have you looked into the new Illinois situation? I believe they have opened closed records to a certain extent. Maybe you can get your original BC now. Here's hoping!

"All that you have is your soul." Tracy Chapman

kjpugs 5 pts

I think a lot of these things are great to hear! Also, it was funny you mentioned Peoria because that's where I was born (but was adopted into a family in NJ.)

I also think it's important to mention how closed adoptions can actually give adopted kids MORE issues... I have ZERO medical history, and unless I locate my birthparents (which is virtually IMPOSSIBLE) my future children will inherit that. Having two non-adopted sisters, I felt very different and that didn't help. I'm glad we're finding ways to make it easier for adopted kids now, with various forms of open adoptions, but I wish something would be done to help adoptees from closed adoptions as well.

falnfenix 6 pts

if these children weren't wanted, they wouldn't exist. I wouldn't exist. the assumption that birth mothers don't care about or want their children makes me want to cry, as i know this isn't so.

...i have to believe this isn't so. otherwise, i'm terrified of what may face me when i finally start the process of finding my birth mother.

heathers 7 pts

Brava! And thank you.

Overthinking adoption at Production Not Reproduction ( http://www.productionnotreproduction.com )@hedra
( http://www.twitter.com/hedra )

Shannon LC Cate 46 pts

...to everything you said. People also tend to ask me if I'm "afraid" my children's mothers will "change their minds" or "want them back."
My girls are wanted very much and loved very much by their first mothers. Want to and can are two different things.

I hope there is a happy reunion in your future.

"All that you have is your soul." Tracy Chapman

FabGrandma 5 pts

is another misconception. I wanted my child--I just knew I was not going to be able to take care of him. In 1970, there weren't many options available to a teenage mother--at least not that I was aware of. I was 17, no job, no car, no support from my parents or the father of the child. I cried every day of my pregnancy because I knew I would have to give my child away. I cried every day of my life until his 6th birthday, when I just plain told myself that crying accomplished nothing. I hope he will want to meet me someday, which is another misconception associsted with adoption--that all birthmothers don't want to be found.

Read the latest at http://fabgrandma.blogspot.com/

Marina DelVecchio 5 pts

This is a very informative post, Shannon. An adoptee myself, I love #6. Yes, we ar elucky, but in order to be adopted, we had to be neglected and abandoned first. This is our first wound, and we never get past it; no matter how loved we were or how lucky.

Regards,

Marina DelVecchio

Email:marinagraphy@gmail.com

Blog:http://Marinagraphy.com ( http://marinagraphy.com )

Web site:http://Marinadelvecchio.com ( http://www.marinadelvecchio.com/ )

FB:

lisanoel03 7 pts

I really thought this was a great piece...right up until the very end. Then it went very very wrong. I realize the point of this piece is adoption but the comments on abortion it me BEYOND poorly. To imply that someone who had an abortion is not a mother is about as true as implying someone who had a miscarriage is not a mother and I dare you to find a single woman who's had a miscarriage and ask if she feels that was not a child she lost or that she is not a mother.
I don't mean to take away from the other good information here but sometimes one wrong note can ruin the whole song. I personally have experience abortion and know MANY MANY other who have and their stories are very very similar. They all feel like mothers who've lost their children but they simply can't be recognized as such. Much the same as birth mothers, they hide their story and their loss for fear of judgment. But just like birth mothers, they ARE in fact mothers and experience a great deal of grief after their loss. I truly wish that the choice of adoption was more accepted in our culture so that fewer women would chose abortion. Most women I know who've chosen abortion VERY quickly regretted it. They often turn around and attempt to get pregnant to try and heal the hurt, or turn to drugs or alcohol to numb the pain, suffer from depression or become very promiscuous because of a lack of value for themselves because of their choice.

Lavender Luz 27 pts

Thank you for adding depth and texture to this multi-dimensional issue, Shannon.

It's easier for people to think in stereotypical and simple terms about something that's so complex and layered. You did a great job of highlighting the most common myths and adding perspective.

I especially like this: "Often though, adoptive parents will tell you that they feel lucky to have their beloved children."

*raises hand*

Write Mind Open Heart ( http://www.writemindopenheart.com/ ) (formerly Weebles Wobblog)@LavLuz
Examiner ( http://tinyurl.com/oaexaminer )for Open Adoption.
( http://twitter.com/LavLuz )

JennaHatfield 289 pts

Kudos, my friend. Big thumbs up.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

lauracarroll 14 pts

What you know is true on adoption is so needed out there. There is so much emphasis on having one's biological child, when there are so many children already in the world to parent and love. I wish more people who have trouble conceiving would know more truths about adoption, and those who want children, fertility issues or not, would think about adoption First..

Laura
Families of Two
http://lauracarroll.com

idyllicchick 15 pts

'Birth mothers are severely judged in U.S. society.'
Unfortunately true. Hopefully with the continued writing of articles such as this that will someday come to pass. Thank you!

Rose Leigh 6 pts

Thank you for this. My husband and I suffered a miscarriage in March 2010 and have been trying to conceive since then. Overall, due to medical issues, we know adoption is a very real alternative that we will need to consider, and possibly within the next few years. The bottom line is, we are parents without a child when there are so many children out there praying people like us will come along.

Your article was reassuring and informative on some of the points the general Internet research world tends to muddy up.

http://rosythoughts.com