Negative Obama Email Circulates Internet, Huckabee Supports Changing Constitution
by Dana J. Tuszke

I missed five days of work last week because I caught bronchial pneumonia, also known as "hell in my lungs". My son brought it home from daycare. I was so miserable, and I could barely talk, so I prayed for a miracle recovery, also known as "Aunt K's homemade chicken soup".

Instead, she sent me an e-mail instructing me to drink lots of fluids and warned me not to be tempted to vote for Barack Obama should he win the nomination in this election.

Several of my conservative, Republican relatives forwarded copies of an e-mail claiming that Senator Obama was a Muslim with an Islamic agenda, that he was secretly chosen to carry out a plan designed by terrorists to destroy America, and that becoming President of the United States was the first step to completely annihilate our country.

What's worse is that I received that same e-mail eleven times in that week. My family and friends wanted to be sure I got the message that Barack Obama was the closest thing to the anti-Christ.

The opening paragraph of the e-mail urges, "If you do not ever forward anything else, please forward this to all your contacts. This is very scary to think of what lies ahead of us, here in our own United States. You better heed this and pray about it and share it." But what really frightens me, are the inaccuracies and downright lies that this e-mail is circulating through the Internet.

For example, the claim is made that "this information is factual" because it was "verified on Snopes.com", and instructs the reader to click an enclosed link to check it out for themselves.

From Snopes.com:

One version of the e-mail in circulation claims "We were told this was checked out on 'snopes.com'. It is factual. Check for yourself," and includes a link to this web site. It's our guess that whoever included that bit was counting on folks to not check, as our article says the opposite: that the polemic is not factual, but rather is false.

The first "fact" states that Obama was born in Honolulu, Hawaii, to Barack Obama, Sr., a black Muslim from Kenya, and Ann Dunham, a white atheist from Wichita, Kansas. However, it was Obama's father that was an atheist, and his mother did not practice any religion.

Obama's father and mother separated when he was two years old. He lived most of his life in Hawaii, but from ages six to ten, he lived in Jakarta, Indonesia, after his mother married Lolo Soetoro, an Indonesian foreign student.

The second misconception is that Obama's stepfather is a radical Muslim, and that Soetoro raised Barack as a Muslim as well. While living in Jakarta, Obama attended Basuki School in Menteng, Jakarta, in which classes were taught in the Indonesian language. The Basuki School has been inaccurately reported as being a "madrassa" (an Islamic religious school).

In January 2007, Insight magazine printed an article which alleges that unnamed sources close to Senator Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign had discovered that the Basuki School was an Islamic learning institution (A CNN article debunks this myth.), when in fact, it is a public school for people of all faiths. Barack Obama also attended Catholic school in Indonesia as well.

The third untruth states:

Obama takes great care to conceal the fact that he is a Muslim. He is quick to point out that he was once a Muslim, but that he also attended Catholic School. Obama's political handlers are attempting to make it appear that he is not a radical.

The e-mail even goes so far as to claim that Barack Obama will not recite the Pledge of Allegiance, nor will he show any reverence to the American flag; and that Senator Obama was sworn into office not with the Holy Bible, but the Koran instead.

Most of the information in the e-mail is distorted and exaggerated. There is simply no evidence to support the notion that Obama is a "radical Muslim". Barack Obama describes himself as a Christian and says that he is rooted in the Christian tradition. His association with the United Church of Christ began over twenty years ago, long before he contemplated a political career or launched his campaign for the presidency.

Upon further research, I discovered that this malicious e-mail has been floating through the Internet since as early as October 2007, when questions of Obama's faith began to surface.

From WashingtonPost.com (Nov. 2007):

Despite his denials, rumors and e-mails circulating on the Internet continue to allege that Obama (D-Ill.) is a Muslim, a "Muslim plant" in a conspiracy against America, and that, if elected president, he would take the oath of office using a Koran, rather than a Bible, as did Rep. Keith Ellison (D-Minn.), the only Muslim in Congress, when he was sworn in earlier this year.

In campaign appearances, Obama regularly mentions his time living and attending school in Indonesia, and the fact that his paternal grandfather, a Kenyan farmer, was a Muslim. Obama invokes these facts as part of his case that he is prepared to handle foreign policy, despite having been in the Senate for only three years, and that he would literally bring a new face to parts of the world where the United States is not popular.

In June 2006, Senator Obama gave a 'Call to Renewal' keynote address in Washington D.C. in which he talks about the connection between religion and politics, and offers thoughts on how to sort through the bitter arguments that have been popping up over the past several years. He spoke of when he ran against Alan Keyes for the 2004 U.S. Senate Election:

"Mr. Keyes is well-versed in the Jerry Falwell-Pat Robertson style of rhetoric that often labels progressives as both immoral and godless. Indeed, Mr. Keyes announced towards the end of the campaign that, "Jesus Christ would not vote for Barack Obama. Christ would not vote for Barack Obama because Barack Obama has behaved in a way that it is inconceivable for Christ to have behaved."

Now, I was urged by some of my liberal supporters not to take this statement seriously, to essentially ignore it.

But what they didn't understand, however, was that I had to take Mr. Keyes seriously, for he claimed to speak for my religion, and my God. He claimed knowledge of certain truths. Mr. Obama says he's a Christian, he was saying, and yet he supports a lifestyle that the Bible calls an abomination. Mr. Obama says he's a Christian, but supports the destruction of innocent and sacred life.

And so what would my supporters have me say? How should I respond? Should I say that a literalist reading of the Bible was folly? Should I say that Mr. Keyes, who is a Roman Catholic, should ignore the teachings of the Pope?

Unwilling to go there, I answered with what has come to be the typically liberal response in such debates - namely, I said that we live in a pluralistic society, that I can't impose my own religious views on another, that I was running to be the U.S. Senator of Illinois and not the Minister of Illinois."

When I began to dig further into the biography of Barack Obama, I didn't uncover a radical Muslim. I discovered the junior U.S. Senator from Illinois, the fifth African American Senator in U.S. History, and the only African American currently serving in the U.S. Senate.

I learned that Senator Obama is a graduate of Columbia University, as well as Harvard Law School, and that he worked as a community organizer, university lecturer and civil rights lawyer before running for public office.

This is a man who was raised in culturally diverse surroundings, a politician that was elected to the U.S. Senate with a landslide 70% of the vote.

Senator Obama supports many important political issues. He co-sponsored the enactment of conventional weapons control. He made official trips to Eastern Europe, the Middle East and Africa, and he sponsored legislation on lobbying and electoral fraud, as well as global climate change, nuclear terrorism, and care for the returned military personnel.

Since his presidential campaign launched last February, Obama has stressed the importance of ending the war in Iraq, increasing energy independence, and he's a firm supporter of universal health care.

Far be it for me to make inaccurate assumptions based on an e-mail that was intended to scare the pants off uninformed voters.

I may not agree with every aspect of Barack Obama's political campaign, but I'm certainly not going to disregard the fact that he is a modernistic candidate for the Presidency of the United States.

Keeping in mind what Senator Obama said, "...we live in a pluralistic society, that I can't impose my own religious views on another..", I was baffled with Mike Huckabee's revelation that he supports changing the Constitution to reflect God's word.

From NewsBusters.org:

If a spoonful of sugar makes the medicine go down, does Mike Huckabee's sweet way with a word make tolerable views that would be rejected as extreme in the mouths of others less verbally gifted?

Exactly which Word of God is Huckabee referring to? Will it be the NIV, King James, NASB, Living Bible, The Promise, Today's English Bible, Amplified Bible or something else? How do we determine which version to use that would be suitable for Catholics, Lutherans, Methodists, Baptists, Jews, Muslims, Mormons, Buddhists, Evangelicals, Jehovah's Witnesses, Atheists, Agnostics and every other religion or non-religion in existence today?

Coffee-Drinking Woman writes:

"Wow. All I can say. Wow. So much for separation of church and state. This man is dangerous..."

Snow on Roses writes:

"This man got this far in a presidential campaign? How the hell does that happen? Would someone please pull him aside and sit him down with a copy of the Constitution and explain to him about the separation of church and state? At this very moment Thomas Jefferson is spinning in his grave fast enough to power Monticello for a year."

Nicole Belle of Crooks and Liars writes:

"Please. Make. It. Stop. I hate to break it to the Huckster, but the Middle Ages weren’t really that much fun. Why is it that the Republican Party seems to want to force us all back there?"

From One Girl's Blog:

"I think that alone makes it clear that we don’t need Huckabee in the White House. What we have is bad enough; we don’t need to see the faith-based initiatives this freak would put in place."

From Liberty Street:

"The Constitution, of course, does not mention God at all. The Constitution takes its authority from the people, not from God or any other religious authority."

From Delaware Watch:

"This man actually wants to adjust the constitution to accord with the Bible. Replace "Bible" with "Koran" and you have the same logic as an Islamic theocrat."

From The Democratic Daily:

"This guy is a real threat to our basic rights under the Constitution and I don’t think we should under estimate the sway he may have with the Christian right."

Oooh, nuance! writes humorously:

"Ah, yes. Good ol' Hackabee, with his five o'clock shadow and folksy manner. What an appealing candidate! He was a Governor. He's not a legacy candidate like George W. Bush. He's got real evangelical creds, being a Baptist minister. Heck, he even seems to have compassion for poor people - something a lot of elected Republics lack. What could be wrong with this guy?"

For the record, I couldn't find one single blogger, Democrat or Republican, who agrees with Huckabee's statement. Two weeks ago, Morra Aarons asked me what I thought of Mike Huckabee. My response was:

"I think Mike Huckabee is too good to be true. I like him, but I feel a little uncertain about his ability to lead this country. I can't quite find the words to describe my feelings. I know that sounds ridiculous. To be honest, I want to vote for him, should he win the nomination, but something holds me back."

 

I think I found the "something" that stops me in my tracks. The man is a loon, and after speaking to my parents, they believe he's off his rocker, too.

Voters like myself and my parents were swooning over Huckabee based on his smooth rhetoric and persuasive abilities. We loved that he wasn't afraid to say "Merry Christmas" on television and we were impressed that he kept Christ in Christmas. But we are not extremists.

As a Catholic, religion is important to me, and it plays an important role on how I vote in this election -- particularly because of one very important issue dear to my heart.

However, once religion becomes the sole focus of a political campaign, it begins to trample on the rights of others. I can't imagine that this is what God intended, and I don't believe that Mike Huckabee will have any chance in moving forward in this election based on his extreme statement. But don't take my word for it, it's obvious the blogosphere speaks for itself.

 

----------

Contributing Editor Dana J. Tuszke also writes at The Dana Files.

Comments

 

Brava, Dana

It is astonishing that this email about Obama still needs to be debunked and actually continues to circulate. And great job in investigating. You don't have to agree with Obama politically to get the facts and think for yourself.

Are the people forwarding this thing still waiting for their money from Bill Gates?

PopConsumer
Beyond Help

 

Maria, the funny thing is

Maria, the funny thing is that every single person that sent a copy of that e-mail to me was Republican, conservative and Catholic -- and most of them are over age 50.

I was curious to find out what they thought of it, so when I replied back they just said they forwarded it without even digging into the truth of the matter.

I hate to say that they are naive, because I don't think that's necessarily true, I just think that it didn't dawn on them that the internet can be deceptive at times.

I told one friend that this was an inaccurate e-mail and she was insistent that it was true and when I asked her to check out the snopes link, she replied that maybe snopes wasn't a reliable website. Yet, she was going to believe a random e-mail that had been forwarded hundreds of times before she got it!

Dana J. Tuszke
The Dana Files
The Dana Reviews
Belly Hungry

 

Thanks for sharing your story & perspective

Wow, it's scary how badly people want to create enemies and generate unwarranted fear and hatred. I hope that most of the people who received that email acted as you did, although what makes me sad is that I suspect your desire for truth is pretty singular. People of all stripes love when their biases and unfounded suspicions are "confirmed."

Suzanne Reisman, Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS)& Other Rants

 

Thanks Suzanne. I really

Thanks Suzanne. I really enjoyed looking into this because I hadn't really delved into Barack Obama's history before -- I was too busy sifting through GOP garbage. My family is so worried that I'll vote Democrat this year because, lately, I've been fed up with the Republicans. I can only chalk up the e-mails as fear of the unknown. It's a good feeling to know that I crossed that line and discovered what the truth really is.

And Huckabee, Oh my...Huckabee is just one hammer short in his toolbox.

 

Astounded

Do they really feel that any Republican is better than a Democrat even with some of the evidence piling up indicating that ... (flails around for a polite way to say) their candidates are less than desirable?

I know I've voted Republican before when the Democratic candidates disgusted me. I had hoped the opposite was true but I guess not.

Jim Heivilin

 

Jim, I'm not certain what

Jim, I'm not certain what people are thinking during this election. It's clear that America is suffering "Electile Dysfunction" as BIll Maher puts it. With a different GOP candidate winning in several caucuses & primaries (Iowa, New Hampshire, Michigan) I'm not certain who will come out on top.

I think every American has different priorities, and regarding the Republican candidates, we "righties" can't decide between Huckabee, McCain, Romney thus far. Which has me wondering about Giuliani & Thompson (not so much Paul; he is creepy.)

And the same goes for the Democrats. It's a real nail biter when it comes down to Obama, Edwards and Clinton.

I'm anxious to see how this plays out, on both sides.

 

Thanks for this

When I saw your headline I couldn't wait to see what you were going to say because I knew you'd take a conservative view. I was actually delighted by the article. I'm especially happy to see you debunk the Obama myths with facts. Several of my friends have received an emailed photo of a bunch of the candidates with their hands on their hearts and Obama's hand is not quite in the right place. They all swear that this proves that he won't say the Pledge of Allegiance and that he's not a good American. I don't know why people believe these viral emails that are so clearly not factual, but they do. This article is going to be sent to them!

http://www.webteacher.ws/
http://first50.wordpress.com/

 

Thanks Virginia! I have to

Thanks Virginia!

I have to say, I don't always take the conservative view on everything. 90% of the time I stand on the right, but even I know when things are misleading.

It was Mark Twain that said, "a lie can travel halfway around the world before the truth can tie its shoes." I think the same is true on the Internet.

 

Wonderful post Dana

I learned a lot from this post. Email forwards are a modern ill. I hope Aunt K has learned from this experience!

 

Morra, I hope so, too. :)

Morra, I hope so, too.

:)

 

Resounding Applause!

Thank you for such a thoughtful and complete analysis of the political dirty pool playing out.

I'm not looking forward to the late summer/fall season when all the stops will be pulled out by the swiftboaters and mudslingers. Posts like this do a lot to debunk those myths in a reasonable, rational way.

karoli (odd time signatures)

 

Thanks Karoli! I'm grateful

Thanks Karoli! I'm grateful for your thoughtful compliment. And I agree, when the big guns come out, I'll be hiding behind my imaginary political bomb shelter. I know that politicians have the right to respond to attackers, but it really starts so many feuds that don't seem to end.

 

Excellent post!

Very well researched and written.

I'd love to know if you sent this back to everyone who sent you the original email, and what their reaction was.

Visit my blogs at ThreeSeven (all that's irrelevant and amusing) and
ecochick (all that's green, cool and Canadian).

 

Thank you, zchamu! I did

Thank you, zchamu! I did reply to all of the persons that e-mailed me. (A few of them refused to acknowledge what blogs were, so if that tells you anything....)

Some of my pals were indifferent, probably because they realized they were duped. Others still insist that Obama is Muslim despite the fact that there is no real evidence. I suppose I can't win them all, and it makes me laugh just a little, that they are so convinced the e-mail is the Gospel according to GOP.

One relative replied, "Well, I still think Obama is too shady." He has a right to his opinion, even if it is incorrect, I guess. :)

 

Dana, I hope your post gets circulated far
and wide

You reach an audience that would likely not find many of us who have tried to derail some of the lies credible.

Great work, and a great roundup on the Huckabee statement as well.

Kim
BlogHer Contributing Editor|Professor Kim|

 

Thanks, Professor Kim!

Thanks, Professor Kim. And I just realized that I forgot to use the link you sent to me. It has completely slipped my mind!

I'm posting it right here:

http://newsweek.washingtonpost.com/onfaith/georgetown/2008/01/yesterday_...

For everyone who is reading today's post, please check out the link above. It's a great piece and mentions some very interesting Huckabee quotes. Like the Obama e-mail said, "If you never read anything else, or forward anything else, you better heed this and think on it and pray on it." (That was my lame attempt at humorous sarcasm. Did it work?)

:)

Dana

 

thanks for this

Thanks for such a well-researched article. Now when I receive this forward from well-intentioned, but sometimes misguided, relatives, I'll know where to direct them. :)

Amy
Crunchy Domestic Goddess
http://crunchydomesticgoddess.com

 

Amy, thank you so much. I'm

Amy, thank you so much. I'm honored that you'll send them this way!

 

this is the best summary i have read

of Obama's upbringing (and of Huckabee's looniness, for that matter). Clear and thorough, I know I will refer to it again.

Aside from the excellent points you raise, though, is no one else struck by the implications that being a muslim is a bad thing in and of itself and a charge against which someone needs to be defended?

laurie
www.notjustaboutcancer.blogspot.com

 

Laurie, that is a great

Laurie, that is a great point. Why are some voters (clearly Republicans) so paranoid about the Islamic faith? Why do they fear Muslims?

I have a hunch that perhaps they are associating all Muslims with terrorists and this is very unfortunate and also a very naive, close-minded way of thinking. It's such a cruel stereotype, too.

 

Fantastic

I'll just echo what everyone else is saying. This is an outstanding political post--one of the most informative and memorable I've read this entire campaign season. Thank you for your perspective and your intelligence. And for calling Huckabee a loon! :-)

Stefania Pomponi Butler


I blog:
CityMama
Kimchi Mamas
MOMocrats

 

Stefania, you've got me

Stefania, you've got me giggling. A wanted to call him a "dodo bird" but I couldn't stop laughing as I was writing it so I changed my mind. :) Thanks for the great support.

 

Amazing round-up, Dana --

Amazing round-up, Dana -- you are such an easy read -- this year's campaign is very confusing, for me, and your post is just the type of political writing I'm looking for. Honest and true. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and...you know...that beautiful BIG brain of yours ;o)

--------------------------------------------
This Full House
This Full House of Product Reviews
Imperfect Parent

 

Thank you, Liz! I really

Thank you, Liz! I really appreciate your comments and I'm glad I've contributed to making the campaign a little less confusing. :)

 

Just what we need - another speaker of God's
word!

Dana - Thank you for addressing the Obama email. I too had heard of it and its ear popping accusations. I agree with your thoughts about Huckabee - I mean really - which "word" of God is he speaking of?

I can only desperately hope that we as a Nation select the best candidate and pick our country up again.

Helene
The Modern Woman's Divorce Guide
http://themodernwomansdivorceguide.com/blog

 

Helene, I agree. This

Helene, I agree. This country needs to rebuild itself. I do hope we can choose the right person to lead our country.

 

what's funny is...

...there are still people who believe email forwards! let alone, crazy claims that some random website has gotten "the facts" on. had this story had any real legs, the mainstream media would have been all over it. so i hope you forward your post to everyone who forwarded you this email.

mos def says..."my umi says shine your light on the world"...it is up to us to bring the truth to light, esp when we know it for certain.

~~
Gimme Love: http://theprisonerswife.blogspot.com