Bio
A prodigal Southern Belle, Adrienne recently returned to her hometown of Chattanooga, Tenn. after living in the DC Metro area for several years. A re...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

The New Female Reformers: Nikki Haley

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

The Atlantic has an interesting profile of Governor Nikki Haley. Written by Hanna Rosin, who also writes for Double X, the piece focuses on the rise of Haley and how conservative women are working to reform government.

Rosin captures the cesspool of South Carolina politics, such as this conversation with State Senator Jake Knotts. He made the infamous "raghead" comments about Haley, and his comments to Rosin aren't much better:

Knotts later claimed that his comments had been “intended in jest.” But when I caught up with him just before the November election -- which Haley won, becoming the state’s first Indian American governor and first female governor —- his complaints, though less coarse, had if anything grown broader in scope. “Let me say this: people going into politics these days are different than the people I always served with. Strom Thurmond, Fritz Hollings -- one Democrat, one Republican, but they had mutual respect for one another,” he told me. “You had to be one of us to get elected. Now we’ve gone so far down the ladder and backwards. We don’t know who it is, or what it is. As long as it’s got an R in front of its name, we vote for it.”

Ew, ew ew ... how can people like him still exist? I'm not just working to fight socialist liberals, but Neanderthals in my own party. You can promote the values of limited government, free markets and family values without being a racist or a misogynist.

One of the remarkable factors about Haley's victory, and even Governor Bobby Jindal's win in Louisiana, is how racist the South was towards Indians. Haley downplayed her ancestry, but her success is remarkable. Some of the experiences from her childhood were terrible, such as the time she and her sister entered a beauty pageant. Rosin writes:

Like Palin, Nikki Haley had a beauty-pageant moment, but one with a more discouraging outcome. When her sister was 8 and she was 4, the two of them entered the Little Miss Bamberg pageant, Singh told me. In previous years, the judges had crowned one white and one African American winner, but they were baffled over what to do with the two Indian American girls. At intermission, they called all the contestants on the stage: white girls on one side, black girls on the other, with the Haley sisters standing alone in the middle. The judges then announced that they had to disqualify the sisters, and handed each of them crayons and a coloring book. Before ushering them off the stage, they let Nikki sing the song she had prepared, “This Land Is Your Land.”

How could you do that to little girls? Not only is there the issue of segregation, but kicking out two girls of Indian-descent because they don't fit into the pre-selected categories of segregation? So, so wrong!

More than a "mama grizzly," Haley fits the mold of reformer, which is actually a better description of women within the Tea Party. We want to reform this country starting with corruption within our own parties. Many conservative women have had to take on the good ol' boy network before moving onto actual policy debates. I agree with Rosin's assertion here:

It is no accident that the rise of the Tea Party has coincided with the rise of conservative women. According to a Quinnipiac poll from last March, 55 percent of voters who identify with the Tea Party movement are women. The movement’s scattered national leadership is largely female as well: four of the seven board members of the Tea Party Patriots group are women, for example, as is the chairwoman of another group, the Tea Party Express. One of the three main sponsors of the seminal 2009 Tax Day Tea Party event was Smart Girl Politics, a group founded by mothers blogging about politics. “For a long time, people have seen the parties as good-ol’-boy, male-run institutions,” Smart Girl Politics spokeswoman Rebecca Wales told me. “In the Tea Party, women have finally found their voice.”

One way the Tea Party has benefited female candidates -- and the conservative movement generally -- is by consciously steering clear of social issues. When I asked one activist at the Smart Girl Summit about the role of abortion in the movement,

  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
My Ex- Life 5 pts

Its been a few weeks since you wrote this post however I'm glad I finally found it. I too am a conservative Christian but am somewhat open minded to new changes in government. I love to see women stepping up to office and the people stepping up to elect them. Major step forward.

NerdMom 5 pts

Ok, So I agree that based on the title I thought I was going to be reading a different article;). But that said, great piece and I totally agree! I am also a conservative and while I am a social Christian conservative I think we can get more done by trying to get our government to just hold to the Constitution;). I don't feel I have had to compromise any of my Christian values.

Jill Miller Zimon 5 pts

From an academic perspective, the unique nature of Murkowski's path to winning deserves attention. I will be shocked if no one writes that up in detail re: how'd she do it and can anyone repeat it, should they need to, and how does a candidate keep from every having to do it.

RNC Chair - yes - watching it all. Just interested to know if you had speculation about strategies that might be deployed etc. Just for considering - obviously I'm a political junkie - find it fascinating.

Jill Writes Like She Talks ( http://www.writeslikeshetalks.com )

In The Arena: Jill Miller Zimon, Pepper Pike City Council Member ( http://jillmillerzimon.blogspot.com )

Denise 9 pts moderator

I'm from South Carolina and would have liked nothing better than to vote for her. I'm so glad she held on, against all of the horrendous attacks so common in the good ole boy southern political network.

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager
Life. Flow. Fluctuate.

BarnMaven 5 pts

Well, Adrienne, politics isn't what my blog is about, so technically you could say I've done absolutely nothing. I write mostly about my special needs kids, and over time I've garnered readers on both sides of the political aisle. We might be politically disparate, but we do share common ground on things like parenting, the need for better services for our kiddos, some of us connect via our faith and our hope that things can get better.

And there was this, once:
http://www.barnmaven.com/2010/06/woman-eternally-c...

Mary a/k/a BarnMaven blogs at http://www.barnmaven.com about single parenting, living with ADHD, too many animals to count and dealing with ADHD/Bipolar kids.

AdrienneRoyer 5 pts

But I worked as a consultant to her opponent, so I saw a lot of the behind-the-scenes activity. It wasn't pretty.

Personally, I like Wagner or Anuzis. We're at Round 3 now, and Priebus is in the lead with 54, so we have a long way to go. The chair needs 85 votes to win.

Adrienne works in the conservative movement and blogs at Cosmopolitan Conservative. ( http://www.cosmopolitanconservative.com )

Jill Miller Zimon 5 pts

It's the post's title that gave me the expectation I described and I frequently disagree w/Rosin on her perspective so I really went skimming for more content that had to do with the title of the post.

Haley is an excellent case study, as frankly Murkoswki would be as well, and also Martha Coakley in terms of disaster. Lots of lessons to learn all around.

And in the meantime...who do you have your money on for RNC Chair!? (I'm watching in CSPAN while eating lunch)

Jill Writes Like She Talks ( http://www.writeslikeshetalks.com )

In The Arena: Jill Miller Zimon, Pepper Pike City Council Member ( http://jillmillerzimon.blogspot.com )

AdrienneRoyer 5 pts

As I stated previously, I'm not afraid of openly being partisan.

However, on Blogher, I'm one of few against an overwhelming majority. That situation is always difficult for the minority voice and often places me in a corner. If my remarks come across as inflammatory, I do apologize.

I am curious to know what you've done to reach out to conservative women. Since you're so quick to try and call me out, it's only fair to turn the tables. What are you doing?

It takes all types to make a democracy work. That includes those on the left, right and middle.

Adrienne works in the conservative movement and blogs at Cosmopolitan Conservative. ( http://www.cosmopolitanconservative.com )

AdrienneRoyer 5 pts

Completely agree, but read the original article by Rosin in The Atlantic. She spends a considerable amount of time talking about the larger movement, which was the biggest takeaway I got from the article.

Perhaps, I'll write a post praising Haley. Heaven knows she deserves it. I think we can all agree that she set a good example of how to handle pressure with grace and stay focused on issues in the midst of nastiness.

Adrienne works in the conservative movement and blogs at Cosmopolitan Conservative. ( http://www.cosmopolitanconservative.com )

Jill Miller Zimon 5 pts

I'm really disappointed that it doesn't - because she deserves it. Her choices and the circumstances that contributed to her success should be examined and embraced from a completely nonpartisan perspective so that all women who seek success in the elected office arena can understand another example of another path for how it can be achieved.

Jill Writes Like She Talks ( http://www.writeslikeshetalks.com )

In The Arena: Jill Miller Zimon, Pepper Pike City Council Member ( http://jillmillerzimon.blogspot.com )

BarnMaven 5 pts

Perhaps we do need more "middle of the road" writers. You, however, aren't one of them. Your continuous insults to liberal women only serve to widen the divide.

Mary a/k/a BarnMaven blogs at http://www.barnmaven.com about single parenting, living with ADHD, too many animals to count and dealing with ADHD/Bipolar kids.

AdrienneRoyer 5 pts

Barb, I understand your perspective. However, those women seeking to build bridges are few and far between. (See Mary's comments above.)

Living in the Beltway likely thwarts my perspective, but I only see extreme partisanship. I never see women working together, which frustrates me as well.

What you see as stereotypes are realities for me. Just last night I attended a women's event at American University in NW DC with Gloria Feldt. Nearly every single stereotype about feminists was proven, complete with ERA references.

While my writing may seem inflammatory, it's only because that's what is reflected in our Nation's Capitol.

We need more middle-of-the-road writers to step out and provide examples of what's being done.

Adrienne works in the conservative movement and blogs at Cosmopolitan Conservative. ( http://www.cosmopolitanconservative.com )

AdrienneRoyer 5 pts

Walk back from the ledge, Mary.

I'm a partisan conservative. I've never shied away from that. Nor is "diminishing the accomplishments of liberal women" my "schtick."

I've written at length about the accomplishments that liberal women have done for all of us. While I disagree with many of the things that this movement stands for, I do appreciate many of the victories that they earned, particularly in the areas of discrimination, equal pay, rape and custody laws and especially in the areas of abuse awareness. (I've spent a lot of time volunteering on abuse issues.)

How am I being disingenuous? Most feminists link their hatred of Sarah Palin directly to her views on abortion. The abortion debate is at the crux of the Sarah hate.

Given that I'm ONE voice amidst of a sea of liberal women, I call it like I see it. If this solitary blogger bothers you this much, perhaps your movement isn't as strong as you think it is?

When was the last time that a liberal women reached across the aisle to us? Why should I be the one to extend an olive branch?

Adrienne works in the conservative movement and blogs at Cosmopolitan Conservative. ( http://www.cosmopolitanconservative.com )

BarbD 5 pts

My political beliefs fall left of center, and I came of age during the "Our Bodies, Ourselves" era of feminism.

Still, my focus over the past several years has been to seek bridges of understanding across the chasm that divides my beliefs from yours. I appreciated reading the first part of your post about Nikki Haley and other conservative women. I certainly see them as valid representatives of feminism, even though I don't always agree with their positions on the issues our country faces.

In the latter half of your post, though, I think you fall into the same trap you accuse left-leaning women of -- stereotyping the opposition. We are not all stuck on the social issues or Sarah Palin (who gets most of her relevance from left-leaning commentators and websites who cover her every word).

The issues our country faces are too serious for *either* side to keep ignoring each other. How about striving for more of this ( http://www.ted.com/talks/elizabeth_lesser_take_the... ) and less stereotyping?

BarbD

BarbD blogs at The Middle Way ( http://barberra.typepad.com/the_middle_way/ ) about topics that interest her in midlife.

BarnMaven 5 pts

In one paragraph you accuse liberal feminists of being solely focused on abortion rights and in the next you say that you "can't think of one topic that even vaguely unites the movement aside from hatred of Sarah Palin."

Which is it? Are you being deliberately disingenuous?

The basic tenet of "feminism" in and of itself is women's rights. If a candidate truly believes that "no one even cares" about the abortion issue any longer then she is sadly disconnected from her constituents. While there are many women who do not identify strongly either way with a woman's right to choose, there are equally as many who do.

You seem to enjoy diminishing the accomplishments and goals of liberal women, which of course is your prerogative, and which is your "schtick" to gain a lot of page hits. Unfortunately you aren't winning any liberal feminists to your agenda, since you're more interested in handing out insults than in actually gaining cooperation amongst women.

Mary a/k/a BarnMaven blogs at http://www.barnmaven.com about single parenting, living with ADHD, too many animals to count and dealing with ADHD/Bipolar kids.