Bio
Principal of Galvanized Strategies. Erica Holloway is an award-winning former journalist and public and media relations expert with broad experience i...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

NEW HAMPSHIRE: Santorum, Mr. Wrong for Conservative Women

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 22
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Seems this Republican field of presidential candidates can't take a step forward without a few backwards for women voters.

Admittedly, I'm a social moderate, but a Republican nonetheless. Don't raise my taxes, burden my business, add more government to my life, or run the government budget ashore.

You get what you get, and not a penny more.

Don't tread on me.

The Republican candidates -- aside from being all white males - are very different from one another. We have Mormons, Catholics, a twice-divorced man, a father of adopted daughters, a Libertarian isolationist, a senator, a congressman, two governors, a wide range of ages and family compositions.

Yet, it's still a very packed field even with the recent drop-out of Congresswoman Michele Bachmann. If you're a betting girl, then the latest InTrade prediction of Gov. Mitt Romney snagging the Republican Presidential nomination by 83% will interest you.

The candidates have made as many right as wrong steps, in politics as in life -- but they lived the lives they wanted. That's what freedom's all about.

But sharing oxygen with liberals in Washington, D.C. may have squashed the Republican Party's once-important precept: personal responsibility.

No candidate could be speaking further from our modern conservative woman's epicenter than Senator Rick Santorum.

On the surface, he's a likeable and non-threatening guy. He sports sweater vests and dotes on his family. When he smiles, he shows every last tooth.

Rick Santorum
SALEM (U.S.), Jan. 10, 2012 U.S. Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum speaks during a campaign at Town Hall in Salem, New Hampshire, the U.S., on Jan. 9, 2012. (Credit Image: © Fang Zhe/Xinhua/ZUMAPRESS.com)

Here's also a man who overcame great personal loss. I cannot imagine, nor would anyone want to dare face the death of a child. It's a devastating wound that's left a visible scar on his family.

It paints an authentic and painfully human picture.

Yet during Saturday night's debate in New Hampshire and recently on the campaign trail, he's seemingly blaming the nation's problems on American society needing a good swift kick back to the 1950s.

If women just stayed home with the babies, gays didn't marry, and only straight couples raised kids, America wouldn't be in this jobless, endebted tailspin.

Well, Mr. Santorum, I'll bite.

He paints a charming picture, a la AMC's Mad Men-style Betty Drapers greeting dashing Dons at the door with a rye highball and the kids sacked out in front of America's best babysitter.

No abortions, no birth control, only straight and vanilla as far as the eye can see.

Well first of all, God bless the woman who has a job good enough so their husbands can spend more time with the kids or afford daycare or nannies, especially single moms.

It's exactly this sort of silly idealism that the AdoptUSKids campaign pokes fun at in a brilliant and tender way.

On the one hand, Santorum disagrees that gays should raise children, and on the other he rejects the notion of birth control or abortion.

After years of infertility, I'm the last person to agree with abortion. But you cannot stand ground on both ends of the spectrum.

More than 26,000 preteens are currently are on adoption lists in America. While it's plausible for those conceptions to have resulted from inseminations, or worse, abuse, I imagine most were conceived consensually between man and woman.

Santorum recently stated that what's right is "Giving every child in America their birthright, which is being raised by their own mother and father. So we want to encourage what is the best for children."

He's not entirely alone or wrong in these beliefs. Courts struggle across America with giving birth parents another shot at raising their kids, even when evidence mounts against their ability.

But conceiving a child doesn't make one a "parent." Yes, giving birth, as I will blessedly do in April, does make you a birth parent. There are valid ethical concerns around instances of domestic newborn adoption agencies violating birth parent rights. But unfortunately, some people abdicate those rights and that responsibility.

I'd like to give Mr. Santorum the benefit of the doubt; he may have never ventured much outside his Pleasantville bubble.

In my foster parent classes, our caseworkers described endless cases of children born and separated from unfit parents at birth over and over. In one case, one couple raised not one but eight children by the same mother from eight fathers and she had more.

Sure, it's extreme, but true.

With thousands of kids aging out of the foster care system every year, is whether there are two moms or

  • 22
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Violina23 5 pts

I'm your newest fan -- Love this article.  I'm fiscally conservative, mostly liberal on social issues [I'm pro-choice, but anti-abortion if that makes sense -- and I'm VERY pro-gay-marriage].   Right now, the fiscal issues will determine my vote in the next election, because I don't think we can afford to kick the can down the road by just raising taxes and decreeing that people should pay for other people's stuff (instead of questioning why the stuff is so expensive in the first place).   But, while I think I can explain fiscal issues convincingly, I can't explain Rick Santorum and his preposterous views on who is "morally acceptable" to live in this world.  I can't explain his comments on homosexuality or birth control.  I am angered at the idea that he would like to pull funding for pre-natal testing because it might increase abortions. I don't believe Santorum, if elected, has ANY intention to act on these opinions. He's not going to "set women back" by outlawing contraception, forcing women to become 50's housewives, or whatever other hysteria I keep hearing.   But it doesn't matter what I think, it matters what independents think -- and they'll take the bait that Santorum is going to do "horrible things" to women as much as people are taking the bait that whether or not we pay for a 30-year-old law-student/feminist-activist's sexual habits is more important than the economy, jobs, Iran, etc...

victoriakerley 6 pts

You hit the nail right on the head. I concur that sticking by your principles is to be applauded but a continual quest to set many groups back several decades does not in any way constitute the FREEDOM portion of his road show. His momentum will fade as he clears the south and certainly the money and momentum will fade way before he crosses the continental divide.

I try to give every candidate the chance to reach me, but hate and backward thinking are not the way. RS will go away and the quicker the better in my humble opinion. As a Proud LGBT Republican Woman I say...don't mess with my Faith, Freedom or Family. They are all just fine.

@erica_holloway 9 pts

Dear Victoria:

Thank you for sharing your unique perspective.

His personal definition of "freedom" certainly leaves out whole groups of people. It's unfortunate that his candidacy caught fire prolonging these ugly conversations.

Really hope he flames out before he does our party further brand damage.

Best, Erica

victoriakerley

Kathy K 30 pts

With all due respect, the problems with the Republican party are not caused by "breathing the same air as liberals", but rather with the Republican party itself. I say this as an independent. As long as the party trying to appeal to the "base" in the primary, it's going to remain in shambles. This "base" is the far right fringe. The "base" will not win a general election.

@erica_holloway 9 pts

Dear Kathy:

I agree with your assessment. Strategically, the Party aims for the 70 percent or so that identify themselves as "conservative" in the GOP.

However, that eliminates the chance to pick up swings during the primary round. It's a tricky gamble and one that candidates, such as Senator Santorum, must risk in order to potentially receive the necessary funding.

Hopefully, some more thoughtful conversations emerge in coming weeks.

Best, Erica

Kathy K

Conversation from Twitter

williaminsd
williaminsd

erica_holloway Maybe he missed the part about freedom for ALL.

erica_holloway
erica_holloway

williaminsd Bet he didn't. Probably defines "all" a bit differently than you and I.

williaminsd
williaminsd

erica_holloway Our rights are inalienable. There are no asterisks in the Constitution...

erica_holloway
erica_holloway

williaminsd I recall a time when "property" did not necessarily mean land. We're a complicated people.

williaminsd
williaminsd

erica_holloway All part of the journey.Or as Lincoln said in his 1861 speech to New Jersey legislators, we're God's "ALMOST chosen" people.

erica_holloway
erica_holloway

williaminsd Clever. Gonna cite that gem one of these days!

williaminsd
williaminsd

erica_holloway Yeah that Lincoln... pretty darn clever. Now HE would help raise the "cleverness" level of men on Twitter lol...

erica_holloway
erica_holloway

williaminsd No question.

williaminsd
williaminsd

erica_holloway lcrsandiego LogCabinGOP Such a STUPID path to go down... These are the issues that will derail the Republican nominee...

erica_holloway
erica_holloway

williaminsd lcrsandiego LogCabinGOP Agreed. A dangerous slippery slope.

Conversation from Facebook

Erica Holloway
Erica Holloway

Dear Ruthanna: My blog posts are biased - fortunately. Best, Erica

Ruthanna Stiner Morrow
Ruthanna Stiner Morrow

I am not a fan of Santorum but if I hadn't watched the debate, I would be seriously misled by her take on Santorum's views: "If women just stayed home with the babies, gays didn't marry, and only straight couples raised kids, America wouldn't be in this jobless, endebted tailspin." He did not even come close to saying this. He answered the questions put to him (though as Romney said some of the questions were silly) and gave his opinion as requested. Unfortunately, it appears the author is quite biased.

Nelle Douville
Nelle Douville

Bedford is heavily Republican (and wealthiest town in the state.) With a contentious Republican field, I'd expect a heavy turnout. My sister, on the other side of the city, claims things are quieter in her town.

BlogHer
BlogHer

Nelle Douville I was going to buzz you to see if you were going out and would swing by a polling place to see if it was busy. Heh. Good to know the voters are at the polls! - Denise

Sara Abercrombie
Sara Abercrombie

Very interesting

Nelle Douville
Nelle Douville

Hmmmm... not for me to say who they should vote for. That said, RS seems to have personal issues he needs to work out, like how not to continually trash others.

Polling place was quite busy, but this is a Republican town.