We were New Mooned
by Denise

I've been a fan of the Twilight books since long before there was Twilight mania. But the Twilight movie, ugh. I never wanted to see another Twilight related movie again. It was so bad that it was even hard to heckle. And if I can't heckle something... Did I say ugh?

What was I thinking when I agreed to take RJ, her sister and her only slightly hesitant brother to see New Moon - at 7pm on Friday night? I'd like to blame menopause but I think I'll blame Honeybeast instead. It was HER idea.

There we were, in a theater full of screaming, bouncing, hysterical, over-caffeinated tween and teen girls (many of whom were in full Volturi costume.)

I pre-ordered the tickets weeks ago and felt blessed to be able to avoid the madness of that particular line. The refreshment line was a wee bit hyped up but the screaming was minimal (too many parents keeping the girls toned down?)

Then, I saw the line to get into the actual theaters showing New Moon... we were there an hour early and there were hundreds of hormonal teen girls ahead of us. I was frightened and also pleased that we hadn't arrived earlier. At the back of the line, I thought we'd be safe.

The manager of the theater lowered the velvet rope and the masses didn't just swarm, they ran, screamed, pushed, and trampled anything in their path. RJ started to surge along with them but I held out an arm and said "Hello. Are you crazy?" and we walked calmly to the second row of seats and sat ourselves down. Safe. We were safe. Our eardrums, not so much.

The screaming continued for the next three hours. Every time Edward appeared on screen, even when he appeared in a preview for his upcoming, non-vampire related flick "Remember Me". Every time Jacob appeared, particularly if he was shirtless, the screaming started. There was even a bit of screaming for Jasper, bless his heart.

Screaming makes it very hard to nap. Thank goodness for Raisinets (I'm #teamraisinet) and my iPhone. I Chattered/Tweeted and popped Raisinets to survive.

Rather than giving you a review of the movie, let me introduce you to RJ. She's 14 and vampire crazy (those of you who met her at BlogHer 09 can attest to this.) She cut her vampire teeth on the Twilight series but quickly moved to any other book that contains a bloodsucking fiend (Oh wait, she hasn't read Bloodsucking Fiends yet. Must introduce her to Chris Moore, soon!) Sookie Stackhouse is her hero. She's a Buffy junkie. And, I think she's read Dracula (yes, the real Dracula) three times. She also writes a blog called, wait for it, Vampire Vocab. Enough said, here's her review.

I was laughing all the way through this movie. It was simply so melodramatic, it was hilarious. Add that to the screams of delight from the theater full of tweenage girls, and you’ve got LOL comedy.

The fight scenes were charmingly ludicrous: Bella’s frantic screaming, and the wolves’ snarling, and the dramatic slow-mo vampire fight scenes...I was having a giggle fest. Though, I will admit, this movie was far better than Twilight.

While Twilight was depressing and mediocre, in New Moon, the mood was far lighter, the acting was better, and more enjoyable overall (thanks in part to the many scenes in which Taylor Lautner was shirtless.) Edward was more “I am a man of few words” than “I have nothing to say." Jacob was much more observant than in the book, and the transitions to wolf form, and the wolves themselves were actually done well. Jasper, with the two lines he speaks, is hilarious. Alice is...very interesting and likable. Overall, the Cullen family is no longer completely awkward and pathetic, rather, it seems more like an actual family of actual people, albeit actual people with freaky eyes. Charlie is a great dad and actually has a pretty major role in Bella’s life in this movie. I hope that continues in the Eclipse movie.

Now, onto the bad points. Bella’s endless squealing made her sound whiny and immature. Which she is, but still. Edward acts like a dog. He says things along the lines of “I’ll never leave Bella’s side until she orders me away.” (Arf, Arf, good Edward, have a Milkbone!) Seriously. Ick. Also, Jacob apparently takes the “I’m turning into a werewolf” thing to mean “I have license to be mean.” Even though he is a werewolf, (shape-shifter, if you want to get all technical), Jacob isn’t ever really mean in the books. Moody, sure. Resentful towards Edward, absolutely! But not mean. Ever. It takes away from his character. Bad move. The Volturi are more laughable than scary. The matching “V” necklaces that look like the one that Troy gave Gabriella in High School Musical 2 are a bit much. Just a bit, though.

On a scale of 1 to 100, Twi-Hards would give this movie a 100, normal people who have read the books would give it a 60, normal people who haven’t read the books would not understand it enough to rate it, and the unfortunate older brothers who are dragged to it by their sisters would give it a -50. I would give it a 70 because not only am I a recovering Twi-hard, but also, I found it incredibly funny. Especially when it wasn’t supposed to be.

~~RJ

If that's not enough New Moon mania for you, check out some of these links. (RJ and I particularly recommend Jennsylvania. This was the post that we both read right before heading to the theater to watch New Moon. Perfect!)

  • Mommycosm
  • Twilight Tuesday
  • Women and Hollywood
  • Oh and you definitely need to visit Momlogic who not only survived the teen girl screaming but shares an audio clip of what it was like to be in her theater. I felt her pain. I did.

    ~~Denise
    Flamingo House Happenings

    Editor's Note: The older brother dragged along to watch New Moon did not give the movie a -50, he gives it a 40.3.

    Comments

     

    There wasn't a lot of screaming in our
    theatre

    But we did go to the 10:30am screening on a Saturday morning and the theatre was blessedly less than half full. (Yay for teenagers who can't get out of bed before noon!) There was a lot of giggling and a bit of commentary here and there but not a lot of screaming.

    I felt much less inclined to call Jasper "Jasper Scissorhands" this time around. He's growing on me...possibly because he tried to eat Bella. I was disappointed in not being able to yell "Stalker" at Edward as I do consistently through the first one.

    And I still think that Edward looks like a discoball and would look lovely on a Christmas tree. Is there a discoball Edward christmas tree ornament? I think I need one.

    Oh, and the fake husband liked Dakota Fanning and thinks that Edward is a wuss. I think he's #teamvolturi.

    Sassymonkey and Sassymonkey Reads.

     

    Disco Ball! Love it!

    I mean, honestly. It's 2009. Couldn't the sparkling effect be done better? There were better special effects in the 80's, for Pete's sake! I can't get past how HORRIBLE it looks especially considering how beautiful it looked in my mind when I read it. Surely it could have been done better!

     

    @FireMom from Stop, Drop and Blog and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land

     

    Better special effects

    The first picture was pretty low budget, which is what I used to explain away the poor disco ball effect. I had hoped they'd improve the glitter in this one but maybe they wanted to keep it close to the first one, rather than showing just how low budget they were at the start? Or maybe the special effects folks just like wolves better? Maybe they're #teamjacob? hah

    ~Denise BlogHer Community Manager
    Flamingo House Happenings

     

    I like the fake husband

    Because I also liked Dakota Fanning. She's awesome.

    Jasper didn't get enough screentime for you to want to call him Jasperscissorhands, wait for the next movie.

    Love the idea of a disco ball Edward ornament. Surely there is one...

    ~Denise

    BlogHer Community Manager
    Flamingo House Happenings

     

    Hmm, I actually liked the first one . . .

    Now I don't mean to say liked it as in "This is a great movie and should win an academy award" liked it, but liked  it in "This movie is a lot better than I thought it would be" liked it.

    New Moon is pretty much getting slammed by everyone.

    I'm slow, barely finished reading New  Moon, but I'll probably read the other two books just to finish off the series.

    Kalyn Denny Kalyn's Kitchen

     

    One of the reviews I saw on television

    Said something I thought was interesting. I mean, he seriously critically panned it but he also said that whereas the first one had a female director the second one didn't. The first was romance, the second is melodrama. He thought that the romance, which is really the core of the story, suffered because the director of the second one had never been a teenaged girl.

    Sassymonkey and Sassymonkey Reads.

     

    Romance vs Melodrama

    Interesting. Very interesting. There wasn't much romance in New Moon. I think I'd need to read New Moon again in order to decide whether the move to melodrama was the right one or not. (And I'm definitely not going to re-read New Moon, lol.)

    ~Denise BlogHer Community Manager
    Flamingo House Happenings

     

    I thought it was worse

    For me, the first movie was worse than I expected. The second was much better.  And you definitely need to read the other books. Must read so you see what happens with the whole #teamedward/#teamjacob stuff. :-)

    ~Denise BlogHer Community Manager
    Flamingo House Happenings

     

    I hope

    the actor playing Jacob doesn't have that terrible wig job in this one. I didn't like Twilight the movie so much but I still want to see New Moon.

     

    No comment on Jacob's hair

    You'll like New Moon better than Twilight, I can pretty much guarantee that. It's hard not to like anything better than Twilight.

    ~Denise BlogHer Community Manager
    Flamingo House Happenings

     

    LOVED the Review

    I have to say that I did like the movie. I didn't want to and tried not to as New Moon was my least favorite of all four books. However, everything mentioned in the wonderfully written review was spot on. Couldn't say it better myself. Except that I'd add that Bella's BREATHING, not just her squealing, was obnoxious and redundant. Oh, and the wolf changing and fight scenes were too loud for my ears but that's just because I am coming to realize that my oldest son gets his sensory issues from ... me. Sigh.

    Our theater had teens and tweens who were squealing. But so were the Cougars. I remembered why I hate theater experiences in general.

     

    @FireMom from Stop, Drop and Blog and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land

     

    I'm with you on the breathing thing

    I was a little surprised by RJ focusing on the whining and not the breathing. I almost sent her back for a re-write, heh. But, it was her review so I left her alone.

    Not many "cougars" in our theater. There were three moms up front outside of the velvet rope and I'm not sure what happened to them during the stampede. They could have been trampled for all I know. Two women were behind us, by themselves not together. Other than that, no others unless they came in after the majority of us were seated. (Also only about three guys in the whole crowd.)

    ~Denise BlogHer Community Manager
    Flamingo House Happenings

     

    I'm a late comer to the

    I'm a late comer to the books but read them all in two weeks (the first book for me was the best). I had no intention of seeing the movie but I ended up watching it when DH came home with it about half way through the books. It kind of ruined my book characters (especially the supporting ones) but I persisted; ok, I was addicted. I didn't mind the movie. I tend not to compare movies and books because there is no comparison really. They are just two completely different entities. Anyway. I thought about going to see New Moon at the theatres but decided it would be too crazy. Now I know. LOL. I will wait for rentals where I can watch it in the quietness of my abode.

    Moe
    Big Girl Blue, M.E. Wood lens, Large and Lovely, Five Favorite Things

     

    The first was the best

    It was kind of downhill after that, though each book had good things about it. I think the mania will die down and of course if you go to an early morning showing, like Sassymonkey did, you'll probably be able to avoid massive screaming. :-)

    ~Denise BlogHer Community Manager
    Flamingo House Happenings