A few weeks ago I posted something on my Facebook status regarding
breastfeeding support. Most of my friends know that I breastfeed my
daughter, and while I am not of the Breastfeed-or-Die clan I am pretty
well versed in the pros and cons of both breastfeeding and formula
feeding and have opinions on both.
Well, as you can imagine,
my status sparked a conversation with a younger girl with whom I used
to work. In so many words, she stated that she too supports
breastfeeding but she doesn't want to "look over and see boobs in the
middle of Sunday morning mass. That's what cry rooms are for," she
claimed.
Well now. As you can imagine, this struck a chord
with me. As a breastfeeding mother and an equal rights activist for ALL
I was slightly offended. "I'm sorry if I'm mistaken here, but I was
under the impression that cry rooms were meant to be a place where you
take your crying baby, as not to disturb the rest of the congregation.
You'll have to excuse that assumption as I'm not exactly a member of
the church but that is what the name implies. Now, I can't speak for
other mothers, but I can read my baby's hunger cues and get her fed
well before she starts crying, so there's no real need for me to take
her to the cry room, is there?"
I got an immediate response.
"Sure there is. Don't you think that waving your bare breast around in
the House of the Lord, or in any public area for that matter, is
inappropriate?"
Hah! Inappropriate! Boy oh boy.
"Let me
tell you what I find to be inappropriate: First of all, the fact that a
mother who feeds her child formula from a bottle wouldn't have to leave
the room yet I am basically punished for feeding my child the best
possible food for her and blacklisted from any public area while doing
so. Yes, let's reward the mom who feeds her baby what scientists call
"artificial milk." That's right - it's artificial. It's a half-assed
chemical reproduction of the better choice.
"Second of all, I
find it completely inappropriate that society has marked breasts as
first being sexual devices and only second as what they were naturally
intended to be. If GOD has a problem with me using my breasts the way
he intended them to be used in his house then I shall choose not to
visit Him. Although I doubt that is the case.
"Last but not
least, I find it HIGHLY inappropriate that you claim to support
breastfeeding. As a breastfeeding mother, when people tell me something
like what you've just said I hear 'Oh, it's okay to breastfeed, so long
as it's convenient for me and doesn't offend me. Because that's who
it's about anyway, right? Me.'
"I am all for modesty. While I
disagree with the way society has forced our view on breasts as sexual
objects I understand that that is the world we live in and if I feed my
daughter in public I will do so as discreetly as possible. But I refuse
to shy away from giving my daughter what is best and I refuse to be
inconvenienced by people who go out of their way to be offended by it.
I'm sorry if this seems harsh but I am tired of being looked down upon
for making what I believe to be the healthiest, most responsible
choices for my child. I appreciate your opinion but that's not the kind
of 'support' I need."
Cross-posted at http://beatniksbeatonlife.blogspot.com/
Comments
Awesome!
Church is one of those really hard places to breastfeed for me (church sort of screams modesty to me). I generally sit in the crying room with my daughter (throughout) because I find it hard to manipulate her (and all her things!) out of the "main" area quickly. But you do make an excellent point - why not feed her there (esp. if I use a wrap, so I'm not exposing anything)?
Good for you!
My Baby Sweetness
www.mybabysweetness.blogspot.com
I can't agree more
As a former breastfeeding mother and HUGE supporter of breastfeeding I applaud your response to the young woman. I think as nursing mothers all of us at one time or another will be drawn into the debate, especially here in the States, where there is still such a stigma against public nursing. Before I began breastfeeding my son I was convinced that I would not want to nurse in public, but that idea went completely out the window when I realized how often I would be forced to nurse in the car (during the summer, and really? Should I have to nurse in the car? I think not) if I chose not to nurse in public. It was just such a natural act to me. I fell into it easily (I know some of us don't) and didn't see the problem. But of course there were the times I had to defend my choice. Who doesn't, right? Anyway, I loved your response.
http://mami2alittlebalkan.wordpress.com/
Thanks to you both
Thank you both for your comments... There are so few people I know that will jump into that type of a conversation on the pro-breastfeeding in public side that when someone comments and says they feel the same way I do, it is extremely validating.
I find it so hard to believe that people are so uncomfortable with the subjects of not only breastfeeding in public, but also breastfeeding period. Considering that this is how I feed my child it tends to be a big part of my daily conversation and I sometimes forget that some people aren't comfortable with it. Not that I would censor myself, but I am often surprised by the way the look on their face changes from that of comfort to that of disgust or shame or embarrassment.
In terms of support, particularly early support when we're still trying to figure this all out, I didn't have much. I asked my husband if he was okay with my decision to breastfeed and he shrugged and told me, "Whatever you wanna do. Sure." That was the extent of support I received from him.
When we had to stay in the hospital for almost 2 weeks because of jaundice that just would not go away, each time we were readmitted her pediatrician would suspend breastfeeding for 12 hours to see if it was being caused by breast milk, or if it was a deeper issue with Kairi's liver that we would have to deal with. He determined that it was in fact breastfeeding jaundice and kept her for observation but asked that I continue to breastfeed because he agreed that breast is best. My mother on the other hand told me that I was making my daughter sick by forcing her to eat something that she was clearly allergic to.
Several people asked me to quit breastfeeding right out of the gate. Rather than become discouraged (or rather, discouraged enough to quit) I turned their lack of faith into a sort of self support. "I'll show them," I told myself. And I've since proved them all wrong.
But unfortunately some women who are making attempts at breastfeeding could easily become discouraged by the kinds of comments I've received, including those by the girl in my post. If it's something that is so "dirty" or "shameful" that we should be shunned from doing it in the house of God, then could it really be the best thing to do for our children?
While the answer is obvious to me and to you, it often times isn't to a lot of women just starting out. I don't see these types of comments being hushed or silenced any time soon, but I would like to do my part to educate those around me of the joys of breastfeeding as well as the health benefits for both mother and child. Thanks for reading.
(And I've basically written another post in my comments. Go me. HAHA)