Bio
I'm a PR and Marketing pro who's been in the game for 11 years. I've worked with start-ups of all shapes and sizes and Fortune 500 companies. I spent...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

No. You Can't Pick My Brain.

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 39
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I was reminded of this post, which has sat in a Word doc on my desktop for two months, while reading "Can I Pick your Brain," by Kevin Dugan. Thanks, Kevin, for inspiring me to finally get it posted.

I’m not sure where to start with this topic, because I feel like it might offend many people who know me who have asked the very thing.

Gears Inside of a Woman's Head

For close personal friends, I can make an exception, but there has to be a line drawn somewhere.

Several years ago, I had upgraded myself to first class on a flight from LA to NYC, where I was living at the time. As the plane was boarding, I was flipping through the current issue of Wired. Highlighted in the magazine was a book called “Ambitchous” (has since been changed).  It was, ultimately, about how the female psyche can hold one back in business. How we can under-value and under-appreciate what we contribute and our desire to not push too hard or ask for too much because we don't want to be "the Bitch." The author interviewed hundreds of women and is a career psychologist of sorts, as well as having a strong background in business.

I felt a tap on my shoulder, and it was my travel partner handing me a note. I opened it and it said: “Turn to page 76. That’s my book.”

It was the author, Debra Condren (@debracondren) of Ambitchous, seated directly across the aisle from me. The author of the book I just dog-eared a magazine page for to remind myself to buy.

I immediately got up and went to her and engaged in conversation that continued some during the flight and finally into the baggage terminal at JFK. She gave me a galley copy of the book, which I found a huge honor. I devoured it. There were so many eye-opening examples that simulated behaviors and ways of thinking that I’d found myself trapped in. But one chapter hit me the most.

I like to call it "Pay Me." I would cite it, but I loaned the book out ages ago to other powerful females I know but my takeaway was this: Time is valuable, and creative thought is even more so. Don’t undervalue either. As women (and compassionate people everywhere), we like to help and can get trapped in giving our time and ideas away for free because we're afraid to ask for compensation. Or just don't realize it's within our right to do so.

When you are a creative individual who is a “popcorn machine,” as my mom says, who spits out ideas on a continual basis, doling out advice is no big thing. It’s easy to have coffee with someone whose company I enjoy, most who will ultimately take my ideas and somehow help benefit their business. Whatevs.

I used to do this a lot more than I do now, because here’s the thing that I finally came to terms with that helped me start standing my ground: My popcorn machine has value.

Creative ideas and connections are the real currency in this digital economy. We are bombarded with fragmented channels to communicate with, audiences to communicate to and many masters to serve on the business side. Having someone who can view this entire ecosystem, understand your market and then advise you on what is wisest for your company to build brand and business is an invaluable resource. But those advisers are typically under-appreciated and under-monetized.

I am asked on a weekly basis to meet with people for coffee or lunch or cocktails. Requests range from asking if I know someone for a position to resources for an interest to the need for creative advice and consulting to helping to promote an event. There are a lot of needs in LA (and beyond), and it shows this industry is raring to go and bursting with ambition. But, I can’t help everyone.

I do have my own work schedule and my “life balance” that I attempt, and they leave me little free time to “donate” to others. I appreciate that I am seen as a resource for the community, but some of the requests have shown me a repeated trend –- people need ideas. A lot of them.

Strategic and creative counsel is one of the most under-monetized aspects of being in the

  • 39
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
MelADramaticMommy 5 pts

Just found this post through a Tweet from Elisa. Amen and thank you for writing. I got sucked into the same situation. I met someone for coffee. We talked for about an hour. I popped. A lot.

She called me about 2 weeks later to say thanks. She put some of my ideas into practice and her site traffic doubled and she made an appointment with a potential new client. I was happy, for both us. One, because my ideas had value and produced results and she was struggling to get her business off the ground.

When she said she'd like to go to lunch, I agreed. We had lunch and when the check came she paid her portion. I was blown away! I thought the lunch invite was a thank you for my help. I assumed and it bit me in the butt.

I learned a good lesson there. And no, I've never heard from her again.

Melanie @ MelADramatic Mommy

Alexandra Go 5 pts

I really do enjoy meeting with other entrepreneurs and sharing ideas. But I know exactly what you mean; there's a different type of person who isn't sharing anything but is only out to pick up up free help wherever possible.

Those who really like to help others can fall into this trap easily. If you aren't great at valuing your own time - such a common problem for women - it may help you to remember that when you give away too much, you're undervaluing everyone else's time too.

Nicole, thanks for the book suggestion; I just put it on my list.

Morgan Shanahan 6 pts

I live this. I lived it in my full-time salaried job until they laid me off while I was pregnant.

Only then did I realize what a horrendous mistake I had made. Still, every time I hit "send" on an email where I'm quoting my rates (or worse, negotiating them!) I feel that awful churning in the pit of my stomach, fully expecting the response to come back: ARE YOU OUT OF YOUR EFFING MIND? THERE'S NO WAY YOU'RE WORTH THAT!

Although it hasn't yet.

Great post. Thank you for making me realize I'm not the only one with this crazy problem.

the818.com

Cindy0305 5 pts

I found your post to be so timely!  I have this type of situation come up all the time. I did space planning and closet/furniture design for about 5 years, and I always had friends/neighbors/acquaintances asking for advice on how they should lay out their project to do it on their own. I really don't mind helping people out, but what they fail to recognize is that I work on a commission basis: no fee = no pay = no food on the table.

I have given away many, many hours of free services, and your post reminded me that I don't have to work for free. A friend of mine recently brought up this very subject. She is looking for a new job and I offered to help her with her resume and cover letters. She immediately offered to pay me for my time - to which I responded "no big deal, I don't mind helping." She was adamant that I should be paid for my efforts and wouldn't take 'no' for answer. She said basically the same things you mention, that my time is valuable and also that if I hadn't offered to help her, she would have found someone else - and paid dearly for it.

Thanks for the reminder.

renewbee 5 pts

This so resonates with me. I taught microcomputer applications on the college level, as an underpaid adjunct professor, before becoming a Realtor. In real estate, there are many who aren't computer savvy, and I was constantly asked to teach others how to do things on the computer- from constructing meaningful property searches, to building a database or a property flyer, I was constantly giving my time away to others, who often didn't even bring me a mug of our (free to us) office coffee.

I had an epiphany when I was helping a friend to "learn how to find properties focused on my clients' needs". Her phone rang, and realized. She had done this before, more than once. She left the room, engaged in a long conversation, and when she was done, was startled to find, I had not completed her task for her. My answer was, "You asked me to show you how to do this, not to do it for you. You still need help learning how to do this, you will have to ask someone else, because I don't have time to "show you how" again." Hard, I know, but sometimes you just have to call folks out on this sort of behavior.

For some reason, folks were more inclined to "borrow" my time when I was single. Once I was married, they somehow realized I didn't have any extra time to give to them.

It has been so interesting to read the reactions to this article - many of us will, as I did, act much like the author's "popcorn machine", until someone acts as my friend did, and we realize some folks will take advantage of our generosity. I am afraid I gave too much for too long, to the detriment of my own business and personal life. My "teacher" personality caused me to want to help my colleagues learn the things I knew how to do. Teacher's colleges didn't offer any courses when I was in school on how to value what you have to give. It was assumed students would become paid teachers, and that was that.

One of the most difficult things to learn is how to strike a balance, and there have been many invaluable comments in this thread. I wish I had read it twenty years ago.

Candelaria Silva 5 pts

that drive me crazy.  People who really want a consultation but don't want to pay you or people that ask for a proposal and then don't hire you but do use your work.  The image of "pop-pop-pop" is so on.  I also think of myself as a percolator of ideas.  When they come easily to you, it doesn't always occur that those ideas don't flow for other people and that they can be an income stream.

 I have done a lot of free work and will continue to do so .

I don't mind if I've decided to donate my facilitation or training skills to an organization.  This post is so timely because in the past week, I've been asked to do three major things for free for organizations.  I've wondered what message I've sent the universe that this is happening. 

I am working on the art of talking and listening while trying to figure out what a person really wants and deciding if I want to give it away or  get paid for it.  I've actually found myself saying, "It sounds like you'd really like a consultation around this.  This is how I make my living.  I'm happy to talk to you about how we might work together."  And then shut my big,-so-happy to help you mouth up and see if they'll hire me.

http://blog.candelariasilva.com ( http://blog.candelarisilva.com/ )

Good and plenty!

Shelly Kneupper Tucker 5 pts

My situation is a bit different in that I work as a professional storyteller.  though people don't ask to "pick my brain,"  I am constantly asked to perform for free.  "But it's for a good cause," folks say, and "It would be great exposure."  I've been known to tell them, "People can die of exposure."

My solution (because I do like to donate to worthy causes) has been to allow myself one "donated gig" per month.  I'm able to tell clients that if they would like to get on the list I'll consider their requests for a future time.

Sometimes I ask for a tiny "honorarium" to cover my expenses.  I then give them an invoice showing the full price for my performance with their discount figured in to the mix.  I've found that if people don't pay you anything, they assume you aren't worth anything. 

As women, we are taught to be "givers."  We are asked to give until it hurts.  I do not think you are a bit "me-centric" to value your time and your skills. Would they ask the same thing of a man?  I darned sure doubt it.

Have you considered having a business card ready for your "popcorn machine of ideas" and politely handing it to people when they ask to pick your brain?

Great topic ... and always timely!

Shelly Kneupper Tucker

writes at This Eclectic Life ( http://thiseclecticlife.com/ )

Twitter handle: @shellyktucker ( http://twitter.com/shellyktucker )

niseag03 5 pts

Last year I realized my time and talents were being used and abused by friends constantly. I vowed that the new year would being a new leaf turned.  I've unfortunately not followed my vow, and I know in the coming months the demands on my time will be come greater.

I really, really needed to read this right now. It's giving me a much needed reminder that I am more valuable than I've been crediting myself.  I don't mind helping friends, and I've benefited myself from picking friends brains. But I have to draw a line somewhere. The ideas in this post as well as the comments are ones I will be enacting for myself. THANK YOU again.

Denise
Musician's Widow ( http://denise.mattox-live.com/blog )

meg127 5 pts

I love this post! I actually just wrote about this on my blog as well, I called it "Take a Number". 

I do web and graphic design, and get asked a lot for "free advice" . I've worked on an occasional small project that might take me 30 minutes, and only becuse I want to. 

Recently, that has extended to people asking extremley large favors, and then actually setting deadlines for them. In the last  month, I've been asked to work on 5 different things for free, each requiring many hours of design time and research. When I thougnt about it, I realized all I had to do was say "I'm sorry I have paying work that takes priority."

It's good to feel empowered, and I'm so glad you validated that for many of us here!

Meg

http://designsbymeg.com/blog/

lornajane 5 pts

I might freelance one day (I'm currently salaried) and having read this post and the comments I have some good idea.  It seems like its a good thing but, like everything, must be in moderation.  I think I will limit myself to one lunch/coffee per week perhaps, thanks to everyone for the inspiration and discussion!

moomettesgram 5 pts

Thank you for a wonderful piece and a definite wake-up call.

In my younger days I wanted to get an MLS, but it never happened.  As a Research Analyst, it's in my blood to feel I have to disseminate information to people - whether professionally, or for family.

But where do I draw the line as a freelance writer and blog author if I want to retire from my day-job?  There's a fine line between pointing people in the right direction and giving away the farm.

Cindi

Moomette's Magnificents

http://moomettesmagnificents.com/blog

Moomettesgram's Favorite Recipes

http://moomettesgramsrecipes.com

Twitter
http://twitter.com/Mo

Cancocom 5 pts

I think this is a hard subject to have an opinion about. I have benefited from "picking" someone's brain and I have felt like I needed to pay it forward by helping others when asked. I guess I would feel differently if I were an accountant or a lawyer or something in a service industry where people would come and ask my opinion. Since I am a data geek, (and proud of it!) I feel like I have probably benefited from it. 

I also don't find that this phenomenon is specific to the female gender. Today's society is such an information sharing society. The sharing of ideas and asking what other people think about them occurs whether you are a male or a female. 

Michelle

www.einsteinonthebeach2.blogspot.com ( http://www.einsteinonthebeach2.blogspot.com )

Nicole Jordan 5 pts

Wow. I am so humbled and overwhelmed by the response.  Although, I am not surprised.  This is a hot topic.  Something that may have been missed in the post and reply comments on my own blog by some is that I completely support giving some time away, espeically to what you're passionate about.  Maybe it's an 80/20 rule. It's up to you.  Boundaries are key.  Where are yours and are they respecting what you offer? That's what YOU need to come to terms with.

What you might not know about me is that I regularly give time away - emails, FB messages, Tweets, coffees, office mtgs, phone calls, etc. to my peers giving them free counsel. You know why? Because I know they are the kind of people who appreciate it.  Who respect my boundaries and will not just suck me dry for information they need but don't want to pay for.  There is no black and white answer here. 

Everyone needs to decide what works best for them.  I just know that i've learned it's OK to ask for compensation for the value I bring.  It took me a really long time to get here.  But I am glad I've arrived and I'm not going to apologize. 

Thank you for reading.  Thank you for supporting. And thank you for disagreeing.  What matters here is that we're talking and that we are. 

I've been very moved by all the feedback and personal stories.  I'm working on a wrap-up post of sorts to capture the great advice that's being distilled.  Keep sharing.  It helps.  It really does.

Let's keep it up ladies.  Success to all of us in our pursuits.

Cheers,

Nicole

Nicole Jordan http://www.kickingsand.com T: @nicolejordan ( http://twitter.com/nicolejordan )

alyssaroyse 5 pts

I read this post yesterday and have continued to be a little saddened by it as well. I'm a big brain-picker. I love having mine picked, and I love picking others. I think of it as tilling a field, turning the soil, planting things. And as the conversations deepen, a sort of cross pollination occurs, and I think that's what keeps our intellectual ecosystem alive.

I don't say yes to everyone. But I do say yes as often as I possibly can. And I can't recall the last time anyone said "no" when I asked if I could pick their brain. At least in Seattle, I think people know that I am open, and I have found them open to me as well. I know that if I'm going to succeed in both life and business, I'm going to need people to help  me - whether it's a referral or to pick up my daughter. We're all connected, that's how it works. Almost every great opportunity I've "found" has been the result of being able to follow a lead that was offered to me by someone else - either out of the blue or because I asked.

It's ironic to me that this post was on Blogher. If ever there was an example of a hugely successful venture that was successful because people - women, in this case - were willing to freely share their insights and experiences with others, it's Blogher. And the vast majority of us do not get paid to do so. But we know that our sharing is what creates communities - and in many cases it has created businesses, partnership opportunities, friendships and more. And from what I can tell, the founders are very well aware of the gifts that we have all shared and the value it has created.

The key is in knowing your own boundaries and making sure that you don't feel taken advantage of. It's not a case of yes or no, it's a case of how and why. But in my experience, you reap what you sew. And I always choose to share, if I can. And accept what others are willing to share with me.

(this is a much smaller and less "thinky" post ( http://www.seattle20.com/blog/Make-It-Worth-My-Whi... ), but I wrote it before reading this post, after spending a lovely afternoon having my brain picked. I regularly blog - for free - on a site for the Seattle Startup community.)

____________

Alyssa Royse ( http://www.alyssaroyse.com )

JUST CAUSE Magazine ( http://www.justcausemag.com )

TIFFLS 5 pts

As an attorney, I can definitely tell you that people invite professionals out for coffee to "pick our brains".  And from what I hear, the experience of my male colleagues isn't much different.  In fact, they don't always (or even usually) offer to buy us coffee...they "ask a quick question" in line at the grocery store that will have us standing in the parking lot for twenty minutes watching our ice cream melt.  They sit down next to us on airplanes--complete strangers--and say, "Oh, you're an attorney?  Let me ask you something..." and launch into complicated sagas of families divided by estate issues.  My father is in construction, and he gets the same; someone from down the block whom he doesn't really know will knock on the door and say that Fred on the corner suggested he'd be a good person to offer some advice on putting in a deck. 

I don't mind it much; my dad doesn't, either.  I like to help people out when I can, and if they're asking too much I'm a big girl and a professional and I am perfectly capable of inviting them to make an appointment if they'd like to discuss the matter further.  What I do find very interesting is the fact that nearly every group this happens to seems to read it as a slighting of their gender or profession or talent or whatever it is they see as an identifying characteristic.  Lawyers think people do it because they perceive attorneys as overcharging and making so much money that they can afford to give out a little free advice.  Women think it's because they're not valued as professionals.  Artists think it's because their skills aren't valued.  But, in fact, it's simply the way people interact--it's our choice, regardless of our age or gender or profession, whether or not to give away our knowledge and talents.  Personally, I choose "yes" as often as I can.

Mom101 5 pts

I think there are also ways to disagree with a post without being sarcastic ("precious ideas") or attacking the author as small-minded. Perhaps you need to ask for more information from her if something doesn't add up in your mind. Maybe there are more specific examples that would illuminate her point.

Personally, I didn't get me me me out of it at all. What I got--and what I think the commenters here got--was a very generous person who is bombarded by requests for free business ideas and is finally drawing a line. Someone who has spent her life being "you you you" and now is reassessing.

Seems fair to me.

Making millions at Mom-101 ( http://mom-101.com ) ( http://coolmompicks.com )

Cool Mom Picks ( http://coolmompicks.com )

DeanaBirks 5 pts

I am shaking my head because this is so familiar. If people want their questions answered, tell them you'd be happy to do a consultation. Because that's what they're asking for.  They likely aren't going to hire you if you've given great answers because they'll think, "Oh, well I can do it myself if that's all there is to it." And they will walk away not really valuing you or your advice.

My dad runs a business and when people ask for advice, he tells them he can come to their home and give them an estimate.

If your business is organizing, then your knowledge and experience are what you're selling and it's not fair for people to expect you to give them all the answers for free. A doctor or lawyer would tell them they can come into the office for an appointment.

Deana Birks Eat. Drink. Read. Blog. ( http://www.deanabirks.com )

aishazoe 5 pts

While I do understand that time and effort has certain monetary value, I can't tell you how lost I'd be without the time and energies mentors have offered me. I try very hard to pay it back in kind, but really without their 30 minutes of career advice (or sometimes even free legal advice) I probably wouldn't be as savvy as I am today.

I think of it was this way: if people are going to use my work or ideas in a commercial way, I should be paid for that. If they need guidance or a push in the right direction, then that should be free.

--Aisha O'Brien--

DeanaBirks 5 pts

It's not that something is wrong with you; it's that our culture grooms women to be this way. Men would not give it all away for free, not would they feel like huge jerks if they said no, but women really struggle with it.

Deana Birks Eat. Drink. Read. Blog. ( http://www.deanabirks.com )

DeanaBirks 5 pts

It doesn't look too direct; it just looks professional.

Deana Birks Eat. Drink. Read. Blog. ( http://www.deanabirks.com )

Susan Getgood 5 pts

I've finally started pushing back. And I still give away too much for free. 

Bookmarking this one for the next freebie request.

Susan Getgood blogs at Marketing Roadmaps ( http://getgood.com/roadmaps ), Snapshot Chronicles ( http://snapshotchronicles.com ) and Snapshot Chronicles Roadtrip ( http://snapshotchronicles.com/roadtrip ).

yogini cowgirl 5 pts

It's clearly not a popular sentiment on your blog, but your post completely depresses me.  Not because you don't deserve to be compensated for your time or precious ideas ...I'm sure you do.  But because it's so "me-centric" and small minded to think that generously offering your time, your ideas, your help, is considered a bad thing in this day and age.  

We live in a "me, me, me,"  "I, I, I,"  "mine, mine, mine," world ...it's no wonder it's all falling apart.

Jory Des Jardins 5 pts

I sometimes get notes from people I know marginally: "You two just HAVE to get together and have coffee." READ: "You have to help my friend out. I don't mind when I get this from good friends and colleagues--and if I can't help someone I'll be pretty frank about it. But if you don't manage these requests it can take up an awful lot of precious time.

I actually wrote about brain-picking some time back, because yes, it's a problem if you don't manage it:

http://www.jorydesjardins.com/pause/2009/11/the-en... ( http://www.jorydesjardins.com/pause/2009/11/the-en... )

 and Part II (yes, there was a part II)!

http://pause.typepad.com/pause/2009/11/the-entrepr... ( http://pause.typepad.com/pause/2009/11/the-entrepr... )

Jory Des Jardins writes on business and career topics at BlogHer, and on her personal blog From Here to Autonomy ( http://www.jorydesjardins.com )

afreshspace 5 pts

This post so hits home with me - as a professional organizer - whenever I mention what I do - people always get very excited and want to talk about their organizing issues.  Which is great.  Except then the whole conversation is me answering all of their organizing questions.  And most of the time I really don't mind but as a business owner wanting to grow my business, sometimes I get frustrated with it not generally turning into anything more.  I look at it as connecting with them as the expert and potentially getting a referral out of it but it doesn't always work that way.  It's a fine line I feel like I walk every day.  I love what I do and love to talk about it but then how my "brain picking" can I go with before I just don't want to anymore.

Liz Jenkins :: a fresh space :: home staging and thoughtful organization :: www.afreshspace.com ( http://www.afreshspace.com )

Kim_Mance 5 pts

I get invited on these multiple times per week. Thanks for the sensible nudge, I'm going to start naming these consultations instead of coffee.

Kim Mance
Editor-In-Chief, Galavanting ( http://www.gogalavanting.com/

SweetWICK 5 pts

I never thought of that this way!  I feel sooo guilty!  I have "Picked" the brains of many people I admire (although I always paid for the coffee or lunch:o).  I have had people come to me and ask mutlitudes of business questions.  At first you feel that it is your duty to share the knowledge, but there has to be a point where you're entitled to benefit from the session also, isn't there?  If a prominent individual responded to me as you did that they don't like doing the PYB sessions for free..I would honor it, and in fact it would make me want to pick the brain of such a confident person even more.  If they are worth that much, maybe I can be, too.  THANKS FOR THE POST

www.ineedacanoe.blogspot.com ( http://www.ineedacanoe.blogspot.com )

~*~Eneida~*~

Melissa Ford 5 pts

Love this post, and I'm sitting in a room with two other women, with two of us helping the third build her website (for free!).  So you have kicked off a great discussion in here, especially the part where we told the third woman that she owes us $300 :-)

I both agree and disagree.  Sometimes I see the giving of ideas or information as a barter, with my item coming at a later, unknown date.  Sometimes I don't know in the moment how the connection will help later on; I just trust that it will.

Though I only do those sort of meetings when I have time.  When it isn't detracting from another part of life.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

kdc521 5 pts

That's what my husband calls it...my tendency to give away everything for free (including information). 

It's interesting.  I didn't have this challenge when I was working in corporate America. It was very clear that time and energy = money.  I became really bad about this once I began working for myself in the parenting area.  Recently, I had to get strict with myself/set some firm boundaries.  For family and friends, I don't mind my brain being picked (within reason).  For businesses that are making money off my input....they get 10 minutes tops (since I bill in 15 minute increments).

Reminding myself that my time is even more valuable now (simply because I am saying "no" to more things in order to say "yes" to others) helps me to not feel "guilty".

-Kimberly/Mom in the City

Deb Rox 5 pts

My consulting partners and I talk about this often.  Often.  When to invest in sharing ideas, building relationships, showing what you can offer, and when to make a turn towards getting paid for the popcorn.  I tend to handle it a few ways.  One thing is to name PYB for what it is, consulting, even if you are giving some away.  I play it fluid, but do set boundaries.  Perhaps brainstorm a bit, and then say "I'd love for you to think about signing on as a client, and then we could really move some of these ideas into actionable concepts and strategies for you."  One of my colleagues has a firm policy--"I'd love to do some consulting with you on that topic, and my first half hour is free so we can both see what might be possible.  I'll bring an NDA and contract with me in case we want to formalize a relationship."

Deb
www.debontherocks.com ( http://www.debontherocks.com/ )blog
www.3smartgirlz.com ( http://www.3smartgirlz.com/ ) consulting

katstone 5 pts

Awesome post.  I have a huge problem with this.  I give everything away for free. 

I'll have to read that book.  My psyche is clearly messed up.

Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com ( http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com/ )

Boston Mamas 5 pts

I immediately clicked over to this post because whenever someone asks to pick my brain the phrase is like nails on a chalkboard for me.

When it's a business contact, I respond that I'm happy to consult and here are my rates. If it's a really close friend then I'm usually happy to just talk and share openly. But then there's that grey area -- someone you know in a friendly way, but isn't a super close friend, and is asking you for business advice.

As Facebook continues to connect with me with lots of people from my past, I've had this sort of thing crop up a lot. My husband gave me great advice on how to handle it, noting that part of my job now is to educate that this kind of advice is what I consult on. So here's what I do: explain my professional services in the context of what they are asking. Then offer something like a 10% discount on my rate as a nod to our personal relationship. Another recent tweak is that if the person works at a non-profit, if there' s no budget and I really like them and their mission, I tell them I can do a 15 minute phone call gratis.

It's worked brilliantly so far. People either don't respond (fine by me... it means they aren't willing to pay), respond and pay me for my time, or if they are in bucket C (no budget, but still want to talk) I can give them a short window of my time but not be overwhelmed by their requests because it is very firmly delineated.

http://www.bostonmamas.com/ (parenting blog) | http://www.poshpeacock.com/ (design work + blog) | http://popdiscourse.com (personal blog)

sharonmostyn 5 pts

Nicole, your article is wonderful - I'm Tweeting it, bookmarking it, and printing it out for the next time someone wants to pick my brain without any opportunity for something in exchange.

I'm always happy to help, but sometimes I need a reminder to maintain a balance between what is ok to share for free and what I need to keep for myself or only share if I get something in return. A copy of this post will be my gentle reminder when the scales get a bit unbalanced.

Thank you,

Sharon Mostyn

http://sharonmostyn.com

Twitter @sharonmostyn ( http://twitter.com/sharonmostyn )

miguelina 5 pts

I'm taking your post and forwarding it to all the brilliant women I know that are giving it away for free.

Creativity is valuable and I don't understand why we continue to undervalue our own.

PYB syndrome drives me insane. In fact, I have a dedicated page on my blog that I send to anyone that asks to pick my brain, or to "help them get the word out" -- perhaps it's too direct for some, but they need to know what they're getting into.

HOW TO WORK WITH ME ( http://www.everydaytreats.com/2010/01/how-to-work-... )

.html

Mata H 5 pts

I loved this article. It made me think of the old Ruth Brown tune ( http://lyricsplayground.com/alpha/songs/i/ificants... ) about a chair-- "If I can't sell it, I'll sit down on it. But I sure ain't gonna give it away."

That having been said, I will do free informal consults for non profits or for worthy struggling small businesses that couldn't afford to hire me. And of course the friends and extended family rule applies with me too. I might preface a free consult with some humorous comment that "I usually charge for this, but for you -- a one time only freebie!" , just to let the party know that this is a favor, not something to expect.

I have no problem being generous with what I know, if it can be of real use --  I just am selective about where that happens.Saying no can be fun ..."Gosh, I'd love to help - but  I can't charge my clients and not charge you -- it wouldn't be fair to them."  "Sure, pick my brain -- I'll get a quick letter of agreement over to youlater today. Once we get that executed, you can pick away."  OR I will barter. Quick consult in exchange for merchandise -- that works too. Pick my brain, and let me pick your products.

~~ Contributing Editor, Mata H. also blogs right along at Time's Fool ( http://timesfool.blogspot.com )

Rita Arens 7 pts

I am something of a popcorn machine myself, and I used to give it away all the time. Now I've started realizing that my opinions are based on experience that not everyone has. That knowledge inspired me to change jobs when I realized I had something to offer that was a little bit unique. I wish more women -- particularly women writers -- would demand a fair wage for what we do.

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy ( http://bit.ly/Qp0sS ) and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak ( http://tinyurl.com/9pg62e ). She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

lizmacniven 5 pts

I would add that I believe that people always value it more if they have to pay you something, even if a really nominal amount. 

I run workshops as an introduction to my coaching practice.  Many coaches do this for free.  I decided I had done enough over the years for free and I wasn't going to do it anymore.  So I charge a small, very affordable amount and guess what.... my 'no show' rates are really low and the feedback is fantastic.

My Mum always told me 'you get what you pay for'! I think she was right.

Working to encourage as many women as possible to practice 'extreme self care' at least some of the time.

www.justimaginecoaching.com ( http://www.justimaginecoaching.com )

loraleechoate 5 pts

...because I decided her idea and words were so awesome I didn't need time to develop and write my own.

;P

LindsayDianne 5 pts

For me... The important thing is having connections. I would rather spend the time talking to someone (I might learn something) from them....

Obviously if I do taxes for a living, I'm not going to do someones taxes for them, but if one person asked me a question about line 29... Then I'll give them a brief explanation. 

But if I'm a ... "popcorn machine of ideas".... I'm keeping those to myself.

Your opinion, and expertise is "worth" something. I'm glad you've realized that. No one is going to pay you for something you'll give away for free.

Mom101 5 pts

I have no problem with brain-picking when it stems from an actual relationship. Friends, family, co-workers are all welcome to call me up and seek my counsel, as I will do for them. It's one of the great things about women, I think.

It just seems like lately, it's become a sneaky way for people--people you don't know-- to ask for free consultation. Pitch after pitch has been flooding my inbox from PR reps, publicists, small marketers, college students, other bloggers, all asking to "pick my brain" or give them 30 minutes of my time or review their website or fill out this survey or that, or sit down over coffee for an hour, or stop by their offices, or...or...or...

It's overwhelming.

What's hard for me is that I am hard-wired to help people. It's in my DNA. I want to help.

But I also need to value what I can offer enough to say no where it's warranted.

Making millions at Mom-101 ( http://mom-101.com ) ( http://coolmompicks.com )

Cool Mom Picks ( http://coolmompicks.com )