Bio
Mary Tsao lives in Silicon Valley and is married to a computer geek. A former technical writer who survived both the dot com boom and the dot com bust...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Pomp and Prejudice on the Pageant Circuit

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 5
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

The horrible death of JonBenet Ramsey is back in the news with the false confession of John Mark Karr. And with pictures of her made-up face and fancy dresses, the world is once again reminded of Ramsey's life as a darling of the pageant circuit.

Mommyblogger Lindsay Ferrier of Suburban Turmoil recently attended a baby beauty pageant and wrote about it for the Nashville Scene:

"So you’re watching a bunch of heavily made-up girls wearing blond wigs, painted-on tans and bikinis wriggle their butts on a stage to the beat of suggestive dance music. Maybe you’re at an upscale strip club. Or better yet, you scored an invitation to a party at the Playboy Mansion.

Or maybe you’re sitting in a conference room audience at the Opryland Hotel while a bunch of toddlers strut their mini-stuff for a panel of pageant judges.

That’s how I spent my Saturday. After receiving a postcard about the Dixieland Dolls and Darlings National Pageant, I knew fate was telling me to check out the baby beauty queen scene for myself. I didn’t think it could possibly be as bad as the media would have us believe. As it turned out, I was right.

It was worse."

During the pageant, she witnessed the tense relationship between a stereotypically overbearing stage mother and her barely two-year-old daughter. On her personal blog Lindsay writes about The Problem with Pageants and explains how she felt watching this mother/daughter interaction:

"I felt sick. How could a child who just turned two be expected to smile and perform on cue? And why was her mother so angry when she didn't? Surely she knew this might happen. All of us with toddlers know that the moment we most want them to display their knowledge of the alphabet or "Twinkle Twinkle" is the moment they choose not to perform."

It's not difficult to find articles written describing the dark side of pageant life and highlighting the evil parents responsible for pushing their children at any cost. Kariba of Right in Canada points us to an article in the Harvard University Gazette, "The Whys and Woes of Beauty Pageants"

Via Amelie Gillette of Political-Nutshell Dot Com, we learn that four four has uploaded the HBO documentary Living dolls: The Making of A Child Beauty Queen to YouTube. She describes the documentary:

"From the gay couple who coach their 7-year-old daughter to flirt with the host, to the herky-jerky modeling style called "Pro-Am," to the ridiculous pageants themselves, it all seems too over-the-top, too perfectly absurd to be real. But it is. And, really, it's amazing."

Bringing us another opinion about the prejudice against stage mothers, Contributing Editor Suzanne Reisman recently wrote about Stereotypes about Motherhood, Family Life, and the JonBenet Ramsey Case. She asks, "what is easier than to point the finger at a pushy mom who oversteps her role? Reportedly, JonBenet liked being in pageants. Why can’t people accept that?"

And in defense of her peers, pageant mom dreahwrites on Associated Content explains that "anywhere you have precocious children in the public eye you will have pushy parents."

She also notes that the media attention surrounding JonBenet Ramsey did nothing if not help promote pageants. If that's the case, looks like they're here to stay.
---

BlogHer Contributing Editor Mary Tsao also blogs at Mom Writes.

Image credit: Garden Pary Collection

  • 5
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Mary Tsao 5 pts

I particularly like:
* Loves her kids and hugs mine
* Knows how to say no to her darlings...

To shower a child with love doesn't mean that you give them everything they want, when they want it. "Spoiled" is not a word that I want used to describe my kid.

I think you've covered all of the basis with this list -- go, hottest mama!

Mary
BlogHer Contributing Editor, Mommy & Family ( http://www.blogher.com/topic/mommy-family )
Mom Writes ( http://marytsao.blogspot.com )

Lisa Stone 6 pts

If not, Deb can save you from another tour :) - check out How To Sew, Part Two: Stitching ( http://www.blogher.com/node/10559 )

Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder ( http://www.blogher.com/member/lisa-stone )
Surfette ( http://surfette.typepad.com )

JennaHatfield 11 pts

I was helping Denise look for a flower girl dress for Munchkin recently (for a wedding they are in this December). Ever traversed through teh intraweb and look for flower girl dresses? You get a lot of pageant dresses, too. Looking at these teeny tiny little girls with fake ass smiles and more makeup than my Grandma made me want to weep.

Or vomit.

I'm sorry. But kids are cute without makeup and bikinis. I promise you. :)

Family Living; Hatfield Style ( http://www.thejhatfields.org/blog ) - Our Family Blog
The Chronicles of MunchkinLand ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.wordpress.com ) - My adoption blog.
Jenna

Lisa Stone 6 pts

Child pageants I cannot even bring myself to laugh about or poke fun at, I find them so horrifying. But what say you to this: I see in a Hottest Mom in America ( http://www.blogher.com/node/10646 ) contest being pimped promoted in our very own forums! What timing. So I'm thinking they may need a little bloggy help with their criteria, angles they just might not have thought of... The hottest mom:

* Doesn't talk about her children in front of them, unless it's lavish praise or code that means "if you don't thank this woman for the cookie/compliment/correction she just gave you in the next five fucking seconds, you are DISOWNED"
* Doesn't insist that other women who discuss their kids with her call them "The Children"
* Alternates "shit!" with "s-word" when my four-year old is in the room, but forgives me when my kid reports to the room that her son's name "Tucker" rhymes with...
* Has single friends and, instead of sending them 200-word emails on why she and The Children are soooooo busy this weekend, actually SEES them in person on weekend nights
* Doesn't allow [male] partners say they are "babysitting" their own kids in her presence, a phrase typically uttered as a guilt trip as she is leading their wife out the door (probably to tequilas with friends who are still single and don't have to put up with this).
* Reads and votes.
* Knows how to say no to her own darlings and does so, regularly.
* Knows when to take a break, a drink, a well-timed temper tantrum, and when not to.
* Loves her kids and hugs mine.
* Doesn't enter her baby girls in pageants. Or herself.

Okay, what am I missing...?

Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder ( http://www.blogher.com/member/lisa-stone )
Surfette ( http://surfette.typepad.com )

DSW123 5 pts

Just wanted to say that you truly are making a huge deal out of the beauty pageants and if you ladies are as well educated as you seem to be then why not use your time and abilities in actually helping with real problems in the world. Just wondering if you ladies really do care about those little girls that you think are being so mistreated. Those little girls are usually very spoiled, very well taken care of, and lacking anything -even their mothers love. Now with that being said why don't you look into the mother in the grocery store that is loosing it on her 2 yr old in the grocery cart. Yeah we've all seen them haven't we? Do you ever stop and either try to help or at least step up if the situation seems to be turning abusive? I doubt it but I could be wrong. You need to turn your intentions in other directions. Leave the pageant schene alone. If you don't like it -simple- don't watch it.