What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

“You Don’t Look That Old” is Not a Compliment

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Due to the federal Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA), it has long been illegal in the U.S. to discriminate against workers based on age. Not that the law discourages companies much from maintaining young-only work environments. Horror stories abound (I have a few of my own) and it’s not just old folks who are affected. Age discrimination begins striking women as young as 35. In men, it begins at about age 40.

Until 1 October 2006, when new legislation went into effect, England had no age discrimination laws. Ever since the legislation was enacted two years ago, corporate Britain has been screeching that all business will come to a halt if they can’t fire old fogies just for getting wrinkly. The law has now been in effect for two months with no discernible breakdown in commerce.

Meanwhile, one Francesca Pagnaccio has been living the real story of age discrimination. Writing in the Times of London last weekend, she explained:

“Last January, amid the season for resolutions and job hunting, my conversation with a recruitment agent took a depressing turn. ‘So how old are you, Francesca?’ she asked. ‘Thirty-eight,’ I told her brightly. Yes, 38 and shifting career into the high-paying world of information technology. ‘Oh. Never mind,’ she replied. ‘I know what it feels like to be old — I’m 28.’”

[Never mind, too, that a 28-year-old believes she is old. That’s a story for another day.]

Fed up with the lack of enthusiasm for her age from potential employers, Francesca reversed two digits of her birth date on her resume from 12/18/1967 to 12/18/1976 effectively lopping nine years off her age. Two weeks later, with employers believing she was 29 instead of 38, Francesca landed a job.

For the next year, she avoided conversation about age so as not to reveal her lie, and she found it to be liberating. Thinking of herself now as 29, Francesca carried on a romance with a 23-year-old man – until, she says, she realized he had his whole life ahead of him and she didn’t. (From my perspective of 65, 38 seems young enough to still have a lot of living ahead, but that’s another story for another day.)

Francesca says that she made a pact with herself to live as much as possible with no conversation or curiosity about age and found it nearly impossible to achieve because

“…people are so eager to tell all: twenty-somethings are gagging to divulge how bloody young they are; thirty-somethings often think they really look 20-plus so they’re dying for you to ask; and people in their early forties want to let it all hang out. From 50 to 80 there’s a period of calm until 90-plus when you are potential material for The Guinness Book of Records. But at every stage there remains the need to hear that time-worn platitude: ‘But you don’t look your age.’”

Francesca makes an important point. It is no different in the United States and as long as everyone – employees and employers; women and men; young and old - is desperate to appear younger than they are, age discrimination will continue. As long as people Botox, lipo and cosmetic surgery themselves into grotesque facsimilies of the human form to hear that coveted phrase, age discrimination will cut short professional lives when there were years and even decades of productive work left in those kicked out of the workforce for what? For not looking young.

Age discrimination is notoriously hard to prove in general and is further hindered by the fact that corporations employ in-house counsel who get paid whatever their assignment while plaintiffs must pay an attorney $300 or $400 or more per hour. You can guess who wins most cases.

So next time you’re preening when someone says, “you don’t look that old,” why not instead say something like, “I know you think that’s a compliment and I appreciate your intentions, but I’m comfortable with my real age and don’t mind revealing it.” If enough people do that, we’ll begin to make a dent in age discrimination – maybe even before you become a victim.

* Contributing Editor Ronni Bennett also blogs at Time Goes By - What it’s really like to get older.,

  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
laurie 5 pts

It's illegal, at least in Canada, to ask a potential employee your age. I would never put my birth date on a resume nor would I advise anyone else to do so (nor would my MIL, a career-counselor).

laurie
www.notjustaboutcancer.blogspot.com ( http://www.notjustaboutcancer.blogspot.com )

maryrwise 5 pts

I love Elana's comment: "This is what 55 looks like!" I turn 55 next week, and I will also adopt that answer. That is, assuming that people actually say "You don't look 55."

Also, I've never lied about my age. My dad used to say "Liars need good memories" -- and I haven't got one, so I don't lie.

The Blog: Red Nose ( http://bozoette.typepad.com )
The Book: Girl Clown ( http://www.lulu.com/content/45470 )

sassymonkey 97 pts

But people put their birthdates on resumes? Really?

Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.wordpress.com/ ), Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.wordpress.com/ ), and Sassymonkey Eats ( http://sassymonkeyeats.wordpress.com/ )

heivilinj 5 pts

I wasn't necessarily taught to revere my elders but that philosophy came through in what my parents did teach me (as well as my grandparents). And ever culture that I've studied seems to have some aspect of it.

But if that's what we learned at home, why do we now lie about our age? Why are women who are 20somethings considered more attractive that ones who may have a few stories to tell and a *reason* for opinions she has?

Jim Heivilin

Virginia DeBolt 9 pts

How about collecting some photos of real elder faces: the unretouched out here. Then show a real gallery of "what 55 (or 65 or 75 or 85) looks like."

You can't tell from the itty-bitty photo next to my posts, but my face is a deeply carved road map of southwestern sun, living with smokers, and 65 years of growth. Personally, I think it's a perfect match for the gray in my hair and the brown liver spots on my hands.

http://www.webteacher.ws/
http://first50.wordpress.com/

Elana Centor 5 pts

As a college student in the early 70's, Gloria Steinem was one of my heroines. I do remember Steinem's 40th birthday and her response to the reporter who thought he was complimenting her by saying 'you don't look 40."
Steinem's response, "This is what 40 looks like. We've been lying for so long, who would know?"

So, Ronnie, when people say to me, you don't look 55 I will stop smiling and saying thank you and instead I will say, " This is what 55 looks like."

elana
Blogher Contributing Editor,Business&CareersFunnyBusiness ( http://funnybusiness.typepad.com/funnybusiness )

Joared 5 pts

I'd sure like to see the momentum build across this country and others, resulting in those of us at all ages responding in just the way you suggest, Ronni. I've actually been doing more of that as a consequence of some of your ideas. How else do we make people aware unless we speak up?

I've never denied my age, but in retrospect I am aware that in past years, primarily in work environments, I probably avoided mentioning the years on occasion after I reached a certain age. I ceased taking that "precaution" a few years ago, but still find myself wondering if there are repercussions with my revelation.

I am reminded, and find it a pretty sad commentary, that an organization such as "40 Plus" had to be established in this country so many years ago due to age discrimination in the workplace affecting men and women.

I wonder if our younger people realize how at risk they are -- they think it will never happen to them, but it may only be a matter of time. For their own futures they need to get on this band wagon.

Joared-along.blogspot.com

Jane Byers Goodwin 8 pts

It feels the same as 25, only with creaky knees. I turn 55 next week, too, and I really don't care. Well, usually.

Seriously? We are every age we've ever been, and if we're doing it right, we remember how it was to be all those ages. Put it all together, and you have. . . us.

"Let Joy and Innocence prevail; believe that Love will never fail."

Liz Rizzo 5 pts

OMG, I *love* that! I'm totally using it from now on.

Liz Rizzo ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/liz-rizzo )

I blog at Everyday Goddess ( http://everydaygoddess.typepad.com/ ), The SexySmart Blog ( http://sexysmart.typepad.com/ ), and On The Lot ( http://community.thelot.com/blogs/lizriz ).