Blog
Zandria.us
Bio
Hi! My name is Zandria, and I live in Washington, DC. I wrote for BlogHer.com for over three years (on topics related to single life and online datin...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Childless by Choice

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

There are quite a few places where mothers, and potential mothers, can find information and support. Less talked about are members of the childfree movement, or women who are childless by choice. It's not as easy being a member of this group as you might think. There are endless questions to dodge, societal expectations to ignore—especially if you're married, in a committed relationship, or past a certain age. You might have to deal with guilt heaped on you by family members, constantly asking about the possibility of a grandchild. You might find that longtime friends drift away because they have children and no longer feel like they can relate to you. People might even go so far as to accuse you of being selfish.

Proponents of the childfree movement are quick to separate it from the term "childless." Childfree denotes a conscious choice, not simply an inability to get pregnant. This is not a temporary state of mind for a woman who thinks she might want children at a future point in time, but a lifestyle decision. From Spotted Elephant:

I describe myself as childfree, not childless [emphasis hers]. I chose not to have children. I am not suffering from the lack of children in my life. As this is my chosen state, I am quite happy about things. Pity is neither needed nor desired.

Elisa Gonzalez Clark wrote this article in an open-letter format for the San Francisco Chronicle, calling it "Off the Mommy Track."

When you showed me your freezer filled with a three months' supply of stockpiled breast milk, I had to turn and confirm you were the same girl who would jump into the mosh pit and hold her own with misogynist skinheads. And when you were ecstatic over the 10th pink baby outfit, I had to squint to see the same girl who would gyrate until 3 a.m. and then make out with bad boys on the sides of cars in the gritty twilight. [...]

I chose to take my road without children. It doesn't make me shallow or immature, it makes me realistic. If I had children it would be to satisfy other people, not me. I am a lover, daughter, sister, writer and friend. I don't need the label of mother to make me more. I am enough.

Another one from the San Francisco Chronicle, Kids R Not Us.

[Christine] Fisher knew as early as third grade that she did not want children. She had no interest in games that involved playing house or cooing over babies. In the world of childfree men and women, she is what's known as an "early articulator."

In the 1950s, there was an assumption that everyone would get married, then have children. [...] As many as 80 percent of people thought that staying single and childless was "deviant or abnormal," [professor Stephanie Coontz] said. But in the 1970s, amid turbulent social change...those assumptions were challenged. These days, the "vast majority" of people think it is acceptable not to have kids or marry.

Some statistics suggest more women now are childless by choice, but it's hard to come up with a firm estimate because women, on average, are having children older, and demographers don't usually ask why they don't have them. The National Center for Health Statistics confirms that 6.6 percent of women between the ages of 15 and 44 called themselves voluntarily childless in 1995, up from 2.4 percent in 1982. And according to 1998 U.S. Census Bureau statistics, 19 percent of women 40 to 44 were childless, compared with 10 percent in that age group in 1976.

Soon after the launch of the parenting website Babble.com, they included an essay by Lisa Gabriele. (Seemingly at odds with their dominant theme, it's the first in a series called "Notes From a Non-breeder.")

Now way back, my friends and I all vowed that we weren't going to allow being parents to change us, to turn us into conservative, frazzled neurotics. I hope it doesn't sound smug to say that I seem to be the only one who took those vows seriously. You may think it's inappropriate to speak to children the way I do, but I've always been of the firm belief that we talk down to them way too much. Also, I like to remain unalloyed in their presence because children have the best bullshit detectors around.

Laura reprinted an article about the childfree movement, called "The New Breed," found in the Summer

  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
BeccaP 5 pts

Look at the stats for children in foster care in the U.S.....maybe we, the child free, are being selfish in not fostering or adopting, and maybe those that have their own children when there are already so many children without familes are being selfish, too...just a thought...

http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/stats_research/...

BeccaP 5 pts

Suddenly I find myself surrounded by female co-workers of all ages that have children & in a neighborhood of idyllic families with children. I announced when I was 5 that I would adopt a child at 35 if I wanted a child. I remember this moment vividly because I had such clarity. I am 40 now, in a committed relationship, & I can imagine, in a dreamy fog, wanting to have a child with him, but I cannot envision having a child in reality. I have 8 animals..where would I put the crib? I am fully aware of what an outsider I am. Most women are at a loss as to what to talk to me about, especially those under 60. Post-menopausal women, especially happy ones, seem to "get" me more. I sense that my independence and my choices are threatening in some way...shouldn't be as they make me who I am and have nothing to do thing with anyone else. I often hear statements like, "It's different when you have a child...with a dog you can just put it in the other room." Well, I would never put my dog in the other room if I had some work to do. To me that is as neglectful as locking up your 2 year old in the car to go get groceries. I would also never say to a mom, "Well, it's different when you don't have children, you can commit to doing your job well." I wouldn't say that, because it isn't true. Children aren't an excuse for bad behavior, they don't get you to heaven, they don't make you smarter or nicer or holier. If being a mother got you those things we wouldn't have so many bad mothers, so many bad parents, so many bad choices, so many neglected children. It is such a disservice to women as a whole to divide ourselves on either side of the child line. It is heartbreaking to the woman who wants children and cannot have them. It is alienating to those of us who choose to be child free. There are enough forces at work in our culture to divide and conquer women, we should not backlash against ourselves.

miss.bokononist 5 pts

Hello, I'm a polish psychology student currently writing my MA thesis. I'm looking for volountary childless women who would agree to take part in the psychological research concerning highpoints and costs of being childless both in Great Britain and in Poland. The research is of course anonimous and contains few short small questionnaires. If you are childless by choice, at least 30 and heterosexual and willing to fill in the test, please contact me on the e-mail adress: n.o.schiller@gmail.com ( n.o.schiller@gmail.com ). I would really appreciate any help:) Best regards – Natalia Schiller

lonestarbt 5 pts

I am childfree by choice but am blessed with many friends that have children and I have a beautiful niece who will be one next month.  Even though I am around all of these children often I still have no desire to have my own.  I like kids a lot but I never felt having my own would have made me a more complete or better person.

The comments most often heard from men when I was dating were "why do you hate kids?" and "oh, you'll love my kids, they're great".  Neither comments were true but trying to explain my reasons was silly on my part so I just stopped explaining.  When my husband and I met we agreed to "no kids" and we still believe this even though we do have 2 furry kids that we love.

I am in awe of anyone who wishes to procreate and be fantastic and selfless parents.  I am very well versed in kid-speak so I do know what's going on when mothers are talking about kid stuff.  In the big scheme of things these women accept me for not having/wanting children and I accept them for having/wanting them.

So glad I found this blog...a place where I can just be childfree without hassle.

Dara 5 pts

Childfree Women   Women who have chosen not to have children are needed for a research study. This research is being conducted by a doctoral student who is interested in learning more about the experiences of childfree women so that mental health professionals can provide better support for these women.  To qualify for this study, you must be female, heterosexual, over the age of 40 and have no history of infertility.  If you would like to learn more about this research, please contact Dara Reyes, M.A., a doctoral student at California School of Professional Psychology – San Diego, at (619)-410-3207 or delanodumas@hotmail.com ( delanodumas@hotmail.com ). Thank you!

stepmommy 5 pts

After dealing with my husbands X wife, selfish physcho, will make you think twice about having children. In this day and age, you can't make 100% positive that you wouldn't be an X to the husband at some point and would not like the child having to go through this drama. My step-son is 5 yrs old and realizes who pays him all the attention. It is sad...

patsyterrell 5 pts

I never had a great desire to have children - there's nothing special about my genes that needs to be passed on. And the thought of raising a child is overwhelming to me.

I do think child rearing should be left to those who REALLY want to do it. It's hard work, and not for those of us who are wishy washy about the desire to do it.

I can relate to what was said about, "is this the same woman..." I have a friend who once discussed the intricacies of politics and now is only interested in the consistency of poop. I love babies, but I am just not that interested in burping and pooing and how to wash it out of clothes, bedding, etc. And we can't seem to have a conversation about anything else anymore. So, unfortunately, we have fewer and fewer conversations.

Just a couple of years ago we had plenty to talk about and never enough time to do it. Now I can't find any topic of interest to her other than her toddler and what cute thing he did today or his bodily functions. I don't mind sharing that, but that takes about 22 seconds. I want something beyond that and it no longer seems to exist.

It's not enough for a conversation. And I fear it's not enough for a friendship long term, either. It's sad, but I'm at a loss.

Patsy Terrell
www.patsyterrell.com ( http://www.patsyterrell.com ) for blog and more

beverly kline 5 pts

Children, when they are very good, are SO rewarding! I cannot imagine being so happy without my son and daughter! Before they were born, we went through the daily routine...eat,work,sleep,gym and of course play a little. But finally, when we decided to have kids...we surely see
the difference....the kids bring us joy!

beverly@LunchHourSale.com

Jenny Horton 5 pts

I want to stand up and applaud this blog. I couldn't agree more with the points you made in this blog. If only the people that surround my life could understand this. Wow. Thank YOU!

Zandria 5 pts

I think it's far less selfish to know and realize that you don't want children, than to bring someone into this world that you're not ready for. Plus, being a mother doesn't automatically make you an unselfish person.

Personal blog: Keep Up With Me ( http://www.zandria.us )
BlogHer blog: Life - Singles ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/zandria )

TLSchaefer 5 pts

My hubby and I have been married for over sixteen years and are childfree, although we are awesome aunts and uncles for a variety of family members and close friends. We decided early in our marriage that having kids just wasn't for us, and it's a decision we've both been very content with.

That's not to say we didn't make it a point to discuss it periodically, to make sure one of us hadn't changed our minds. Now, at forty, our path has been chosen, and we couldn't be happier!

TL Schaefer/Keira Ramsay
Link Text ( http://www.tlschaefer.com )

Amanda_Magee 5 pts

The ability people have to project their own needs and wants on other people is a never ending intrusion. Having two kids I don't face this particular question or pressure, though I did have my decision to have our second questioned:
You're pregnant?
Again?
Was it an accident?
I don't think there are ever easy responses when someone is trying to shoehorn you into their reality.

And in response to the accusation of childfree being selfish, I just shake my head. I am so sorry. That is just so absurd. My children's lives are enriched every day by selfish people who complete the family they know.

kperfetto 5 pts

People might even go so far as to accuse you of being selfish.

I have had people call me selfish for not having children. My answer is always, "How is my not breeding hurting anyone? If I had a kid, and couldn't provide a loving environment, enough clothes, food, education...that would be selfish, but I'd be a mother, so I guess I'd get a pass."
Five Dollar Camera ( http://www.fivedollarcamera.com/blog/ )