Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Working Parents: Are We Cheating?

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

It seems that the working-mommy versus stay-at-home-mommy debate is not the only debate raging with regard to working parents. Childless workers have a viewpoint, too, and it’s not one we can afford to ignore. And it’s not a new issue – here is a 1996 article talking about unequal distribution of benefits between working parents versus childless workers.

When I was childless, I never thought about whether or not working parents got any favoritism on the job. For one thing, they really didn’t. Flextime, telecommuting and being able to skip a meeting for your kid’s soccer game didn’t seem to be occurring much in the late nineties, at least not where I worked. I never got someone else’s work dumped on me, because I really didn’t work with anyone who had kids that closely. The people I worked with were like me, in their mid to late twenties, staying as late as they wanted and only cutting out early if they had a kickboxing class or were meeting someone for a drink after work. It just wasn’t part of my reality. When I did think about workplace flexibility for parents, I was happy about it, because at that point I had decided that I probably did want to do the parenting thing – I got engaged when I was twenty-six, and by then, I thought the guy I was marrying would probably become the father of my children.

The job I had when I got engaged didn’t have any maternity leave at all. The one person I knew who had a baby when I worked at that job brought her two-week-old newborn to work because she was breastfeeding and had no maternity leave. I remember walking into her office and seeing her there, typing away with one hand and shushing her baby while taking conference calls. I remember thinking that pretty much sucked, and that I would have to find a different job before I got knocked up.

When I had the little angel, I was self-employed and had no maternity leave. I saved up enough money to keep us afloat from my end while I was out struggling to recognize my new life. When I did go back to work, I was convinced that the next time around, if there was to be a next time around, I would be a full-time employee somewhere so that someone else could damn well worry about my benefits and salary while I was shoving my boob in a baby’s mouth. Suddenly benefits for working parents became very, very important to me.

At my current job, everyone seems to have the same degree of flexibility. I leave to go to the little angel’s doctor’s appointments, but my childless friends leave to let in the cable guy or close on their new house or do what they need to do. That’s my perception, anyway. They may feel differently. I do know that I’ve made decisions in my own career to have a job that doesn’t require a lot of travel or late nights that can’t be tapped out on my laptop at home. That’s my choice. Do I feel like my company would not promote me because of my daughter? No. Do I feel like my company would not promote me because I refuse to travel frequently or attend meetings at 7 p.m. on Wednesday? Yes. Am I upset about that? No. I have my boundaries, and that was my choice. Every choice comes with consequences.

The argument gaining popularity in the media today is not really my argument. (Check the comments section of this article – there is some excellent dialogue there.) Some childless people clearly feel they are being discriminated against, being asked to pick up the slack for working parents (and I don’t say “mommies” here, because today’s dads go to soccer games, too) when parents cut out early to attend to their children. If that’s happening, and I believe it is, even if I don’t see it happening at my own company, then that seems unfair. I think your personal choices should affect only you and your career, not other people’s. If childless people want to take on more, stay later and travel at whim, then they should be rewarded for that. If parents want to do

  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
cagey333 5 pts

I've worked in public accounting and software development. Frankly, my experience as a Childless Worker was pretty different than the examples already cited. We had deadlines that didn't care about the ticking clock, soccer games or the setting sun. At the public accounting firm I worked with I actually had a manager say "You don't have kids, you SHOULD work more." When I was in software development it was hard to not be resentful when a co-worker would leave to go home to their kids and we were stuck doing their work until the wee hours of the morning. And yes, I didn't understand. But there was one specific situation that still sticks in my craw where we hired a gal and told her specifically that we worked long, LONG hours. Then, down the road, she got pissed at US that she wasn't able to be at home to tuck her kids into bed. It was a bad hire on both parts and I never did figure out how it could have gone differently - we were a small startup and we were very graphic in the interview with her about the insane hours we worked.

I've never had a family friendly job and it definitely factored into why I decided to just leave it behind and stay home full time.

Amanda_Magee 5 pts

I second your motion that we all cool off a bit with regard to who gets how much slack and for what. We have a guy who takes smoke breaks approximately every 15 minutes, each break lasting about 10 minutes. I'm not great at math, but I doubt he's clocking in at a real 40 hour work week. I don't care. I don't think he should smoke, but if his work gets done I don't care if he does it chainsmoking, doublefisting scotch on the rocks and wearing a tutu.
And the childless folks at work? Hair appointments. Contractor rendezvous and more. Again, I don't care. Do I wish I had more disposable income to do those things? You bet, but that has nothing to do with work.
Each day I leave the office at 1 to work from home, and each day our receptionist says, "Ok, you go enjoy the day. I'll email you tomorrow." To which I respond, "Patti, you can email me today, I'll be working." Then, without fail, blink, blink, "Oh, are you working today?" No matter what I do she conveys to callers that I take afternoons off. I am exhausted by trying to defend what I do and how I spend each moment that I am not occupying space in the office.

I suppose though, if I am being fair, I should accept that not everyone will be able or willing to accept the arrangement I have created. I guess I just wish we could all be a bit more accepting. Is that wanting to have my cake and eat it too?

MC Milker 5 pts

MC Milker - The Not-Quite-Crunchy Parent ( http://notquitecrunchyparent.blogspot.com/ )

I too had many child unfriendly jobs as a single childless worker. In marketing and advertising, they usually only come in that flavor. Though a child lover- I did resent lower pay (i.e. benefits) and being stuck with the work of parents off to get their kids after hours. When I became a parent I knew I couldn't do what was expected of me (late nights, travel) and without resentment decided on a different career.

The comment above about a "bad hire" resonates with me. Where I a manager now in the type of company for which I worked, I could not, in good conscience hire a parent who wanted regular hours. It would not work.

On the other hand, there are many jobs that can and should be measured on output, including many in my field. Someone must manage the office home front, show up for meetings and travel to trade shows...but many jobs are more project based.

I'm happy to say that one of my former employers, Avery-Dennison does just this, using a cadre of former gung-ho, late worker, live on an airplane, single women who are now moms as part time contract workers. The Moms work hard and efficiently a few days a week and support their younger, single colleagues providing both product and guidance. It's a perfect situation enjoyed by both parties - more companies should consider their model!