The Growing Health Care Crisis and the Uninsured in America
by Catherine Morgan

How bad is the health care crisis in America? What can be done to fix it? Are you one of the growing number of uninsured? Could you become one? How can the richest country in the world be allowing this crisis to continue?

It's not just the poor and unemployed that are living without health insurance...it could happen to any of us. You can see a map showing the percentage of uninsured in each state at Informed Voters (my political blog).

Personally, I think the introduction of HMOs in the 80's, marked the beginning of this problem. Not that the concept of HMOs isn't great, it's the increased power that the insurance companies have gained with HMO's that is the problem. The insurance companies have systematically taken power away from doctors, hospitals, and patients...and given it to themselves. What they do with this new-found power is make money for shareholders, with little regard to anything (or anyone) else.

Here is one woman's experience with finding herself uninsured...

LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - Volunteer firefighter Cindy Holland has no medical insurance, and her husband's health benefits as a full-time paramedic do not extend to family members, so she and their three children go without.

The hard-working Northern California family makes too much money to qualify for public health insurance but too little to afford a private policy, caught in a Catch 22 that puts many U.S. workers at risk of financial ruin. -- read full article

When Cindy, 36, shopped for coverage for herself and their children, she found it would cost about $1,000 a month, excluding dental insurance.

“It would kill us financially to do the insurance — if we want to keep a roof over our head and food in my kids. You end up rolling the dice,” said Cindy, a California native who works a pair of part-time jobs on top of firefighting.

As a two-parent family, the Hollands could earn just over $60,000 and still be eligible for Healthy Families, a children’s health insurance program financed by state and federal funds.

But that would require John to stop working overtime, which he does in order to pay old medical bills and other expenses.

Meanwhile, Cindy wrestles with the idea of applying for public benefits. -- read full article

Some of the facts...

Uninsured, national — 46.8 million (15.9% of the population), 2005, up from 45.3 million in 2004. Hispanics highest rate of uninsured – 32.7%; African-Americans, 19.6%; Asians, 17.9%; whites, 15%; children, 11.2%; middle-income ($50k–$75k), 14.1%; work full-time, 17.7% (U.S. Census Bureau). 82 million, or one in three non-elderly Americans, went without health insurance during 2003–2004 (Washington Post, Dec. 13, 2006).

Lack of health insurance causes 18,000 unnecessary deaths every year (Institute of Medicine, January 14, 2004), the equivalent of six times the number who died in 9/11. (Louisville Courier-Journal, Jan. 30, 2006) -- read more

More facts...

One-fifth of all Americans, 48.8 million individuals, were in families spending more than 10% of their family income on healthcare in 2003, an increase of 11.7 million persons since 1996. Of these, 18.7 million (7.3%) were spending more than 20% of family income, a figure normally associated with home ownership. The percent of middle-income Americans (22.7%) spending over 10% of their income on healthcare was almost identical to the percent of low-income Americans (23.7%) on healthcare (JAMA, Dec. 13, 2006). -- read more

From 2000 to 2005, health insurance premiums rose by 73%, compared to an aggregate increase in workers’ income of just 15%. (Chicago Tribune, Jan. 31, 2006) Premiums rose three times faster than wages and inflation in 2005 (UC Berkeley Center for Labor research and Education, Dec. 2006).

Surfing around a bit on BlogHer, I found some interesting posts on this subject.

Jori Des Jardens wrote two great posts on the topic of the uninsured, both with many interesting comments. Why Your Should Be Grateful for That Tedious, White Color Job - and Do We Work To Like? Or Work For Health Insurance?

Here is a link to a BlogHer forum discussion on dealing with being uninsured.

Morra Aarons a BlogHer Contributing Editor wrote on "Our Broken Health Care System" back in Janurary

What are the presidential candidates saying they will do to solve this growing heath care crisis, if elected?

You can check out ExpertVoter.org (a Video Guide to the 2008 Presidential Candidates) to see what each of the candidates are proposing for all the major issues facing our country, including health care.

Here is an article about what Hilary Clinton would do.

What do you think about all of this? Are you concerned? Are you already being affected by this crisis? Do you think a particular presidential candidate has the best plans for correcting this problem? Will the issue of Health Care be important to you at the polls in 2008?

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and CatherineBlogs.com

Comments

 

Thank you Catherine

Health care is so scary to me- I often don't want to think or talk about it! I think in that sense it's a tough issue on the campaign trail. Many people have horror stories, fears, etc, but like taxes, we often don't want to face the realities of HMO rules, premiums, etc. Better to ignore and hope for the best- especially for younger, healthier people.

 

Thanks Morra.

Thanks Morra - I know exactly what you mean. This is one of those issues that for many people is easier to ignore than to actually deal with.

Catherine Morgan
Women 4 Hope and Be The Change You Want To See In Yourself

 

not a one solution problem

The thing that I find most frustrating about the health care crisis (being that my family and I have insurance) is the insistence on the part of many advocates that there is only one 'right way' to fix the problems, and that theirs is that way. I'm so tired of arguing with the people who are holding out for single payer health care, and refusing to accept any more modest reforms. I'm also tired of the people who want modest reforms talking about how there will never be single payer in this country. I think the real solution includes both elements--we certainly don't have the political will, now, to have a single payer system. But that doesn't mean we should just give up on it. On the other hand, the people who are suffering from the health care crisis currently deserve a quick fix, even if it isn't a permanent one.

 

I agree...

I agree. This is a complex problem and it is going to require a complex solution...maybe more than one solution. I also agree that a temporary "quick fix" for the people currently in need of health care is a good place to start.

Catherine Morgan
Women 4 Hope and Be The Change You Want To See In Yourself

 

I agree, too!

And can't wait till Michael Moore's new movie Sicko comes out. It's about the United States health care industry.

Although I haven't seen it yet, I hear it tackles not only the un-insured but also the under-insured. Apparently, he tells the story of a man who has had two fingers nearly ripped off his body, and his insurance company tells him that given what he can pay out of pocket, he must choose only one.

Stories like this are real American tragedies...

Visit my blog:
Complete Guide to Egg Donation

 

Michael Moore's new movie...

Hi Bloggeroo -- I heard a little about the movie, but not much. As far as the insurance company only covering one finger...I wish I could say I was shocked, but I'm not. The insurance companies are what is wrong with health care in America...they should have NO say in what is best for a patient...the doctor should make these decisions. If the doctor thinks it is in the best interest of the patient to have both fingers repaired, the insurance company should have to cover it.
Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and CatherineBlogs.com

 

Thanks for all this research

I've been scouring the search engines for some of this. I also find it curious that none of the reports I found break the uninsured numbers down by gender. My guess is that a large majority of the 46,000,000 are women and children. Any ideas?

Anyway, I'd like to link to this post.
Peace.

 

I imagine you are correct.

Although I don't know the statistics on this. I imagine that you are correct in assuming that the majority of the uninsured are women and children.

Thanks for the comment, and please feel free to link this post.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
also at Women 4 Hope and CatherineBlogs.com