Feeling sorry for "Psychos"

This week, the killer of Alicia Ross was found guilty of second-degree murder. Ross, 25, who was from Toronto was raped and then beaten to death by her next-door neighbour, Daniel Sylvester, 33. I remember when she disappeared two summers ago and the faces of her parents as they pleaded with someone to come forward with information. Sylvester finally mustered up enough courage to confess to the police months after he allegedly visited the place 10 times where he dumped her body, moving parts of her decomposed body to another location when he thought that the police might have found the locale.

Sylvester, while confessing to the murder, tried to plead guilty to manslaughter, only for it to be turned down by the courts. He was a pretty screwed up guy, who said in his confession that he attacked Ross when she called him a 'loser.' While anyone else would have either dismissed the insult or retorted verbally, it set him off. He said that after years of being taunted as a kid for being 'different,' plus his inability to socialize with others, he snapped.

Now maybe that is a lie, and it certainly doesn't excuse his behaviour of not only killing Ross but of also being a self-admitted peeping tom who harboured thoughts of raping girls. From news reports, though, it seems as though he had always had some mental problems, had sought some psychiatric help, but stopped. It was also insinuated in previous news reports that his mother had not been proactive in getting her son some help. From the time he was a child, he was withdrawn from other kids, never 'fit in,' never had any friends. by the time he was an adult, he rarely left his house.

You know what? I feel sorry for him. As much as there might be some people out there thinking Whaat? when they read this, I can understand - if this story is true - what he is and how he became to be a murderer, but don't get me wrong, he's guilty as hell.

Have you ever felt like you didn't belong? That despite all your efforts, you could never fit into social circles? I certainly have. I wonder how my turbulent childhood has affected me, my inability to well......do alot of things, mostly issues surrounding trust. While it didn't drive me to kill, it makes sense that if Sylvester felt that Ross, a beautiful, popular blond woman who represented everything that he could (or believed) never have, he would strike out against her.

Then there's Kenneth Eng. You know, that guy who wrote articles about why he hated Blacks...and Whites... and Asians. I wrote about this when the news first broke and one commenter gave me shit about my approach on the story. I peeped this appearance on Fox (of all places) and I didn't see a virulent racist - I saw someone who is dealing with some serious mental issues and (perhaps) feels that he is invisible, unwanted, ignored. He said something like " blacks get all the attention," which spoke volumes about him, plus his incoherent ramblings about his Sci-Fi novel. Again, I felt pity when he was arrested after threatening to kill his neighbour, thinking, is this guy ever going to get some help?

My question is, how many people are out there, just waiting to snap? Do they have friends and family who are in denial about their mental health? How many people are sitting at home alone, not knowing how to get through the day? Even though we (myself included) might laugh and sneer at such public displays of insanity, it is disturbing. I don't know if I am a total advocate in the mental health industry, but I wish some people could talk to their loved ones, and their loved ones have the patience to listen.

Comments

You are a bigger person than

You are a bigger person than me. I don't feel pity at all. It is nauseating and makes me angry. It sounds like an excuse (defense) to commit violence against someone who obviously couldn't defend herself.

Regardless, this was a interesting commentary and I appreciate you sharing it.

Moe
BigGirlBlue
Large & Lovely

"Women are going to form a chain, a greater sisterhood than the world has ever known." ~Nellie McClung, 1916

 

Interesting Point, Lainad

You bring up an interesting point.

Unfortunately, our society trains the "haves" to trample the "have nots". Yes, that can be remedied by parents paying close attention to their children and trying to teach them "the right thing", but a lot of this is learned on the playgrounds outside of the watchful eye of parents.

Society gives to the "haves" and takes.... or at least sanctions 'taking' from the "have nots". If you look at a crime show where something happens to a woman, if she was attractive, they play it up. They play up how it's such a tragedy that something happened to such a beautiful girl. OTOH, if she wasn't seen as (visually) attractive, you barely hear anything about her... IF they make a show about her at all.

It's the same thing with soap operas. I didn't realize until I started visiting the mid-west how unrealistic soap operas are. EVERYBODY on EVERY show is attractive, in shape, etc... unless there's a reason in the script for someone specifically to be fat or facially unattractive. Meanwhile, people are being trained that attractive=good and unattractive=bad. in-shape=good and out-of-shape=bad. Everyone considered to be "less than" others is fair game for ridicule, bullying, whatever, because everyone agrees that they're not deserving.

While, as you said, it's NO excuse whatsoever, I definitely empathize with the pressure that "have nots" are under... especially "have not" guys that would like to have at least a DECENT interaction with a female, but get ruthlessly shot down every time due to their looks or status. I can't relate to it at all, but I see why living like that, day in and day out might lead someone to snap and go off the deep end.
--
Bill Cammack
BillCammack.com
BlogHerBiz '07 Media

 

I've felt like I didn't fit

I've felt like I didn't fit in on several occasions and often today I still feel that way. But even when teased or picked on or insulted, I've never felt the urge to beat someone up or kill them.

I don't know if I feel sorry for Sylvester. I wish that he'd have gotten the help he needed when he was younger. I feel sorry that the system failed him, perhaps. I don't know. It's such a tough call. If I were his mother, I'd probably feel differently, or guilty for missing the signs of his illness or social impairments.

 

I Salute Your Compassion, Lainad

I usually can't get beyond my anger to summon up much compassion for the perpetrators of these kinds of crimes, but I do understand that they almost never happen in a vacuum. The things some children are exposed to are truly deplorable and that can't but help to contribute to extremely disturbed adults.

And Bill made a great point when he said,

Meanwhile, people are being trained that attractive=good and unattractive=bad. in-shape=good and out-of-shape=bad. Everyone considered to be "less than" others is fair game for ridicule, bullying, whatever, because everyone agrees that they're not deserving.

When the media consistently shows the "pretty people" as the "stars" of the world, everyone buys into that idea, including the "unattractive people." They start to believe that they can only ever be "supporting players" and to work toward more is useless. It's a very subtle message, but dangerously pervasive and girls are especially susceptible to it.

Regarding violence against women, I'm constantly amazed that you can't show loving nude sexual acts between men and women, but you can show the most disgusting and brutal violence against women. Check out what gets an "R" or "NC-17" rating and what passes for "PG-13" these days. It's very scary.

The media's not going to change, but our perceptions of it must. We need to watch and read entertainment as just that, not as a representative of real life. We need to teach children how to be discriminating viewers.

And more of us need to listen, listen, listen.

M. Smith
www.megansminute.com

 

Speaking as someone that

Speaking as someone that lives with mental illness I can say for certain that it isn't just about feeling like you don't fit in.

I'm glad that you wrote this piece. It will give people something to think about. Mental illness should never be an excuse for violence, or any kind of crime for that matter, but it can be the reason behind it. There's a real difference between those two things.

I watch the stories on the news and feel the same sense of horror and anger that other people do, but I feel something else as well, I feel sympathy. Because I've had the benefit of access to treatment and medication, my Bipolar Disorder is under control and I am able to lead a normal life. Without that access, I would not be so fortunate. People who do not have adequate access to mental health services because of lack of health insurance, lack of understanding about their own condition or lack of support from their families when they are young suffer horrible consequences.

Imagine being trapped by your own mind. That's what mental illness can be like. Society doesn't react with kindness or sympathy when they find out you have a mental illness. If you have cancer or AIDS or another physical illness, everyone is kind and caring. If you have Bipolar Disorder, Schizophrenia or anthoer mental illness people treat you like a pariah.

Thank you again for taking the time to write such a well worded and thought provoking piece.

 

I agree with you, and I am

I agree with you, and I am happy to read that I am not the only one feeling this way. Maybe it is because I have a brother with a mental illness, I see things from another poit of view (not that my bro has ever been violent) than most of the people around me.
Here in Belgium, a 16 yo killed tried to kill his school's principal a few months ago. Turns out he comes from Bosnia, he's been through horrible things during the war there, and doctors suspect he is mentally ill. And still, I hear most people and the media talking about him as of just some wacko who should be punished.
Of course he is guilty, but life made him the way he is, and he has a mother who must be so sad about how things turned out. How can we not think of that?

 

Thanks, Lainad

Yours is such a fine post.

My concern is severalfold -- 1st to get the potentially homicidal/suicidal persons off the street and to prevent them from harming themselves or others -- second to get them real care.

And if they have already crossed that line from thought into action, sadly there is often no real care. I wonder how much of our prison population is made up of people who are mentally ill -- and getting no treatment there or anywhere else. I think of our prison system and how to reform it and I do not even know where to begin - the task is so huge and so complicated.

I knew a pastor once who had a woman in his congregation with two grown sons, one who was a righteous and upstanding guy, and one who always was the "bad boy", getting into trouble, acting out, living marginally, on drugs and on the street. Nothing she or thefamily had tried worked with him. One day the second son came to his other brother's home, where the mother had just moved in. Only the brother was home. No one will ever know what happened, but the younger shot his brother and then himself. The mother discovered them. When the police got there, she was sitting on the floor, cradling both of her dead sons in her lap.

The pastor pointed out that she cradled them both, loved them both, mourned them both --and added that was how God looked at all of us - as His children equally deserving of His love regardless of our place in life.

It is that slipstream of love that you are talking about -- the part of us that 'gets it' that we are all connected in some way -- whether we get that thru what we understand about God, or whether we just get that intuitively on our own. (For me the faith story matters -- YMMV)

I have a hard time seeing that connectedness on some days -- thanks for the reminder and the thoughtful post.

~~ Contributing Editor, Mata H. also blogs relentlessly at Time's Fool

 

Great piece that I just had to link to!

Thanks so much for sharing your thought-provoking insights on the Alicia Ross tragedy!

I so enjoyed your outlook that I included you in a BlogHer Conference round-up I just posted at my Blog Band-Aids.

If you're attending the BlogHer Conference, I hope to meet you there!

'kweenkong'
South Side Star

 

Most Commented this WeekMost Commented this Week

Featured PostsFeatured Posts

BlogHer NewsBlogHer News

BlogHer ConnectionsBlogHer Connections

ConferencesConferences

Upcoming
Featured Posts

BlogHer Voice of the WeekBlogHer Voice of the Week

BlogHer Voice of the Week: Miss Banshee of Inverse Candlelight

The real work of recovery is not only saying goodbye to what was destroying your life, but accepting what you may have detroyed that once...

Read more

Tour BlogHer.com
Getting to 10 in 2010
BlogHer of the Week