In a speech at Georgetown University last week, retired Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O'Connor warned that some Republican leaders' efforts to reign in the judiciary, left unchecked, could lead the US into dictatorship.
Justice O'Connor, who was appointed to the High Court by Pres. Reagan, retired last year. She was an important swing vote on many high-profile cases, including her tie-breaking vote to halt the presidential vote recount in Florida, securing the White House for Pres. G.W. Bush.
According the NPR's Nina Totenberg, who appears to have been the only reporter present, O'Connor said:
"Attacks on the judiciary by some Republican leaders pose a direct threat to our constitutional freedoms. I am against judicial reforms driven by nakedly partisan reasoning. We must be ever-vigilant against those who would strong-arm the judiciary into adopting their preferred policies."
.
According to Totenberg, the threats O'Connor was referring to included efforts such as Justice Sunday, the rallies held by religious conservative activists and politicians to urge the appointing of judges who agree with their views. She also decried threatening statements by politicians such as former House leader Tom DeLay (R-Texas), who denounced a judicial decision to remove Terri Schiavo from life support by saying, "The time will come for the men responsible for this to answer for their behaviour."
O'Connor also criticized Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) for suggesting that judges decisions might be the reason behind increasing violence against them and and their families.
Finally, O'Connor said,
"It takes a lot of degeneration before a country falls into dictatorship, but we should avoid these ends by avoiding these beginnings."
BlogHer Daily Briefing has been concerned that we might be on just such a slide for some time. Since the beginning of February, she has been viewing current events according to criteria laid out by Dr. Lawrence Britt, a retired businessman who has written articles and fiction warning of the possibility of a dictatorship led by religious conservatives.
Daily Briefing's conclusions are too lengthy to summarize here, but the upshot is this: she still sees the US as a free society, but like Justice O'Connor, she sees cause for heightened vigilance and concern.
Comments
RE:OConnor Warns of Dictatorship
I have seen this coming for years. I am sure that others have as well. women can change the face of this country if they stop voting against themselves
I know that a lot of women vote Republican because they are against pro-choice. and the right has always put out a convincing propoganda effort in favor of Pro-Life.
The truth is pro-choice is not about taking sides. It is about choice. giving women the right to chose their destiny. Even if they may not always make a wise decision, at least the y have the right to make one and not have it made for them.
If things keep going the way they are headed, we will soon find ourselves in a state of no choice
our vote will not count, and every aspect of our lives will be controlled by men.
Look around the world, to places where women have no voice. It ain't pretty folks.
That is but one example. I am sure the retired Justice is more savy about what is really going on than I. But in the same breath, Women need to make their votes count for something.
I think that we are much better than we give our selves credit for being.
We just need to stand up and say so, and say so with our votes.
Peace, Z...........
You're right that we all need to get involved
Hi Z,
The fact that Justice O'Connor is sounding the alarm should certainly make all of us sit up and take notice. The only thing I can compare it to is when former Pres. Eisenhower warned the US about the dangers of the growing military industrial complex. But Eisenhower was speaking of a hypothetical danger arising from the growth in the defense establishment as a result of the Cold War. O'Connor is pointing to the actions of people in power. And when considered along with other concerns about our freedoms, her warning takes on even more seriousness.
Professor Kim
Contributing Editor, Law and Media/Journalism
Oyez oyez
Exactly professor. This particular women's decision to sound this alarm is extraordinary on its face. Look at O'Connor's biography. This is the life story of a woman who was socialized and trained to excel within a man's system and did so. She has worked within so many systems for so long, as both an elected and appointed official, that one would expect that she could become of the system, inured to power grabs and rhetoric. At the very least you'd expect her to be tempted a little bit by the opportunity to stay at home, lie low and enjoy time with her ill husband. But she is not, according to this report. She is sounding an extraordinary alarm, one that should raise concerns on all sides of the aisle.
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette