What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Record Collecting in the Digital Age: O'Donnell Explains Soulseeking

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

collections
Paige Maguire also blogs at her personal site.

Mallory O'Donnell is discussing a subject near and dear to my heart: the problem of music collecting in the digital age. For most of us nearing the end of our 20's or slipping quietly into our 30's, there are memories of vinyl collections, dusty crates and boxes of Maxells lingering around to remind us of the days when our experience was music actually involved some sort of physical interaction with it as a product.

These days, however, it's harder to manage our love for music. The younger generation does everything digitally, and the rest of us fight off urges to digitize our albums to perfect our iTunes playlists, all while Soulseeking to find the new things we want to try out. We've come to an impasse: we need to bridge the gap between the way we used to listen to music, and the way we have to do it now. We know we can't always rely on the radio to show us what we like, and MTV has long been obsolete when it comes to showcasing new, great music. We turn to the internet, as we do so often, to help us muddle through the rising tide of sounds.

We have to pick our battles, that's the main thing-and the selection of what to really pay attention to and what to blithely cast off into the night is a highly personal one, based on ephemeral criteria. For the overwhelmed listener or critic, one hour of time in which we scarcely pay attention is a cast-off, but for the artist we've taken all their hours and days and wadded them into a missile aimed straight at the rubbish bin. Unfair? Well, sure-but no more so than any other aspect of the process of natural selection in our media-crowded world. And it's only getting more and more jam-packed, day in, day out-just think, 300 years ago it was possible to have read every book ever written in English. Today, I doubt one could read so much as a list of all their titles. The same applies to music.

So how do we manage all of this? Do we give up and just stick to what we like? Or do we keep trying to discover new things to turn us on, get us excited, make us want to put in the effort necessary to truly enjoy our music community?

O'Donnell's persepctive is decidedly depressing for the music obsessive:

There are a million records to be heard and enjoyed, each one as deserving of your attention as any other. You will never get to hear 99% them.

Get over it.

  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
ColoMtnWoman 5 pts

I'm new to the blogher site, and new to blogging in general, so bear with me.

I grew up on jazz, and my earliest musical recollections were when I was 4-5 years old, and my father would set his drums up out in the garage, get out the old wind-up "Victrola", and put on the 78's of Gene Krupa, Benny Goodman, Harry James, etc. (While other kids were listening to nursery-rhyme records, I was digging Glenn Miller...) I started playing jazz-guitar in college, and have been playing professionally ever since. (Jazz, rock, country, funk, pop, whatever...)

My own collection of vinyl, 33's, 45's, etc. is pretty exhaustive; (I have one whole closet in my house that I built shelves in, and it goes from floor to about 6-7' up with records.) I would say that I probably have close to 2,000-2,500 albums alone.

Well, recently my father, (who is now 84--and I'm proud to say that he is STILL playing drums about once-a-month with a 19-pc 'big-band', and kicking-b*tt!), decided to move into a nice retirement-center, and sell the house, etc. My legacy from him included HIS entire record collection! So, I just inherited another 800-1000 albums; (almost all jazz, with a little "pop" thrown in..), as well as about 600-700 mint-condition 78's, still in the original paper-sleeves! It will probably take me the next 5-6 years to catalog all of this, and start weeding out the better stuff!

I have two things that make it "worthwhile", though. One is that they've just come out with a USB turntable that lets you play 33's/45's and convert it directly into MP3's on the computer, (and clean up the surface-noise in the process!). So, I'm digitizing the better stuff as I run across it; and then, I'm burning some "Best of..." CD's for my Dad, so he can still "share the wealth." Secondly, I've found a pretty nice shareware program that allows me to catalog stuff as I go through, and search for things later. So, I doubt that I'll ever give up my collection, and my turntable!

I figure I'll be retiring in 10 years or so, and I can't think of too many things that bring me such pleasure. I have to start thinking about what to do with it after I am gone, though. I don't have any kids to leave it to, and I'd much rather see it go to some organization that can "share it" in some way, rather than sell it off to some collector who will just put it on the shelf and forget about it.

I still play professionally...(a LOT, actually)... and it helps me keep my "day-job" in perspective. As a matter of fact, I've been blessed with having been able to play with quite a few of the jazz-greats I grew up on!..(Benny Goodman, Lionel Hampton, David 'Fathead' Newman, Arnette Cobb, 'Brother' Jack McDuff, etc.) Most recently I've collaborated on a couple of jazz albums with a world-class woman bass-player out of Colorado Springs, Kim Ciara. She has a new CD out called "Through The Eyes Of A Child." So, I'm staying busy...

Great topic...Thanks for starting it...

CMW
a/k/a www.ladyjazzer.com ( http://www.ladyjazzer.com )

---"You play pretty good...for a girl"

Julie Marsh 5 pts

I recently posted ( http://mothergoosemouse.com/2006/05/15/dance-to-th... ) on this topic too. I'm a bit embarrassed by the fact that I worked in the music industry and yet didn't have the same level of musical knowledge as my peers. I think I stagnated around 1992.

Like Mrs. Davis, I like getting music recommendations from other people. I've had a great time exchanging CDs with other bloggers. But I still love my turntable and my old records.

The Lovely Mrs. Davis 5 pts

Yes, we turn to the internet to find new music, but I find that I rely mainly on other people for music recommendations. If you're someone I enjoy spending time with, I'll probably like some of the music in your collection, and chances are good that I'll find something new there.

It is depressing to think that there's so much music out there I'll never get to hear, but when you stop and think about how much mediocre (or just plain bad) music there is, it's not so sad.

I've parted with most of my old cassettes, finally admitting that I had outgrown most of that music - or that it's really not as good as I thought it was in 1985.