At the BlogHer conference, when Barbara Ganley of Middlebury College mentioned she is an edublogger, someone mistook her as saying she was an "antiblogger."
She at once embraces and brushes off such a label: "I bet some of the people here (and even in my edublogging world) think this loose kind of essay writing I do is anti-blogging. I know that. I'm okay with that."
There's a definite sense of alienation in Ganley's reflections on BlogHer. And she isn't the only edublogger to have what she calls "mixed feelings" about the sessions at BlogHer.
She writes,
But rumbling through the two days was, as Laura points out, a strong whiff of the almighty dollar. People were looking for hints on increasing traffic to their blogs, making money blogging, encouraging advertisers. In sessions I attended, and in the buzz around the pool, there was a whole lot of attention paid to getting people to your blogs. Fascinating.
Okay, so I learned that my world is indeed what I expected to find out--a bit out of touch. But I expected there to be a huge outcry against DOPA--after all, Danah Boyd spoke on Day Two. But no--NOTHING within my earshot. And in fact, as I went around talking about it, I found out that many, many bloggers, including those in academic circles, hadn't even heard of it. How can that be? I was shocked and not a little bothered--we were surrounded by the sponsors giving us everything from zipdrives to condoms, fake flowers to souped up water; but no talk about legislation that will deepen the digital divide by making blogs and other social networking sites out of reach for kids without computers in the home, and force those who do use the sites underground to form their communities. Read Danah Boyd's inspired research on MySpace and adolescents if you don't believe me.
Personally, I enjoyed the conference, and my encounters with the edubloggers convinced me that these women have embraced BlogHer's mission to effect meaningful change through blogging. While I share the sense of unease the academic bloggers exchanged over wine, soda, and hard liquor, I can see the appeal of driving traffic to one's blog with the hope of profitting from it. I straddle the increasingly apparent divide between those who blog-for-fun-and-profit and those who blog-to-change-the-world. My little salary as an adjunct instructor doesn't pay the bills, so I need to freelance occasionally, and blogging helps me to showcase my knowledge and my mad writin' skillz.
So I ask: Can't we all get along?
Biz bloggers can learn from edubloggers
Business bloggers, you should know that edubloggers aren't eccentrics on the edge of the blogosphere. There are a lot of academic bloghers. Check out the Research and Academia blogroll here at BlogHer for a partial list.
A subset of those blogs includes the edubloggers, those dedicated and hardworking souls who write about the usefulness of blogging and related technologies to education. These bloggers ask the hard questions about how to bridge the "digital divide" that separates the haves from the have-nots.
Edubloggers take the BlogHer conference's motto of "How are your blogs changing your world?" and ask instead, "How can students' blogs change their worlds?" And by "students," they mean anyone who might otherwise lack a voice.
In short, edubloggers show students and others how to democratize knowledge and participate in conversations about issues that are changing their worlds whether they like those changes or not. They are blogging evangelists because they believe in the power of blogs to transform education.
Business bloggers could take a page from edubloggers' insistence that instructors open up a forum for their students rather than trying to control content and message. For edubloggers, blogging is a reflexive practice constantly open to revision. That means transparency, being open to new directions, and for the love of all that is holy, giving up scripted presentations. (Microsoft Live Spaces and their shills, the ridiculously scripted and bubbly Be Janes, who presented prior to one of BlogHer's sessions, should take note. Dear Home Improvement Barbies: Women with the level of technical prowess in that room aren't likely to be cowed by a router. Hugs, Leslie)
Edubloggers can learn from biz bloggers, too
As much as the staunch liberal arts education purist in me would like to believe otherwise, many of our students haven't prioritized polishing their critical thinking skills and developing broader worldviews. Rather, they enrolled in college to prepare for the working world.
We might, then, take a page from the biz bloggers' books and teach our students the tips-n-tricks of business writing on the web. They can still write about Adrienne Rich and Audre Lorde--they'll just be doing it in a concise, conversational tone with pithy yet informative headlines: "Seven Reasons to Sing the Body Electric." Who knows? Maybe they'll end up "selling" such poets to their metrophobic peers.
Of course, there already is a middle ground between the traffic hunger of the biz bloggers and the idealism of the edubloggers: the nonprofit blogosphere, where bloggers sell readers on worthy causes. There's another skill we could teach our students: how to advocate for others as well as for themselves.
What about you? Where do you fit in? How is your blog changing others' worlds?
Leslie Madsen-Brooks blogs at The Clutter Museum and Museum Blogging.
P.S. Julie Meloni, the lit student and tech geek extraordinaire of No Fancy Name, promises to write a series of posts on the conference, including one on "why more than a few bloggers who attended now feel incredibly ambivalent about blogging." Julie, you've piqued my interest, and I wonder if you're referring to any academic bloggers. Please share your thoughts!
Comments
training & education
I do trainings in how to use blogs in higher education. Why would a faculty member want to use them, how would they use them, and what are they good for? I am, probably, the biggest advocate of social software on our campus and people flock to the trainings. They are interested. They want to know not only why it is good for classroom use but why they should use them personally and/or professionally.
I have found that academicians are often on the fringes at conferences - especially technology conferences - even though we often lead the way in what tools are used and we are the ones giving this information to new generations. Because we don't typically have the big $$$ and are necessarily concerned with making the big $$$, we are regarded as odd in the corporate world.
I think that the corporate world is missing out, though. We are great resources in understanding how and why technology is a hit or a miss. We are, afterall, in the thick of it and working with their audiences.
dawn m. armfield shares her writings and photography at life inchoate. She also has 4 other blogs she keeps up on a regular basis.
The lessons we can learn from one
another...great theme.
Great post!
There are many many different kinds of bloggers, and we give it a shot to have all kinds co-exist at BlogHer. Obviously with the announcement of BlogHer Business we are interested in branching out into subject-specific events, but I think the blogging community is also well-served by the cross-pollination that can occur at one big mixed-up event!
This post illustrates that beautifully.
Hmmm. Perhaps '07 should include a series of sessions based on your theme of "What xxx bloggers can learn from yyy bloggers, and vice versa."
Elisa Camahort
BlogHer and Worker Bees
elisa@blogher.org/elisa@workerbees.biz
Lunatic fringe...
Leslie,
Atleast you FOUND other edubloggers there!! I found one knitting blogger. (yes lots of bloggers who knit, but not knitters who blog about it). No one else from the hobby-sphere. I was so alone! (though meeting you was a high point!!) Still trying to figure out how to get the word out that it's worthwhile to attend. Guess I need to blog about this a lot.
We crafty/gardening folks all seem to be content to stay out in our own not-so-little worlds... where a wider exposure would be quite cool.
So, YES, Elise. Maybe the theme of BlogHer 07 should be what we can learn from each other.
Debra
A Stitch In Time
Deb's Daily Distractions
Freeing our minds and blowing everyone else's
Lindsay, Marianne Richmond wrote a great piece on DOPA yesterday and it's in posts of note - everyone go read it, link it and love it here: http://www.blogher.com/node/8494.
Now - back to the subject at hand, which is your lovely essay on the for-profit and academic blog-worlds colliding. My reading of posts about the conference indicates your experience is one of many such collisions from BlogHer '06 -- our differences as bloggers made for shock, appreciation and disappointment throughout the conference. Here's another: the intersection of women who blog about parenting and women who aren't parents, for example. This is a societal division writ large that always troubles me. But it's just one example: There are equally important distinctions within the community of women who blog about motherhood. To your point, "Can't we all get along," I found relief last night when I read "Mommybloggings," a post by the always articulate Mom-101. She nails it - here's an excerpt:
Bingo.
This, to me, is why it's so important to have discussions and disagreements--here and at conferences--that explore the diversity of what women are writing online and doing with our lives. This way we're using web-based technology to:
1. Liberate the external/outside world's/media discussion of women's work from its usual two-dimensional shrink wrap and sound bites.
2. Liberate our internal thinking/conversations and mindsets from our stereotypes of each other -- a far more intellectually limiting barrier and one I fear more.
So - my goal is to keep blowing my own mind (and you helped, as always, thank you L). Then keep advocating to blow everyone else's.
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
Liberate! AMEN.
Thanks Lisa. I hate emoticons but I am smiling.
http://mom-101.blogspot.com
http://coolmompicks.com
We find it, you flaunt it.
Becoming Proactive
Will Richardson of Weblogg-ed is taking a very proactive method to getting DOPA slowed down or reworked. Anyone, or lets say everyone, who wants to get involved should read his blog.
In today’s entry he says that it is time to take the fight outside of the education community and presents a few good ideas about how to do this.
He also has written names of some politicians and how to contact them.
lia from luebeck, germany
(author of the media safe 101 page on the Red Tent Blog)
Great essay, Leslie!
Thanks for posting about this! I didn't make it to BlogHer, and I also had mixed feelings about that. Besides the fact that one of my best friends would be there, as a CE, I thought I should go and I was genuinely sorry to miss out. But I also felt a little unsure about where I fit in the community and how relevant the sessions would be for me, as an edublogger/biblioblogger. My other hesitation was, as Lisa said so well:
I'm one of the latter, and it seemed to me that the conference seemed to be focused more toward the former and I just can't relate. I'm definitely blogging from my perspective as a woman (and as a member of a profession that is predominantly female but seems to advance men to leadership roles disproportionately), but my focus is more on building networks and sharing information than driving traffic or earning revenue from my blog. That said, BlogHer 07 is on my calendar for next year and the more I read BlogHers' accounts, the more I'm looking forward to it.
Edubloggers are like mommybloggers--many
faceted
There are so many edubloggings. There are the collegiate bloggers who are writing about their lives as academics, but not using much connectivity in their classes. There are the collegiate bloggers who are using blogging (and other Web tools) to teach. There are the high school teachers, also bifurcated, and the k-8 bloggers ditto. Then there are the edubloggers writing about edu policy
Some of the dissonance, I think, is that "edublogging" has not yet come up with an internal taxonomy or categorization.
I will have to think and write on this more...
Liz Ditz
I Speak of Dreams
lizditz@gmail.com
And homeschool bloggers! ;-) nm
~Denise
Daily Dose of Denise and Fast Times @ Homeschool High
Anti-DOPA rounduup
The anti-Dopa wiki
http://dopa.pbwiki.com/
Victoria Davis's blogging against DOPA
http://coolcatteacher.blogspot.com/
There's another RSS feed, but I can't find it just now.
Liz Ditz
I Speak of Dreams
lizditz@gmail.com
Check out UThink
...for great blogging related to everything academia. We just celebrated our 40,000th post, even!
UThink Blogs at the University of Minnesota
blogging personality disorder
I've followed this post and thread with some interest--I was not at BlogHer, but have followed the subsequent discussions all over the place. Ganley's concerns, and this discussion about "types" of blogging connects with something that is on my mind right now--I have a humorous personal blog that if anything is more of a "mommy" blog than anything else, in that i write candidly (but certainly not exclusively) about my experience as a parent (yes, I embrace the term politically--although I think I like "muthablogga" better;-).
In its early days, I attempted to post more "academic" musings (I work as a researcher in Digital Humanities) but soon realized that this was not the audience I was attempting to reach or connect with in this space--indeed, my writing was more stiff, my sense of audience too prone to second-guessing. I've learned a great deal by writing a non-academic blog (even though I still take on some academic issues--like body image or gender stereotypes). It's been freeing, and the blogging networks to which I belong tend to be more connecting, affirming, proliferative (though this may be the case with academic or edublogging, I am not yet part of that community--and I am pretty sure there are differences based on the contexts here).
But now the academic in me wants to reflect, think more, and write--for other interested academics and researchers. About blogging, gender, social networking, and the future for the technologies we build. And I realize that in order to do this, I need another blog, another persona (one that I professionally stand by with my real name). Yes, I can ponitificate on some of these larger issues--gender, social networking, identity, subjectivity and communuity--in my personal blog, but the context is wrong. It'd be like changing the channel unannounced.
And I need to "change the channel" subjectively and rhetorically if I am going to pull this off. But I wonder what kind of schitzophrenia it will breed(!) Will my two blog doppelgangers get along?!
which brings me back to your main point and questions--how is your blog changing your world and others?
my personal blog has helped me locate a writing voice I never knew I had, and one that helps me process anecdotes into big picture ideas much more effectively than some of my more academic musings. In a nutshell, it has made me a writer (I never called myself a "writer" before--even with academic articles and a dissertation on the CV). I also gained something I was not bargaining for--a community of friends and readers that are unbelievably talented and generous. And I think this was key to me developing that voice--and yes, I am thinking that the "Her" in BlogHer has a lot to do with this.
As I look at creating another blog to reflect on my research, I wonder how my approach to that writing will be different, how the community will (or will not) reinforce itself differently through that blog.
Hmm. I think I might just have posed a question for one research agenda.
Thanks for this opportunity to think this through--I'll be back for sure:)
I'll look forward to BlogHer 2007!
Thanks for the Revised Topic!
I blog mostly on what I've learned about teaching English/Language Arts/Reading 4-8.
And, I appreciate BlogHer's recent name change on the Research, Academia, and Education topic!