It was May Day, and I’d just started dating a guy who was really good friends with an ex-girlfriend. No big deal to me. I’ve got lots of ex-boyfriend friends.
Guy asked if we could be cool, no public displays of affection, etc. at the party we were attending. He didn’t want her to be uncomfortable. He said she still had feelings that he didn’t share. At the time, I really liked and respected her, and I didn’t want her to be uncomfortable either. It seemed like a reasonable request to respect her feelings. I admired their commitment to their friendship. I was so innocent then.
So I spent the day “being cool.� And frequently uncomfortable. Because as the day went on the occasional snuck kiss (not initiated by me; I was following his lead) became a drop of pretense and she was anything but cool. The party ended with her screaming and crying at him at the top of her very drunk lungs on the back porch while I sat shocked and miserable in the kitchen.
“It’s not about you,� one of his friends said.
Yeah, that’s what you want to hear at the beginning of a new relationship: It’s not about you.
Ultimately, that particular incident would be but one of so many bizarre episodes that peppered 5 ½ months of more hell than a girl should reasonably stand, but I am convinced it was the foundation of the dysfunction to come. I definitely feel in retrospect (ah, hindsight!) that I should have walked away from the situation right then.
I’ll tell you one thing for sure: I will never enter a “quiet� relationship again. I think it’s negative and unhealthy and that I deserve better.
It’s tricky because surely there are many understandable reasons to keep a new relationship on the down-low: office romance, pending divorce, children. We all have to make judgment calls for ourselves about what works and what doesn’t for us. And surely some of us are against public displays of affection to such a degree as to make it moot.
But here’s how it works for me: I think a relationship needs support and nurturing, and that support is both internal – between the two partners – and external – within the community of family and friends that surround the couple. The couple has to find out how (and if) they fit with each other and within their communities. A relationship that is out in the open facilitates relationship growth and discovery in both areas at once. A couple dating quiet may not discover their public dynamic until after they are completely entangled internally – making it harder to separate should a problem arise.
More importantly, someone asking you to date quiet is asking you to subvert yourself and your emotions. Asking you not to celebrate publicly the new relationship and not paying you the respect of doing the same. For me, that’s a negative energy I won’t abide again.
And then there’s the why of it. Why are you being asked to date quiet? In my case, I believe it was because he was lying to me (and to her and to all his friends) about the specifics of his situation with both of us. At the very least, it was an indication that he was not free and clear of her emotionally.
I believe the request to keep a new relationship quiet is absolutely a red flag. So while there are understandable reasons why you might enter a quiet relationship, I have to ask: Are the reasons to date quiet actually reasons not to date at all?
Contributing editor Liz Rizzo also blogs at Everyday Goddess and The SexySmart Blog.
Comments
you are very right
"""both internal – between the two partners – and external – within the community of family and friends that surround the couple""" I don't think many couples think about that when they're getting together. The world revolves around the two of you. But, obviously, it's not like that... you have coworkers, family, friends, neighbors whose lives intermingle and create your social network. Hmm. Interesting thoughts to ponder, thanks for the great post!
Melanie Perry
***not all who wander are lost***
http://mistressofthedorkness.blogspot.com
Guys are strange
I completely agree that it's a good idea to leave a new relationship in the very beginning if there's something that doesn't seem quite right. It's so much easier than waiting until months (or even YEARS) down the road.
This reminded me of a post I did a few days ago about a recent date. I was glad that this information came out sooner rather than later! :)
Keep Up With Me
I always get something
I always get something valuable from your posts, Liz. I started dating my last serious boyfriend soon after relationships had just ended for both of us. We didn't like those circumstances...were worried upfront about the "rebound" aspects, but just really liked each other and didn't see the point of waiting. I had moved 500 miles away from my ex, but his worked up the street, for the same company that we did.
The first time we ran into her, we'd only been dating for a month, maybe. He was holding my hand and he dropped it. He hadn't seen her since their final breakup, and it was a bad scene. This was hurtful to me, but after watching them interact, I could almost understand. The communication between them was so unhealthy. The thing that worked well for us was that we could talk just about anything through. I honestly believe he was afraid of her reactions, as I witnessed a few of her rages. It's hard for me to even write that, because I don't believe in assigning blame and it's not like I was unbiased, but in this case it's just an honest observation. I truly did see his part in it, as well, especially after WE had issues down the road.
She kept "needing supplies" from our store. I witnessed one screaming fight - her screaming at him, him listening - in the back room. He told me she was still "emotional" (there had been threats of self-harm throughout their time together) and and he wanted to see if he could keep the "friendship" because she was lonely. I told him that I would never forbid him to see anyone, because we were grown people who needed to make our own decisions. Still, he needed to know that this was having an impact on our new relationship, and he needed to decide which was more important to him - developing a stronger connection with me, or ruining it by keeping the one with his old girlfriend. I saw what was happening and I didn't like it, and I told him so. He soon cut off contact with her, because he did want to see how things went with us, and he came to see my side (the previous guy had been unfaithful to me with a "close friend" and trust is a huge deal for me, as it should be, I know.)
I still never forgot him dropping my hand, even though I understood...but the important thing to me was that he didn't continue to insist that I stay quiet. We ran into her one other time and he kept his arm around me, and that was good. We never would have lasted as long as we did - and nor would we have the friendship we still maintain - if he had made different choices, and if I hadn't had the courage to tell him what my limits were. It was a risk I'm glad I took - I needed to learn that I could stand up for myself in those situations. It was a challenge for me then, and still is sometimes, but it's really important.
I'm so glad
I'm so glad you like my posts, and thanks everyone for your comments. This post turned out to be a little difficult for me after I wrote it. I think the experience I shared was relevent to the post, but going back there to write it made me feel crappy, even now. Oh, wisdom, why do you have to be earned?
As for your story, Laurie, a good friend recently said to me that when you start a relationship and things come up or happen like your hand drop (been there, too, BTW) and you deal with them, talk about them, get through them and then move forward - well, that's exactly how you build a relationship. I get a lot of comfort from that thought. That these things do happen and sometimes you can address them and move forward through them.
And sometimes, you run for the hills! :)
Liz Rizzo
Everyday Goddess
SexySmart Blog
Keeping it Quiet
As someone who's trying to remain friends with her ex, there's part of me which understands why he might want to keep it quiet. It's awkward the first time either of us meets the other's new partner, and there have been moments when I've thought I'd be better toning things down for his sake. But I know that when he tried to protect me from hurt feelings, it ended up being a lot more painful than it should have been - the short, sharp shock approach might have given me a brief bruised ego, but by mollycoddling me he just made me feel hurt, offended, and defensive. Did he really think I was that pathetic etc etc. There's no point hiding what you're doing from someone who's supposed to be a friend, and it's you he needed to try and impress, not her.
Misty Smith
Excellent.
You are speaking my language. This is a great point. :)
Liz Rizzo
Everyday Goddess
SexySmart Blog
Reality Check
Blah, Blah, Balh. Let's get real. If a man places such value on his ex, you need to wake up and smell the coffee and run- don't look back, just run. It's an indicator as to where you will land on his list of priorities. Today it's his ex's feelings tomorrow it will be someone else. Break-up's are hard, there is no disputing that fact. How you handle it is an indicator of future relationships. Men who have the need to be quiet about things indicates that there continues to be unresolved personal issues. Until he is capable of working through those issues, he will continue to go from one relationship to another. Women have to stop thinking that they are going to be the ones to change them - because they won't be. Instead, you'll invest time and effort into a relationship that will eventually go nowhere. Then you'll be sitting at home crying and beating your self-esteem into an all time low. If a man has to hide or be quiet about your relationsship you need to be honest with yourself and walk away. There are alot of fish in the sea. Why waste your time on someone that devalues you from the get-go?
Reality Check
Blah, Blah, Balh. Let's get real. If a man places such value on his ex, you need to wake up and smell the coffee and run- don't look back, just run. It's an indicator as to where you will land on his list of priorities. Today it's his ex's feelings tomorrow it will be someone else. Break-up's are hard, there is no disputing that fact. How you handle it is an indicator of future relationships. Men who have the need to be quiet about things indicates that there continues to be unresolved personal issues. Until he is capable of working through those issues, he will continue to go from one relationship to another. Women have to stop thinking that they are going to be the ones to change them - because they won't be. Instead, you'll invest time and effort into a relationship that will eventually go nowhere. Then you'll be sitting at home crying and beating your self-esteem into an all time low. If a man has to hide or be quiet about your relationsship you need to be honest with yourself and walk away. There are alot of fish in the sea. Why waste your time on someone that devalues you from the get-go?
Have to agree with the above
Have to agree with the above post. If I was with a guy who thought more about hurting his ex's feelings than about mine, he'd be history.Why make excuses for him? If we are together my feelings come first, otherwise my advice to him is he'd best be getting back with his "ex".