Bio
                                                 Since 2005 I've been blogging on politics and parenting for The Huffington Post. I am also an award-w...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

North Carolina Sterilized Thousands of Women without Their Consent, and Now They Want to Pay Them

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

They were sterilized--all 7600 of them--by the state of North Carolina. Mostly they were women and girls, and many were black.

Like Elaine Riddick, who was raped and impregnated by a neighbor when she was 13, who was sterilized moments after she gave birth, they did not give their consent. A state eugenics board recommended that because Riddick was “feebleminded” and “promiscuous,” a poor student, she be sterilized. When she married at 19 and couldn’t get pregnant, that’s when a doctor revealed what had been done to her. "They cut me open like I was a hog,…” Elaine Riddick recalled in an interview early this week with NBC News.

Oh. And the rapist was never prosecuted.

Imagine being Elaine Riddick. The shock and pain and loss of understanding that you were deemed so subhuman, so deficient, that you were not fit to have a child. Ever. And that five strangers, a government panel, had determined that. I doubt I would be capable of comprehending that. Of wrapping my mind around that. Of accepting that.

Could you?

Imagine then suing to have your case heard before the United States Supreme Court, and the court rejecting it.

Now some of the survivors are telling their stories. North Carolina is trying to figure out a way to make reparations for its shameful past, for the victims’ suffering. But that appears to be an elusive task.

How much is enough, really, to account for a woman being deprived of her fertility? Is $20,000 enough? $100,000? A million?

Would any amount be enough for you?

It occurs to me these are questions better suited to a reality TV show.

North Carolina Governor Beverly Perdue addressed the impossibility of compensation, this stab to address the unfathomable, when she said in an interview:

From my perspective, and as a woman, and as the governor of this state, this is not about the money. There isn’t enough money in the world to pay these people for what had been done to them….

north carolina

Credit Image: Pesky Library on Flickr

  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
LucindaA 16 pts

Frankly I'm surprised this hasn't been discussed earlier. I thought it was common knowledge that this kind of stuff happened. Mentally disabled were also victim to this treatment regularly, regardless of race. I'm actually impressed by the governors admission that there isn't enough money to undo this wrong. While it is easy to say it happened in another time, I could see this kind of movement coming back with the way women's reproductive rights are being systematically eroded. Justification being the woman has violated the rights of the fetus and should not be allowed to reproduce. Scary stuff.

Polish Mama on the Prairie 18 pts

LucindaA

You read my mind! Very scary, indeed.

Mona Gable 5 pts

LucindaA Sadly, I don't think it is common knowledge that eugenics was widely practiced over several decades--and also tacitly condoned by the medical establishment. Which is why it's so important for women to hear stories about this.

My Pajama Days 6 pts

I am in shock! This is just so unthinkable that it seems unreal. My heart breaks for those women and families involved.

Robin Carpenter 6 pts

No amount of money is good enough, nor will it solve the problem. If it was a tubal, perhaps the state could pay to attempt a tubal reversal. I know they often don't work, but at least it is a chance to repair the damage. Otherwise, perhaps have the state pay for all adoption fee's for at least two children.

Stitchandboots 6 pts

There is no forgiveness in "nothing would be good enough". I prefer to think that all these women can find it in themselves to forgive and heal. I'm also pretty jaded about people putting prices on healing. I think the most appropriate reparation is to convict the rapist in that one case and take away every doctor's medical license who performed sterilization on women without their permission, and prosecute them.

Mona Gable 5 pts

Stitchandboots Thanks for your comment. Unfortunately, most of these women were sterilized decades ago. The story is only now coming to light. This was also common in other states during the eugenics movement in the United States.

karenapp 5 pts

I remember hearing about this several months ago when the story broke locally, as I am from NC. I was absolutely mortified when I heard, but not surprised unfortuntely. NC, and other Southern states do not have a great track record when it comes to their treatment of the mentally ill and developmentally disabled. Mistreatment of these individuals has gone on down here for decades. I know that no amount of money can change what was done, but I have to commend the state for at least doing something to make amends.

Rita Arens 45 pts

I don't know what to say. Nothing would be good enough.

gorillabuns 5 pts

The Government and doctors would never ever think about sterilizing a man or the rapist for that matter.

avflox 13 pts

Oh my God. I don't have the words to describe how this makes me feel.

Conversation from Twitter

thehealthyhippi
thehealthyhippi

blogher whaaaat???? THAT IS ABSURD! grrrr

speedytot
speedytot

blogher awful :(

Conversation from Facebook

Polish Mama on the Prairie
Polish Mama on the Prairie

Wow. I have to read this one. I wonder if it's like what we as a nation were doing before WWII where many mentally handicapped and physically handicapped people were sterilized without consent (btw, in case you don't know this, the Nazis did the same in WWII and their doctors admitted getting the idea to do so from the USA's own programs)... Sometimes, it's hard to remember that we live in the land of the free. But I still love America.