Bio
Full time working Mommy of two boys. I'm obsessed with pop culture, good music, and my family. I wish I had more time to blog- heck, I wish I had more...

Penguin
Bookmarks

Top Picks


The Next Always

Nora Roberts

The Weird Sisters

Eleanor Brown

The Ideal Man

Julie Garwood
 
 

Book Club in Your Inbox


Sign up for our email newsletter!

Reading Next!

With a sharp and distinctive voice, Stephanie McAfee delivers a hilarious and fast-paced tale about Ace Jones and her two best friends. Stay tuned for Diary of a Mad Fat Girl!

 
 

Girl in Translation is Not a Fairy Tale

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Girl in Translation, by Jean Kwok , tells the semi-autobiographical story about a girl named Kimberly Chang and her mother who emigrate from Hong Kong to Brooklyn. Due to family debts from the immigration and a lack of employment, her mother begins working in a sweatshop. Kimberly must help her mother in order to make any money, forcing her to lead a double life, one of an exceptionally bright schoolgirl in the day and a sweatshop worker by night. This is the story of her childhood and the struggles of life in America, which was not as wonderful as she was promised. 

I was surprised at how quickly I tore through the pages of this book. I kept hoping for Kimberly that things would get better for her and her mother. All of the details that Kwok gives made it hard for me to believe that this novel was not a memoir. I thought the first two thirds of the story was very strong, and I enjoyed the way that Kwok would use phonetic sounds to describe what she thought people were saying to her as she learned the English language colloquialisms and accents. It made me look at just how difficult it would be to live in America with English as a second language. Some of my favorite details were the Chinese sayings she included with explanation and the descriptions of the food. I found the descriptions of the sweatshop so realistic they was almost hard to read, which made the book all the more enthralling. The book also covered Kimberly's schooling and how she was such a naturally smart child, even though there were many that doubted her abilities; I was glad to see that she excelled in school despite the hardships she faced.  

The last third of the book covered Kimberly's high school years and became more of a romantic story. Without giving too much away, I will say that this part of the book was a little disappointing for me, especially with the way that she dealt with consequences of her actions. I do like that the book does not give a perfect fairy tale ending or make Kimberly perfect in her actions. That being said, I was still hoping for that ending, particularly since her childhood was so difficult.

Overall I really enjoyed this book, it was definitely a page turner, and I enjoyed reading about Kimberly and her childhood overcoming adversity.

  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Jean Kwok 5 pts

Jannabee,I really agree with you that he deserved to know. I think that the Chinese are much more reserved in general and Kimberly was still Chinese enough that she would have kept silent. That decision kills me as well, and you're correct that the entire story isn't played out yet. I won't be writing a sequel to this but Kimberly and a mystery character will be making a very brief cameo in my next book - that will answer some questions, although not all. Thanks so much for this review.

Best,
Jean

Author of Girl in Translation

www.jeankwok.com ( http://www.jeankwok.com )

www.facebook.com/pages/Jean-Kwok/213583280524 ( http://www.facebook.com/pages/Jean-Kwok/2135832805... )

EmSun 6 pts

"I was surprised at how quickly I tore through the pages of this book. I kept hoping for Kimberly that things would get better for her and her mother. "

I also hoped that things would get better for them. I'm not certain that financial success truly meant something better when it came at the expense of her sense of community and belonging.

However, I did think that her behavior was heroic and sacrificial - like her mother's.

Jannabee 5 pts

I agree for the book it is "tragically romantic", and brings back an idea of self-sacrifice, but I just keep thinking about what would happen down the road when her child starts asking questions about his Dad. I guess I am more of a realist? And here I thought I was a romantic! :)

flutie.mcd 5 pts

that's what i *loved* about this love story... she made the ultimate sacrifice. sure she could've told what's his name (so sorry i can't remember) that she actually kept the child but in the end she understood that neither of them would be happy. she loved him so much that she chose not to tell him - so that he could have a happy life. it was tragically romantic.
i agree that she probably should have told him at the very beginning -while they were still teenagers... but her choice to not tell him 12 years later is what i think is heroic...
maybe i'm just a hopeless romantic nutcase? :)

Jannabee 5 pts

because many of the decisions she made regarding her child could be deemed "heroic". Specifically what disappointed me was not telling the father (Matt). I think he deserved to know.

flutie.mcd 5 pts

i thought she was very heroic in "the way she dealt with consequences of her actions."
what was it that disappointed you, i wonder?