Hey there Fox,
cough.
So listen... You and me? We kinda need to talk.
Fox, I know we've have had our problems in the past. And I know that in anger and frustration, I've said some things online that may have hurt and offended you. Or rather, I've intentionally said some things with the expressed purpose and aim of hurting and offending you. Because seriously, dude, setting aside the whole stealing-my-copyright-protected-content-and-broadcasting-it-on-national-tv thing (good times, good times), and the whole mangling the greatness of "Kitchen Confidential" thing (quoth USA Today: "...odds are that the folks in this Kitchen are about to find out why so many restaurants — and sitcoms — close in the first year." -- I SO CALLED IT! [pumps fist]), there were also the unspeakable crimes you committed against my beloved "Kitchen Nightmares" (what do you people have against kitchens, anyway?), and it's probably best if we don't even get into the matter of "Paradise Hotel" (douchebags check in, but they don't check out! (well, at least not without some kind of nasty rash in need of topical ointments or perhaps even a course of Cipro)). After all, I'm not made of stone, Fox. If you cut me, I bleed. If you broadcast "Temptation Island" I'll watch it, feel disgusted, scream at inanimate objects as though they were cognizant of the despicable behavior and attendant emotional carnage unfolding on the screen before us under the laughable guise of "entertainment," then get another bowl of ice cream, hate myself, question god and the worth of the entire human race, weep into the now-emptied-of-ice-cream bowl, set a season pass on my DVR and... well, you get the idea. This madness must end. IT MUST END TONIGHT.
Because I see what's coming, oh yes I do. I can feel it deep in my bones (actually, that may just be a touch of the osteoporosis -- I've been running a deficit with regard to my calcium consumption for quite some time now). And when a warm wind blows in from the west, tinged with Pacific Ocean brine and the moldering scent of sweat-drenched UGGs, I can almost smell it.
You're going to try to cancel "Dollhouse," aren't you? AREN'T YOU? Yeah, well you should be ashamed of yourself. Yes, even more than usual.
Dawg, listen yo. "American Idol" aside [coughWaningFranchisecough] "Dollhouse" is the only game in town for you. It practically justifies your otherwise questionable existence. It is, in a word, redemptive. Please allow me to explain.
Let's face facts, Fox: "House" and "24" are dogs who've had their day. You can keep milking them for a few more seasons sure, and profitably no doubt. But the writing's on the wall there and both of us know it. It's like the last few seasons of "The X-Files," when Chris Carter had reached that sad but inevitable point where, drained of truly inventive and engaging storytelling like "Clyde Bruckman's Final Repose" and "Humbug," he began to rely almost entirely on a hokey narrative arc that increasingly resembled a snake swallowing its own tail, a narrative in love with itself, a mythology spellbound by its own perplexing mythos. But in the end, however badly we Want To Believe (heh, geddit?) in a show, there comes a point when putting a fork in it is an act of mercy.
Regardless, the truth is that despite our rocky past I was genuinely excited for you when I heard you'd tapped Joss Whedon for a show (who, incidentally I've been known to stalk a time or two... and, okay, encourage others to do the same, fine, yes, GUILTY!). It seemed to speak of a new maturity on your part, in terms of taste-level if nothing else. For the first time in years, I managed to speak of you without hurling insults. It was progress, marked growth, I thought. And when the show finally aired earlier this year, I beamed with something like actual pride.
And then I was, well, disappointed. Because as much as I love the previous productions of Mr. Whedon -- and indeed I SO do -- following the initial rush of the pilot, the show seemed kind of... meh? Lacking in a certain... Whedonyness? A bit devoid of Whedonacity? Not as Whedontastic as I'd hoped? YES. THAT.
And despite what might appear from the outside to be irrational fanaticism on my part, I consciously chose to move on rather than try to talk myself into believing it was a better show than I actually thought it was. And now, the letting go. Le sigh.
But then I started to hear things. Good things, and from good people whose opinions I respected and trusted. I started to hear that after the first few somewhat stunted and stifled episodes, the show took a fantastic turn -- that it basically became the show I'd hoped it would be when I first read of it a year or so back. So I tuned in again. And they were right. Almost precisely at the sixth episode mark, an episode entitled "Man On The Street," the show positively blooms. It transforms itself from a flat, wholly plot-driven Sci-Fi-ish drama in almost literally the blink of an eye, morphing into this whip-smart, arresting, 3-dimensional exploration of identity and memory, of the boundaries of the body, mind, and something like the soul. But, like, in a completely kick-ass and entertaining way. In other words, it gets TOTALLY Whedony. Curious, that. So curious, in fact, that I did some research on it. YES, I KNOW HOW TO RESEARCH THINGS. I... have Google. cough.
And lo, you know what I found out, Fox? That it was you that pushed for the first episodes of "Dollhouse" to be 'stand-alones', ie: not part of a larger, deeper, more intricate and finely wrought narrative arc, ie: not the kind of thing that the actual brains and creative force behind the show, Mr. Whedon, does best. And the dramatic upswing in quality and depth, at episode six precisely? Well it just so happens that that's the first episode Whedon wrote himself since the pilot, and it's also when you apparently stopped trying to micromanage the man's creative impulses. Eliza Dushku, star of "Dollhouse," shared this insightful nugget on the matter with the A.V. Club:
"...people have said that the show took off once they finally realized that
Joss is best off left alone to do his thing. That happens around
episode six—six through 13 are just extraordinary. I love one, two,
three, four, and five, but Joss’ first script that he did after the
pilot is number six, which is called “Man On The Street,” and it is
just unbelievable. From that point on, the world unfolds in Joss’ way,
with Joss’ speed, and it’s really remarkable."
To which I say: INDEED. And also: WORD.
Really, Fox, try to be sensible. Can you not see as I do the promise inherent in this show? Can you not see the greatness of it, and the even greaterness that could be? With each succeeding episode its gotten better and better, converting me from a disbeliever -- nay, someone who'd given up on the show and walked away from it entirely -- into a hardcore, diehard fan. One who'd write an elaborate mock letter to a personified you and publish it on a prominent website, hoping that perchance my dancing monkey act will amuse you enough that you might pause and actually listen. Because I know many, many people who want you to give this show another chance just like I do. In my earnest dorky-geekiness here, I indeed do contain multitudes, and you'd better believe it, buster.
So think about it, okay? And while you're thinking about it -- you know, mulling it over with some tea and scones and what-not -- I WILL COMMENCE WITH ORGANIZING AN ARMY OF DISGRUNTLED TELEVISION VIEWERS AGAINST YOU.
[ And to that end: if you are a fan of "Dollhouse" and would like to voice your desire for them to renew it for a second season, you can make yourself heard by doing any or all of the following:
- If you're a Twitter user, tweet @FoxBroadcasting.
- If you want to email, email askfox@fox.com
- If you're on Facebook, join the FOX Facebook group and post a message.
And if you aren't a fan? Well, if you've read this far I have to believe there's something here that's intrigued you. So why not head over to Hulu and do some catching up? The last 5 episodes -- from the aforementioned awesome series turning point-y sixth episode "Man On The Street" up through last week's are there for the viewing in full. Heck, if you just don't sleep for the next 24 hours (or go to work! Work, who needs it?! Phhbbt!) you could watch the whole season before the new episode airs tonight (Fridays at 9pm ET! Get out a black sharpie and write it on your forearm now!). JOIN US. ]
Thanks for reading, Fox. TTYL!
Your pal (or nemesis-to-be, your call dude),
Tracey aka Sweetney aka d0LLh0uZe4eVa!!!
. . . . .
Tracey, aka Sweetney, writes about Pop Culture & Entertainment at MamaPop, and Joss Whedon is her co-pilot.
Comments
I'll do just about anything for Whedon
*disclaimer* I've only seen one episode of Dollhouse. My husband has watched them all, and all I know about it is that there's an Australian actress on there (Dichen Lachman). But I'm with you on the House. It's a little bit...weird this series. Or is that just me? So if there is an army of disgruntled viewers to be raised, I'll enlist ;)
For the love of Whedon
Joss elicits those feelings of allegiance for good reason -- his shows have consistently been some of the best network TV ever produced. Would be a shame to lose that, but I'd echo what another reviewer (a writer for the Chicago Sun Times, if I recall correctly) said: If Fox does cancel this show, Whedon should flee the networks forever, and if he ever does decide to do TV again go to cable, where he'd likely be allowed more autonomy & the full expression of his talents, and not have to bend his will/vision to network suits who ultimately gauge a show's value not by it's craft and content but by almighty Neilson numbers. I mean Sci-Fi? FX? They'd crown him Emperor and give him free reign (well, after peeing their pants, I mean), yanno?
Still, I really hope Fox comes to their senses and realizes that after they awkward start *they themselves* engineered for the show, it deserves another shot at proving itself.
Tracey Gaughran-Perez, aka Sweetney
CE, Entertainment & Culture
Author/Editor of Sweetney, MamaPop, & We Covet
Fox's cancellation crimes are many...
Arrested Development. Futurama. Greg the Bunny. Firefly. ARRESTED DEVELOPMEEEEENT. Just to name a few.
Don't do it again, Fox. People are DVRing it (maybe you'd get more live viewers if it wasn't in the Friday night time slot of doom), people are talking about it, people are BEGGING YOU TO KEEP IT.
I would type more but I'm getting too stabby.
(Also Arrested Development.)
Joss Is A TV God!
I totally agree, if Fox ditches "Dollhouse" Joss should ditch network TV forever.
I agree that "Dollhouse" has improved significantly, but they still need to write around Eliza's limited acting abilities. I love her, but she can only do so much.
And Tracey, since I loved your post, I'll ignore those comments about "House" and "24" 'cause I LOVE those shows!
Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video
Megan's Minute
I've seen this before...
Please don't let this be another Firefly. PLEASE. For the love of good television, don't let this be another Firefly!
Fox, Let Joss be Joss
You'd think Fox would have learned not to f**k with a creative genius with a loyal fanbase and proven track record, eh?
Fox, please let Joss develop his vision, and we will reward you handsomely. Yes, handsomely.
The Real Adam Good
Performance Researcher & Creative Strategist
@asgood
Whedon's Dollhouse is superb storytelling
Glory hallelujah Tracey! Thank you for this post. I agree 100 percent. We watch Dollhouse religiously chez moi, often pulling it off our Apple TV again later in the week in order to try to unravel the mystery. (Which is impossible, which is so Whedon, which is why we drop everything to watch this smart, smart TV.)
And I love the roles for women on this show! Eliza Dushku has range I didn't anticipate, she's fantastic -- and Olivia Williams has launched plenty of fan posts like this one with a single line: "I played a very bad hand very well. There's a difference."
Yum.
Off to tweet Fox...
Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette
BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.
LOVE this show
I'mwith you on this - I love this program. And, like Lisa, I often watch it more than once (I tend to try and 'multi-task' during episodes, so I need another time through to catch it all).
If you don't have anything nice to say, come sit by me
http://rhiinpink.com
I love this show...
I love this show and I would be very upset if it was cancelled.
Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
at Catherine-Morgan.com and Women4Hope
WORD, indeed
spot on, sweetney. ep. 6 was the turning point, and it's been off to the races since. will be VERY VERY upset if Fox pulls a Firefly on this one.
You tell 'em, Sweetney!
I watch it with my daughter every week. We're both Whedon fans. So, I see this as Fox attacking the sanctity of mother-daughter relationships.
Nordette: BlogHer CE and NOLA Lit Examiner. Blogs @ WSATA & UMBOP.
Love Dollhouse!
I agree with everyone and really really really hope they save this show.
I only recently watched Firefly and and now understand the torment of not getting another season.....please FOX, don't do the same with Dollhouse!
I Concur
That week they aired Prison Break instead of Dollhouse, I totally freaked out. I was worried the show had been killed just when it was getting good.
Now I've heard so much about episode 13, they had better not cancel it before I get to see it!
"Active" Supporter Ready to give Fox Silent
"Treatment"
I, too, have long been a Whedon fan - from Buffy through Firefly and Dr. Horrible all the way to Dollhouse. I admit I allowed the faults of the first few episodes out of bias, but I'm so glad I rode it out.
I hope that our feelings and sentiments do not fall on deaf ears - Fox has long been a little too clueless about what quality television is. And while I do enjoy a good number of Fox shows lately (e.g., House, 24, Bones, Lie to Me), I'd be willing to boycott Fox if they made such a heinous decision as to drop this show (it is bad enough that they are dropping Terminator and keeping Fringe) - which I've expressed as such on my blog as well.
Weird but Fun
My college-student younger daughter adores this show and begged me to watch it, too. I have to admit that at first I thought it was ... well, sort of stupid and clearly an attempt to cash in on the Lost/24 trend, with doses of pod people, Twin Peaks and James Bond on the side. But it sort of grows on you, I have to admit. Definitely a keeper!
Cathy
cathylwood.wordpress.com
Catching Up
I caught episode 6 and thought: this is where everywhere changes. Since then, I'm unfortunately managed to miss a number of episodes.
Will be spending the early evening catching up on hulu. (lame, I know).
And will gladly join any twitter/facebook campaign to keep it on the air. Fox can't do this to Whedon again!
deb
Debra
A Stitch In Time
Weight for Deb
RE: Catching Up
Deb, not lame at all. I watched eps 6-10 on Hulu (thanks, Hulu!). Kind of jealous because eps 7, 8 & 9 are SO SO GOOD I almost wish I could watch them all over again with fresh eyes. Let me know what you think after watching those -- I'll be interested to hear!
Tracey Gaughran-Perez, aka Sweetney
CE, Entertainment & Culture
Author/Editor of Sweetney, MamaPop, & We Covet
Late to the show
I am late to the Whedon-love and have only now watched Buffy The Vampire Slayer for the first time (am on season 7 and am savouring every episode, knowing it's the final one). I missed Firefly when that was on originally, too, but watched them all on Hulu and loved it.
I've been watching Dollhouse from day one, though, and love, love, love it. I can't believe it took me so long to become aware of how great Joss Whedon's stuff is, but now that I have, I'm definitely hooked. I will be extremely unhappy if Fox decides to cancel this.
I'm not sure if there are any concerted efforts to keep this show going, beyond all the blog posts I've read, but when I come across those, I read & comment on them, in the hopes it will make a difference.
and furthermore...
I don't understand why Fox keeps killing off quality programming while churning out inflammatory (if not outright treasonous) "news" and frickin' American Idol. Are we, as a nation, as stupid as they seem to think we are?! Vampires, I tell you.
Naomi
http://www.superdumbsupervillain.com/
Whedonism
No matter what happens, we will always love you! And I WILL buy a whole new season six of Buffy so that I can watch Hell's Bells because my little brother scratched that disc!! I WILL encourage others to see Firefly BEFORE seeing Serenity!! and I will keep telling people to watch Dollhouse because no matter how un-jossy the first few were, I can still feel it. So help me Fox....I won't even watch you, I watch all my shows on Hulu now!! (the few that I watch, TV is such crap these days) So help me...I am going to go buy some poster paper and start making my signs now!! Don't take my Joss away!!!!!!
I Hate To Tell You This
Hi Bambi,
I hate to tell you this, but Hulu is partially owned by News Corp, which owns Fox, so watching stuff on Hulu isn't boycotting Fox. However, hopefully there won't be any need for you to boycott them at all because they'll renew the show!
And better a late Buffy lover than no Buffy lover at all.
Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video
Megan's Minute
WOW, Megan!
I didn't know that. I'll keep it in my back pocket for the next time someone tells me they don't watch Fox for all kinds of principled reasons but they do watch Hulu. :-)
Nordette: BlogHer CE and NOLA Lit Examiner. Blogs @ WSATA & UMBOP.
wouldn't surprise me
I love this show. It's the only good thing about FOX except Idol, which I'm getting tired of anyway.
So clever. So interesting. And so sexy.
However, I watch it in hulu.com, so FOX is not getting my ratings blip. Will now TiVo, because they're capturing that data.
Lynn @ human, being
http://www.humanbeingblog.wordpress.com
I'm not a Whedonaphile and I really like
Dollhouse too!
(I'm going to try not to be too hurt that you dissed my Hugh, Sweetney)
As someone who never got into Buffy or Angel (although it's possible I would if I ever actually sat down to try), and I've been pleasantly surprised by Dollhouse. I even made my husband watch the old episodes online to catch up so he can watch it with me.
The biggest reason to save it? While Eliza Dushku is great and all, I have to say that I am most impressed with Miracle Laurie/November/Mellie. It's about time a super hot woman with a little flesh was part of the dreamscape of American TV viewers.
Fox, don't just save this show for the Whedonites- save it for all of us!
Eliza On Twitter?
It seems this may be the real Eliza Dushku on Twitter: http://twitter.com/ElizaPatricia
Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video
Megan's Minute