Optimism Plus Action Equals Balance
by Maria Niles

Previously I've written about the upside and downside to positive thinking. And while positivity and negativity might be polar opposites, combining optimism with action can lead to finding a balance between the extremes.

Positive thinking presents a conundrum in that it involves first finding a negative and thinking about the negative repeatedly and even in the context of working on convincing ourselves that it is not true doing so can reinforce the negative thought. Negative and positive thinking both contain and element of belief that our thoughts are the truth which is often more about ego than reality.

One way of finding a middle path is to practice being present in the moment rather than judging the past or focusing on predicting the future. And that can be a great path for calming the incessant chatter of our minds. But much as I find meditation incredibly useful, sitting around waiting for life to happen to us and then benignly accepting doesn't sound terribly appealing to me.

If optimism can be defined as a hope for and belief that life and the future can always be good if not better than it is how we can form goals and dreams. Action is how we can then pursue those goals and dreams.

You might believe to be snake oil salespersons those who push the idea that if you just wish hard enough for a pony one will appear in your front yard as if by magic. Yet you would probably admire the little girl who sets up a lemonade stand to raise money so she can save up to pay for riding lessons because she hopes that a pony is somehow in her future and she is putting her optimism into action.

The win in this scenario is not the pony but the action. Her dream might morph but she is working towards it and I believe that if she never sits in a saddle she's better off for having the dream and doing something about it.

Though you might not subscribe to the belief that reality can be shaped by the power of our minds, you can choose to take action. And without discounting the reality of depression and other health issues, we can choose our outlook; we can choose to believe that our lives can continue to improve and make it so.

How do you find a balance between optimism and pessimism? Even if your disposition does not naturally tend towards optimism, do you find taking action helpful?

Related Reading:

Julia Baird at Newsweek: Positively Downbeat

But surely there's a middle way between clueless cheerleaders and grumpy prophets. The Dalai Lama shows you can strive to be content and remain angry about injustice.

Russell Bishop at The Huffington Post: Could You Just Get Over Your Negativity About Positive Focus?

Far from denial or pretense, the consistent theme across these many articles over the past 18 months is one of taking charge and doing what you can to improve your life experience along with your life circumstances. To play off the editor quoted above, there seem to be many puerile comments from the "shoot from the lip" crowd distorting this kind of advice into some kind of namby pamby pabulum about just pretending that things are fine or that things will get better if you just sit around and hope.

Far from it. It takes great courage to face adversity, imagine a better outcome, and then get off your butt and do something about it.

Tim Byrd at Under An Outlaw Moon: Optimism, Action, and How To Be The Neighborhood Pulp Hero

Optimism and action.

That’s the sort of formula I’d like my son to imprint on, more than trite “believe in yourself” homilies or the sort of self restrictions people come up with (“This is how a man acts, a man never does that,” and whatnot). That’s the sort of formula I’d like myself to imprint on, fully, so that I can live it.

Megan Hustad at The Daily Beast: Why Are You So Damn Happy?

Finally I asked Ehrenreich if there might be times when willful, defiant optimism can be a force for good, even for social progress. I tossed out the name Elizabeth Cady Stanton and mumbled something about how the first generation of suffragists didn’t live to see the 19th Amendment. If they’d been pessimists, would they have devoted years of their lives to a seemingly hopeless and thankless cause? Ehrenreich paused for a split second—she collects her thoughts faster than most mortals—then defined what she sees as the critical distinction: “There’s a difference between being willing to take on really difficult things and being overly optimistic. I’ve taken on many things that turned out to be extremely difficult. I didn’t take them on feeling, ‘Oh, I’m going to ace this.’ I took them on thinking I was just going to do my damnedest, whether it was some sort of outdoor adventure or an intellectual task. That’s a very different spirit. It’s not, ‘I’m going to win because I know I’m going to win because I’m wonderful and God loves me so much.’ It’s thinking ‘This is so important, I’m going to die trying.’“

Tina Su at Think Simple Now: How to Motivate Yourself to Massive Action

It’s the action behind the attraction that makes the wish come true

Powerful motivation comes in understanding that you can achieve anything you truly desire in your heart. It is the knowledge that you are destined to fulfill your every goal, which drives you to change.

The decision is the first step towards change. Regardless of the decision, every change requires some form of action.

Comments

 

Feel the despair and continue keep pressing
forward

I love this post.

A few months ago, I had the opportunity to interview Colin Beavan, the No Impact Man who is one of my personal heros.  I asked him if he ever got overwhelmed by the immensity of our environmental problems.  Here is what he said:

There’s a story about a woman who’s a layperson, and she’s a Zen adept and she gets to be a grandmother. And all her life she’s been a lay preacher. And her granddaughter dies. And she’s sobbing her eyes out. And all the people are so surprised, and they say to her, “Don’t you understand that everything is just like this? Everything is one. Everything is just the way it’s always been. Do you not understand the point?”

And she stops crying and says to them, “Don’t you understand that my tears save my granddaughter and all beings?” So that is to say my compassion, my sadness for the human condition is what makes me human. So, that in itself is a great story, right? But the really important part of that story is that she stops crying. In other words, she’s overwhelmed with sadness, but when somebody comes to her who needs to be taught, she puts one foot in front of the other. She stops crying and she teaches. So, we have to accept that the problem is overwhelming and immense and at the same time just get on with it.

This is why I am on the board of an organization called Green Sangha, which combines mindfulness with action.  "Awakened action," as they like to call it.  Of course, we meditate.  And then we act.  Retreating to a monastery is fine for some.  But for those who want to make change, action is crucial.

Beth Terry
www.fakeplasticfish.com
@fakeplasticfish
FaceBook

 

Awakened Action

What a great concept, Beth. Thank you so much for sharing it and the story from Colin with us. No matter how overwhelming the problem might seem, like environmental issues, you have to believe that your actions can create change and then get to it. And I believe that doing so is both positive and optimistic without being sucked in to a false hope.

Thanks so much for your kind words and comment!

BlogHer Contributing Editor PopConsumer Beyond Help

 

Optimism versus possibility

Optimism is not what gets me into or keeps me in action.
Optimism is a mind game I no longer need.

For me it is seeing a possibility, a personal dream and then working towards it step for step.
Be the change you want to see is NOT a hollow saying for me anymore.

I want to see a healthy world, so I live healthy,  I found a way to move to the country and now I grow my own veggies and that happened by taking one step at the time.
I do that by NOT expecting things to be instant, I just do today what there is to do and be grateful for any progress I am making.
I do not expect the world to change, I do not judge people who are not changing, I just do and share how I live differently on my blog so by my doing I might inspire and support others AND eventually may or may not add to the achievement of the tipping point.

I am 'self focused' and yet I also look beyond to a bigger for the sake of what.
I make sure that what I do always adds value, and is never taking away from anybody.

I know that what I do is enough and that it makes my world a better one.
If we all did that and stopped biting off more than we can chew, we would make a wholesome tapestry. 

Wilma Ham

www.wilmasblog.com

 

Be the change

Thank you, as always Wilma, for your wonderfully thoughtful comment and for adding to the discussion.

I think we are basically on the same page - I see optimism as essentially belief in possibility. Though, it can become a term that is overloaded with expectation and a demand of certainty that can be, as you so well put it, a mind game.

And, yes, the saying "be the change you want to see" can be a tired cliche these days but I appreciate how eloquently you demonstrate its quality of essential truth by putting it in practice everyday in your life.

Again, thanks so much!

BlogHer Contributing Editor PopConsumer Beyond Help