If you live in the Western world, you've no doubt heard the catch phrases "Babies were born to be breastfed" and "Breast is Best." Many women start out with the best of intentions for breastfeeding their new bundles of joy, but sometimes circumstances beyond their control can cause interruptions in early breastfeeding relationships.
Talk of jaundice, biliruben levels and supplementing with formula are not things many parents are prepared to be confronted with just days after their child's birth. So what should you do if you find yourself suddenly dealing with the unexpected?
After experiencing a labor and birth with my daughter that was unlike anything I had anticipated, breastfeeding seemed to be the one thing that was going in our favor. Ava came into the world as they say, born to breastfeed. Although I had a little trouble with her latch initially, with some help from a nurse we soon seemed to be well on our way. She would eagerly latch on and spend 30 to 45 minutes on each breast, nursing contentedly. Then a pediatrician (not her's, but one in her pediatrician's practice) told us that she was jaundice and not only did he recommend that she go under the bilirubin lights (in the form of a bili-blanket, thankfully in my hospital room), he also wanted me to supplement with formula to help flush the jaundice out of her system. Formula? But, but, but, I'm exclusively breastfeeding. We even had a note on her bassinet in the hospital saying, "I'm a breastfed baby. No artificial nipples or bottles please." I had every intention of breastfeeding her exclusively and now it seemed that even that wouldn't happen. Not knowing what else to do, I acquiesced and allowed my husband Jody and/or a nurse to feed her formula from a bottle, while I continued to nurse her 'round the clock. I absolutely did not want to give her a bottle myself because I wanted to avoid confusing her. I wanted Ava to know I was the one with the breasts and that those breasts were the only way she was getting nourishment from me. (Kellymom states: "If your baby is less than 3-4 weeks old, it is best to avoid the use of a bottle for a couple of reasons: regular use of a bottle instead of breastfeeding can interfere with mom's efforts to establish a good milk supply; bottle use also increases baby's risk of nipple confusion or flow preference.") Little did I know that I could have given the formula to her myself actually from my breast and avoided a bottle all together had anyone at the hospital told me about something called a Supplemental Nursing System (SNS) or lactation aid. "A lactation aid consists of a container for the supplement -- usually a feeding bottle with an enlarged nipple hole -- and a long, thin tube leading from this container." The tube is taped onto the woman's breast, allowing the baby to nurse at the breast and receive expressed breast milk, formula, glucose water, etc. at the same time. So why wasn't an SNS mentioned to me - a mother who wanted to breastfeed exclusively and obviously wanted to avoid nipple confusion that could come from introducing a bottle so early? Are other hospitals recommending SNS to breastfeeding moms?
Thankfully, Ava did not suffer from nipple confusion and took to the breast well every time (and, if you are familiar with my previous posts you know she ended up breastfeeding for a long time), but that's not the case for everyone. Many babies who are offered a bottle before they are ready to differentiate between mom's breast and a rubber nipple have trouble with their latch or will refuse to latch onto the breast at all.
Nell who blogs at Casual Friday Everyday gave birth to her third son Dash just two weeks ago. When her pediatrician (note: not her usual pediatrician) determined that Dash had jaundice - which was not unexpected since her other two sons had it as well - she was told he needed to go to the NICU. That news, however, came out of left field and was completely unexpected. Neither of her other kids received any special treatment for jaundice.
I almost couldn’t process what was being said. Like it wasn’t really sinking in. We walked down to the NICU with our tiny little baby…a place with a few other babies with jaundice also. They removed his clothing and began hooking him up to everything.
We set up a time that I’d be back to nurse him and my husband and I left…left our newborn baby all alone, under lights, with strangers…I cry just writing about this.
I walked back up to our floor empty handed and broken hearted. My heart felt like it had been shattered. Like part of me was missing…well, because it was. Every single part of me wanted to run back into the NICU, grab him and run out of the hospital.
Dash also received formula from a bottle to help treat the jaundice, and Nell believes, the combination of him being taken to the NICU and use of the bottle contributed to the nipple confusion they are now trying to overcome.
This has been a particularly difficult thing for Nell because she struggled with breastfeeding issues like tongue-tie and thrush with her first two children and was determined that this time, with Dashel, the breastfeeding relationship would be different.
This baby was going to be different. I was determined not to introduce a bottle to him. To avoid the nipple confusion. To nurse well into his first year, if not longer. And then unexpectedly he was put into the NICU and supplemented with a bottle. Had I been offered the option of an SNS I would have taken it in a heart beat.
Again, why wasn't a SNS (lactation aid) offered to this breastfeeding mom? And was it really necessary for them to take a jaundice baby to the NICU?
Since leaving the hospital, Nell and Dashel have also developed thrush, but she is determined to make breastfeeding work this time around and is reaching out for help.
I’m not ready to give up even though this has turned into the most difficult experience of all three.
I have reached out to the local LLL gals in my area for help. I’ve explained my problems via email and asked for a phone call. I’m going to attend the meetings for one on one help. And I’m going to try some Thrush remedies that don’t require a doctor to prescribe them.
I think Nell did one of the most important things a woman who find herself in these situations can do - reach out for help. Call another breastfeeding mom, call La Leche League, call a lactation consultant (International Board Certified Lactation Consultant). Call or email someone who can point you in the right direction of the resources and support you need to help you succeed.
Carina of Greetings from the Jet Set had a difficult time getting a good breastfeeding relationship started with her son after a fill-in pediatrician, concerned that her two-day-old son was jaundiced, recommended she supplement her nursing with an ounce of formula after each feeding. The supplementation took place via bottle, her son suffered from nipple confusion and her supply dropped a great deal. After her son's two week appointment, she sought out a lactation consultant and was able to figure out a good latch and taught how to use a SNS. "After a few weeks of that, my supply righted itself and we went on our way." She told me on Twitter, "I tell everyone that while they are short term WORK, they yield long term results. 1-2 wks of SNS yielded 2.5 years." That is to say that she used the SNS for one to two weeks and, as a result of the reestablished breastfeeding relationship, she was able to nurse her son for 2 1/2 years.
Carina, a self-described lactivist, also responded to a woman's question on Yahoo on this very topic. The woman wrote, "Doctor told me that my breast milk is increasing his jaundice level, so I was told to give him formula milk and breast milk alternatively." She asked, "how long will I be asked to give him formula milk? When will he be switched completely to breast milk?"
Carina replied, "your doctor gave you outdated advice. It is NO LONGER advised for you to stop breastfeeding and give formula." She then quoted several articles that support her claim. The first is from Dr. Jack Newman.
Breastmilk jaundice peaks at 10-21 days, but may last for two or three months. Breastmilk jaundice is normal. Rarely, if ever, does breastfeeding need to be discontinued even for a short time. Only very occasionally is any treatment, such as phototherapy, necessary. There is not one bit of evidence that this jaundice causes any problem at all for the baby. Breastfeeding should not be discontinued "in order to make a diagnosis". If the baby is truly doing well on breast only, there is no reason, none, to stop breastfeeding or supplement with a lactation aid, for that matter. The notion that there is something wrong with the baby being jaundiced comes from the assumption that the formula feeding baby is the standard by which we should determine how the breastfed baby should be. This manner of thinking, almost universal amongst health professionals, truly turns logic upside down. Thus, the formula feeding baby is rarely jaundiced after the first week of life, and when he is, there is usually something wrong. Therefore, the baby with so called breastmilk jaundice is a concern and "something must be done". However, in our experience, most exclusively breastfed babies who are perfectly healthy and gaining weight well are still jaundiced at five to six weeks of life and even later. The question, in fact, should be whether or not it is normal not to be jaundiced and is this absence of jaundice something we should worry about? Do not stop breastfeeding for “breastmilk” jaundice.
According to Breastfeeding Basics:
In most cases, jaundice is a normal, possibly even beneficial process that can be managed without interrupting breastfeeding. The treatment for physiologic jaundice is more breastfeeding rather than less, and sick babies with pathologic jaundice need breastmilk even more than healthy babies. Even in rare cases where the jaundice is caused by the breastfeeding, there is no reason to wean and every reason to continue giving your baby the best possible nourishment – mother’s milk. In most cases, jaundice is a normal, possibly even beneficial process that can be managed without interrupting breastfeeding. The treatment for physiologic jaundice is more breastfeeding rather than less, and sick babies with pathologic jaundice need breastmilk even more than healthy babies. Even in rare cases where the jaundice is caused by the breastfeeding, there is no reason to wean and every reason to continue giving your baby the best possible nourishment – mother’s milk.
According to a La Leche League article:
In an article in the November 1990 issue of BREASTFEEDING ABSTRACTS, Kathi Kemper, MD, MPH, suggests that prolonged hospitalization, phototherapy, and the interruption of breastfeeding may be unnecessary and even harmful for the mother and for the infant with normal neonatal jaundice. She writes, "In the case of healthy term infants who are jaundiced, the treatment could be worse than the disease."
So what is going on here? Why are hospitals treating jaundice this way if it's a "normal, possibly even beneficial process?" Is the real problem that pediatricians attitudes about breastfeeding are deteriorating?
I think educating one's self is always a good thing. Of course, it's impossible to prepare for every possible scenario, but if a woman knows in advance that breastfeeding jaundice is a normal occurrence and isn't always a cause for concern, then perhaps she can make better informed choices with regard to her child's care. If she and her doctor decide that supplementation is necessary, then knowing about a SNS/lactation aid and asking for the help of a lactation consultant could be invaluable. And then, if a woman finds herself in a situation where, for whatever reason, she has trouble with breastfeeding, knowing where to look for help at the first sign of trouble is key. It's also helpful for family and friends to know what to do (and not to do) to support a breastfeeding mother.
Lastly, there's an eye-opening article that ties into this topic nicely on Today's Parent called "Nursing Confidential: Breastfeeding can be one of the biggest challenges of new motherhood. Now 7,000 Today's Parent readers tell us why."
What was your early breastfeeding relationship like? Did you have to overcome any obstacles? How did you do it?
Contributing editor Amy Gates blogs about green living, attachment parenting, activism and photography at Crunchy Domestic Goddess.
Comments
20 years ago, I gave birth
20 years ago, I gave birth to my firstborn son. I had a difficult labor, we had Rh incompatibility, I had gestational diabetes, yet was determined to give birth to him in the most natural environment possible. We hired the services of the local birth center with the knowledge that if anything went wrong during the birth process, we would be transferred to the closest hospital.
Well, things did start to go downhill when my water broke and was in labor for days with no resolution. Finally, after a very long and difficult labor, my son was born. He was immediately tested for blood sugar, among other things. Soon after that, I was told to feed him a bottle of sugar water to get his blood sugar up, which of course, I did, as I trusted my midwife. My son was yellow, but my midwife assured me that all would be fine in a few days. She told me to let him sleep next to a window in the sunlight, which we complied with. A few days passed and we received literally NO help from any member of the birth center. My son wasn't latching on correctly, but I didn't know what breastfeeding should or shouldn't feel like. I didn't know what was normal. When my midwife came by to check on us a few days later, she noticed that he was still yellow and told me to call our pediatrician right away. I brought him in and he was immediately admitted to the hospital. My son had sky-high bilirubin levels plus dehydration.
He spent the next 2 days under the lights. My pediatrician told me to start feeding him formula and my milk, which never seemed to amount to anything anyway, eventually dried up.
I was happy that my son was discharged from the hospital healthy and somewhat relieved that I was now bottle feeding him,thereby eliminating any further problems. I realized later on that my son and I were let down by so many different people who just didn't care about the breastfeeding relationship.
4 years later, when son #2 came along, I was better educated. I gave birth in a hospital with a midwife. After he was born, a lactation consultant came to see us to show me how to acheive the all-important latching on. I was also given helpful hints when I went to several LLL meetings. He nursed well for 2 years.
I decided to dedicate myself to helping other women and took some classes so that I could volunteer at our local WIC office to help low-income women succeed with breastfeeding.
I would not argue with the pediatrician or hospital's decision to admit my son to use the bilirubin lights. My son might not be alive today had it not been for his hospital stay. However, I would definitely encourage other mothers to start pumping if they find themselves in a similar situation.
We live and learn
We all do the best we can with the information we have at the time. I think it's great that you were able to educate yourself and get a better start with your second son. And I admire you for volunteering at WIC offic. What a wonderful service you are providing to the community. :)
Amy
Crunchy Domestic Goddess
BlogHers Act contributing editor
Eight years ago, I didn't have this problem
My son was born eight years ago and had jaundice that required time in the lighted bilibed. Never did my doctor suggest that he be supplemented with formula and I am forever grateful for that. The pediatrician just told me to continue to breastfeed on demand. There's enough worry about the jaundice, especially with a first-born, to introduce worries about nipple confusion. Hopefully this trend will continue.
My son did have trouble at first at daycare with taking breastmilk from a bottle, but eventually he was fine.
Angela at mommy bytes
So glad your Ped
So glad your Ped encouraged you to breastfeed on demand. From what I understand, as long as the mom's milk has come in and the baby is producing an adequate number of pee/poop diapers,there should be no need for formula supplementation.
I'm right there with you. Nipple confusion is the last thing postpartum moms need to deal with.
Amy
Crunchy Domestic Goddess
BlogHers Act contributing editor
jaundice is not normal
while most cases of jaundice in the first few days of life is newborn or breastfeeding jaundice, you should always see your doctor if your newborn's jaundice continues past a week. especially if it is accompanied by loose, pale coloured stools, dark urine or slow growth. there are a number of pediatric liver diseases for which jaundice is the first symptom. my son has one of them. one of the most common diseases needs to be diagnosed early to take advantage of a procedure that can correct it.
so, yes, continue to breastfeed. but see your doctor too. jaundice is NOT normal. it is a sign of the liver not working properly.
You are so right!
I know so many people with similar situations and no one thinks to start getting these mothers pumping or to use alternative feeding techniques, like cup or spoon feeding, which helps them adjust to breastfeeding. With more nurses receiving breastfeeding education, I hope this culture changes. Moms need options and offering their baby expressed breast milk and feeding at the breast with a supplementer should be the #1 options. Great job! Anyway, colustrum will get things moving out from their system faster than formula.
However, as some posters mentions, we still need to be aware that bilirubin can be very dangerous, especially as it spreads down their body and can lean to kernicterus, so treatment is necessary (so long as its not "breastfeeding jaundice")
Debra
www.BeyondPrenatals.com
jaundice and formula
I had the same experience and my DH had to give my son what amounted to 2 ounces of formula. I HATED it and to this day feel upset when I think about it. It was a slap in the face and felt as if I wasn't good enough for my son. If I had to do it all over again, I would assert myself and pump and have my DH give him my milk as a supplement. I don't get how advanced medicine is in a lot of areas but not in breast feeding support. It's ridiculous a national disgrace, really.
My BF experience so far
I gave birth to my beautiful daughter 5 weeks ago, and except for some latch problems when my milk first came in, she is doing great! I did have an issue with the pediatrician when we went in for a visit the day after coming home from the hospital. She showed signs of being hungry when we were at the office, so with out really asking he automatically when and got a small bottle of formula- like you get at the hospital- and gave her some. As a first time mom- I kind of just stood there and went along with it since he is the doctor and knows best- even though my gut told me otherwise. He told me to nurse her for 15 minutes and then offer the formula. I took a breastfeeding class while pregnant and knew that this was not a good idea. Most babies will take a bottle after nursing if offered to them for this reason: they suck for comfort and bottle unlike breast will give then formula which they end up spitting up. I did not end up giving her the formula at all and at our 2wk appointment she had gained back her birth weight and an additonal 12ozs. The pediatrician did not mention the formula, but did mentioned what a great job I was doing exclusively breastfeeding.
I understand why some doctors like FF babies, you know exactly how much they are eating at each feeding and can ensure they are getting enough and growing. The problem though is that this decision should be left up to the parents, not the doctor. Unless the baby is showing signs of dehydration or so forth, breastfeeding should be continued if the parents want to. I will still continue to go the same ped because he is such a great doctor, but I know with my next baby , or if it happens again with this one, to assert myself and tell him "no thanks" if he tries to offer formula.
I think knowledge is the key- the more as moms we know about breastfeeding the better equiped we are to address situations like this and the ones you mentioned.
~The future belongs to those who believe in the beauty of their dreams- Eleanor Roosevelt~
My son had jaundice and the
My son had jaundice and the nursery gave him formula from a bottle without ever even telling us. Breastfeeding had started out great, and then after a few days he just refused to breastfeed at all. I had no idea why until we figured out what had happened. I tried everything, but he never wanted to latch on after that, so I pumped for several months. I think hospitals need to work with moms on this rather than make decisions without their input. I deserved more help.
Katherine Stone Postpartum Progress http://postpartumprogress.typepad.com