Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Pacis and Sippy Cups: Champagne Going In, Sewage Coming Out

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

When people asked me if I was going to let my infant daughter use pacifiers, I was all "Y-E-S to the YES."  I gave her a paci when she was three days old and didn't take it away again until she was eighteen months old. She promptly replaced it with a Nuby cup and went along, sucking her way to sleep each night. Why? Because taking them away was SO PAINFUL.

Here's how it happens, though: I was just thinking to myself when asked to write this post, "Maybe it really wasn't that bad?"  So I surfed through my Surrender, Dorothy archives for an hour or so and found this gem from August 2007:

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The little angel had her first trip to the dentist this morning. She was great during the teeth counting, teeth cleaning and demonstrative twirling she did for the dentist.  She was great while I got my teeth "cut" as she called what the dental hygienist was doing with the sharp, pointed stick.  (I tried to tell her they were cleaning my teeth, but it did sort of feel like the woman was intentionally missing a few too many times with her instrument of torture.)  Then the dentist dropped on us what I've been dreading for months:  "Does she use a bottle or pacifier?"

Ah, the cup.  The famed Nuby.  Or, as we like to call it around here:  F*cking Hell F*ck Cup.

Here's what happened when we took away my daughter's paci:  Six months during which she woke up every two hours for anywhere from twenty minutes to four hours.  By the end of this period, I was barely capable of working my full-time job, operating an automobile or smiling. I'd also gone on Zoloft. It was the worst six months of my entire life, and I'm going to go ahead and include Ma's cancer and my eating disorder in my life, because this was the first time I experienced months on end of three to four hours of choppy sleep with no naps, no relief, and an irritible boss.  It hurt my marriage, it hurt my relationship with my daughter and it threw off my dopamine so badly I was crying at least three hours a day.

So you can guess how excited I am to chuck the F*ck Cup.  The dentist seemed surprised when I promptly commenced crying right there in her open, cube-style office.  "What's wrong?" she said.

"Oh, it's just that the last time..." I stammered.

"Well, just give her a reward system.  Have you tried that?"

And then I killed her.

Not really, but seriously, how stupid of a question is that?  No, I never have ever tried a rewards system on a potty-trained, vegetable-eating three-year-old who didn't sleep for six months of her life except during naps at daycare.  Why?  It never occurred to me.  What a brilliant idea!  Clearly, I've got much to benefit from your parenting advice.  Wow, thank goodness I stepped foot in this dentist office today.

Now, of course, I'm not being fair, but seriously?  "Have you ever tried that?"  The thing is that these advice givers don't have to come live in my house and experience the night that goes like this:

Bed at 8:30.  Screaming for paci or cup will go on for about two hours.  That will put us at 10:30.

She'll wake up first at 1:30.  She'll ask for the paci/cup. Screaming will go on for about twenty minutes to two hours.

If she went back to sleep at all, she'll wake up again at 3:30, and we'll repeat that session.

At 5:30, when she wakes up again, we'll go down on the couch, where she'll finally fall into a deep sleep, I won't hear the alarm, and she'll wake up crabby as hell and I'll give myself a black eye trying to get showered and to work in time.  I'll slog through the day like a zombie, crying in the bathroom approximately once an hour, fall asleep in the parking garage when I get in my car, wake up, realize there's no way to get to daycare on time because it's now a full hour away, stress all the way there, and pick up a little angel who's rejuvinated from a three-hour nap and ready to do the whole thing again.  If this goes on for more than a week, I'll have to add

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
sugarbritches26 5 pts

I feel your pain. Getting my first to give up the paci was a horror stricken, sleep deprived, hair falling out hell. He was 3 before he gave it up entirely. My second son gave his up peacefully at age 1. My daughter just turned one yesterday and there is no freaking way I'm even attempting to remove that thing from her mouth at bedtime. Not gonna even try it. 

A.A.

knittingzeal 5 pts

I never truly understood what real torture was until having a child and experiencing so much sleep deprivation.  While my son's sleep issues are not the same as your daughter's, I can totally sympathize with you regarding the fear of losing sleep again.  Glad things are on track now for you!   

 Diane

http://knittingzeal.typepad.com

GlassDragonfly 5 pts

I am not sure why the paci needs to go away. My now 20 year old daughter gave up hers on her own terms when she was 3 1/2 years old. *It was cute, she was using it and I asked her what she was doing, and she took it out of her mouth, looked at it with a questioning face and then she threw it in the trash. I don't know what she was thinking, but she never asked for or needed it again* She didn't have ANY dental issues because of it. She felt secure while using it and when she was done, she was done.

Her baby teeth...looking at photos...did show a little curve because of the pacifier (she did see a dentist regularly, and the issue was never brought up), but it didn't correlate to her adult teeth. At all! I think that sometimes these things are over worried about.

I am not saying that your decision was wrong, I just had a different experience.

Every child is different. As are we!!

babybeatnik 5 pts

Here's to hoping that my second daughter, 1 mo, gives up on her paci as easily as my first did. Gracie, my first daughter, took the paci from day one, but only for about 2 months when she just on day decided that she didn't want it anymore.

And let me tell you - I'm not at ALL religious, but I just got through helping a friend deal with "weaning" her daughter from the paci, and having dealt with that ounce of Hell, I got down on my knees and thanked Jesus (yes, specifically Jesus.) for the fact that Gracie gave it up so easily. She had just begun sleeping through the night (yes, I thanked God for that too.) so the only time it was ever difficult was during the daytime, and that faded quickly.

When I was pregnant this time around, I had made the decision to not use a pacifier with my daughter. I am breastfeeding exclusively and I didn't want any nipple confusion. But, after my third completely sleepless night in the hospital with her, I caved. It's helped quite a bit, and she, like Gracie, only takes the paci when it's practically forced on her. So, I'm hoping that the similarities there are a sign of good fortune ahead.

And if, after Kairi (my infant) has begun to sleep through the night shows no signs of giving up the paci, I am going to attempt weaning her... I think it will be easier on both of us if we do it early. But who knows? So, here's to hoping.

AmberS 5 pts

Oh, the well-meaning advice from the clueless. I remember telling a relative I couldn't take my 2-year-old to the grocery store because she didn't want to sit in the cart, and if I let her out of the cart she would run away from me. Then there would be the screaming. It was awful.

She replied, "You should just bring a snack with you." Because it never occurred to me to try offering my toddler a snack. Come on, that's the first thing I tried, it didn't work! Like they say, free advice is worth what you paid for it. ;)

~ Amber

www.strocel.com ( http://www.strocel.com )

Elisa Camahort 5 pts

Ha! Kate you totally just reminded me of my grandma. Whenever the subject of potty training came up she'd say (imagine this in a lovely European accent):

"Don't worry too much about it. (S)he'll get there. No one ever walked down the aisle in diapers!"

Makes me LOL just remembering it...which is nice :)

Elisa Camahort Page
BlogHer
elisa@blogher.com

My BlogHer profile ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) truly shows you everything I do online...Check it out!!

aftercancer 5 pts

Hang in there!  I work in early childhood intervention and I promise, she's not going to take it to college or on her honeymoon. Also these are her baby teeth, save for braces now and you'll be fine. 

Kate

I blog at http://www.aftercancernowwhat.blogspot.com