Bio
I'm a mom, a blogger, a private dayhome operator, and a big fan of quiet activism.  I love to read, swim, bike, watch my kids discover their wor...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Parenting Lessons Learned

from Hoarders (or, How Not

To Raise a Little Hoarder)

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 31
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Hoarders. Do you watch that show?

Please tell me you watch that show. The fact that I (a) watch reality TV at all, and (b) watch the most spectacular oh-my-god-i-can't-avert-my-eyes kind of car accident primetime television has ever provided, makes me feel a little (okay, A LOT) embarrassed. I'm not alone, guys. Right? Please?

I mean, I'm an educated woman. Shouldn't I be watching NOVA and participating in global chat forums on improving the happiness of humanity?

Well, I don't.

I get my kids to bed, finish the end-of-day clean-up, park my ass on the couch -- Harmony remote in hand -- and watch, slackjawed, while a group of profoundly patient people try to rid a house of all manner of disgustingness and/or improve the life of the person who had accumulated all of that, well, shit.

Wowzers.

Sometime between the end of high school and the beginning of university, I prided myself on being able to fit all of my belongings in a single tomato crate. Now, my house gets purged regularly of all that is too small, too worn out, too unused, or too useless. I do keep file boxes of my kids' crafts. I do have my old hope chest full of mementos, unfinished novels, and photos from way-back-when. We have a few memory albums, cupboards of project supplies, and tens of thousands of digital photos that need to be edited for processing. For me, anyway, life with kids has equaled life with more stuff. And I'm good with that. As long as it's clean.

BeforeMy daughter? Ohmygod, my daughter loves stuff. Tiny toys, bits of paper, notebooks, stuffies, stickers, stick-on tattoos, activity books, silk flowers, birthday cake decorations, and hundreds of other pretty little things. She also has a tiny bedroom, which makes storing all of this stuff impossible a special kind of challenge. By her fifth birthday, the volume of stuff in her room had surpassed the ridiculous. And vacuuming her bedroom carpet put her into a state of supreme anxiety for fear that one of her useless miniscule precious items would get sucked up into the dust bin.

Sigh.

So, here's where I made the error. Since we have a firm no-hitting policy in my house, spanking is just not an option for us. My daughter has been smacked twice in her life, both times at the end of class-five temper tantrums that resulted in me losing my cool after she screamed and then spit in my face. My kids get strong verbal reprimands (sometimes at, ahem, volume). They get time-outs. They get privileges revoked. And last fall, I decided that one of those privileges would be toys.

You can see where I went wrong, here.

Danica would get the 1-2-3 count for escalating incidents of bad behavior. At "3", a toy would be confiscated and either donated or thrown in the garbage. I can't adequately describe for you the state of pain and fury this brought upon my girl. We progressed between losing the toy forever, to losing the toy for a week, to having her choose the toy to get rid of, and so on. It wasn't working. Her behavior improved marginally. Her resentment improved exponentially. But she was going through such a rough time handling her own attitude and impulse control that I honestly didn't know what else to do.

And then, one night this summer, I looked up from my bowl of greasy popcorn at the horrors unfolding on Hoarders. I saw an adult standing in the one remaining square foot of carpet in a room packed full of filth and TOYS, and very nearly vomited. He said, "My parents always took my toys away. Now I can have as many as I want."

Oh. My. God.

The next weekend, I made plans to clean up Danica's room. All of her toys, papers, art supplies, birthday party favors, cards, pens, her spinny chair, a side-table, everything. I sorted it into piles of things that I wanted to store for later, move to other parts of the house, keep in her room, or throw away. And then she and I spent that morning going through those piles so she could make the final decision about what she wanted done with it. We talked about how small her room was, how she really couldn't use this many toys, and about how much fun other kids might have with them. She told me she wanted more space for playing in

  • 31
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
MamaMia11 5 pts

Wow - thank you for sharing this! Hoarding - not truly hoarding, but something awfully close to it - runs in my family. It's horrible, frightening, and I just don't want to go there. I am on a mission to rid my house of clutter, and to raise a child who understands the difference between material and memory. It's a journey, not an instant fix, but reading posts like yours give me hope that I can slowly pull us out of what feels like a clutter filled doom! Thanks again.

DesiValentine4 295 pts

You are so welcome! My daughter loves to collect stuff, so helping her stay organized and make decisions about what of her things she really wants to keep is an ongoing thing. It is very tempting to just move her into a bigger bedroom, but that really wouldn't solve anything. Best of luck on your journey! De-cluttering is like therapy for me. So liberating! MamaMia11

Just_Margaret 8 pts

My own secret indulgence is watching Hoarders, too. I watch, and I so admire the courage some of these people have to not only let someone in to help them, but to allow it to be filmed. I watch, and honestly think, "There but for the grace of Maude go I", because I have definite hoarding tendencies myself. I also appreciate and respect the patience and care that the professionals on the show bring to these often shut-in people who are facing dire consequences because of their psychological disorder.

Because I am organizationally challenged myself, I fear what it is that I am NOT teaching my own kids because of my own disarray. I wind up cleaning their rooms for them because they just don't know where to start--and then I purge all kinds of stuff out of there.

I'd be interested to hear more about how this is working after a few months DesiValentine4 --do come update us!

DesiValentine4 295 pts

Just_Margaret I used to clean my kids rooms for them because I didn't want to cut into their playtime. They're kids, right? They should have as much time to play as possible, right? Until, of course, my daughter's room had escalated to the point I wrote about here. Sometimes choosing that first thing to put away is tough for her, but once she does that she's on a roll. I will keep you posted, for sure. Thanks for the interest! :)

Me a mom at home 5 pts

I have been thinking (for a while) to organize my daughter's room in a way that she would know exactly where to put every little things she has. Every time I make her clean her room I have to sit there and tell her what to pick up and where to put it. If I don't, it results in many time outs and her ending up stuffing everything anywhere like in her wardrobe or under her blanket ! Sometimes I laugh, sometimes I don't. There is so many things she doesn't play with... I think your post might just be the kick in the butt I needed (you scared me a little :-) to go on with my plan and also make my little one give some things away. All the little pieces of toys that ends up everywhere in the house! It's driving me crazy sometimes. Don't you hate McDo's for giving you more unused toys to pick up?

DesiValentine4 295 pts

lol Yes, McDonald's toys drive me crazy! Every once in awhile they get a toy that the kids absolutely love. Most of the time, though, it's just one more little thing to put away or step on :-) Me a mom at home

I was surprised at how much my daughter enjoyed going through her stuff with me. It was actually fun!

Ludicrous Mama 5 pts

My dad used to "trash" our rooms (as he called it,) where he'd clean by tossing everything into the garbage can that goes out to the curb. My husband watches Hoarders and says "Honey, that's almost us."

A lot of the reason I hoard/can't get rid of things is a genetic legacy from my mom; but the reason I am incapable of cleaning/organizing/getting rid of stuff is because I was never taught how. I was expected to clean without ever being assisted or shown how. My dad would toss out anything that wasn't cleaned to his standards, and then my mom and I would go through the garbage and fish most of it out the following day. And KEEPING my stuff is something I have control over now, where I had so little control over my life growing up with a controlling father. But even when I'm WILLING to go through my stuff and sort it into keep/sell/donate piles, I am psychologically incapable of doing it on my own. If my sister comes over and holds up items one by one, I can sort it. But give me a box of stuff to sort through on my own and you'll find me hours later surrounded by it, with nothing accomplished.

DesiValentine4 295 pts

Do you think this is something we should make a conscious effort to teach our kids? I didn't know how to clean until I got a job as a housekeeper during university, so my first basement suite apartment was just filthy. Ludicrous Mama It was packed with garbage, food containers, broken furniture. I'm embarrassed to think I lived that way for almost two years, and maybe that's another reason I'm so sensitive about it with my own kids.

When I tell my daughter to clean her room, she gets overwhelmed because she doesn't know where to start. So, lately, I've asked her to choose one thing and put it where it belongs, and so on, until everything is put away. I'm hoping that in a few years she'll be able to do that on her own.

Thanks for commenting. I really appreciate your perspective on this :-)

Arnebya 5 pts

@LudicrousDesiValentine4 Mama I do think it's up to us to "teach" our kids how to clean. I certainly wasn't taught. And sometimes (SOMETIMES!) at 38 friggin years old I still get overwhelmed with the sheer magnitude of all that is involved in keeping the house clean. Even with my husband and I tag teaming certain rooms, I feel like I'm losing the war on clutter. When I tell my girls to clean their room, I'll go up an hour later and they've made piles. So, clearly, I'm working on just "how" to clean so that I'm not sending clueless women into the world.

DesiValentine4 295 pts

Oh, me too. If it's not cleaning, it's maintenance - and the mess that comes along with fixing things. I'm at the point now where I feel we have to purge every six months or so. Just so that we have enough space left over that everything we own has a place to be put away. I guess the next step will be bringing less stuff in! Just in time for Christmas.... Arnebya@ludicrous

Just_Margaret 8 pts

I can totally relate: I don't know how to do it myself--how to get the kiddos to do it is another endeavor altogether!

DesiValentine4 295 pts

A friend of mine got a professional in to help her family, and she said it was live-changing. One day, when I find that money tree, I might just do that! Just_Margaret

Just_Margaret 8 pts

That's a great idea! DesiValentine4 And uh, if I find that money tree, I'll share with you ;-) We can both get organized

faycinacroud 5 pts

Here's the thing. That show is incredibly exploitative of a very real psychological problem. What's next: Tonight on "Schizophrenics?" The whole circus side show approach is appalling.

Hoarding is a form of obsessive compulsive disorder. It is a very tricky issue to deal with and shaming people is not going to correct the problem. It's all very nice to be able to "sit on the couch with your greasy popcorn bowl" and gape at the sideshow freaks. But those freaks are humans too, and no doubt feel extremely ashamed of their problem.

I am sure I'm going to get bashed to hell for this but how would you like to have people looking at you and going "ewww, what a freak, look how she lives?"

I have struggled with my own hoarding issues as well as type II bipolar disorder and borderline personality disorder. I can tell you that as a freak myself, I find that show disgusting and exploitative. You couldn't pay me enough to have people coming in with cameras and filming the "freak show."

I am not a stupid person. I have a reasonably high IQ. I am also not delusional. What I am is sick and tired of "normals" treating those who live with mental illness as if we are curiosities for the rest of you to laugh at.

DesiValentine4 295 pts

You're right. It is absolutely wrong that these shows are on television, and even more so that people like me sit and watch them. I am skeptical that shows like these truly help anyone heal. However, having had supported my extended family through conditions including oppositional defiance disorder, schizophrenia, obsessive compulsive disorder, and reactive attachment disorder - all conditions that can lead to compulsive hoarding behaviour among children and adults - I am perhaps oversensitive to the issue.

My point with this blog post was not to attribute value to Hoarders (or Intervention, or The Super, or any equally disgusting reality programming). I won't defend what they do, in the guise of "helping" for the love of ratings. I will say, though, that I don't want that life for my daughter. I don't want my behaviour toward her possessions to result in an unhealthy need to accumulate so many things. Having read the current literature on mental illness prevention and resilience development in young children - as I'm sure you have, as well - the methodology most often used on Hoarders is sound, however sensationalized. And, in this one instance of my mentally healthy five-year-old daughter experiencing such anxiety over her needful things, I am grateful for that.

I so appreciate your comment. It takes some bravery to be the one to make the counterargument, especially on such a sensitive, personal issue. And while I can't imagine anyone "laughing" while watching Hoarders, I see your point. There is no "normal", faycinacroud . Have a look at the DSM-IV and you'll see that all of us are on the mental illness spectrum, somewhere. And maybe that's why we watch.

SidMILB 5 pts

I watch that show. I kinda LIVE that show. My SO is the adult child of hoarders. I have to fight his tendencies in our home often. He does not see his own clutter; he only sees mine. He's still cleaning out his late parents' hoard. It's been a year and a half now.

Sounds like you reached a good, healthy middle ground with Danica. Keep up the good work!

DesiValentine4 295 pts

My Mum and my sister keep everything, too and each time I see them I have to resist the urge to wade in and purge the place for them. It is their space, and I love them both too much to be disrespectful of their choices in their own home. It must be really difficult for you, sometimes. SidMILB

Thanks so much!

Laine Griffin 95 pts

I am always wondering if I have a future hoarder on my hands! Awesome post!!

DesiValentine4 295 pts

So glad you enjoyed it! Laine Griffin When my mum read this post all she could say was "Wait until she's a teenager!" :D

isthisthemiddle 480 pts

Congrats on getting the post featured! You struck a nerve. If we aren't hoarders, we may harbor a tiny secret fear of becoming one.

Go Danica and the clean room!

isthisthemiddle 480 pts

I believe in a little "trashy" tv now and then (pun intended). Sometimes we just need to check out of our own lives and see how silly people can be.

But I'm with you that Hoarders can teach all of us a lesson. I think it's great that the show gave you parenting ideas. You are such a thoughtful mom!

DesiValentine4 295 pts

That's exactly it :) isthisthemiddle I do feel like I'm checking out of my own life for a little while, when I watch that show, And my daughter is really enjoying her clean room :) Thanks!

HomeRearedChef 635 pts

First, I don't watch reality TV. Sorry! So there!

By the way, I like what could have been your other title for this post, "Parenting Lessons Learned from Danica." I guess that as parents we find out that we are never too old to learn new things from our kids. Smiling!

~Virginia

DesiValentine4 295 pts

lol Good for YOU! It's a shameful addiction, I know. I expect my reality tv time will become study time very soon, so at least there is that light at the end of the tunnel :) HomeRearedChef And you're right - my kids have something to teach me every day. Thanks for the smiles!

Conversation from Twitter

DesiValentine4
DesiValentine4

blogher I should get that on a T-shirt!

ysmith2012
ysmith2012

blogher You are absolutely right

MommaBeThyName
MommaBeThyName

DesiValentine4 Woo hoo! Congrats!

DesiValentine4
DesiValentine4

MommaBeThyName Thanks!