Parents' Facebook Infiltration: Why The Natives Are Still Restless
by Gina Carroll

Why are the natives still so restless about adult presence on Facebook? (“Natives” are, of course, the young adults and teens Facebook was originally designed for.) You’d think they would be accustomed to our presence and fully adjusted by now. But alas, they are not. They are sensing what feels to them like a takeover. And they may be right since 35-to-54-year-olds lead the Facebook influx with a 276% growth rate this year. The second fastest growing group is 55 and older. And coming in third is the 25-to-34-year-old age group. Many young folks continue to express discomfort and disdain about, not just our presence, but how we are present.

Take, for example, this description of the Facebook Group called “Parents are Ruining Facebook”:
I am pretty sure everyone is getting tired of mommy and daddy giving you a talk every time you say a “bad word” on your status. Facebook used to be a place we could express ourselves, and now it’s just a place for parents and family friends to spy on us and know everything that goes on in our life. I personally am tired of it, and my parents don’t even have facebooks! Join this group if you are tired of the sh--! Oh wait am I allowed to say that?

This group’s somewhat meager 308 members might not impress you considering the astronomical number of young people on Facebook. But when you take into account all of the other Facebook groups with similar themes,

Parents are now using Facebook. This is a problem

Parents are ruining Facebook for me

Parents are so Nosey

Parents Can’t Have Facebook

Parents Being On Facebook Sucks,

the commonality of this anti-adult sentiment is striking.

Forced Friendship

For younger kids just starting out on Facebook and other social networking sites, parental presence is an expected part of the experience. After all, their parents are likely already participating in the medium by the time they come to it. And as discussed in several posts and comments in this Family Connections group, many kids cannot participate unless they friend their parents.

Older teens and young adults, however, consider Facebook to be their domain… and they are mourning its expansion to include both younger kids and adults. My older children were just entering college when Facebook hit the cyber-scene. It was an exclusively college student network. In fact, you had to have a college or university email address to join up. This was so exciting to me because for my kids, having lived their childhoods in several places throughout the country, Facebook was a mechanism to reconnect with many of their friends in other locations. Also mine, like most kids their age, enjoyed Facebook as a place to share the college experience with their high school buddies who had dispersed in every direction after graduation.

Once the floodgates were opened, my older kids thought it “weird” when their little sister’s high school buddies asked to be friends. They felt awkward about this phenomenon. You can just imagine how they felt when their 55-year-old uncle suddenly appeared with a friend request!! Yikes! How do you say no to your beloved uncle? And how much torture must you endure when the aunt that you begrudgingly friend starts making disparaging remarks about your status statements or your pictures? This is just not the same Facebook experience!! Rotten In Denmark expresses this sentiment perfectly, in his letter to his Facebooking mother:

Dear Mom, I know I still hold a serious deficit for the head-first labor, the bed-wetting, the braces, the moody angst, college tuition and the time I made you take me to see ‘Problem Child 2’. But can I make it up to you without adding you on Facebook? I am not ready for you to see the genital references on my wall, the filthy verbing in my applications or my pictures tagged ‘TUESDAY-DRUNK-AGAIN.’ My heart breaks a little bit every time I click ‘ignore’….but I’m not going to stop clicking it. Love, Your Ungrateful Mike

From “Don’t Embarrass Me” to “Cooler Than Me”

Part of the problem may be that parents appear to be having more fun on Facebook than their children. Leslie Ventura, at UWire.com, laments her parent’s new mastery of the digital world:

While we wait for Conan O’Brien to come on, the volume on the television is lowered so my mother can hear herself shoot zombies on her favorite iPhone app. Still waiting for Conan, mom checks what movie is in her queue, has a conversation with relatives through Facebook Chat, updates her status on Twitter and downloads mp3s from indie music blogs – all via her MacBook. My mom is cooler than me.

Still, as put off as teens and the college set are about our infiltration, they are still devoted to Facebook as their medium of choice. Most have long abandoned MySpace and have never really taken to Twitter. So they are coping with the onslaught of adults and waiting for that new thing to come to the rescue. All they are asking is that we adults give them some space and allow them a courteous way to keep Grandma, Uncle Al and Aunty Em at bay. Is that too much to ask?

To friend or not to friend?

If you are still perplexed about whether or not to friend your child (young or adult), Dr. Elvira Aletta, clinical psycholgist, mother of two teens, and blogger at ExploreWhatsNext.com, offers a great list of considerations:

1. Begin with the premise that Internet access, including Facebook, is a privilege and a responsibility for all. In other words, be a good role model.

2. Educate yourself about Facebook. Join parents online who are also struggling with this topic. Common Sense Media is a good example.

3. Discuss becoming Facebook friends with your kid first, casually, face to face. You may need more than one talk.

4. Listen and think hard before making a unilateral decision one way or the other.

5. If your child asks to not be Facebook friends, take a deep breath and do not be offended. Respect.

6. If you don’t know your kid well enough that you need Facebook to bridge a gap in your relationship, you’ve got a bigger problem than being FB buds. Get to know your kid another way, not through Facebook.

7. If your child says, yes, let’s be friends: That does not give you license to stalk them. Respect the boundaries and do not abuse the privilege. If you have an older teen, every time a photo goes up of your kid at a party you didn’t know about, do not write on her wall and call her out. Talk it out in private. Resist the urge to ‘friend’ your kid’s real friends.

8. Whether or not you are friends on Facebook make sure you and your kid know the security issues on Facebook and the Internet at large. Facebook has settings that allow the user to control who sees their information including media sharing.

9. Be sure everyone understands the concerns regarding sexting, photo and media sharing, the permanent nature of electronic data, future access by college and job application reviewers, viral spread of personal info, etc.

10. Do they Know everyone on their Facebook friend list?

11. For you, the parents. By all means, open your own Facebook account, play around with it, connect with old friends, make new ones. It really is fun, it’s free and you can always opt out. Do it for you, not just to watch over your kid.

(http://psychcentral.com/blog/archives/2009/08/25/to-be-or-not-to-be-my-kids-friend-on-facebook/)

Comments

 

Parents on Facebook

I am 35 and my father just joined Facebook. I am not so happy about it but my 61 year old father is addicted!

 

Dad on Facebook

I'm 40 and love that my dad is on facebook.  I took a big trip last summer and posted photos of the kids and my roadtrip all the way via FB.  That way I didn't have to send everything to him separately.  Sure he sees my bad words but it's just fine.  A good way to keep up from 3,000 miles.

d.

www.InTheHammerLane.blogspot.com
www.TheSavvyGirls.com

 

A Pain for You, But Good For Dad

Well, redheadedjen,

If your Dad is addicted, that means he is online all of the time. And if you have friended him, that means he sees your status updates just as soon as you post them. You might not like that so much. But take heart, the connection and the online activity is great for his brain and according to studies, his overall morale. Perhaps rememebering that might help you take one for the team!! :-)

Think Act: Proactive Black Parenting

 

Muahahahahahahaha

My tween ( and her friends!) were the ones who friended ME cuz she was still 11 at the time and being on Facebook with your mom was still OK then.

So I'm grandfathered in. Sweet.

 

 

 

http://www.happymealsandhappyhour.blogspot.com

Happy Hour Sue 

 

Not a big deal to me

I have several different social networks intersected within Facebook:  My childhood and high school people, first college people, second college people, coworkers, last city lived people, current city people.  My boyfriend is also there.  So all of it coming together makes it complicated anyway.

If my mom joined and added me, I could set some privacy preferences.  Or delete any possibly "offensive" update or picture.  My mom's best friend is my Facebook friend, and she regularly reports much of my Facebook activity to my mother.  So what I am conscious of in this medium is, "Is all content on my profile clean enough for even my mother to see it?"  I recently detagged myself from any "drunk" party pics.  No suggestive bikini pics, no drunk pics, etc.  Just edit and keep it clean.  Not so hard.  Add privacy settings anywhere else.

http://ediblemarie.tumblr.com

 

Learn the Limited Profile

People with complaints as to who can see what (from co-workers so relatives to the annoying neighbor) need to learn the instructions for a limited profile. Information can be found very easily in Facebook's FAQ (linked here).

You can, of course, make more than one list of limited access. If you don't want your co-workers to have access to your wall but you'd like your mom to still see your status updates, you can make two different limited lists. It's not particularly difficult to manage.

Quite honestly, if my children were old enough for Facebook (they are not), I wouldn't particularly care if they were upset by my presence. Facebook is utilized as both a social networking (friends) and career networking (work) tool for me. Their annoyance with my presence would be a life lesson in respecting my space as I would hope that I could respect theirs (which hopefully still wouldn't include cussing, Facebook or not).

 

@FireMom from Stop, Drop and Blog and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land

 

Not my teens, but other people's teens...

angelawd: the writer gets the last word

My daughters don't use Facebook, but I'm the leader of a high school youth group and have friended many of the teens at their request. It gets uncomfortable when I see some of their updates and wonder how much their parents know about it. I haven't yet seen anything that was serious enough to call a parent about, though.

 

 

Invited to Friend as Mentor but not as Mom

angelawd,

I also have a friend who mentors teens. She got on Facebook because one of her mentees suggested it. All of her mentees friend her, and she makes a point to be a quiet, non-judgmental  presence. She says that she congratulates their accomplishments, but never offers advice or criticism.

Her own two grown children (in their early 20s) refuse to friend her, though!!

 

My mother's disturbing online presence
(advice, anyone?)

I am currently struggling with how to handle my mother's online activity. I'm nearly 30 and my husband and I are getting our own small businesses off the ground. My parents have been very supportive (emotionally and financially) which we really appreciate, but my mom has become obsessive. We use social networks, blogs, and other online venues to promote our businesses, but every time we add any new content she immediately posts and comments (often within seconds!). It has gotten to the point that we had to enable approval for comments on MySpace, and have started routinely deleting her posts elsewhere. Her activity makes us look unprofessional and the energy it takes to police her presence should be focused on the businesses instead.

 

This behavior carries over to our personal social network activity as well. I love my mom and don't mind if she sees my wall posts and links, but I can't post anything without her immediately responding. It is annoying and quite frankly creepy, as she's added all my friends (even those she barely knows from when I was in high school) and will comment on everything I post to their profiles as well. I feel like she is stalking us online. I don't think she means any harm, but she really needs to back off and develop her own social networks instead of piggy-backing and living vicariously through my husband and me. I only feel safe posting this because I don't believe she knows I have an account here.

 

I don't know how to approach her about this. She is smart enough to know what she's doing is inappropriate, but also manipulative enough to play the guilt card if I call her on it. I don't want to hurt her feelings, but she doesn't seem to be getting the hint when her obsessive content is repeatedly removed. Her and my dad are retired and have shared hobbies, but don't have a very strong friendship (so I don't feel like my dad would be able to help much with the situation). Does anyone here have experience successfully managing a bored/lonely/ nosey/overbearing parent as a grown adult?

 

Pass On Some Helpful Info

CtrlAltDeviant,

If you can't directly explain to your mom how disturbing her behavior is, perhaps you can blitz her with articles and blog posts about this kind of behavior-- about online addictions, cyber-bullying, and parental harrassment. There's a lot being said in the blogsphere about these issues, like this article which offers an Internet addiction test and what to do about it. If you keep sending information to her, maybe she'll get the hint...And perhaps some of the advice and tips can help her. When and if dialog between you begins, let her know that you sent the info with love and benevolent concern!!

Think Act: Proactive Black Parenting

 

Good tips

Thanks Gina. I'm going to try posting links on Facebook to articles as you suggest. Since she immediately reads and comments on all my content, perhaps she'll see a pattern emerging.

I didn't realize how common my situation was until after your response when I started doing some searches and found other blog posts. It's unsettling that there seem to be many others dealing with these issues, but at least that means there are helpful resources available online and a community who understands.