Blog
Zandria.us
Bio
Hi! My name is Zandria, and I live in Washington, DC. I wrote for BlogHer.com for over three years (on topics related to single life and online datin...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Personal Trainers: The Good and the Bad

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

If I had the money, I’d hire a personal trainer. I’d want someone really badass – a person who’d get up in my face, push me, yell at me if I wasn’t working hard enough, and be available on my schedule. Basically, I want someone who’d kick my butt on a regular basis. I want to be a lean(er), mean(er), fighting machine.

It’s not that I’m looking for the motivation to go to the gym, because my three-times-a-week weight workouts are going to happen regardless. But I tend to do the same routines a lot, depending on which muscle group I’m working that day, so it would be helpful to have someone there who could lead me through different combinations. (Variety – it’s a wonderful thing.)

Or, if not for just variety and yelling-at-Zan purposes, having someone there to spot me so I can work my way up to lifting heavier weights would be really ideal. I tend to use heavier weights when I have someone there with me, because if I get halfway through a move and I’m stuck with a heavy bar above my chest, it’s nice to have someone there to take it from me so it doesn’t smash down on my ribcage. For this reason, if I’m at the gym by myself I tend to lift weights that I know I can handle.

I’m definitely doing better than when I first started, but if I had someone there with me on a regular basis I’m sure I could have progressed even faster – maybe I’d even be doing “real” pushups by now. (I am determined! I will do them!)

Given all this, you would think I’d jump at the chance to take advantage of the personal-training option at my gym (three free sessions when you first become a member, then one free session per month). However, as much as I like my gym, the trainers on staff are lackadaisical and completely UN-motivating. I’ve never actually had a session with one of the staff-trainers, but I’ve seen enough of them in action to know that I’d much rather work out by myself.

(Picture this: a woman does some ab exercises while her “trainer” stands by with arms folded, looking in the opposite direction. He speaks in a monotone. For the last half hour of their hour-long session? He tells her to get on the treadmill – which, of course, he won’t have to stick around for.)

The only trainers I’ve seen at the gym (the ones not dressed in the requisite bright teal staff t-shirts) who come across as attentive and motivating are the ones who aren't employed by the gym. I’m guessing this is partly due to the fact that they’re getting paid more to be there. Either that, or they really like what they’re doing.

Even though I’ve seen plenty of unmotivating trainers, the ones who do know what they’re doing are truly inspiring and can go a long way in helping someone meet their fitness goals. I think the mark of a good trainer is someone who’s genuinely interested in your progress.

Kelly says that what she likes most about her job as a personal trainer is when she’s able to help people realize what they can do and what they’re capable of.

What I dearly love…is seeing someone who couldn’t do a push up from their knees achieve ten perfect reps of from-the-feet push ups. Watching folks get a first pull up. Seeing people who spent most of their time barely moving become weekend bike riders and runners. Looking at a new person who wants to lose thirty pounds and recognizing the combo of coordination and posture and fire that will mean they’ll have a stellar clean-and-jerk. Watching shlumpy people become badasses. I have yet to meet someone who had no potential. […]

I’m totally in this thing because I believe fitness is possible for everyone. Weight loss? I don’t really care, even though I’ll help you with that any day. But if you want to be in shape, that is yours. It’s right in front of you. Completely and utterly doable. And I don’t just mean healthy; I mean athletic. Generally I feel most fired up about getting women to see they can have upper body strength and they don’t have to ask for help moving shit or whatever, but I’m very equal opportunity. If you want it, it’s yours.

(In another post, Kelly shares how she

  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Kathy333 5 pts

Great, great post! I am also going to check out the others that you listed. I agree, I want someone right there with me pushing me on. I've seen the ones who suffer from bored indifference-no thanks, i can get that from my four year old anyday!

Kathy

Mama Marathoner ( http://www.mamamarathoner.com )

Carmen S 5 pts

I have worked with a trainer since June of last year. I can honestly say that I lost all of the weight by myself, but he's shaped my body into what it is today. I work with him 3-4 mornings a week for about 45 or so minutes, and I know I've never worked this hard before.

He cut our family a great deal, but some months it's still a huge stretch to pay him. I"d do it regardless. I am worth the money.

Debra Roby 5 pts

I've been working with Guido on and off for almost 18 months now. I would never be in the place I am physically or emotionally had he not been there encouraging me. Sometime we work intensely together; other times once a week. And I take time off to work on things on my own.

He does not get in my face. He stands behind me, constantly checking my form. He talks quietly. He touches muscles points gently for the right beginning and end of a move. He laughs. A lot.

When my muscles are at fatigue and I need to move through 2 more reps, his "I'm here with you" just behind my ear helps more than the assist as he reaches out and spots me.

Debra
A Stitch In Time ( http://astitchintime.blogspot.com )
Deb's Daily Distractions ( http://debsdistractions.blogspot.com )

Vered 5 pts

I am happy with the results of my home workout routine, but if I wanted a personal trainer, I think I would find a way to fit it into my budget. I think that you don’t need to see it as a long-term commitment (that would indeed be costly), but rather as a few sessions that you can take every few months, to get important guidance and help you stay on track. So, if you pay this month for 5 sessions spread over 5 weeks, that could bring you to the next level in weight lifting and then you can continue on your own. Then, six month from now, pay for 5 more sessions.

Vered DeLeeuw
www.momgrind.com ( http://www.momgrind.com )