Bio
I'm the BlogHer Contributing Editor on parenting children with special needs, and I'm at your service.  I am more than a parent, but with three...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

The Pertussis Epidemic and the Anti-Vaccination Movement

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 30
  • Sparkle (
    )
     
Patient about to receive injection in arm

Have your kids brought home as many pertussis (whooping cough) booster information sheets and exposure notices as mine have this school year? These notices, the fact that we're in the middle of a whooping cough epidemic shocks me -- because whooping cough is only supposed to exist in books from other eras, such as Ballet Shoes. Also, like you, I have no real-world experience with pertussis in my family or community, due to the success of our national vaccination program. Whooping cough isn't supposed to happen, not anymore.

These notices should shock you, too -- into action, into calling your pediatrician to make sure your kids are up-to-date on their pertussis vaccinations; into calling your own doctor to make sure you're up-to-date, and getting a Tdap booster if you need it. In other words, into taking pertussis seriously.

Why are we seeing the worst pertussis epidemic in 55 years? Why, in California alone, have nine babies died from pertussis while hundreds more are critically ill? Health officials say it is partially due to the cyclical nature of pertussis. But they also say it's due to parents' autism-related fears about vaccinating their kids, as NPR reported this week. Though theories on vaccine-autism causation have been repeatedly dismissed, mercury-causes-autism organizations such as Generation Rescue are still pushing vaccine theories (if you want to see how vehemently the anti-vaccination movement continues to defend its misinformation, check out the 440+ comments on my recent article Why My Child With Autism Is Fully Vaccinated*).

These vaccine fears, and the actions parents take on behalf of them -- such as signing philosophical vaccine exemptions -- have a real and deadly effect on public health. As reported by KQED's Gabriela Quirós, "... in states where getting an exemption is easy, such as in California, the rate of whooping cough was at least 50 percent higher than in states that made it more difficult for parents to opt out."** (If you are in California, you can see the personal exemption rates for your child's school at: http://www.baycitizen.org/local/counties/immunizations/ -- note only schools with kindergarten students are included.)

This is why California is considering cutting back its immunization exemptions. And this is why California will mandate pertussis vaccinations in all middle schoolers, starting July 2011, an action that pleases the anti-vaccination movement not at all.

The parent in this video demonstrate how the anti-vaccination movement stokes viewers' righteous indignation -- she is complaining that she doesn't want her kid being "collateral damage" for other kids' health -- but she has already been accommodated, she had the right to take a personal exemption, whereas the children exposed to pertussis via their unvaccinated peers have been given no such choice. Yes, her child would have stay home during outbreaks -- that is the only safe option for any child exempt from immunization, whether for medical or philosophical reasons. Besides, who has ever heard anecdotes about middle schoolers regressing into autism? Her claims are rooted in absurdity. I also suspect that, if she had any exposure to vaccine-preventable disease victims, she might reconsider her message.

I recently participated in a pertussis education conference call, arranged by the vaccination education non-profit agency Every Child by Two (www.ecbt.org). The participants included Dr. Ari Brown, pediatrician and author of Baby 411, spokesperson for American Academy of Pediatrics, and medical advisor to Parent magazine, and Danielle Romaguera, mother of infant pertussis victim Gabrielle "Brie" Romaguera. We talked about what pertussis is, how frequently it is mistaken for other illnesses, what its symptoms are, and why it's so important for everyone who can -- not just children -- to get a pertussis booster to protect the vulnerable, especially infants too young for vaccinations. We also listened as Danielle Romaguera told us about the heartbreak of her daugher Brie's delayed pertussis diagnosis, prolonged suffering, and eventual death from pertussis complications. Unfortunately, stories like Brie's are becoming more common. (You can read the complete transcript of our conference call at the original version of this post on my blog.)

So, what can you do to keep your kids and all our kids safe, and help prevent more infant deaths? Again, you can check with your and your kids' doctors. If your kids are up-to-date on their

  • 30
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
MsAdventuress 5 pts

For more perspective on statistics,

click http://webappa.cdc.gov/sasweb/ncipc/leadcaus10.htm...

then click "Submit Request"

Ms. Adventuress ( http://www.msadventuress.com ) is where we honor and inspire the desire to adventure ( http://msadventuress.blogspot.com/p/about.html )...

MsAdventuress 5 pts

Most also don't realize that food allergies are not only on the rise, but are often not outgrown and are often undiagnosed.

This creates a larger chunk of the poplulation which must carefully consider whether it's wise to put certain things in their body, temporarily or permanently.

For instance, many suffering with asthma have yet to realize that dairy, additives and preservatives are the culprit for many.

And then we have too many individuals with bodies in permanent states of autoimmune reaction.

There is not one easy answer for all.

We must each do what's right for ourselves, taking precautions for our own particular situation.

http://www.foodallergy.org/files/FoodAllergyFactsa...

http://www.aaaai.org/media/statistics/allergy-stat...

http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db10.htm

http://www.aarda.org/autoimmune_statistics.php

Ms. Adventuress ( http://www.msadventuress.com ) is where we honor and inspire the desire to adventure ( http://msadventuress.blogspot.com/p/about.html )...

Dr. Kathy Johnson PhD CMC 5 pts

When babies are born we try to protect them from any disease that can harm them because their immune system is so weak. But we need to think about elderly adults too. Nationally, the Centers for Disease and Prevention Control are reporting 11,466 cases of the contagious illness – 4,400 cases in California. Elders and their caregivers are encouraged to be vaccinated as well.

There is more to read at HomeCareAssistance.com ( http://blog.homecareassistance.com/?p=1509 )

yasmara 5 pts

I posted a similar response on Shannon's personal blog, but I want to reiterate what she said about the pertussis vaccine (in particular) not being 100% effective. My 4 year old son was vaccinated for pertussis (among other things) but still contracted it & because we weren't 1) aware of the symptoms or 2) aware that his vaccination might not be 100% effective, we unknowingly exposed hundreds of people across 2 states (at a wedding and in our airplane trips to/from the wedding) to pertussis.

We didn't know what to look for and thought his ongoing cough was possibly asthma. When we finally took him to the pediatrician, he identified the pertussis cough *immediately* (we have a great pediatrician) just from my description of it. He immediately ordered a very uncomfortable nasal swab for my son, called us personally with the positive results, put the entire family on antibiotics, and we were contacted by the state Health Dept. We also notified our daycare provider, who notified all the families.

A year later, I am still sick at the thought of how many people we unknowingly exposed. We have no idea how my son got pertussis and even though both of my sons went to the same daycare, my other son didn't get it. This is such an important issue & I hope people really think about the deaths that could be prevented if everyone who could be was vaccinated.

Lulus mom 5 pts

Oh my goodness.. reading through these comments.. those who are of the anti vaccine "movement" are just well.. I can't even describe what I would like to say... but come on people.. YOUR UNvaccinated kids prove a HUGE risk to infants who have yet to be vaccinated... to those who have suppressed immune systems... etc. Get a grip. just because a child has been vaccinated doesn't mean they are completely free and clear from contracting a deadly disease. It is not that black and white.

It is trendy right now to be on the anti-vac movement.... but if anyone can describe the benefits of the anti vac movement without using the "it's MY choice" argument... then please.. I'll be the first to listen. and then I'd like you to use that same argument to a grieving family who has lost a defenseless infant to some horrid, painful disease. Like my friend T... whose infant was gravely ill with pertussis... probably because your child coughed on her...

Quit gazing at your navel... at make the right choice for all children.. not just your own...

Leigh R. 5 pts

Hi, CookinLikeCrazy.

Shannon has already answered your concerns pretty clearly, but I'd like to add and hammer home a few thoughts.

1. You say "If your child is 'vaccinated,' then my 'unvaccinated' child shouldn't pose a threat to your child, right?" I don't think Shannon's saying your child is posing a threat to her child. She's saying that not vaccinating your child is a threat to (a) your child; (b) yourself; (c) in some cases, the elderly (though certainly not seen with H1N1, which afflicted naive people much more so); (d) those who cannot be vaccinated (as explained by Shannon) such as the immunocompromised (e.g., a child in your playgroup with leukemia, a neighbor with AIDS, a newborn who cannot yet be vaccinated, a person who cannot receive the influenza vaccination because of egg allergies).

2. What this all comes down to is herd immunity. With regard to infectious disease, the population is as strong as the weakest members. In this case, the weaker members are the immunocompromised and those with egg allergies or other contraindications for vaccination--who have no choice in the matter--and, through choices of not vaccinating, those children who are not vaccinated. Just one data stream I find most damning to your way of thought, Cookin, is this gem about measles:

"From January through July 2008, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention received reports of more than 130 cases of measles in the United States, the most cases in a year since 1996. Of these cases, more than 90% had not been vaccinated or had an unknown vaccination status." (from the excellent The History of Vaccines at http://www.historyofvaccines.org/content/articles/... ( http://www.historyofvaccines.org/content/articles/... ))

So, yes, your choices DO have a PROFOUND effect not only on you and your children, but also upon the health of the herd. Although I agree that no vaccination is 100% effective, I'll take 90%+ vaccine efficacy in my 2 fully vaccinated kids over them being sickened (or worse) with pertussis, or influenza, or measles, or etc ANYDAY.

Like Shannon, I urge you to please consider vaccination. CDC's MMWR tables on notifiable diseases and mortality, released just yesterday (to my knowledge), are bearing out this sad statistic about 9 babies dying from California's pertussis outbreak. From those data for 2009 and 2010:

"Reports of acute Hepatitis C, mumps, and pertussis all increased." (http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5938md....

I find even 1 child's death from vaccine-preventable disease unacceptable, and that the leaders of the antivaccination movement (Mercola; Loe Fisher; Wakefield, still; etc.) are misleading parents like yourself, Cookin, is beyond reprehensible.

So, again, please consider the data in the context of herd immunity. We who are pro-vaccination are concerned about your children in this whole equation, as well as the other aforementioned vulnerable populations.

Finally, Cookin, I want to leave you and other antivaccinationists with a pertinent, if heartbreaking, block comment. I hope that after reading this you will never again all-too-cavalierly suggest the red herring of litigation against the immunocompromised for somehow "exposing" your child (I'm not sure how leukemia is communicable to your child, but that's another fish to fry, another day):

From the Bad Astronomer blog, where a mom whose daughter has leukemia responds to the story about the 9th baby's death from pertussis:

"As the mom of an immune-compromised leukemia patient, I rely on the herd to keep my daughter alive. When the chemo is taking its biggest toll, we become hermits. It’s bad enough to catch a cold or the flu-we end up in the hospital and wait it out in hopes of avoiding secondary infections. Pertussis, measles, chicken pox-all of these vaccine preventable diseases? Well, they would leave my girl fighting for life on two fronts: cancer AND deadly communicable disease. We try not to think too hard about the odds.

When is the last time you had to ask your kid’s playdates if everyone in the house is up to date on their shots? Flu season is coming up-don’t forget that one! My daughter doesn’t get to have playdates with very many kids." (comment #34: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/201... ( http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/badastronomy/201... ))

Thanks for allowing me my say, Shannon. Great article once again!

Thedomesticgoddess 5 pts

Look, it's pretty simple, really.

-Even IF (BIG IF) Autism and other neurological problems were caused by these vaccines, the diseases these vaccines help to prevent are nasty, awful diseases. There's a reason we vaccinate. TO PREVENT THEM. The problem is that people of our generation don't remember their cousins/grandpas/children dying from the disases.

-nothing is 100% effective. Meaning, yes, there is a failure rate. And it has nothing to do with big pharma padding their pockets. Yes, they are in it to make money but they aren't deliberately trying to kill people.

-Once again, even IF autism were caused by these vaccines? I'd rather have a severely autistic child (which I do) than a DEAD one because I could have prevented a disease and chose not to because of "my personal philosophy". It's neglect not to vaccinate. I chose not to give them for the first year and guess what? STILL AUTISTIC. And then I had a very sick, unvaccinated baby who ended up hospitalized with a disease I could have prevented with an uncomfortable trip to the peds office.

Why does no one talk about the kids who are unvaccinated and end up autistic anyway? Is it convenient to forget them? Oh, that's right, doesn't support their claims.

Domestic Engineer, Total Babe and SAHM

TW 6 pts

The first case of chicken pox was due to my stubborn refusal to get near my sister when she had them during my senior year in high school. I wanted to graduate desperately but was at the cut off for missing days in school. So, I refused to go within 1000 ft of her or anything she touched for 2 weeks.

I got the first case when I was a nanny. From a child who I babysat one night in addition to the usual kids. Actually my ex got it first, the day his dissertation data came in. Then me. Then our son. (6 months old)

Second case, I got from my vaccinated daughter who got a rather mild case (that her step-mother thought was "acne" and took her to a swim meet) and of course, I got another small case--not as bad as the first but we worried since I had been in and out of the hospital.

Retro-Food.com

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

So sorry about the double chicken pox.

And about your neighbor's child dying from measles. How horribly horrible -- that it happened to her, that is happened because of a disease that -- unlike pertussis, which is bacterial, not viral -- could be completely eradicated in the wild, with enough cooperation.

Thanks for sharing the hard decisions you have to make.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

For herd immunity to work with pertussis, we need a vaccination rate of about 94%.

I think a lot of people don't realize how many people can't be vaccinated, and are relying on the rest of us to maintain the herd immunity that will keep the unvaccinated safe: those with compromised immune systems -- who have had organ transplants, undergoing cancer treatments; those who have egg allergies (e.g., eggs are used in the flu vaccine process), etc.

For a great run-down of herd immunity, and how it varies between viral diseases like measles and bacterial diseases like pertussis, see:

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=516

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

TW 6 pts

My kids are vaccinated to more things than the average child because of their travel. My son faints or pukes every time. Would I give up him being vaccinated?

No. You know why? Because when I was a child, our "hippy" neighbor who didn't vaccinate had her child die from measles. Did that just hurt the parents? No. An entire community broke apart over the whispers of the women about why didn't she vaccinate, her family is still feeling the grief and their older son managed a near deadly teen years for him and others, partially related to his grief and his parents.

Then there are the rest of us, children at the time, who sat watching grown men sob as they carried a tiny coffin. I don't think any of us ever felt the same again.

I am not fully vaccinated because of allergies to the pertussis vaccine. I also have a compromised immune system (giving me the unenviable luck of having chicken pox twice as an adult despite avoiding them as a child)

Yes, there are valid reasons to not vaccinate--but if you don't know that there are deadly risks involved.

Retro-Food.com

CrazedMama 5 pts

I know that some parents are worried about getting their kid vaccinated, but.. really?? I mean, do these people not remember how many children died before the vaccinations were available? Why would you want to put your child at risk? Just because of some tiny chance that it could hurt them? By not getting vaccinated, you are not only putting your child at risk of catching one of these diseases and dying, but also passing it on to other smaller kids and killing them, too! There is a chance that you could die in a car accident, but do you stop driving? or riding in a car? Do you not use a cell phone because it COULD cause cancer?

MsAdventuress 5 pts

There is a segment of our population whom are allergic to particular vaccine ingredients.

(For instance, I can't get the flu shot due to an allergen in the ingredients, but I can't say I would, if I could... http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1847794,00.html )

This means we can never be 100% vaccinated, from anything.

I wish we could ensure all are safe from everything, yet there is always risk in all of this.

Everyone must make their own choices.

Ms. Adventuress ( http://www.msadventuress.com ) is where we honor and inspire the desire to adventure ( http://msadventuress.blogspot.com/p/about.html )...

Flucky Mom 5 pts

Vaccinations will always be one of those hot topics (along with circumcision and breastfeeding). I don't think I could fault parents who chose not to vaccinate their kids, just like I don't fault those who do.

But I would urge all parents to research what the vaccines are, what they are for, and if the illness is serious enough to give it to their infant children. There is an incredible lack of understanding about vaccinations. I'm always shocked that parents don't take the time to find out a little more about what's being put into their children's bodies.

I'm not anti-vaccine. My toddler has had most of the vaccines but spread out. I never understood why I should pump him with 4-5 illnesses at once when he's just an infant/baby. Plus vaccines like Hep B seem rather irrelevant at this stage of his life. Or Rotavirus vax seemed unnecessary when my child is breastfed and has access to hospitals.

All is would ask from our medical community and our government is to explain to us why so many vaccines at once at such a young age. The European schedule isn't nearly as intense and they seem to be doing just fine.

I say let's spread them out a little more and truly give thought about what we're injecting into the bodies of being who are just learning to absorb the world.

MsAdventuress 5 pts

Like any task in life, automatically believing a product commercial or automatically believing those who automatically believe product commercials, isn't always the choicest plan of action for all, especially before making a significant decision...

Ms. Adventuress ( http://www.msadventuress.com ) is where we honor and inspire the desire to adventure ( http://msadventuress.blogspot.com/p/about.html )...

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

I'm asking parents to consider that -- given years' worth of claims about vaccine/autism causation which have resulted in not one confirmation, yet many verdicts that vaccines were NOT a factor -- they might want re-evaluate their perceptions on the matter. But it's totally understandable if people aren't emotionally ready to do so. Completely.
Though they could, like Holly Robinson Peete, funnel their energies into helping our children with autism in the here and now, and planning for their future.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

This is not Panama. No one is going to put a gun to your child's back and escort them to a vaccination clinic:

http://shotofprevention.com/2010/10/04/why-my-chil... ( http://shotofprevention.com/2010/10/04/why-my-chil... )

You do get to choose, though your choices may result in inconvenient results, such as your child being forced to stay home during outbreaks (less convenient would be your child catching the disease and then unwittingly passing it onto a baby or immunocompromised individual who would have no warning or choice about your child's unvaccinated status).

Lately, I've been referring readers to an unlikely and NSFW but well-researched source for dispelling the kinds of vaccine/"Big Pharma"/conspiracy myths: Penn & Teller:

http://www.squidalicious.com/2010/09/antivaccionat... ( http://www.squidalicious.com/2010/09/antivaccionat... )

It's a ~30 minute episode, so watch just the 1:30 min intro if you're pressed for time.

Of particular interest to this commenter should be the part mid-way where a woman expresses her fears about vaccine ingredients, & Penn & Teller debunk them using real-world context.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

Each unvaccinated child increases the likelihood of diseases like pertussis being contracted, and then spread. Your unvaccinated child can give pertussis to babies, who can't fight it properly because they're too young to be vaccinated, and who suffer symptoms much more severely than older kids and adults -- sometimes, they die.

Yes, you have the option to choose not to vaccinate your child. I'm asking people to consider the implications and real-world effects of such thinking, and the luxury of being so unfamiliar with vaccine-preventable diseases that we take their low rates for granted. Here's a relevant quote:

“When a serious disease is common, everyone wants to vaccinate. While there might be some danger to the vaccination, the danger of the disease is more serious and very clear. But when the vaccination program is successful and the disease becomes rare, then people worry that the risks of the vaccination are worse than the risks of the disease, and some people stop vaccinating.”

from: http://cosmos.phy.tufts.edu/~kdo/children/vaccinat...

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

CookinLikeCrazy 5 pts

As far as other children that are born with compromised immune systems and are prone to picking up infections....

I'm sorry. I truly am. But you CANNOT tell me that I HAVE to inject my child with known carcinogens just to "possibly" keep your child safe from a particular disease. Technically, I could sue your child for being susceptible to these diseases and threatening my child's well-being (by having to be injected by ANYTHING, by your logic, that is).
These outbreaks of diseases that we "vaccinate" against should be a HUGE red flag to people that there is something wrong with the logic of vaccinations that we have all been force-fed from big pharma.

Seriously. How can nobody see it?
It's more black and white than racism.

CookinLikeCrazy 5 pts

Why on earth should PARENTS have to do that kind of research? When does a grieveing mother have time to find an "unbiased third party"? How insensitive.
Shouldn't it have been done by the companies that issue the "mandatory" vaccines?

I find it incredibly cruel that parents who have perfectly healthy children before they were vaccinated are villified and forced to "prove" cause of death by the money making pharma industry.

SICK SICK SICK

MsAdventuress 5 pts

The intent here is not to sow unease, but to share and accept ones own health and safety experiences. (To discount others because their experiences and concerns are different should cause concern.)

Research vaccination studies and you'll discover whether you're reading gov't/vacc/investor-funded research, or independent third party research. You'll also see the limitations of much research. You'll find challenges and conflicts of interest common to our FDA scenarios http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/editorial_opinio... ( http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/editorial_opinio... ) which also helps explain why proper funding/studies are lacking when it comes to non-synthetic disease prevention and sympton healing.

Unfortunately, vaccine (and other) reactions are not always medically documented. Ask any of us whom has experienced this personally.

We would not willingly choose (nor did we ever desire) this path...had we not experienced something damaging that the medical doctors were admittedly powerless to help prevent or heal.

This is not to say our gov't and medical doctors are bad - I rely frequently upon the nih.gov for much valid and beneficial health data. And I love my medical doctor.

We all need each other. But none of us can always have all of the answers. So we must do our research of the research, consult professionals of all kinds, trust our best instincts and make the best independent decisions for ourselves.

Ms. Adventuress ( http://www.msadventuress.com ) is where we honor and inspire the desire to adventure ( http://msadventuress.blogspot.com/p/about.html )...

Dr. Mar 5 pts

Anti-vaccination is a crisis. Primary care givers of all kinds have a responsibility to change the emerging view of anti-vaccination as a healthy choice. But this pressure to manufacture safe vaccinations is good. Like it or not, vaccines are made by companies that want to make money and they need pressure to keep their product first-rate. Some flu vaccines still contain thiomersal this year which is unfortunate, but not getting the vaccine is still the much much bigger risk.

Lifting in Lace  www.liftinginlace.blogspot.com ( http://www.liftinginlace.blogspot.com )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

Can you clarify: what do you consider "the vaccinations and health conditions that are not being independently researched properly?" Can you provide sources?

Otherwise, yours is the kind of assertion that needlessly sows unease. Parents who are concerned about vaccinations can use the links in my article above as a research starting point -- current research demonstrates that the risks from vaccines are low, certainly much lower than the risk of contracting the disease themselves.

Reactions from vaccines do occur, but they are extremely rare -- and a legitimate vaccine reaction would be medically documented.

Autism symptoms tend to appear most obviously in toddlerhood, around the same time as many scheduled vaccines -- a coincidence, which is unfortunate, and not what parents who have no explanation for the challenging aspects of the child's autism want to hear.

Parents who feel that their child regressed into autism as a result of vaccines really need to methodically investigate their child's medical records via home photographs, journals, and video -- ideally with the help of an unbiased third party.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

CookinLikeCrazy 5 pts

First glaring inconsistency with your story:
If your child is "vaccinated", then my "unvaccinated" child shouldn't pose a threat to your child, right? I mean, your child is vaccinated, and the point of vaccinations is to keep people from getting the diseases they are being vaccinated against. Correct?
So the fact that my child ISN'T vaccinated should have absolutely no bearing on the welfare of yours or other children (so please don't make it my responsibility, as you did with your statement "Please help protect the health of all of our kids").

Second, I make choices for my child that some people don't agree with (drinking raw milk, eating local organic food, not eating processed foods AT ALL), but I don't FORCE my daughter's school to serve 100% organic local lunches. Yes, I'd love it if they did, but they don't; I pack her lunch every day and we all are doing just fine. It is not the government's job to tell me what to INJECT into my child, not ever.

I have confidence that my choices for my daughter are right for US (our family); as callous as it sounds, it's not my job to worry about YOUR kid. If your precious vaccinations are doing what they're supposed to, then you shouldn't have anything to worry about.

Logic.

MsAdventuress 5 pts

It's not that vaccination misinformation is going out to only one side of the debate...it's that there are vaccinations and health conditions that are not being independently researched properly. Until then, parents' concerns (and experiences) must be respected.

Ms. Adventuress ( http://www.msadventuress.com ) is where we honor and inspire the desire to adventure ( http://msadventuress.blogspot.com/p/about.html )...

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

Melindarp - More heartbreak -- but thanks for sharing another example of how these dangers are not theoretical.

Mandy, thanks for sharing that these decisions are not necessarily easy.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

Mel, thanks for pointing out that scheduled vaccinations are not a casual or automatic decision for everyone.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

fouragainsttwo 6 pts

As a nurse, I have seen how parents worry about doing the right thing for their kids.

As a mom, I have cried hoping I made the right choices with vaccinations.

The misinformation has made it so hard to know what to do and unfortunately vaccination has turned into a "trendy" topic instead of a medical one.

I firmly believe that parens have choices, but if those choices are made in fear due to misinformation are they the best choices?

Thanks for the info.

Mandy W.

FourAgainstTwo.com

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I have to admit that we were nervous to vaccinate, though not for autism reasons. Still, we did it. Because the alternative was awful too.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).