Bio
I'm the Family, Moms...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Playgrounds Are Too Safe? Where? Sign Me Up for a Playdate There!

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Newsflash: Playgrounds are too safe. If you're taking your children to one of these un-imaginative, un-inspiring, un-risky, un-challenging playgrounds, you are short-changing your child of a productive future. They won't know how to take life risks or how to succeed at a challenging goal if they don't have real monkey bars. Just another thing to worry about according to a recent article in the New York Times. Swell, right?

Of course, I want to know where these too-safe playgrounds are and I want to build a house in the middle of it. I want to live there. I want to throw a party in honor of this majestic place of safety. I want to tie balloons on safe slides and ladders. I want to climb to the not-too-high heights of the tallest thing on that playground and scream through a microphone, "I LOVE THIS PLAYGROUND!"

That's right: I love safe playgrounds. I love knowing that my children aren't risking their lives by playing on any given playground toy. I like foamy grounds for if they fall. I like a lack of splinters.

This all stems from the fact that I have been repeatedly berated over the past nearly six years of my everyday parenting experience for the woe-begotten "Helicopter Parenting." Due to relinquishing my firstborn at birth under the belief that I wasn't good enough to parent her, I had an overwhelming need to be The Best Parent, and that involved making sure my parented children weren't injured on my watch. I have worked through some (not all) of that in therapy and have forced myself to sit down while they're at the playground. Sometimes I read. Sometimes I do a little work. But I sit. And I know I can sit because we go to safe playgrounds during low-traffic hours. If we're in a new place or if a lot of kids are at the playground, I can't sit. I try not to hover, but I have to move where they move.

Currently, we're away at camp. There's a wonderful wooden playset in the square where all the kids play when they're not sidewalk chalking or in a fun class or eating lots of food. I hate that playset. I didn't hate it before I had kids. But now? I see it wobble when kids swing. I think the slide is too high. I wish the bigger kids wouldn't play on it when the younger kids were trying to maneuver the slide. But I sit. I stare. I wish. I hope. I pray that they won't fall. Or trip. Or break something. Or that the whole thing won't tip the heck over. And I'm glad they're climbing and learning and making friends over the wobbly playset. But, oh man. I worry.

And, yes, I get it. I do. Allowing our children the room to explore, try new things, take risks and accept challenges teaches them great life skills. I'm all for great life skills. Really, I am. I'm also interested in my children having a safe place to play. Without me in their face.

I get so many mixed messages for how I am supposed to be parenting my children. I'm supposed to be encouraging these risks and challenges. The message here: Ditch the safe playground. Noted. I'm not supposed to be a helicopter mom. The message here: Life happens and kids will get hurt occasionally, but it will be okay. Noted. But don't read a book or look at your smartphone while you're at the playground, because if you do, you were a neglectful mother. The message here: You can't win. Noted.

So can someone tell me what I'm supposed to be doing here? And how I'm supposed to parent? Because I thought I was figuring it out on my own, finding a balance that worked for my family and generally flubbing my way through this parenting gig. But it seems, as with everything, I'm doing it wrong.

Are you doing it wrong, too?

Family Section Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land. She is a freelance writer and photographer.

  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
safetylady 6 pts

Parenting.......I believe in balance. I truelly believe if we can teach parents, teachers and kids safety strategies they will be more confident in their parenting/ teaching, in the face of other's comments and opinions. Many parents keep their children inside or helicopter......they know what is safe, but have not empowered their children with awareness and safety strategies. I begin my book with teaching young children to be aware of the behavior of others. Melinda Reynolds Tripp, Author of- What Should You Do? Teaching Children to Protect Themselves in the Twenty-First Century Tate Publishing 2010

kario 12 pts

I've driven myself nuts over time reading about parenting and listening to "experts" and comparing my parenting decisions to those of others I admire (and some I don't want to be like). My answer has come down to this: mind the levies. We can't pay attention to every last little thing and make every choice the "Right" one. So long as we listen to our mother-gut, act out of love and apologize when we screw up, our kids will be just fine. (And I have one daughter who broke three bones before the age of six - some kids are more kamikaze than others. I don't blame myself, but I do caution her a little more lately. I don't want CPS showing up to take her away ;-)).

Kario

http://www.the-writing-life.blogspot.com

victorias_view 2491 pts moderator

It depends on the scenario and the situation. I hover, try not to hover, and try not to scream "get down" when they are scaling trees...But at the same time it's about finding balance and works for you.

I think as parents we know our children and their capabilities. There are times I know I have to relax like when my husband has them skiing moguls on what's considered "blue trail" that I would consider black diamond...

Eventually we have to let them fall, scrape their knee, and grow. But it's also hard to watch.

Sally G 16 pts

It is interesting. Not having been a parent, “only” an aunt, I cannot speak from direct experience.
But I have had discussions with my sister and parents, and had a good upbringing myself, so here are my thoughts as an interested outsider:
• Children at my former elementary school are no longer allowed to throw balls on the playground at lunch; they could get hurt.
• Children at my former elementary school are not allowed to run at lunchtime. I guess the same reason.
• On a trip to Bermuda, my parents saw a schoolyard with running, playing kids, with mussed clothes, and not an adult around. They seemed healthy and happy.
• The elementary school down the block from my sister has enclosed the play equipment in a fence, with a bench outside, which means that the neighborhood children cannot use it, with or without supervision, despite their parents having contributed to the purchase of that equipment through property taxes.
• As children, we did lots of unsafe things and survived. We jumped off a summer house into a pool, climbed trees, climbed onto a roof to reclaim a lost ball, etc. We knew who the daredevils were, who did not have the judgement that most of the others did, but most of us knew pretty much what was reasonably safe and what wasn’t—parents taught us that before we were left “alone” outside with other kids. We also played with older and younger kids, who looked out for us and for whom we looked out.
“It takes a village”—and it also takes teaching independence.
I don’t envy parents; it is not easy—but nobody ever said it was.
Also, remember: there is no such thing as an abnormal childhood; each is different, and barring abuse, each is O.K.
Best wishes!

texasebeth 82 pts

I'm the opposite of you. I tend to be a little too "meh, he'll be fine" in my parenting.

You are 100% right - parents can't win either way. That is the saddest part of all. We attack and critize each other over differences in parenting skills and styles, starting before birth even. Yes, there are extremes on both ends that are harmful but the majority of us are just muddling along the best we know how.

Elizabeth

@texasebeth ( http://twitter.com/texasebeth )  and My Life, such as it is.... ( http://texasebeth.blogspot.com )

Conversation from Facebook

Dana Damico
Dana Damico

I'm basically hands-off at the park and let my kids climb trees and scale the top of the monkey bars and slide structure. My kids make their own danger even at the safe playgrounds because that's a part of being a kid -- pushing yourself and testing boundaries. I'm all for it, though I could do without the disapproving stares and tsk-tsks of the other parents.

Kathy Frederick
Kathy Frederick

Darlene, love this "How will our kid's have any perspective of genuine risk assessment when they've never taken one?" Perfectly said.

Darlene Pineda
Darlene Pineda

As someone who played tag on the roof of her house, climbed trees and rocks, and very often had three kid's on one bicycle...if there isn't a risk of hurt it's just not that much fun. What's the point? And what happens when there is real risk--like driving a car. How will our kid's have any perspective of genuine risk assessment when they've never taken one?