Bio
Nordette is a freelance journalist, published fiction writer, poet, and the mother of two children. She is also a BlogHer.com Contributing Editor an...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

(VIDEO) Police Shoot a Seven-Year-Old in the Head: How Does This Happen?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Detroit television stations, including WXYZ, as well as the city's newspapers, report a story that chills parents' and grandparents' bones: A seven-year-old girl asleep in her grandmother's home Sunday was shot in the head by police. The child is dead.

At The Detroit Free Press, one article about the child's death has more than 900 comments, and another has more than 430 comments.

Freep.com reports that toys were scattered on the front lawn when mourners gathered at the house where police killed Aiyana Jones:

"I seen the light go out of her eyes," her grandmother, Mertilla Jones, 47, wailed outside the home Sunday afternoon after being released from police custody.

Jones was in the living room with Aiyana about 12:40 a.m. when a flash went off and a loud noise was heard.

Police rushed in, guns drawn.

Assistant Chief Ralph Godbee said Jones got into a tussle with the first officer in, causing his gun to go off.

A bullet pierced Aiyana's head and neck.

In the video below, Aiyana's father says that she was his only daughter, and her aunt says, "I'm not against the police, but be right when you do something. Just be right."


WXYZ further reports that the shooting may have been caught on tape by a film crew for a cable show. The Detroit police have called in an outside agency, the Michigan State Police, to investigate the shooting, says the Detroit News.

On Twitter, the hashtag #aiyanajones has surfaced. Tweets reveal both sorrow and anger at the child's death, and under simply her name Aiyana Jones, one tweet from InvincibleDet has been retweeted 19 times, "sick with grief." The tweet shares a link that sends readers to a blog post by Adrienne Maree.

there is no justice. not for aiyana stanley jones.

there is punishment, and perhaps accountability. someone to point towards, many people, a trail of blame, stories, mistakes and tears.

Coverage at the Detroit Free Press includes video of mourners at the prayer vigil and a link to a statement from Assistant Detroit Police Chief Ralph Godbee. You may read his full, unedited comment, in which he says that he understands that this tragedy is a parents' worst nightmare; nevertheless, before detailing the police's version of events, he stresses that no final determinations have been made.

A natural question arises: Why haven't we heard more about this little girl's death in national news? The story is building, however, and has been picked up by the Associated Press.


As do many other American cities, Detroit sags under crime. Facing an outraged public, its officials and others sympathetic to law enforcement have asked people to wait until the investigation concludes before pointing fingers.

"Things go wrong, and things happen that you didn’t necessarily plan for," retired Detroit Police Sgt. David Malhalab told the Detroit Free Press.

Nordette Adams is a BlogHer CE & you can find her other stuff through Her 411.

  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
MLOKnitting 5 pts

The Michigan State Police is one of the most trusted organizations in Michigan - higher trust levels than the FBI in some places due to some unique ethnic populations. It helps to know some of the history that makes it so.

After prohibition, the state found that the State Police was beyond corrupt. They instituted many safeguards into the system within the State Police to prevent corruption. It is very hard to become a Michigan State Trooper. Their training is pretty intensive and requires about the same levels as those of the FBI. I have no idea what other states are like.

When the Michigan State Police hand something to the FBI, it is something that is so bad and so entrenched that it takes more resources than the state has to take it on. It would be a bad sign for those of us who live here if the FBI were immediately brought in. That would mean that they had to bring in more FBI as the DPS has had the FBI investigating them off and on for a little over a decade.

MLO / Melissa

Books, Movies, Games, Ovarian Cancer, and Life in General at http://www.mloknitting.com/

Nordette Adams 6 pts

Jaelithe is it's starting to sound like it was not so much as they were afraid of this suspect as it was they were showing off for a film crew. That stinks even more. It may explain why they stormed in the way they did, all for dramatic effect. If that turns out to be correct, then I think some police departments are going to rethink starring in reality TV segments.

I've had some of the same issues in my head that you mention. It's like they treated everyone in the house as though they were insurgents or criminals. How would any of us react to a flash bang tossed into our homes at 12:40 in the morning.

Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

jaelithe 5 pts

Though the officers initially reported that there was a "tussle" with the grandmother, later they admitted that the officer who fired his gun may well have just accidentally bumped into her.

The police started this raid by throwing a flash grenade into the living room of the house to deliberately stun and confuse everyone inside. The girl's father reported that the grenade actually landed on his daughter's blanket (she was sleeping on the couch) and lit it, and her, on fire.

Even if the grandmother HAD deliberately tried to stop the police officer, I am not sure I would blame her for it. In the seconds it took for all of this to happen, she might not have even known he was a police officer.

If there was an explosion in your house without warning, and then a bunch of armed men came rushing through the smoke toward your grandchild, who was ON FIRE, what would you do?

I do not see how the use of a flash grenade was justified in this situation, when the police knew there were innocent adults and children inside the duplex (the neighbors had warned them). It seems to me the police were more concerned with protecting themselves from a potentially armed suspect than they were with protecting the citizens they are sworn to protect.

Nordette Adams 6 pts

I wondered at that as well. Down here in crazy Louisiana, we don't settle for state police investigation often. If it were not for the involvement of the FBI, we never would have known the truth about Danziger Bridge cover-up ( http://www.blogher.com/danziger-seven-investigator... ).

Stuff like this goes federal relatively quickly down here, it seems to me. I say that despite the Danziger case taking five years before the truth came out.

So, I wonder if it's a perception issue, that if it's in the south, it may be a civil rights issue and if it's in the north it's not?

I still can't get over the whole reality TV angle that's surfacing, so much so I had to comment at my personal blog ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com/2010/05/aiyana-jones-w... ) as well.

Your sentiment about Detroit as a great but forgotten city is noted. I've talked to others who love that city who say the same.

Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

MLOKnitting 5 pts

No city in the nation has had as much consistently hit them. After the riots in the 60s, you had white flight, incredible corruption in all aspects of government, unemployment in the double-digits - and the rest of the country turns up their noses.

It doesn't help that Detroit is a predominately black city. Racism runs deep in this country - and Metropolitan Detroit is no exception.

The Detroit police has been under repeated investigation for decades. The only surprise is that it isn't the FBI doing the investigation rather than the State Police. (The Michigan State Police are the equivalent of a state level FBI for Michigan.)

To tell you the truth, as a resident of the area, I'm more surprised at the coverage. Years ago there was a 3 year old killed in a shoot out with police. There have been others.

Detroit is a place of exhaustion and despair and the rest of the country doesn't really care. Nor, do they try to find out what is going on.

This is one of the oldest cities in North America. It could be one of the most beautiful. Once upon a time we were the City of Trees. Home ownership - no matter origination - was among the highest in the nation. Then the policy makers in Washington, D.C. waged war against manufacturing through NAFTA and other trade agreements.

Those things left a culture of poverty. A culture where crime and corruption seeps into the very being of an area.

Why doesn't the rest of the country care? They don't think that the same can happen to them.

MLO / Melissa

Books, Movies, Games, Ovarian Cancer, and Life in General at http://www.mloknitting.com/

Nordette Adams 6 pts

I checked my own newspaper and found only a brief of about 100 words included in a round-up of other news. However, New Orleans is currently consumed by news of the oil spill. CNN gave this story more attention hours after I submitted this post for publication. CBS yesterday, at the time of my writing the original post, had a flimsy (skeletal) report about it, but later in the afternoon it was updated with more information. ABC News ran the AP story Sunday. The Fox News website also ran a story with a feed from AP and the network's Detroit affiliate.

The thing of it is, usually, once the Associated Press runs it and the big news outlets run the AP story or a scaled-down version of the AP story, then they all can say technically they ran the story.

And that's all I'm going to say on the topic because I think the focus should be on police actions and not media and whether or not it was a slow news day or a madhouse. It sounds like the police may be willing to or be forced to admit they were wrong. I get the impression the department was under pressure to make a display of cracking down on crime.

Worse: A libertarian blogger calls what happened more evidence of law enforcement suffering "Showtime Syndrome." ( http://freedominourtime.blogspot.com/2010/05/death... ).

It may be that the cable filming I referenced in the original post indicates another evil shame in this little girl's death. The attorney for the family implies that the police were rapped up in the filming of the A&E reality television show First 48, and an anonymous source associated with the show says that a crew was at the scene filming when Aiyana was shot, but the police confiscated the tape. See CNN ( http://www.cnn.com/2010/CRIME/05/16/michigan.polic... ).

Thank you.

Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

Nordette Adams 6 pts

My response was not an attempt to insult your intelligence. It was not even an attempt to persuade you that my reporting is the better way to tell the story. It was simply an explanation of why I wrote that one sentence into the post as it reflected an impression from others, a common impression about how news about the deaths of black children get reported.

I attempted to balance that impression with an acknowledgement that the story was being reported more widely as I wrote it.

Likewise, my mention of balloon boy was only food for thought, not a challenge to anyone's thinking skills.

Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

ebyrdstarr 5 pts

I still have to disagree with the observation that this story hasn't been getting national attention. It has had front page headlines on cnn and msnbc's websites since Sunday. I had read many stories about it before I read your post on Monday. This may just be a difference in perception as I am a criminal defense lawyer who naturally gravitates to this kind of story, but in the first days after the incident, I just don't know what more coverage would be expected than a continually-updated story. And, yes, as an educated woman, I can read. I read your "more" but I didn't understand what more you expect. The fact that the story made my local paper is an indication of its national play.

I agree the balloon boy case was nowhere near as newsworthy, but at this early point in Aiyana's story, I don't think it's fair to say the other story will have gotten more coverage in the end. I certainly hope this story will ultimately resonate more.

Preaching to the Choir ( http://rantsofapublicdefender.blogspot.com/ )

ShoreBookworm 5 pts

Nordette, I have scoured the NY Times and have found nothing.

I don't watch television, so I wouldn't have seen it there.

This is a story that needs reporting not to be inflammatory but to keep the spotlight on the specific case (shit, I am calling her a 'case', God forgive me) and to raise awareness/passion/outrage about the larger issues that led to this sickening tragedy.

Marie

www.nourishourselves.blogspot.com ( http://www.nourishourselves.blogspot.com )

www.theshorebookworm.blogspot.com ( http://www.theshorebookworm.blogspot.com )

Nordette Adams 6 pts

This story was not in my local paper Monday morning, but it did appear as a news brief late Monday on its website.

When I started on the story, that was an observation someone shared with me, that the story was not getting major news coverage. They meant national not local news coverage.

However, to make sure that readers understood I was aware of increasing coverage, I stated clearly the story was being reported more in the national MSM such as the Associated Press, meaning it was growing beyond local reports. That's why I used an Associated Press video. It counters the notion that no one's covering the story. I also used the qualifier "more" in the sentence about coverage, "Why haven't we heard more," which by default acknowledges we've heard something.

On some major network sites, this story was reported as a blurb at first, news easily overlooked. I figured more sources would report it later as a bigger story, but when I submitted this story for post, knowing it would not go live immediately, bloggers were giving it more attention than major news outlets.

Everything is relative. Compare coverage of this story to balloon boy, the hoax. Days after the hoax was revealed, we still saw stories about balloon boy and analysis of the family's life.

Which of the two stories deserves more analysis, some family with a father who wants to be a reality TV star, or how police could step over toys on a lawn, toss a flash bang in a family home, and end up shooting a child in the head? Is Detroit Iraq or Afghanistan?

Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

ebyrdstarr 5 pts

I don't understand the complaint that this hasn't been in the news. I have seen this story reported and updated multiple times on every major news website, starting on Sunday. All of the legal blogs I follow are aware of it. The story was in my local paper (Kansas City) on Monday morning.

In any event, it's a horrifying story and the police (who have evidently lied about what happened) need to be held accountable. I was pleased to see that the family filed a lawsuit this morning, which will give the family and a court some authority in making sure the police don't tinker with reports or just happen to "lose" any videos they may have from the scene.

Preaching to the Choir ( http://rantsofapublicdefender.blogspot.com/ )

catalyst1 5 pts

They are asking people to "wait" but I wonder how long they were willing to "wait" before they pull the trigger.

Always the Highest.

ShoreBookworm 5 pts

How could this have not been a screaming headline in every newspaper in the country?! Because this was a black child?! She wasn't a black child, she was a child, period. She was every one of our children. I cannot look at her sweet picture without crying. That dimple. Oh my God.

There is a lot to this story, all of it opportunities to learn and CHANGE. But sometimes it feels hopeless to me. Disadvantaged, chaotic families (why oh WHY did her grandmother wrestle with an armed police officer?!?!); over aggressive and careless police work (were they clearly identified or perceived as a home invasion?); public apathy. Who beyond her family is going to remember her name in a year?

My belief system is that Aiyana is now safe and happy in the arms of God. But what a loss for us all, on so many levels.

Marie

www.nourishourselves.blogspot.com ( http://www.nourishourselves.blogspot.com )

www.theshorebookworm.blogspot.com ( http://www.theshorebookworm.blogspot.com )

JennaHatfield 10 pts

I can't say anything right now as I'm just far too angry. I lied.

I can say that I am horribly saddened for her family. My heart goes out to them in this time of need.

Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )), from Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ), is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

miavitadolce 5 pts

this is absolutely heart wrenching. I have a hard time reading stories of this nature. I don't even get the paper delivered any more. I found it was terrible story after terrible story and couldn't bear starting the day reading so many tragedies.

When situations like this occur it is easy to start pointing fingers and starting the blame game but it's always best to find out all the facts before rushing to judgement.

Grace - La Mia Vita Dolce - http://gracessweetlife.com

Lesbian Dad 5 pts

Utterly horrifying. Thank you for helping publicize it (I got here thanks to Liz Henry's Tweet, after reading her Tweet of Adrienne Maree's post).

Kim Pearson 5 pts

I can't bear to watch the video, but I am glad you did this. I look forward to hearing news of the investigation.

Kim Pearson
BlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://blogher.org/blog/kim-pearson )|KimPearson.net ( http://kimpearson.net )|

Denise 9 pts moderator

Really. Really. Horrible.

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager

Flamingo House Happenings ( http://www.flamingohouse.net/ )