Most Popular

Recent Comments

Politely Powerless: When Self-Defense Fails

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Yesterday, I suffered unwanted sexual advances from a man in a way that I can’t seem to find an appropriate word for. Was it molestation? Sexual assault? Too nuanced to label? The story, in a nutshell:

After a rough week at work, I decided to celebrate Friday by staying in for tipsy laundry night, one of my favorite bi-weekly rituals. I meditated on a glass of tasty young zin while sorting my clothes, then -- bereft of quarters -- ran to the convenience store across the street to withdraw some cash from the ATM. ATM aside, this convenience store isn’t one of my favorites, so on the rare occasions I step in, the 45-year-old owner always gives me a hero’s welcome.

I have a soft spot for this man, the tireless hours he works behind the counter, the cheerful way he corrects his wife’s mistakes on the cash register, the pride with which he looks on his 12-year-old son who spends evenings working on homework in the back. So I didn’t think much of it when he met me at the ATM and opened his arms for a hug.

As he was leaning in, though, I realized something was wrong. Instead of a quick, chaste embrace, the second his arms were around me, he swung his head down and planted a moist kiss on the base of my neck. At the same time, he dropped his hand to my ass and squeezed from one side while pressing his pelvis from the other.

The whole encounter lasted maybe five seconds, but the entire time, my body was frozen and my mind preoccupied with one thought. Not the thought I would have imagined, though. As a strident feminist, I’m never one to hold back when confronted by brain-dead teenage catcallers or men who stand too close in the subway. When presented with actual, physical violation, I always imagined I’d throw punches first, ask questions later.

Woman Says No with HandInstead, the only thought echoing through my head: Oh god, how can I get out of this fast without being impolite? After he’d retreated to the counter, I even bought a soda I didn’t want, so he wouldn’t think poorly of me for treating his store like a bank branch.

Even later, when I was back at home and felt safe, I struggled with the proper reaction to the event. So I did what came naturally: kept drinking wine until I could no longer feel the scrape of his stubble against my neck, then posted about the event on Twitter.

If I didn’t know how to react, my Twitter followers had no such reservations. Of the two dozen responses I received -- through Twitter, text and email -- people’s comments fell in three distinct categories:

1) Are you okay?

2) I want to punch that guy.

3) Why’d you let him touch you in the first place?

The first response came from both men and women -- and, though I was too uncomfortable to even answer, I appreciated it. The second poured in from men I know both online and in real life, and reminded me how happy I am to only associate with guys who are actively respectful to women.

The third response, though, is the one that troubled me. Not just because it hints at the kind of blame-the-victim mentality that perpetuates sexual assault -- both small cases like mine and much bigger, deadlier games -- in our society. But because it mirrored my own disappointment with my reaction. The weirdest thing, though, is that this failure of sympathy came exclusively from women.

There is, I think, an interesting tension in the current cultural conversation about sexual assault and rape. Feminists (and I do hope that all women are feminists) agree that any unwelcome physical advance, no matter how small, is a violation that should be stopped. We agree, furthermore, that often it isn’t physical weakness but rather a feeling of social powerlessness forces a woman not to speak out when she is being violated. And in the ideal scenario, a modern woman should feel empowered enough to ignore any inkling of social powerlessness and just do something to stop unwanted advances.

And it’s a great theory. It is, in fact, such a great theory, that it can be hard to remember that theories don’t always translate to reality. I, for example, would call myself a strong, empowered woman, almost to the point of obnoxiousness (just ask my ex) -- yet the

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
JBee 5 pts

I relate strongly to your reaction in the situation, it upsets me to read it because it reminds me of similar things that have happened to me. I would like to say that when I face sexual harassment or invasion of my space or body, I respond strongly and confidently, that I defend myself. But I can't say that, because I don't. I've found myself too afraid to be impolite or make a scene, so I just quietly try to disentangle myself from the situation without drawing attention or causing offense. This has happened on multiple occasions:

1) Dancing at a club with friends, a guy came up to me and started dancing with me, which was fine. Then somehow he got his arms around me and started kissing and sucking on my neck. I froze in fear, not sure what to do, berating myself for somehow signaling to this guy that I wanted him to do this to me. I eventually managed to pull away and excused myself to the bathroom.

2) Late into the evening at a sister's party one of her friends (a guy much older than me) that I had been talking to offered to massage my shoulders, which I accepted. After a while he surreptitiously unhooked my bra and started to get close to fondling the sides of my breasts. I didn't want to make a scene, so I just made an excuse that I needed to leave and went home.

It's really sad to me that I'm so afraid of disrupting everyone else's good time and causing a fuss (I've always been pretty shy and not liked to draw attention) that I will not defend myself.

Going back farther, there even was a chilhood incident in a crowded wave pool at a water park where a stranger adult man grabbed and held me while he fondled me between the legs. What made it more terrifying was that I didn't have my glasses on, so after I managed to get away I swam in terror from everyone because I didn't know what the guy looked like. I didn't tell my family, who were there by the side of the pool, that it had occurred because I didn't want to ruin their day.

I hate to hear people say "you should have defended yourself!!" because it makes me just berate myself for feeling so weak and cowardly.

Nobody wants to be Ethel 5 pts

I am so sorry this happened to you. Your honesty should make us all realize that this can happen to anyone and that we are not immune. >Patty

mashadutoit 5 pts

What should be acknowledged here, is that most of us prepare ourselves to deal with sexual harassment from a stranger, or from somebody we dont like.

If it is somebody we know AND like, its a lot tougher to know how to react.

Sure, rationally you could say "I should have done x" and come up with many reasons why you should have reacted differently, but I think it is essential to recognise why you did not.

And I dont think it is because you are were powerless -

I think it has to do with how we view sexual deviant sexual behavior. It is so much easier to think that only perverse, monstrous, manipulative and cruel people can harrass somebody sexually.

And (the logic goes) what were you doing letting somebody like that touch you?

But in this case, not only did you trust this person - so why not let him hug you?

But it is MUCH more difficult to know how to react appropriately because

1) you have to revise your picture of him in a split second

2)you have to instantly trust your impressions in that split second to perform a fairly radical action like reprimanding him vocally or pushing him off.

2) you know you have to interact with him socially in the future - not some random stranger in a bar.

I dont think your reaction was inappropriate. It is NOT your problem that this guy did this to you. It is NOT your responsibility to fix him.

And how you reacted, is NOT wrong. It was a natural and understandable reaction.

Kathryn W. 5 pts

I have experienced something similar to this before, please forgive me for not elaborating, but I really don't care to relive the event just now. I hurt for you because he took something intangible from you that you can't really even explain right now. A level of comfort, security, and something else that you just can't describe.

I am sorry to see that some people reacted the way they did, but not entirely surprised. Appalled, but not surprised. Loathing, but not surprised. I am not surprised because I was treated as if it were my fault by some people, too. The important thing is for you to recognize that this is in NO WAY your fault and that guy is just a complete tool. A jerk. Scum of the earth. And those people? Morons.

I wouldn't want to go back there, if I were you. Just because I wouldn't want to get anywhere near that guy. However, if you cannot, or don't feel the need to, avoid the place, my suggestion would be to mention it to his wife. Somehow, I think she might have a thing or two to say to him about it that might get the message across.

----------------------------

The Soap Box ( http://www.blogher.com/andthatsmysoapbox.blogspot.... )

gaeayudron 5 pts

Gaea Yudron Sage's Play Exploring creative aging, wellness and spirit www.sagesplay.com ( http://www.sagesplay.com )

I'm sure sorry that happened to you, and when I put myself in your place I wonder now what? I could never go into that place again. Or would I go in and confront him about it? (Not by myself for sure).What a predicament. He deserves some very direct feedback on his very bad behavior, but how could that happen?

KMayer 5 pts

You can like the guy all you want, but the second he crosses that line, gives you that uncomfortable feeling, it's your responsibility to STOP BEING POLITE and firmly and forcefully -- including the punch in the face if warranted -- tell him no. Make no excuses -- even the good guys are the bad guys. They push the envelope until we let them know it won't be tolerated. Uncomfortable for us, perhaps, but most definitely necessary.

If you can't articulate immediately, don't hesitate to return later, with friends as back up & support, to clearly set the boundaries.

Good for you, and so sorry your trust was broken.

Kathy (p/t copywriter, f/t mom)

Diary of a Return-to-Work Mom: Going Back to Work After Kids ( http://returntoworkmom.blogspot.com/ )

lishide 5 pts

Great post and thanks for sharing. As a man (for whatever that is worth), I'll echo the hope that you're able to stop blaming or evaluating your own behavior very soon. Calling upon women to recognize their own strength is a great message, but men have a part to play too. Centrally, we need to somehow collectively grasp our own privilege. To even contemplate more than friendly hug reeks of entitlement. Anyway...thanks again.

neakycan 5 pts

Before I read further, I thought the third comment was asking for more info to give them (and me) a heads up so maybe I can avoid this situation; as in did he build this up so you thought a hug would be OK or just give off (safe vibes) while all the time he's a predator I think the whole event very scary and I wonder how many women and girls he has done this to.
As to your response (don't get mad but)maybe that was the safest way out of there.
And telling people makes you strong
And I would report him even if it goes no where it might show a pattern if he does this to someone else or even goes further with someone else

Nanakoosa 5 pts

Wow, fabulous! I really enjoy posts like yours that openly and authentically address the grey areas and confusion that we all face at one time or another. Abuse of any kind is not a black and white, either/or phenomenon. I'll bet you anything if that guy was a stranger who snuck up behind you and grabbed you, you would've fought back with every fiber of your body; but this situation had no context, no clear definition.
Great post!
Peace,
Jenny

copyright  2010 Jennifer Hazard

www.whitewaveconsulting.org./ ( http://www.whitewaveconsulting.org./ )

GemmaRow 5 pts

I am hesitant to comment because i don't want it to seem like I am telling you how you should feel or react, but something you wrote really bothers me:

"in order to eradicate sexual assault in our society, women need to be empowered to recognize their own strength"

I strongly disagree. The only way to eradicate rape, assault and any other sexual crime perpetrated by a man against a woman is for MEN to decide to stop. There is nothing we can do it stop it, yet the onus is constantly put on us.

I think recognizing our own strength and calling on it (and the strength of our friends, families and communities) can be helpful when we are violated. It can help us heal. It can save our lives. But I do not think it can stop sexual crimes.

That said, I really hope it's clear that I'm not criticizing you for examining the way you reacted. I'm sorry it happened to you and I'm glad that you have an outlet like this one in which to work through it.

Kuriku24 5 pts

The third response is very silly, and it's sad that it was mainly women who tweeted that. However, I understand the disappointment that you felt when you couldn't react, because I've felt the same earlier in my life. But for me, I think it was a wake up call to know that the way I thought the situation would play out in my head was played out very differently in reality. And I think that's perhaps the most important lesson here, because now at least you KNOW what the problem is. While I (and you of course) certainly wish that this had never happened to you, I hope that it empowers you in the future.

And for the record, I definitely want to punch him in the face.

Gena Haskett 6 pts

Culturally something was transmitted to you that being polite was more important than having your body violated.

Mentally you do have to mental flip a switch that invokes my protection is paramount.

Please don't keep assaulting yourself about his actions. Nor should you tolerate anyone that tries to do that to you.

It is like women are supposed to have a 24/7 alarm system to know which guys are gonna be on the attack.

It doesn't work that way. It never did yet we still have people who ask "Why did you allow..."

It takes practice but you will find the right way for you to assert and protect yourself.

Gena Haskett is a BlogHer Contributing Editor. My Blogs: Out On The Stoop ( http://outonthestoop.blogspot.com ) and Create Video Notebook ( http://createvideonotebook.blogspot.com )