Bio
Blogger, comedian, artist, activist, attorney, Catholic, pretentious urbanite, Social Media strategist, libertarian, observer, Rockabilly. Haiku.
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Politics: Its All About The Boobs

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

A little over a week ago, Meghan McCain, columnist, blogger, quasi-conservative and daughter of former Republican Presidential candidate Sen. John McCain posted a photo of herself in a tank top on Twitter and set off a firestorm of anger that almost threatened to put breasts over health-care as the hot topic of debate. Well, almost. At the very least, there was enough nonsensical outrageously outraged outrage from the usual, Puritanical suspects for Meghan to feel the need to pen a column, questioning why it's so inappropriate to post a photo of oneself in a tanktop on a social network.

On Wednesday, I posted a hastily taken self-portrait on Twitter—which I thought was funny and silly—and within a few hours I had caused a minor media scandal. I spent most of the next day thinking about what exactly was so shocking about the picture, why there was such an immediate and nasty overreaction. After all, it’s not like I was caught making a sex tape. I certainly didn’t pose nude for Playboy. And I hadn’t even exposed a nipple.

Could it be it's because I have breasts? Because for those of you who didn't know, I have two. They're larger than some women's and not as big as others. I don't usually show off my cleavage—as I did in the photos I posted—which I will admit is not the smartest thing I have ever done. But it’s just not worth the drama it caused.

I know Meghan is new to this game, so I'll go easy on her, and as a firm believer in avoiding the circular firing squad, I'll only mention in passing that she's not the first and won't be the last to feel the wrath of the anti-sex segments of our society (welcome to the club!). After all, its not like Meghan did anything wrong. Well, other than, say, having the breasts in the first place.

To tell the truth, I agree with Meghan in principle (not really so much in practice, but I'll get to that later). Americans have a problem with breasts, and not just Meghan McCains. And before anyone starts pointing fingers about who is currently responsible, this is nothing new to the United States. We are a Puritanical nation. Sex and anything associated with it is and has been a dramatically divisive topic, and without exception, Americans think more about the political implications of sex and nudity than anyone else in the world; whether they are "for" it or "against" it, the mere topic of sex brings out the most animalistic political instincts in anyone. Compared to the rest of the world, we're sex-obsessed.

Trevor Project Gala

Hugh Hefner, founder and editor of Playboy and possibly the world's foremost expert on boobs (perhaps in more than one way depending on who you ask), once penned in the Playboy Philosophy that sexual liberation was only possible in a society that valued individual rights above all else. Sexual freedom only grows naturally in a free society where individuals were free to pursue their own interests and where the state refused to interfere in their personal business. Republicans, content to protest on ideological grounds even the slightest whiff of the smallest tendril of government interference in the boardroom are more than happy to poke their noses in the bedroom, and Democrats, while faring marginally better, are still guilty of censorship and mere lip service to more serious issues of individual liberty.

Puritanism and a harsh perception of what is "right" and what is "wrong" in matters of sex is deeply embedded into the American psyche. The earliest Americans were notoriously tough on sex and throughout history, humans have always had a Gnostic streak. Europe had a long time to get over it, and the Enlightenment, a period where we were more concerned about the pressing issue of earning our political freedom. As a consequence, everyone gets excited, defensive and impressively worked up about sex. That's the political landscape in which we live. When you press your boobs to a camera and put it out on the internet while presuming to be political, you naturally enter into this landscape and if you're not schooled in the ideological debate, you'll pay the price in angry mail. And its going to take a lot more than personal outrage in response to change the way that this sort of situation is handled. Its going to take a massive cultural shift for Americans to fully accept people

  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
avflox 5 pts

Have I told you I adore you this morning? No? Well, I adore you. This piece rocked my morning. Now I can go to sleep feeling just that bit less alone. I bow down to your genius in articulating so well what I have so often failed to express in regards to America and sexuality.

michaelareynolds 5 pts

Really, I cant keep myself from commenting on that boobs of hers. Ok, I would really like mine to be a little bigger, but come on, I would never dream of pushing my boobs all the way up to my chin; I prefer to be able to look down. Gotta agree with Flightkeeper, the whole thing is just dumb. 

Michaela ( http://kredittkortforbrukslan.wordpress.com )

confusedhomemaker 5 pts

I saw the picture it was "suggestive" but that is somewhat "subjective" and I'm sure wasn't really thought through. It was just a quick pic posted without a lot of time to think about how others would view it. 

I don't know, really I don't get the big deal. And I am pretty conservative by most people's standards. IMO It doesn't make her more or less conservative. I mean did her political views change?

beth aka confusedhomemaker

Expat Mum 5 pts

Don't agree with her politics, but she seems like a nice enough person. However, that she claims not to have anticipated this fuss is absolute bull! She was intimately involved in her father's campaign and must know more than most people, exactly how the publicity machine works. Come on Meghan - we're not that stupid!

sberneche 5 pts

Really great read, thanks for posting!

kimsisto 5 pts

Excellent read! 

I just looked at the photo and although she looks like one of Heff's girls, she still has the right to flash those babies any where she pleases.  Of course, one may not respect her as much or take her seriously, but she can do with her boobs whatever she wishes. 

I am wondering why this is making news, though.  Who gives a damn. 

 And I WOULD NOT apologize for revealing too much boob....but perhaps I would pull my tank top up a bit more! next time!  OR NOT.

cluelesscrafter 5 pts

It's not the breasts alone!  When I took a look at that picture, I couldn't stop scanning from breast to face, breast to face.  Together, they are highly suggestive.  Why the come-hither look?  Imagine the shot were taken head on, a smile on her face that conveys self content not a deeeeeeep longing need for visual approval.  racks the brain.

http://www.thecluelesscrafter.com/

Erin Kotecki Vest 5 pts

"...Meghan McCain, columnist, blogger, quasi-conservative and daughter of former Republican Presidential candidate Sen. John McCain..."

Meghan McCain calls herself a conservative. A Republican. Yet other conservatives don't want to own her. 

Why is that? Why call her quasi? Is there no room for any disagreement on anything in the Right side of the pendulum? 

Politics & News Contributing Editor Queen of Spain ( http://queenofspainblog.com/ )

Flightkeeper 5 pts

I guess some thought that it was pretty indecent and that she meant to do that on purpose.  The whole thing is dumb.

(My blogs are http://flightkeeper.blogspot.com and http://cutefuncool.blogspot.com)

PunditMom 5 pts

Wow!  Here I go again agreeing with you!  Seriously, even though there are many who try to mock Meghan McCain for a lot of reasons, I think she is the new GOP -- someone who can see shades of gray and whose only party line is the one that makes sense to her.

I think she sells herself short in the long run by posting those photos because our societal fascination with breasts still is a minus for women.  But isn't that part of the problem for all women in politics?  Men can't deal with the fact that people with boobs are trying to have opinions,  even though women still have to deal with the fact that many of those men are boobs themselves.

PunditMom ( http://www.punditmom.com )

aka Joanne Bamberger

BlogHer News & Politics Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/punditmom )