Bio
Laina Dawes is a contributing editor for Blogher and is also a music journalist whose writings can be found at Exclaim! Canada and...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Pregnant British Woman Jailed in Laos

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Samantha Orobator is a 20 year-old Nigerian-born British woman who was arrested last August on suspicion of trafficking heroin in Laos. If found guilty, she could face execution by a firing squad. It took months for British officials to learn that she was in jail and currently, the prison has not allowed her lawyer to visit her.

Laos is known for its harsh anti-drug laws and unlike other countries, there is no difference in the severity of punishment based on the type of drugs. If one is found with a pound of marijuana, they would receive the same punishment as if they had a pound of heroin. (Edit: I've updated the above link. Sorry!)

There  have been numerous cases of travelers who have been arrested in neighbouring countries and have received severe punishments for trafficking drugs. Currently, two Canadians have been sitting in an Indonesian jail for almost four months for allegedly possessing and using 3.6 grams of pot.

So why is this case so different? In January, the imprisoned Orobator told her mother that she is pregnant. But luckily for her, on Tuesday the Indonesian government announced that they will not execute a pregnant woman. But what happens if she is convicted after her September due date?

And how exactly did she conceive while in prison? What About Our Daughters wonder the truth will ever get out.

How exactly do you become impregnated in a women’s prison? And how exactly does a 20 year old get her hands on 1.5 pounds or heroin? We don’t know the facts of this case, however, there is many a federal prison bed filled by a Black woman who got involved in the drug trade because of “love”. Paging Kimba Smith. Paging Kimba Smith!

Huffington Post reports that officials say that she told a doctor that she was impregnated before she landed in jail, by her boyfriend. but she has been imprisoned since August. And due in September. Do the math.

Melissa McEwan from Shakespeare's Sister was perturbed at the lack of national media coverage:

Despite all that, this story has received almost no attention whatsoever in the US media; USA Today, which is possibly the only US news org besides CNN and HuffPo who's addressed it at all, merely linked to the Telegraph's coverage.
Since when does a Western woman with no history of drug involvement who has nonetheless been arrested and detained as an alleged drug mule, was quite likely raped and forcibly impregnated while being held, and faces a kangaroo court trial not warrant news coverage? I dare anyone to tell me it has nothing to do with the fact that Samantha Orobator is black.

Some people are not so sympathetic. Here's a comment from MomLogic:

How much you wanna bet she was sleeping with whatever she could to get pregnant in there, and probably at the suggestion of a legal advisor trying to spare her life and drum up some sympathy with a baby, and now putting a spin on it as a rape. Uhhhh huh, so at 20 years old she can find herself subject to exploitation in a prison, yet she’s completely innocent to her situation? I think not. Judging by the answers her mom gave, this girl sounds like a skeezy, manipulative liar whose only actions are meant to serve her. She knew the crime, she should do the time. Baby or not, I think she still deserves a punishment, whether or not that be death is not up to my discretion. But if death is the penalty they truly want to give her, it doesn’t be reduced just because she had a baby. Honestly, it’s not like the thing was conceived in love, or she’s got a great career/life/moral fiber that she’ll be able to raise a child with. This girl is pretty pathetic if you ask me. She wanted to get preggers in prison, I’d bet on it.

For more information on this case,check out the Facebook page for Samantha. You can also head over to Reprieve, the UK human rights organization that is working as Samantha's legal counsel.

  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
lainad 5 pts

My bad. Ill go in and edit....... 

Contributing Editor - Race, Ethnicity & Culture

Writing is Fighting: www.lainad.typepad.com ( http://www.lainad.typepad.com/ )

msjen 5 pts

The versions of this story that I have read in British newspapers say that she is being held in Laos, not Indonesia.

Laos ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laos ) is a land-locked communist and buddhist country next to Thailand, Vietnam, Myanmar, and China.  Indonesia ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indonesia ) is a island nation half way between Southeast Asia and Australia geographically that is predominantly muslim country with very strict drug laws.

Laos has been and is a very very poor country that is a part of some of the biggest poppy producers in the Golden Triangle area ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Triangle_(Sout... ). I am not sure what their drug smuggling laws are, but they may or may not be the same as Indonesia and Singapore's drug laws, which are famously strict.

Black Phoebe :: Ms. Jen ( http://www.blackphoebe.com/msjen )

lainad 5 pts

 Regardless of what we personally think about Samantha, we sould be concerned about what legal and health care she is getting in the prision. We should also investigate how she got pregnant - because that all seems really shady.

My first reaction was, 'when in Rome, do as the Romans do' in the sense that while I have never been to Indonesia, I did know that those folks do not play around when it comes to drug trafficking cases. I hope that she is given equal treatment ( even though I doubt it) and the healthcare a pregnant woman should get, but on the other hand, if she did the crime (and the courts are fair and just, that is....) she needs to do the time.

On the other hand, yes, I agree that black communities tend to be very judgemental but not only because Samantha is less than perfect - they know very well how the accused is going to be percived by non-blacks. They are readying themselves for some backlash, and yes, that backlash has come. But I also agree that it might also stem from a 'foreigner' perspective, that because this is not happening in North America, it is less relevant. They will not worry as much that their family members or friends might face the same predicament, therefore the concern is not there.

Contributing Editor - Race, Ethnicity & Culture

Writing is Fighting: www.lainad.typepad.com ( http://www.lainad.typepad.com/ )

PPR_Scribe 5 pts

I probably should not have been, but I was initially surprised by the lack of sympathy expressed by commenters on several blogs. Even in blog conversations populated by (presumably) a lot of Black women.

Perhaps it is because this woman is not American, and the bloggers/commenters are. 

But I think a bigger issue is at play. I think I'm going to name it the Claudette Colvin syndrome, afer the young woman whose bus demonstrated predated Rosa Parks', but who was deemed "inappropriate" by the Black Civil Rights leadership.

Black women in particular must be squeeky clean before mass sympathy is paid to their plight. Young attractive White women (especially if they are middle class) can have a past that includes posing nude or hanging out at bars without their plight as victims being compromised. Black men can have criminal records without their plight--at least if it involves injustice at the hands of police officers or the criminal justice system generally--being compromised.

But this is not the case, by and large, with Black women. And other Black people are some of the worse offenders when it comes to this. "Well...she should have known better than to be carrying drugs in a country like that..." "Well, she should have known better than to let her 3 month old baby come into contact with such a thug..." "Well, she should not have looked at his private text messages..."

And so on. Really, it gets tiring.

~~

This So-Called, Post-Post-Racial Life

http://postpostracial.wordpress.com/