Bio
I am a blogger, vlogger, writer and life long learner. I  finds no greater pleasure than to sniff library dust on a regular basis. And make vide...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

The Price May Not Be Right - Is College Worth It?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

My mother wanted me to get a job. I am fairly certain of this because when she got pissed off at me or my siblings she reminded us that when we were old enough we were to get a job and then get the hell out.

Other relatives also reinforced the message that I should work hard, graduate and then get a job to help out my mother. It was what they believed to be true. I knew that my mother felt that 12 years of schooling was more than enough. It would have been tolerable if I had decided to go to a trade school; which in those days it would have required attendance at night school to learn how to be a secretary.

I wanted to go to college. I wanted an education.

Maybe my mother felt that it was a waste of time. Perhaps she was protecting me in not allowing me to dream past the practical. Perhaps my mother was protecting me from what she believed to be institutional blocks of class and race.

I don’t know. We never talked about it. My mother did not stop me from attending college. She also did not support or encourage my efforts. I was on my own in figuring out how to get into college and how to finance my education.

You see, I was paying attention to what my mother and relatives communicated. I saw how hard it was for her to raise a family on almost minimum wages. Being exhausted and underpaid does not inspire maternal June Clever warm and fuzzy behavior. It was hard. Some days it was too much to bear without anger or tears.

I worked part-time as a teen. I knew crappy jobs. I specialized in crappy jobs like the restaurant owner who did not believe in hot water. Part of my day was spent washing dishes in that joint. In winter.

I didn’t last long.

There were other jobs that cringe in memory. The people with “good jobs” who were miserable, cranky and about to go psycho at the least variation of their carefully constructed empire of cubicle power dictates.

Yet the mantra was graduate high school, get a good job.

I did not have illusions about going off to an educational Disneyland. I wanted to go someplace where people wanted to talk and think about the big questions.

I listened to the voice within. I went off to college. I struggled through disappointment. It seemed like a sped up version of high school. Teachers talking and I was stuck listening: some times to a fool. Occasionally there would be inspired exchanges but routinely I was bored.

It did not matter that I worked as I attended college. The rank troopers like Pepper and Skippy did teach me that there was an educational inequality in our respective public school education.

They taught me that the meritocracy they spoke of wrapped around their necks like a shield might have been their parents’ money and not necessarily any effort they specifically had put forth toward their education.

I did much better with the campus activities and groups. The school radio station, a community silk screen art center, or volunteering. My grade were ok. I just wasn’t good at being a student drone.

The days leading to my dropping out were filled with a counselor trying to tell me discretely tell me that not everybody is cut out for college, perhaps a trade school would be better. A instructor, who did not want female students in his class, did his best to purged out as many as he could.

I took longer than most of my class but I dropped out of formal education and created my own. I eventually found the right schools that actually meant what they said about education and dropped back into the fold, on my terms.

Why Am I Telling You This?

I feel the current debate about education is centered on vending machine outcomes. Not what a specific person needs at a given place and time. We are so locked into the mantra of if you follow a directed path you will get a perfect result and ipso facto a perfect life.

Life really doesn’t work that way. How many recovering lawyers do you know?

There are a range of educational options, not absolutes. The goal of education to me is to provide as much life flexibility as you can acquire. It is

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Melissa Ford 5 pts

I love your thoughts on the point of education is to create that flexibility.

I like the idea of a gap year between high school and college, but I would fill it with an internship/life skills project. Though I have to admit, I don't care if the kids change religions or choose a different political party, but I do care (and I think it has to do with believing that college gives you more flexibility) if they go to college.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

Gena Haskett 6 pts

Many years after the degree. I wanted to pay as I went so that I didn't have to face that. I had loans but I kept them as low as possible. It was a struggle.

It is worth it if you are able to tap into the full experience. If you are paying big money and can't access all the bells and whistles because you have to work 3/4 or full time then it might be a questionable investment unless you are in specific career building program.

Gena Haskett is a BlogHer CE.
Blogs:Out On The Stoop ( http://outonthestoop.blogspot.com ) and Create Video Notebook
( http://createvideonotebook.blogspot.com )

Gena Haskett 6 pts

With school districts actively fighting to have the lowest common level of education so that their students can pass a test (and get funding) I don't see a solution in sight.

What might happen is some day a validation process that proves you have a certain level of knowledge could evolve that would not require you to spend thousands of dollars.

I do support a true liberals art education but paying for someone to recite a book is the way to go about getting it anymore.
Gena Haskett is a BlogHer CE.
Blogs:Out On The Stoop ( http://outonthestoop.blogspot.com ) and Create Video Notebook
( http://createvideonotebook.blogspot.com )

thlsralv 5 pts

Education has gotten stretched out and even more stretched out over the last century, in my opinion - what used to be taught by 8th grade now gets taught by 10th or 11th grade; college, for many, is just a continuation of basic high school knowledge. I think college for some is worth it, but for many, many others, is a complete waste of time, energy, and money. I don't know many liberal arts graduates (like myself) who are in a career ANYWHERE near what they actually studied during the undergraduate years, for example...and I don't know that college did much for me career-wise except expose me to many different scenarios and put me in various social situations that I may not have had otherwise, which I am thankful for. I'm still on the fence about this whole college thing...

sassymonkey 6 pts moderator

I was the first in my family to really go to college. My sister went for a semester or two but it was too hard for her to do the single mom thing, the put food on the table thing, and the student thing all at the same time.

I loved college. I really did. I didn't love every class and I didn't love everything about it but college was good for me, even though it was hard to do the student thing and the put food on the table thing at the same time.

But I also left with a lot of debt, which I am still paying off. Right after university I couldn't even afford minimum payments and ended up on special programs for people like me (which I have to say, thank goodness those exist). It used to be that you could go to college, get loans to get you through, and then when you graduated you would get a job that allowed you to pay off your loans while not quickly, but at least make payments. Not so much any more.

Was it worth it for me? Absolutely. Is it worth it for everyone? I don't think so.

Contributing Editor Sassymonkey also blogs at Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.ca ) and Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.ca ).

Gena Haskett 6 pts

When you don't know what other people do or have done. We can see the doctors and lawyers on television. You don't see a web designer working with wire frames and color pallets.

Career education and college education are not equal. They can be related or work together. Maybe that is where the confusion comes in to play. People go to college to find careers. Nothing wrong with that but it is expensive.

Perhaps this is a good time for the colleges and universities to recalibrate their product. That is being done for them by the marketplace but they are not taking the hint.

Gena Haskett is a BlogHer CE.
Blogs:Out On The Stoop ( http://outonthestoop.blogspot.com ) and Create Video Notebook
( http://createvideonotebook.blogspot.com )

TreniaP 5 pts

I have often said that higher education is over-rated but I had to force myself to question this logic because I have two degrees and I'm not sure how I would feel if I didn't have them.

I think college is a great learning experience for young adults in that it allows them to be a part of an enclosed microcosm of larger society within the confines of an institution. For some people it's the first time they've ever encountered and interacted with people from different cultures and backgrounds and it gives them an opportunity to squash any prejudices they may have grown up with.

But I think we are doing kids a disservice when we tell them that college is the only way to be successful. Looking back over my educational experience, I would have learned a lot more from being an apprentice to a successful entrepreneur than attending some of the classes I needed to graduate. We need to open our eyes about what it means to be successful. I work with middle school girls and it always saddens me when they list the same professions they'd like to explore "doctor, lawyer, teacher,etc..." I have to push them to think about what they love to do and then find a career path that fits what they want and not the other way around.

www.fatgirlweightlossmap.com ( http://www.fatgirlweightlossmap.com )
www.fatgirlweightloss.com ( http://www.fatgirlweightloss.com )
Bridging the gap between weight loss & body acceptance