Bio
I am a co-founder of BlogHer and manage its events, marketing and corporate operations. After 13 years of marketing in Silicon Valley, I left high te...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Project Runway Recap: The Top Twelve Tackle a Team Challenge

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

And you know that isn't usually pretty, right?

Actually this week the team challenge didn't seem to bring out as much drama as they usually do. One big diva, one designer who got picked on, one backpedaling, two-faced beeyotch. I know that might sound like a lot, but usually it's all twelve who would be engaging in such antics!! of course the episode came with an unexpected twist ending which brought all the drama and drama-seeking viewer could ever want!! You'll just have to stay tuned and find out.

This episode actually brought us some good learnings before the challenge was even announced. For example, we learned that:

  • AJ is skinny. Really skinny.
  • April is sad that no one got her diaper from last week. But Peach "got the diaper". And you know? I wouldn't be saying that out loud, Peach. You're on shaky ground as it is.
  • April doesn't have great editing skills. She didn't know to edit out the diaper. And she didn't know to not compare egotistical designtestants to Hitler. Because while Gretchen may be annoying and obnoxious, I think a Hitler reference might be a bit over the top, how about you?

We also learn that this is a team challenge, one where there will be a six-piece collection from each team.

Project Runway Season 8 Top 12
Image courtesy Lifetime

The teams break down like this:

Last week's winner (and immunity holder) Michael C picks Gretchen.

Who picks Christopher.

Who picks Andy.

Who picks Ivy.

Who picks AJ.

So, winners of every challenge to date are on this team.

April picks Mondo.

Who picks Michael D.

Who picks Valerie.

Who picks Casanova.

Who is left with last choice Peach.

This was the Garnier-sponsored challenge, so we had to hear some blah blah about hair trends, and then later had to spend 60 rather than 30 seconds seeing models getting their hair done. Whatevs.

The designers were given a brief period to sketch out their vision for the respective collections and then sent to Mood to spend $1000...which made them all pretty happy.

On Team "Luxe," Gretchen took the lead. Big surprise. They decided to take the approach where rather than each designer being primarily responsible for one piece, they would all work on various parts of every outfit. Not really a great strategic choice -- in fact, a choice that made it seem like no one wanted to be in the position of taking ownership and responsibility for how any one outfit came out. Or maybe Gretchen wanted to do it that way because she figured that way she could work on every garment and sprinkle her magic Gretchen dust on every one, making it so much better than it could ever be without her guidance and special attention.

Team "Military and Lace" was obviously totally inspired by Prince in "Purple Rain", even though none of them said so out loud. But I can tell. They decided to each do an outfit for the collection. I suppose it's true that it could be challenging for six different designers and their individual aesthetics to come together and create a cohesive collection, but this team was well-aware that they were the underdogs and seemed pretty determined to work together to overcome the low expectations the judges (and we, the viewers) might have of them.

For me the biggest, most exciting moment of the episode came at Mood. No, not because they got to spend $1000, but because they showed Swatch, store mascot and apparently crabby little dog. After the requisite "Thank you Mood," Tim threw out a "Bye, Swatch!" and there he was! Swatch lives! Hooray!!!!

Just had to share.

Tim came in for his visit, and other than a brief diversion provided by his "Zippers and chains? Talk to me!" reaction to Valerie's work-in-progress, Tim's visit served as an anti-deus ex machina -- it sent Casanova into a tizzy, rather than solved all his problems!

Casanova is tired of being criticized. Casanova thinks this is all bullshit. Casanova is thinking of quitting. Casanova is a poor abused innocent.

Or, as Valerie put it: Casanova needs to put his big boy panties back on.

But other than this diva meltdown, Team Prince (which is so many fewer words than Military and Lace, so I'm going with it) seems to be working efficiently together.

Team Luxe, on the other hand, is having a chaotic time of it. And, while they all seem to want to blame Michael C. for it, none of the rest of them seems

  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Designer Studio 5 pts

This military style from Aj is amazing. I would get it for me!

Style is a state of mind.

Designer Studio Store ( http://www.designerstudiostore.com )

Elisa Camahort 5 pts

Looking down their noses at the other team.

Of course, that made it so so obvious that, in the world of reality TV editing, it meant that Team Prince was kind of a lock to win from the beginning.

It's funny, because I also post this on my personal blog, and I got this comment from someone who was outraged I didn't spend more time yammering on about Gretchen's runway turnabout and subsequent come-uppance. That's the *least* interesting part to me. That's just reality TV. I like to watch the creative process and see the outcomes. Apparently I'm weird like that :)

Elisa Camahort Page
BlogHer
elisa@blogher.com
My BlogHer profile truly shows you everything I do online...Check it out!!

texasebeth 6 pts

I couldn't believe how Gretchen just took over and ramroded her ideas through at the beginning of the show. I'm so glad the judges took her down a notch or two!

Team Prince wasn't overall that impressive to me BUT it was so much better than the blah beige Team Luxe sent down. I did like Casanova's outfit. I thought Team Prince had a better grasp on the concept of "no leader" and worked so well together. They were determined to win.

Team Luxe were so busy looking down their noses at the others they forgot about the "no leader" clause. None of the outfits truly showed their own viewpoint/asthetic. Ivy's outfit was horrid. AJ is the only one I respect now, and it isn't because of his sewing, because of how he spoke up and said "I can only speak for myself".

I abso-fricking-lutely loved Tim's rant at the end. I love going to his blog & seeing the more indepth stuff he does too. Made me crack up at the end when Gretchen said she doesn't see herself as manipulative and Tim hurt her feelings. She didn't disagree with his bullying statement, just the manipulative part. And then Ivy at the end, saying Tim was right & maybe they did all get sucked into following Gretchen, just slayed me!

Elizabeth

@texasebeth ( http://twitter.com/texasebeth )  and My Life, such as it is.... ( http://texasebeth.blogspot.com )

WorkingGirlsShoeCloset 5 pts

I love the review!! Check out my Friday weekly post, What Would Project Runway Shoe? on http://workinggirlsshoecloset.blogspot.com <3

Maybelline 5 pts

Get after it, Tim! You held back man. I was talking to my TV telling Gretchen that she was "out".

Elisa Camahort 5 pts

If Gretchen's nasty character would matter as much if she actually was as talented as she thinks she is. I just haven't been impressed at all. Didn't understand why she won, particularly the first challenge.

And that makes her personality insufferable.

Elisa Camahort Page
BlogHer
elisa@blogher.com
My BlogHer profile truly shows you everything I do online...Check it out!!

varouna 5 pts

Tim giving Gretchen the business and the judges seeing right through Gretchen's back pedaling were the best parts of the show.

Candelaria Silva 5 pts

I so enjoyed Tim telling it like it t...i...is! I hope the designers listen I hope Gretchen & the other snippies get what they deserve.

http://blog.candelariasilva.com ( http://blog.candelarisilva.com/ )

Good and plenty!

Candelaria Silva 5 pts

I so enjoyed Tim telling it like it t...i...is! I hope the designers listen I hope Gretchen & the other snippies get what they deserve.

http://blog.candelariasilva.com ( http://blog.candelarisilva.com/ )

Good and plenty!

Megan Smith 5 pts

I love Tim on the rampage!

I was very happy to see Team Prince get themselves together and win it. The Team Luxe outfits were horrible and boring.

Hello!? Anybody could have seen that picking beige and menswear styling was disaster waiting to happen.

Then all those designers got sucked into thinking Gretchen was a wunderkind because she won two challenges in a row, instead of reminding themselves that there were no team leaders!

Hopefully someone gives Gretchen a good ol' beatdown next week.

Megan

TV/Online Video Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/megan-smith )

Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Meg's Rad Reviews ( http://www.megsradreviews.com )

Julie Ross Godar 5 pts

As soon as they chose "military/lace" the doves commenced crying.

I love Righteous Tim. The wretched Gretchen flipflop soliloquy and team machine-gunning of Michael C was exactly what I loathe about reality television -- I like the drama to be about muslin and zippers and such -- but the Tim Gunn dressdown was great :)