Most Popular

Recent Comments

Proposition 8: This Time, It's Personal

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

50 some odd years ago, a young man was coming of age in his conservative Christian family in a small town in Colorado.  They probably didn’t seem conservative actually in that small town, as regular church attendance and an attitude of general adherence to biblical doctrine were relatively common - both for the time period and location.  In fact, the church was the community, it defined the family.  Covered dish dinners and weekend picnics with other church families were probably the norm. 

By all accounts, life in the family was generally happy.  The parents had a solid and loving relationship - one that would be counted as unusually good by close friends and family who remembered the couple lovingly at silver and golden anniversaries before mourning the loss of the patriarch.  The family was comfortable economically, partly attributable to a careful budget and the rest to hard work and luck.  The two boys, four years apart, while not exceptionally close, were amicably friendly. 

Of course, the oldest son, as he entered his adolescence was expected to find the general bumps in the road experienced by all adolescents….  an awkwardly developing body, the intermittent worry of feeling left out and trying to fit in.  But somehow, for this young boy, it was even more difficult.  A constant feeling of not belonging road his coattails wherever he went, and the years passed by with more awkward moments than most that age experience.

Dating for this young man was never easy.  There wasn’t the glib and happy feeling of “first love” - or a sense that he couldn’t stop thinking about a coveted young girl.  It was all nerves - the feeling of having a blindfold over the eyes as one tries to navigate an unknown country…  not speaking the language, or knowing the customs, and finding only failure, running into the brick wall at every turn.

Nonetheless, the young man persisted along, leaving his small town and pursuing an education, and eventually earning two masters degrees.  Finally, meeting a woman with whom he felt comfortable, beginning a family with his own daughter and son. 

As happens for all young people becoming adults, the man expanded his realm of experience.  He traveled, visited with others, questioned the beliefs he’d been raised with, coming back to many of them, but along the way developed his own sense for who he was.  Within this time of discovery came the slow awakening of an always known, but never recognized, truth.  The man was gay.

Together with his wife, he faced the truth.  The pain experienced by both is generally unaccounted for… left buried somewhere, and maybe for good reason.  Yet together they made a decision to move forward, spending the next 15 years much as they had spent the previous several - as good friends, as husband and wife, father and mother…  raising the two children in the family each had envisioned, but without the traditional marital relationship.  They didn’t divorce, only acquired twin beds.  They shared a room, many glasses of wine and good discussions, parented equally and carefully - putting their children ahead of what must have been their personal sadness and sense of loss. 

The son and daughter of this man grew to be teenagers before they ever had an inkling that their family was “different” from other families.  In fact, the peace and calm within the house, the even-keeled parenting, and the obvious friendship between mother and father taught them that maybe their family was better. 

The “difference” finally came to light, towards the end of the children’s own adolescence.  As all children do, they traveled, questioned, and eventually accepted their family - coming back to the idea that it had been a happy place to grow.  The man and his wife, successful in the raising of daughter and son, eventually divorced, allowing each to search for their own romantic happiness, but remained close friends.  The son and daughter succeeded in school and their respective careers, began families of their own, contributed to society in their unique ways.  The man retired, and found joy in living near his grandchildren, contributing his love, time, and attention to the now young and growing family in immeasurable ways.

Proposition 8.  This is my final appeal as the vote draws near, and this time, it’s personal.   

I am the daughter of that gay man, this is the story of my father, the loving “Bapa” to my children, and one of my closest friends.

My dad wasn’t the traditional dad in many ways.  He never enjoyed sports, never tossed the football with my brother - didn’t throw down a beer out

  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Marcwolf 5 pts

Thanks you so much for your story and please give 'Bapa" a hug.. He deserves one for raising such a warm hearted and open minded daughter.

Myself - I am a gay man approaching 50, and I have a partner of over 12 years.  From my own experiences I have seen being gay as changing from being something evil, a perversion that must be lumped into every other perversion no matter how evil or revolting.
A life that has no meaning other than to be scorned upon. A person who through movies, TV, and other media must by all accounts be evil and thus killed or destroyed at the end of the show so to promote the rightousness and wholesomeness of being 'straight', or christian.

But times change. No longer being gay is a disease, or a crime. The movies are more understanding of us. It is recognised that it is not a 'choice' , but rather the very essense of our being.

Even zoologists are removing their Judia/Christian blinkers and seeing that homosexuality and all variants of sexuality exist in the animal kingdom. Its not 'dominant' behaviour. They are not just confused, or an isolated case. In fact gay animals live next to their straight counterparts in harmony and are even essential in their societies. Of course having gay animal in animal husbandary is a disaster for a farmer trying to get his prized 'gay' bull to sire more cattle :>

But with people - I have a lot of younger gay friends who are able to come out as who they are. Express their love and affection for the person(s) that holds that special place in their hearts.  And to hold hopes and desires that they will have that love through to their old age.

Recently on a Gay march I watched two white haired "granddad's" wearing their pride colors, and walking along holding hands. My heart went out to them both in that they could be open with the one they loved without fearing shame or ridicule. Knowing that twenty years before they would have been vilified for such tenderness.

Myself - with my friends, and at work - my partner is just that. My partner. And deserving the same respect as I would give one of my co-workers partner. I explain to the doubting that  "I am the same as you.. except that I prefer the same plumbing on my partner as I have on myself". And it seem to answer any uncertainty that my love for my partner is true. Just like theirs for their partner. 

As for families. Children need love and caring. For a gay couple to have a child it is more than just a biological event. It is the dedication of WANTING that child, and willing to do all that is one's power to have that child. Of course the child will be loved, cared for.. and above all WANTED!!!
But bringing a child into a gay relationship will not make the child gay, nor will it be abused, subject to the parents performing lewd acts infront of them..
But what it will do is allow the children to see a different relationship that works, has love, and caring. Whe the child can feel wanted and protected with its two Dad's, or mum's.

Sadly as bringing a child is a biological exercise it if sometimes done by accident, or without concern of the child. Single parent familes abound where one or the other parent has fled the relationship. I do not condone all of those as relationships do not always work. But if they can work together for the good of the child and not resort to 'point scoring' then all is good. And the child accepts that Mum and Dad do not get along but they still both love the child.

What really is happening to the perceptions of gay people by the populance?  Acceptance. They are being accepted as slightly different but still people, still human beings with feelings, loves, hates, desires.  To quote Shyloc the Jew from the Merchant of Venice "Prick us - do we not bleed, Hurt us do we not Weep"
That was written when the Jews were persecuted through medevial Eurpoe and those words hold true even today with any group who are considered less than human.

And for some this acceptance and normality is terrifying because it destroys their main weapon.. How can we fear what we know.  Can your grandchildren fear 'Bapa' because he is a warm loving grandfather, who hugs and cuddles them.. oh and he happens to be gay!

One of the first things of any war is the dehumanising of the enemy. He is not seen as a man who has a mate, has children and is willing to die for them and his country.. Oh No!! - He is a thing, something so despicably evil that you would give not more thought to killing him than crushing a dangerous insect.. A symbol to all that is bad and evil...

And for years the proponants of Section 8 has been beating that drum, and will continue to beat it until people start to ignore it.. And then the drum will lessen from a Deep Bass that drives the feeling of hatred and mistrust, to that of a small tin drum, a child's toy, and is looked upon with kindness and amusement of the ignorant.

Take care to you all, and any one who reads this.
May your God(s) go with you and watch over you

Love David, partner to Colin of 12 years... And many more years to come.

DrumsNWhistles 5 pts

Thank you for telling it.  I'm straight, Christian, and committed to seeing Prop 8 fail.  It's wrong. It's ugly. It's discriminatory. I wrote about it here ( http://politics.drumsnwhistles.com/2008/10/yes-on-... ). 

 It is my deepest hope and prayer that voters will understand how wrong this is and vote NO.

karoli

odd time signatures ( http://www.drumsnwhistles.com/ ) (life)
bang the drum ( http://politics.drumsnwhistles.com/ ) (politics)

Goddess in the Groove 5 pts

I love your post. I am watching this debate, and often think of my gay friends. 15 years ago, we were sitting at work discussing how hard it is for one of them and his partner, because they have a house together in France, live together in the city, have a car together, and otherwise live their whole life TOGETHER, yet do not have any rights. Such as healthcare, emergency room visits, custody of dog, etc. All these discussions bring up old memories.....

The haters often bring up how "screwed up" children will be by seeing/hearing/ being raised by gay parents. This is so typical of an intolerant society. It is also quite ridiculous. Your post states that well, and hopefully some of the sheep will read it. Just because they want to "ban" gay marriage does not make our world less "gay". It just makes life harder for people.

 For all of us not gay people, just remember this debate is important for you too, as it is a debate of tolerance. Once the haters do not get their vote here (and I am confident that they will not), they will find someone else to pick on. Have tattoos, purple hair, biracial relationship??? You could be next......

Goddess in the Groove! Women with opinions wanted.....

Daily (almost) musings and Kaffeeklatsch...

http//:www.goddessinthegroove.blogspot.com

To see the magic bellys, or the magic book, venture to

http

Goddess in the Groove 5 pts

I love your post. I am watching this debate, and often think of my gay friends. 15 years ago, we were sitting at work discussing how hard it is for one of them and his partner, because they have a house together in France, live together in the city, have a car together, and otherwise live their whole life TOGETHER, yet do not have any rights. Such as healthcare, emergency room visits, custody of dog, etc. All these discussions bring up old memories.....

The haters often bring up how "screwed up" children will be by seeing/hearing/ being raised by gay parents. This is so typical of an intolerant society. It is also quite ridiculous. Your post states that well, and hopefully some of the sheep will read it. Just because they want to "ban" gay marriage does not make our world less "gay". It just makes life harder for people.

 For all of us not gay people, just remember this debate is important for you too, as it is a debate of tolerance. Once the haters do not get their vote here (and I am confident that they will not), they will find someone else to pick on. Have tattoos, purple hair, biracial relationship??? You could be next......

Goddess in the Groove! Women with opinions wanted.....

Daily (almost) musings and Kaffeeklatsch...

http//:www.goddessinthegroove.blogspot.com

To see the magic bellys, or the magic book, venture to

http

MJ2007 5 pts

It's outrageous that this is even an issue. All people should be afforded the same rights.  Period.  It's a legislation of morality. What's next? Jail time for divorce?  If the extreme right has their way....

Did you see that Sarah Palin supports a constitutional ban on gay marriage?  I don't know why our world can't just live and let live.  What two consenting adults do in privacy isn't anyone's business.  

HollysFollyGlass 5 pts

I went through heck trying to sign up on blogher to comment here. I love this post. I get physically ill just hearing the hatred of these ads. It's like gay people are the last group we can still pick on!

I have a blog post of my own on this subject and why it's so personal to me but your story is so moving.

Kudos to your parents for the way they raised you. I find that kind of sacrifice is so rare these days.  

Liz Rizzo 5 pts

It's so shocking how widespread the hate is - I don't understand why people don't mind their own business and let other people just be. It's got nothing to do with them.

Sigh. I will be so so so sad and discouraged if prop 8 passes.

Liz Rizzo ( http://blogher.org/blog/liz-rizzo )

I blog at Everyday Goddess ( http://everydaygoddess.typepad.com/ ).

GingerW 5 pts

for putting such an eloquent arguement out there. You articulated everything that I've been feeling about Prop 8 in a way that I never could.

Ginger

Rambler Ramble ( http://rambleramble.com )

Chrystibella 5 pts

"this is a bigoted attempt at exclusion"

I agree!  I get so tired of hearing the scare tactics used in the campaign. 
Fear is what causes a lot of the hatred and segregation in our society.  It
fuels the fire!  

Your article was a beautiful example of love, trust, friendship, family
support, acceptance, and sacrifice.  

I felt compelled to leave a comment on this one.  =) 

Crunchy Carpets 5 pts

It saddens me that this is going on.

Again...this insane fear of 'different' 

Look for me at http://crunchycarpets.com or check out the ladies at www.wetcoastwomen.com ( http://www.wetcoastwomen.com )

everydayreasons 5 pts

I don't know why there aren't a million comments on your post.  I loved every word of of it and wanted to tell you, my dad also "wasn’t the traditional dad in many ways.  He never enjoyed sports, never tossed the football  - didn’t throw down a beer out by the BBQ with his buddies" either, and he's not gay. There is nothing nontraditional about your family, there is no such thing as a traditional family. Marriage is a joke to most people and like you said, there are a lot of hetersexual couples that are unhappy and in my opinion much less qualified to be parents or even married couples than a loving "nontraditional" couple.  Marriage is not intended to exclude people. ~Z