Bio
Sarah and the Goon Squad Sarah is a SAHM of six year old b/g twins living in the D.C. Metropolitan Area. You can find Sarah at her personal blog, Sar...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Ralph Nader Wants To Put An End To Athletic Scholarships

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Ralph Nader wants to put an end to those pesky college athletic scholarships.

Why? Nader says he wants to "de-professionalize" college athletics.

*sigh*

Okay Ralph, I get the problems with the athletic scholarships, particularly in men's basketball and football. I understand that some NCAA sports are full time jobs. I'm sure anyone that plays Duke basketball will back me up here. I understand that there are some shady goings on with college athletes accepting money. I can sympathize that some people who get college scholarships for crew or golf or tennis might not qualify for anything remotely need based, but I would still argue that the merit based athletic scholarship does more good than harm.

OSU vs PSUHow many thousands of students enrolled in college right now would be otherwise unable to go to a University at all?

For a lot of kids a sports scholarship is their best shot to escape poverty.

Either that or dealing drugs.

And no, I am not overstating things. You see it all the time. How many NFL or NBA players grew up in the ghetto? How many of them would be playing professional sports without being recruited out of college? And how many more (easily 90%) of kids that received some higher education because of an athletic scholarship have a professional career outside of sports that they would not have qualified for without a degree?

Ralph Nader is proposing that the current scholarships be replaced with need based scholarships.

So do we also get rid of the scholarships for students with exceptional grades and test scores?

I agree that we could improve the system. I honestly believe that some college athletes should be paid, but that is a post for a different time. For now, I say that eliminating all talent based athletic scholarships would be tragic for the young people that work so hard to excel in their sport.

I don't hate Ralph Nader. Sometimes he has really good ideas. This is not one of them. Should there be more need based college scholarships available? Yes. Should we eliminate financial assistance for athletes across the board. No.

 

More:

BlogHer Contributing Editor, Sarah can also be found at Sarah and the Goon Squad and Draft Day Suit.

Photo Credit: Ohio State vs Penn State on November 13, 2010; Jenna Hatfield.

  • 3
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
nellewrites 6 pts

Sheesh, all those silly Tea Partyers out there doing silly Tea Partyer things, and he is picking on scholarships.

Some schools do need based, Dartmouth (an Ivy League school) for one. Yet athletic scholarships encourage people with less focus on academics to concentrate on academics, at least in high school, sufficient to get them to college. What happens after, well...

We can talk a lot about athletics, in the same way we can talk about beauty contests and such for young kids. Gifted athletes are spotted at a very early age, and people start lining up to hitch their wagon to that child, it is inane. How about that issue, Ralph - you know, helpless, exploited child, versus big adult getting scholarship?

And if it is college athletics he wishes to take on, where was he when Title IX first passed in 1972, when 300,000 women played vs 3,000,000 million men? Wouldn't that have been a major issue to tackle? Wouldn't equalisation via scholarship have been a wonderful issue for him to sink his teeth into?

Or, if gender doesn't stir his college passion, he can take on the exploitation of athletes by the big time Division I football and basketball schools, who use these gifted athletes (only a fraction of whom will play pro) yet look the other way on some of them getting a real education, the NCAA making billions in TV revenue.

Oh well. We all find issues that tweak us, not necessarily because it is a big issue overall, or in our lives. I guess more people hear him rant than most of us. '-)

nellewrites ( http://nellewrites.wordpress.com/ )

JennaHatfield 10 pts

As I live just east of Columbus, deep within OSU territory, I've been following the NCAA drama with Coach Tressel and the players who accepted money for memorabilia. So, yes, I recognize that the system is kind of wonky and needs some changes, but I don't think Nader's plan is the appropriate course of action. Unfortunately, I don't quite have the answer either, but I know that offering less educational opportunity won't serve the public in any real way.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and photographer.

ebyrdstarr 5 pts

The promise of athletic scholarships goes even further. I remember Sherron Collins, former point guard for the Kansas Jayhawks (and key member of our '08 championship team), telling about growing up in Chicago. He said that it was an unstated agreement among the competing gangs that he was off limits, that he wouldn't be recruited to any gang, because he had mad basketball skills. The fact that he had college recruiters watching him from a young age and had a clear path out kept him safe from gang wars. And as a result, in 2010, his mother got to realize her dream of watching her son graduate from college.

Preaching to the Choir ( http://rantsofapublicdefender.blogspot.com/ )