Bio
I was raised by my single father in Southern California along with my younger brother. After navigating puberty with no instruction manual, I now liv...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

The Real World Risk of an MTV Contract

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 21
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

When I read MTV’s Real World Contract posted by The Village Voice, one of the many elements that struck me was the danger and acceptability of misusing language when used for financial gain. Words like “rape,” “violate,” and “sexual assault” are nasty, heavy, uncomfortable words, words that land like bricks, words that everyone has difficulty understanding when they are “appropriate” to use, and ironically, even survivors have trouble using these terms to describe their experiences. It is much easier to say “non-consensual physical contact.” It is easier to write “interacting” or “carries the risk.”

It is easier to dress it all up under the guise that a signature means consent.

Courtesy of Atomic Jeep

It was the day after Christmas, 1999. My best friend was throwing a party at her father’s house. I was eighteen years old and excited to visit with friends who were home from their first semester at college. My best friend’s older brother supplied the alcohol, even blended the margaritas, and they were good. After seeing an old boyfriend, I grew nostalgic and decided I no longer wanted to be at the party but the smart thing was to spend the night. The smart thing was for my car keys to remain in my purse. We all agreed to sleep over, so I went to bed early while the party raged on. In the middle of the night I woke up to my best friend’s brother violating me.

Paralyzed with fear, I shrugged him off, pretended like I was waking from a horrible nightmare, unaware it was the beginning of a decade long battle to reclaim my body. After ten minutes of complete paralysis, he came back to continue, thinking I was asleep once again. I flinched when he touched me, sending him back upstairs. When I finally gathered the courage to get up, I walked downstairs to an empty living room. The party was over, my friends had all left, even my best friend who had gone to her boyfriend’s house.  We were alone.

I did everything right. I went to the police. I went to the hospital. When evidence came up inconclusive because I had gone to the bathroom, I wired my phone and confronted my attacker. I got him to confess. I pressed charges and I sent him to jail for “sexual assault.” I cut ties with many people, I cut ties with my past, and I moved to New York. I refused to tell anyone because I didn’t want to give him any more power than he had already taken. Instead, I kept the details of that night buried beneath the breasts I now shield whenever my boyfriend attempts to caress them. I keep that night as a startled gasp in my throat anytime I am gently awaken by the man I sleep next to every night.

That night keeps my dreams in a constant state of alarm, a sleep that never lets me go too deep, in case there is a nightmare waiting on the other side. It has taken me ten years to finally use the term “rape” after a therapist informed me, “It doesn’t have to be a penis for it to be rape.” Only now, at twenty-nine years old, have I begun to unpack the parts of myself that were shut up in silence that night.

MTV’s clause in their Real World Contract stating “Interacting with other cast members carries the risk of "non-consensual physical contact" and should you contract AIDS, etc. during such an interaction, MTV is not responsible. (Stipulation 7) suggests more than “non-consensual physical contact” but rather non-consensual sexual contact, the possibility and the subsequent absolution of rape.

Yes, a rapist, a predator, a murderer are all responsible for their own actions. But can something be said for MTV’s responsibility in creating a powder keg of an environment by placing strangers in a home without criminal background checks, supplying them with liquor on MTV’s dime, and underestimating the psychological effects of being filmed twenty-four hours a day? (For further information on this topic check out Ondi Timoner’s documentary, WE LIVE IN PUBLIC).If you put a four year old in a room with a loaded gun and that gun goes off, who is responsible? If you put intoxicated “young adults” in a hot tub and someone is raped, the fault falls to the perpetrator, no doubt about that. But the culpability of MTV’s responsibility in creating a dangerous environment is one

  • 21
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Emily@SAHM.i.AM 8 pts

Thank you for sharing your story. Kudos to your for handling your situation with such strength! The MTV contract is disturbing on so many levels. Even though it may include fighting and whatever else the fact that it's vague enough to include rape/sexual assault is disgusting. It's contributing to a society where rapists are not held accountable, where victims are blamed. That you for speaking out!

Lindsey Anthony 5 pts

Exactly. There is a purposeful vagueness in their language to basically contract an act that is illegal. Emily@SAHM.i.AM

notsuperjustmom 5 pts

I'm appalled every time I hear about things like this that have happened no matter when they happened. Stories like this one are the kind my high school students need to hear to know that this, too, can happen to them. I also abhor MTV--everything about it--even though I remember being infatuated with The Real World from maybe the second or third season. However, I wonder if their wording in their contract, "non-consenual physical contact" is meant to cover ALL forms of physical contact, including fighting where blood is shed, perhaps with an HIV positive cast member. It seems to me that they've left their wording intentionally vague to free themselves of all culpability in any physical encounter.

Lindsey Anthony 5 pts

I can recall seeing an episode of A&E's reality show INTERVENTION and watching a producer actually break the fourth wall and try to stop a woman from getting behind the wheel after documenting her drinking a severe amount of vodka throughout the day. But up until that point, they even rode in the car with her while she drank mini bottles of vodka. There were other points where it stated the producers were driving and her sister is even called. But as far as MTV, there was an investigation of a rape allegation at the Real World San Diego house in 2003 (which aired in 2004). The assailant was a friend of a cast member who brought another cast member back to the home after giving her what many believe was a drugged drink. At the time it was cited that MTV Producers were so uncooperative there was a police raid of the house to confiscate evidence but the incident occurred in the bathroom, the one place cameras are not allowed. However, I believe there was footage of the assailant exiting the bathroom and the cast member was found naked on the bathroom floor, suggesting someone was present. In the end, MTV was cooperative but no formal charges were made based on inconclusive evidence.

alexash 5 pts

Lindsey, your courage and eloquence is inspiring. I am horrified to see protection of perpetrators of sexual assault in any form, but a network aimed at youth condoning sexual violence, offering protection to perpetrators and silencing victims via contract, is beyond shameful. A boycott of the network in the name of all victims of sexual violence is in order.

As for Melaina25's comment, I do believe that in reality TV crews are supposed to document and never get involved. How many times have we watched irresponsible behavior on reality shows? Violent fighting, people drunk getting behind the wheel - all in the name of riveting television.

Melaina25 5 pts

alexash I've definitely seen shows where once physical violence occurs a producer or other staff step in to break it up. I haven't seen the Real World since New Orleans (think I saw part of Chicago) so I can't really remember.

Amber Brooks 5 pts

Great article Lindsey! I was also sucked in by the Real World show and was never afraid to try out for the show. I would not have guessed MTV wouldn't be there to protect us. I've actually seen the staff get involved in other reality shows when things got out of hand so I'm surprised MTV does not. Personally I would still attempt to take them to court.

Thanks for sharing your personal story :)

Melaina25 5 pts

What would happen if during filming producers saw someone being sexually assaulted or raped? What is there in the cameraman/producers contract about witnessing criminal acts? Do they have to keep filming?

They obviously have a moral responsibility to cross the fourth wall and stop whatever is happening, but is that a contractual responsibility as well or would they be breaking their contract to do so?

I once auditioned for the Real World on a whim in college; I literally passed the auditions walking through Dupont Circle and decided to go in. I didn't make it on the show and by the sounds of it that was a good thing.

Thank you for sharing your story,

Morgan Shanahan 8 pts

I wonder this as well. I saw a short film in film school called "Real Life" which was a brilliantly perfect parody of a real world episode right up until a cast member shot himself in the face on camera while the camera guys did nothing...the exploration of "entertainment" vs. "humanity" that followed was really poignant for a student film! Melaina25

Lindsey Anthony 5 pts

Thanks for your comments. DesiValentine4, I hear you. It is completely criminal. Brie, thanks for your comment. I too was seduced by the Real World show as a teen which is exactly how they find their next "stars." Thanks for the well wishes. Hope you and yours are well.

Brie Shohoudy 5 pts

Wow Lindsey, wow. I am speechless right now. I remember you from many moons ago and to know that any person that I have known has had to go through such an ugly experience breaks my heart. I think you are so brave for saying something and trying to raise awareness on the topic. I always imagined as a youngster how "cool" it would be to go on this show, but thank my lucky stars that I never took the plunge (not that I would have made the cut). I don't understand how MTV gets away with this. Are there no parents overseeing the signing of these contracts? I know mine would have gone through that thing with a fine-tooth comb and disputed me signing if there were any red-flags raised. Nonetheless, it is happening and I think that the network should be ashamed of the situation they are putting these kids into. I am so sorry to hear about your trauma, and I hope that you are able to do whatever it takes to heal your scars in order to live as happy a life as you deserve.

DesiValentine4 79 pts

ARE YOU KIDDING ME?!?!?! In what universe is this REMOTELY acceptable?! I understand that this is an issue of a corporation protecting itself from liability in the event that an assault occurs. But they should not have that protection. If they are creating an environment in which sexual assault is probable, they should be held criminally and financially accountable.

Or maybe they should just take the ratings hit and maintain responsibility for keeping their "actors" safe.

Conversation from Twitter

Tauren_Dyson
Tauren_Dyson

WriterChanelle yeah, all those reality shows have contracts that participants can't sue if they catch stds. #legalteam

kathyzucker
kathyzucker

WriterChanelle That's really disturbing. Reflects the focus on the short-term that is really prevalent right now in US. #genychat

Conversation from Facebook

Viqi French
Viqi French

They've left no hideous stone unturned.

Gina Citelli-moser
Gina Citelli-moser

I can only imagine what goes on with MTV. Call me old but I miss them being only about music. The reality shows suck and paint a very bad picture for younger kids these days. I admire this girls strength for sharing her story. Recovery is a process and pray that every day she will be empowered in helping others.

Skeeter Bess
Skeeter Bess

Shocked, appalled, disgusted, outraged and thinking I might throw up. Shame on you, MTV.

Katherine Amy Vega
Katherine Amy Vega

Thank you for this article.