Bio
I was raised by my single father in Southern California along with my younger brother. After navigating puberty with no instruction manual, I now liv...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Real World Ruins: Tonya Cooley Sues MTV for Filming Rape

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Two months back, I wrote a post for BlogHer about the not-so-cleverly disguised rape clause in MTV's contracts for Real World cast members. The clause (Stipulation 7) states that:


“Interacting with other cast members carries the risk of "non-consensual physical contact" and should you contract AIDS, etc. during such an interaction, MTV is not responsible."

While I believe that each individual is responsible for their own actions, it is no secret that MTV creates powder keg environments to provoke dangerous and vulnerable situations to bolster ratings. They antagonize through a steady supply of alcohol and hide behind the lens of a camera as in the case of The Real World San Diego where there was a rape allegation that happened in the MTV home. Unfortunately, MTV was said to be so uncooperative that the house was raided by police and evidence (including video footage) came up inconclusive since the incident supposedly happened in one of the bathrooms (the only place cameras are not allowed). The cast member who accused the friend of another cast member of the rape, died three years later of cystic fibrosis. It is unclear how thorough MTV's own investigation was and charges were never filed.

Now, Tonya Cooley, originally featured on The Real World: Chicago, is suing MTV for sexual assault and being raped by two cast members using a toothbrush while filming Real World/Road Rule Challenge: The Ruins in Phuket, Thailand in 2009.  Horrific as the claims are, it takes a fearless woman to make this case public and go up against the Goliath, MTV.  Real World producers immediately dismissed the accusations as “baseless” despite there being apparent footage of the incident, and describe Cooley as "provacative" in her official Bio on MTV.com. 

Courtesy MTV.com

Cooley's claims also challenge the limited definitions for what defines “rape,” a term currently up for discussion (in terms of broadening the meaning) by the FBI.  According to reports, Cooley was penetrated by the tooth brush of a male cast member who was not involved in the incident.  Producers allegedly replaced the cast member's toothbrush but did nothing about the assault.  Currently, the legal definition of rape is “the carnal knowledge of a female, forcibly and against her will”. The current term excludes oral and anal penetration as well as cases when women were under the influence as well as excluding male victims. There is some skewed idea that rape is something that happens to women in a back alley while being held at gunpoint. So many sexual crimes and rapes go unreported or seem to go unreported because they do not fit in this very narrow definition which in turn grossly misrepresents statistics which means there isn’t enough funding for police force to prevent such crimes or funding to handle the aftermath of such a traumatic event.

Let’s be real here, public funding goes where the numbers are. Shows like The Real World absolutely should be held accountable for their hand in provoking and creating such dangerous situations for cast members, and instead they have succeeded in burying these incidents by premptively having cast members sign onerous contracts.  But Tonya Cooley is taking this fight to MTV’s door and suing her accused assailants as well as MTV for the trauma she claims she suffered during shooting.  Again, MTV claims the accusations are false, but regardless if there is enough evidence to prove Cooley’s case, it is inspiring despite the gruesome terms, that more victims of MTV’s inhumane and misogynistic practices are speaking up and shedding light on one of the darker aspects of our overexposed modern society.

Lindsey Anthony blogs at RewindRevise.com

  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Writergirl2012 5 pts

I am pretty behind, and just finding out about this story. Honesty I hope that girl helps start a movement towards a more complete and human experience. What are we doing to ourselves? Why are we allowing our minds to be poisoned to the point of the crumbling of our society? If we keep up the mental pollution then soon everyone will be reduced to animals. Non thinking, filthy, creatures. But hey it'll be entertaining for someone. The question is who?

MauiShopGirl 60 pts

I'm old enough to remember the very first "Real World" when they brought together strangers who had dreams or life experiences they were pursuing in New York City. An artist, a rapper, a dancer, a model...In later seasons we saw yet another cast member struggle with aids and saw what happened when cultural, religious and political differences came to a head. These earlier cast members often had jobs or careers which weren't provided by MTV as "something to do", a cop, an illustrator, a bartender, a college student who was actually attending classes. I was in the same age group as the participants and I loved the show, I saw others coming to age and struggling with some of the same interpersonal conflicts I also had experienced. It made me think about the world beyond my rock in the middle of the Pacific Ocean.

At some point the Real World changed and became less of a documentary and more of a voyeur experience looking into a sponsored twenty four hour party where everyone was attractive and in many cases seeking fame. They followed the money...higher ratings for sensationalism. I believe MTV doesn't interfere in many cases as they consider it a documentary, but let's face it, there is a difference between a documentary and hosting a party.

Monsey 6 pts

Good follow up. Its terrible what happened to Tonya. The definition of rape must be expanded beyond the limited scope of what it already is.

alexash 10 pts

I've been following the FBI story since it was released and was blown away to learn things haven't changed much since the decade women were eligible to first vote. This change must come. My fear is in this economy there will be pressure from law enforcement to say they can't handle the larger case loads (look at what happened in Topeka!). But I will do whatever I can to support the cause.

As for MTV, I have no words. Just days following your rape clause piece, I learned that Chris Brown took the stage at the VMAs (I didn't watch). The messages we send about fame and celebrity and violence are so dangerously, horribly skewed. When do we reach the tipping point?

Lindsey Anthony 17 pts

When Chris Brown was the musical guest for SNL's Valentine Day Episode, I was utterly speechless. Not only was NBC's decision enraging, but incredibly tasteless.

Nancy Hill 15 pts

Thank you for reminding us all that what we watch is what we support. If you don't like MTV potentially making money off of rape, or Kim K. making a mockery of marriage for money, stop watching and let the advertisers know you have stopped. Choosing to watch something is a choice and our choices have consequences far beyond the obvious top layer ones. Thanks again for encouraging us to look a little deeper. (As a side note: I, too, worked on a crisis center hotline for years a few decades ago and doing this type of work, volunteer or otherwise, can change your perspectives on how society tolerates a number of severe ills that should be addressed.)

alienbody 447 pts

I'm sickened over it and glad that I've never once lingered for a nanosecond on that show...ever. I spent 6 months as a rape crisis counselor through the YWCA here in San Jose, CA and I learned a lot about the stigma and demographics of rape, which are FAR different than the media likes to portray. Great post, thanks for writing!

Lindsey Anthony 17 pts

Thanks for commenting! And thank you for the work you did at YWCA. alienbody

Conversation from Facebook

Note to Self: a love I deserve
Note to Self: a love I deserve

The clause doesn't surprise me at all. There are plenty of industries even government jurisdictions where the rules meant to protect don't always protect everyone. What I should hope is that personal accountability is what is at the forefront. [Be clear. I'm NOT talking about the victim.] Specifically the assailants, and the individuals who each played a duplicitous role while under the employ of MTV. Pinning responsibility on the corporation doesn't do much for society's understanding of social responsibility... Questions that come to mind more are what do the contracts of the cameramen, editors, and producers say about reporting illegal acts or interacting with "cast". It's traditional for documentary filmmakers and writers to often face tough decisions on what their responsibility is when they witness or find evidence an immoral act.... (Again I'm not defending MTV, only suggesting that when we identify "wrongs" to be outraged by we acknowledge individual responsibility for actions, not hiding behind the company line.) Years ago I worked in a bar where the city passed an ordinance that said any physical contact with a patron can be considered assault, the employee would lose their job and be prosecuted, even if the contact was in self defense. (This was in response to bouncers severely injuring a patron.) It was made clear during our city training on the new policy that even if a patron pulled a gun or a knife threatened us as an employee or someone else we could not in any way touch the assailant, but as employees we would still be responsible for the safety of every other person in the facility... Essentially if in this scenario you'd better be a good talker, and fast thinker to convince the guy to leave without hurting anyone or at least until the police could intervene... (Not the same I realize, I'm just outlining how contracts, laws, and personal accountability each play an important role in horrible situations.) Personal accountability is what can make the difference between hiding behind some legaleeze or doing the right thing.

Melissa Corliss Aiello
Melissa Corliss Aiello

Great post! Thanks for writing!!

Tiffiny Harmer Felix
Tiffiny Harmer Felix

MTV used to be about music. Now it's a joke. The shows they produce and televise are trash, and they twist the minds of both men and women (young and old) who watch them. What happens in the Real World houses is horrific, and it is beyond me why anyone would want to be on one of their shows. I wish Tonya Cooley good luck in her efforts to make MTV be held accountable for what happened to her, but I'm not holding my breath.

Vicki Mallory
Vicki Mallory

Omg...wth is going on? Is it open season on women and girls? Is the rapture coming again?

S.l. Stivers-Menz
S.l. Stivers-Menz

ANGER & OUTRAGE!!!!