Bio
I'm a writer, a woman, a wife, a mother, a feminist, a friend, a sister and more.  Currently, I'm working on several non-fiction projects while...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Teens, Body Image and Feminism: Reflections of a Former Women's Magazine Reader

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     
NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 08:  Editor in chief of Seventeen magazine Ann Shoket attends the second season premiere of MTV's 'The City' at Hearst Tower on September 8, 2009 in New York City.  (Photo by Bryan Bedder/Getty Images)

When I was twelve-years-old, I had a subscription to Seventeen magazine. I had Tiger Beat posters of C. Thomas Howell, Matt Dillon and Rob Lowe all over my bedroom walls. This was back in the day when The Outsiders was the popular movie (and book -- I must have read it five times). It was the time of drop-waisted mini-skirts and Sarah Jessica Parker was just a teeny-bopper on Square Pegs --my then-FAVORITE show!

All I wanted was to be a typical American teenager. But somewhere in the back of my pre-teen brain, I knew there was never a chance for me. I was too fat. I was not pretty enough. I wasn't able to make my hair look right. I would steal my mother's Dexatrim. I stole it from my older sister, too, but all I got for my sticky fingers was a hollow, gnawing pit in my stomach and a dizzy feeling as I walked down the hallway of the middle school.

I wasn't thin enough, and the evidence wasn't just between the covers of the magazine. It was printed on the label on the back of my jeans -- that label that told you the waist size and inseam length right there on the waistband -- behind you, where you couldn't see when people were reading it. But they were ... I knew that they were. My friends' waists were in the 20-24 inch range. I bulged out at 28 inches. I was fat. Seventeen confirmed it.

I would be so excited when my Seventeen magazine would arrive in the mail. Those girls were beautiful. And skinny. I would read each issue cover-to-cover, with the hope that if I just followed the right trends, and bought the right Cover Girl eyeliner, and applied it exactly as instructed, that I might be pretty too.

I wanted to be a model. I wanted people to pay attention to me. All I had to do was to get beautiful. After all, isn't that what Lisa Greene (the most popular girl in my school) had? Boys thought she was cute (we didn't say "hot" then), and girls alternated between hoping to be her friend, and despising her for being the object of the boys' attention.

When I'd get to the back of the issue, there would be those classified ads, which gave me hope that, one day, I too could be beautiful. Enter Barbizon and the John Robert Powers School of Modeling. All I needed was to be discovered, and I could be a model! I fantasized about photo shoots, and getting to wear fashionable, cool outfits, anything other than hand-me-down clothes from my sisters. I imagined what it would be like to have someone behind the camera, snapping shots of me, telling me how gorgeous I was -- so very perfect -- and how easy I made the photographer's job because of it.

So I sent in to Barbizon and JRP, and got "more information" from them. They sent me packets with shiny brochures, showing me how for a few hundred dollars, I could take classes to be a model. I could have them help me to develop a portfolio (more money). Everyone knows that a good portfolio is the key to getting the modeling gigs. I needed a portfolio.

My mother humored me at first, and then flat-out told me that these companies were a scam. That what I looked like didn't matter to them if they thought they could part me from cash while dangling me along with the ever-elusive modeling dream. I didn't believe her -- she just couldn't see my modeling potential. After all, she wasn't a fashion or advertising professional. She was just a mom who read grown-up versions of Seventeen, was forever on a diet, and purchased special concoctions to smear on her face to reduce wrinkles, give a smoother appearance

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Just_Margaret 5 pts

Recently a lot of folks have been referencing Sassy...

Somehow, I missed Sassy--it wasn't on my radar back in the day...though 'the day' for me may have been before Sassy's time. :)

~Margaret

Just Margaret ( http://maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com )

victorias_view 18 pts moderator

I remember all of those ads in Seventeen and YM. They created unrealistic expectations for us all. It was when I found Sassy I realized I could be me and it's very sad that publication no longer exists.

It's great that you are taking the time to discuss important issues such as discrimination, and body images with your daugther. It something I wish my mother and I had did...

Just_Margaret 5 pts

I am often amused by the covers that show celebrities "without makeup" because the mags never explain their own role in creating the original 'with makeup' versions...

~Margaret

Just Margaret ( http://maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com )

crashtestdoll 5 pts

"Today's covers are nothing more than artists' renditions of a celebrity or model. Calling them photos is, at best, misleading."

I was just thinking that the other day when I was at the grocery store. Now, I haven't bought one of those magazines in 3 or 4 years, but this time, something about the cover photo struck me as eerily different from what they were 3 or 4 years ago. Even US Weekly does it for celebrities who pose for their cover! Makes you wonder if anyone's telling these publishers that the same celebrities are in tabloid photos plastered right next to their covers, as well as on tv and the internet, so their jig is up, we know it's been photoshopped. But covers are still getting increasingly more photoshopped. Kind of like a woman who's addicted to plastic surgery and can no longer tell when to stop.

Just_Margaret 5 pts

Until we have that magazine, though, we do have the young women who are writing about it. Hooray for the f-Bomb and the other feminist bloggers in the blogosphere!

~Margaret

Just Margaret ( http://maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com )

westsalem 5 pts

I used to read YM, although it was a bit more snarky than Seventeen it made me feel the same way. This is an excellent post. We need a magazine aimed at young women that is infused with a feminist viewpoint, represents real women, and tells them about the intellectual, spiritual, and social gifts that women (young and old) have to give to the world.

Thanks again for writing this article.

Just_Margaret 5 pts

They are one big ad. If it's not an actual ad, it seems it's an article telling you what to buy, or how to use a *product*.

~Margaret

Just Margaret ( http://maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com )

Just_Margaret 5 pts

It isn't always comfortable, is it? :)

~Margaret

Just Margaret ( http://maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com )

rayvingraychel 5 pts

I must have had shelf upon shelf of seventeen magazines when I was in middle school. I loved looking at the pretty girls, but I never really understood the content. It never made sense to me. Beauty magazines are really one big advert designed to make women feel like we need to change ourselves in order to be accepted by society. I haven't bought or read a beauty magazine in over 10 years. Boycott them!

The Rayve ( http://www.therayve.blogspot.com )

Lavender Luz 6 pts

"That I was being cultivated to be a consumer, and to feel inadequate in my own skin, so that I would consume more."

YES!

It's important for me to remember I am being watched. Not only for what I say to myself or to my daughter, but also what I do, what I read, what and how I consume.

This post has made me more aware. I'm always up for that (though it's not always comfortable).

Weebles Wobblog ( http://www.weebleswobblog.com/ ) ... yin-yanging my way.@LavLuz
Examiner ( http://www.examiner.com/x-13701-Open-Adoption-Exam... )for Open Adoption.
( http://twitter.com/LavLuz )

Just_Margaret 5 pts

If only we had access years ago to social media--perhaps at 12, we could then have seen a different perspective on being a woman.

~Margaret

Just Margaret ( http://maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com )

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I absolutely loved this post. I could have written parts of it myself. I only wish that my 12-year-old self could have read this AND I wish that she would have heard your words.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).