Bio
I can be found at Schmutzie.com, Ninjamatics, and Grace in Small Things.
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

The 40-Day Inner Mean Girl Cleanse: How It Tangled With My Outer Bitch and Lost

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 14
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I have a long history of negative self-talk, and, although I have been less harsh with myself in recent years, I still manage to be my own worst bully. So, when I came across The 40-Day Inner Mean Girl Cleanse one afternoon in late August, a six-week course hosted by co-creators Amy Ahlers and Christine Arylo, I thought it was probably a good idea to join up. My very recent commitment to sobriety, thoughts about positive personal revolution, and a strong desire to be kinder to myself made this seem like the right step to take.

Plus, The Inner Mean Girl Cleanse was free. I like free, and how could the over 7000 women who had already signed up to be a part of The Inner Mean Girl Revolution be wrong? I signed up for the six-week course and waited to see what my e-mail inbox would bring.

In Week One, the goal was to give up gossip for good talk, and the daily practice was to repeat the following affirmation every morning: "Today I speak only from my heart. I leave gossip and toxic words behind. I truly speak only from my heart." I put the daily personal affirmations part aside, because daily affirmations seem to have the opposite effect on me and make me feel terrible, but I did take the message to heart and tried to remain mindful of gossip, both from others around me and myself.

Before I was even able to really get into practicing mindfulness about gossip, though, I hit my first stumbling block when The Inner Mean Girl Cleanse managed to annoy me by August 26th, less than 24 hours into the program. There was a live launch call that was advertised as being accompanied by “FREE gifts!,” which were a free e-course and a teleclass by SARK. The Inner Mean Girl Cleanse had barely begun, and its hopefully worthwhile offering of positive influence against unnecessary internal negativity was already being muffled by its secondary agenda as a vehicle to advertise other programs by its contributors. At least, that’s how it felt with the ALL-CAPS-ed and exclamation-pointed excitement in the e-mail.

I didn’t know it yet, but I had just received the first of what would be many ad fliers.

This apparent bait-and-switch did not help me to cultivate good talk from the outset. I grumbled to myself, but, in the spirit of the first week, I chose to think positively and persevere. The real bully in my life is usually myself, and I wanted to give this course a shot instead of dropping out due to my own knee-jerk response to a sales flier in my inbox. I decided to hope for the best and carry on.

With that in mind, I gave the live launch call with SARK, Susan Ariel Rainbow Kennedy, a listen. As much as I tried to take it in with an open mind though, the repeated use of hyperbolic language struck me as precocious, hammy and pedantic in the way that one would speak to a small child. Words like “amazing” and “inspired” and “empowered” were sing-songed repeatedly, which only inspired me to think Really?, and want to hand them a thesaurus. I wanted to learn how to deal with my Inner Mean Girl, not join some 1990s-style cult of female empowerment reliant on dissociating through fictive, archetypal entities with names like “The Critic” and “The Comparison Queen” and “Perfectionist Patty”.

This is where the Inner Mean Girl Cleanse met my Outer Critical Bitch.

I do realize that this whole thing was called The Inner Mean Girl Cleanse. The title pretty much points out straight away that these archetypes were going to be part of the process and I should have expected it, but, still it irked me. Any therapeutic exercise that calls upon people to separate out parts of themselves as entities with particular characteristics strikes me as not only obfuscatory and reductive when it comes to understanding ourselves as complicated wholes, but, at its worst, it is also dissociative. It is a clever tactic to distance ourselves from the fullness of what it is to be human in all its messy negative and positive glory in order to create a tidier, cleaner package for ourselves to look at. You might think you feel better, but this creates more delusion, not less.

Despite my initial impression, though, I did take care to be mindful of gossip over the course of that week, and I found the vast amount of it, both from others and myself,

  • 14
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
KMayer 5 pts

Okay, if that load of horse crap didn't drive you to drink, you're well on your way to long-lasting sobriety. I have one other comment: mean girls invented that program to continue to suck the lifeblood out of unsuspecting normal girls. You, my friend, sound like we could be buds. Come over some time and we'll gossip about the founders of that BS course.

Kathykate (p/t copywriter, f/t mom)

Diary of a Return-to-Work Mom ( http://www.returntoworkmom.com/ )

Rita Arens 7 pts

I do truly believe in taking a firm look at oneself and thinking hard about environment. I have had to cut several toxic people out of my life because I found every time I came home, I felt horrible for having spent time with them. And life is too short, right?

It's hard for me to do that sort of thing, because I am a pleaser who spends most of my life worrying about what people think of me -- which is such an occupational hazard for a writer. It is pretty hard to be a writer and not piss someone off. It's hard to own your words without coming off judgmental. It's hard to just be in the world sometimes if you are worried about what people think.

I do think there is something to not saying things you wouldn't say to someone's face and choosing not to seek out gossip. I actually had to be very aware about the amount of celebrity gossip I was allowing into my life. I ended up breaking my habit of loading up on tabloids when I'd had a hard day -- I used to read them to make me feel better about myself, and isn't that pathetic? But it doesn't make you feel better.

I'm all for snark, but I prefer it to be maybe more wit than snark -- a poke at society or human nature rather than a stab at someone in particular. I know full well I could not hold up to the glare of reality television or celebrity -- I am extremely flawed. But as my father always used to say, "Rita, I love you despite your many and obvious flaws."

It is an easier row to hoe when you start reframing how you see the world and looking for someone's best features, inside and out, instead of their flaws. I am trying to teach myself how to see the good in every situation instead of my native pessimistic view, because that anxiety has done nothing for me in 36 years, and I don't want to spend the next 36 feeling that way.

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak. She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

Rita Arens 7 pts

Amy, thanks for stopping by and leaving your comment. As a writer, I know what it's like to have your words not incite the desired response. :)

Classy response.

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak. She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

emilycsims 5 pts

Such a great idea in theory, but it's sad that it was so clouded by pitiful advertising.

You should report them to their email service provider for spamming!

Get Travelated ( http://www.travelated.com )and Get Going!

thebitchinwife 5 pts

I say embrace the mean girl within and make fun of this program. I don't like truly nasty women, but some healthy cattiness makes the world go round.

Amy @theBitchinWife http://bitchinwivesclub.com

kgirl 5 pts

PLUR, baby, PLUR. How's that for '90s flashback?

Karen authors the blog, The Kids Are Alright ( http://kidsarealrightto.blogspot.com/ )

bukkweat 5 pts

Schmutzie, one thing I appreciate about you is your insight. You think about things in ways that I never would and it is one of my favorite things about you.

I would not have made it through that course. The lovey-dovey "you are awesome!" stuff would just plain annoy me.

The gossip thing though - I try my best not to, but I'm going to take this as a challenge to TRY HARDER.

MBels 5 pts

I considered signing up for this course when I saw that many other people I knew had. However, I don't do well with self-help type programs. Perhaps my Critical Bitch is too entrenched. Perhaps I'm too tired to grow. Perhaps I just am who I am. I'm glad I took a pass on this.

Marilyn @ A Lot of Loves ( http://www.blogher.com/www.alotofloves.com )

awkwardlysocial 5 pts

When I read this sentence - "when it comes to understanding ourselves as complicated wholes"
I read, "complicated whores." Which made me laugh.

Great article, hopefully the creators will read and take to heart your criticisms.

ozma 5 pts

Oh, I love Outer Critical Bitch.

But what I like here is how you make it clear that there is some knowledge that Outer Critical Bitch can kind of screen out because it comes in a stupid form.

I wish you could take some of what you learned and make something not stupid with it. Because this 'thinking negative' thing is really a problem for me but my Outer Critical Bitch makes it hard to take in anything contrary to it--that stuff always comes in such a saccharine package.

"Most men are within a finger's breadth of being mad."

Diogenes

successcoachamy 5 pts

Hey there...Amy Ahlers here wanting to give a shout out and let you know that I read your article and appreciate the feedback (however painful). Our intention with the 40-day Inner Mean Girl Cleanse was pure: to give women a structure and container for releasing self-sabotaging toxins. And we know many women did just that and fully embraced the cleanse. The response was really quite AMAZING (there is that horrible word again).

That said, I truly do appreciate that the overlap with the marketing for Inner Mean Girl Reform School was disruptive to that process. Originally our intent was to NOT have them overlap, but due to the upcoming holidays, we realized we needed to launch school sooner rather than later and thus, the overlap occurred. We learned a lot and would do it differently if we had to do it over again.

I thank you for your feedback and I'm grateful that you did receive some good tips/tools/ideas from the cleanse, like releasing gossip and negative media.

I appreciate that our language and "nomenclature" will not resonate for some women...and that it felt condescending to you. It is actually said from the heart and meant to be empowering--looks like we missed the mark for you.

So thank you for telling and speaking your truth. And congrats on your sobriety.

Wishing you all the best,
Amy Ahlers

JennaHatfield 9 pts

Oh, gosh. SARK. College memories.

But, no, I don't like being talked to that way either, nor do I appreciate using my time and inbox as a spam tool. So, I would have been equally annoyed.

But, yes, being aware of gossip is always a good project to make sure you're speaking the way you would want to be spoken about. I fail all too often but try to keep it in mind.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

schmutzie 5 pts

Thank you for your kind response.

And, despite my overall response to the Cleanse, I do thank you sincerely for helping me to see so much more clearly how gossip infiltrates our lives. It was a shocking and enlightening revelation that is making me a more compassionate person both with myself and with other people.

Schmutzie can be found at Schmutzie.com ( http://www.schmutzie.com ), the Canadian Weblog Awards ( http://www.canadianweblogawards.com ), and Grace in Small Things ( http://www.graceinsmallthings.com ).

sassymonkey 6 pts moderator

SARK = Holy '90s flashback.

Ok, I have more to say. I found out about the Inner Mean Girl Cleanse when I saw people posting about the no gossip challenge. I thought that was really interesting. But reading this I'm glad I didn't take the plunge and sign up for it. I don't think I could have stuck with it for the exact same reasons that your Our Critical Bitch scored the most points.

Contributing Editor Karen Ballum also blogs at Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.ca ) and Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.ca ).