Bio
Liz Rizzo lives in Los Angeles, works in entertainment, and aims to direct film & television. Dreamer since 1971, Angelino since 2002, blogger si...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

RH Reality Check blogs that Crisis Pregnancy Centers are No April Fools.

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

There are few things that make me madder than thinking about my tax dollars funding so-called "crisis pregnancy centers" (CPCs). CPCs, also known as pregnancy resource centers, are non-profit organizations established by pro-life supporters that work to persuade pregnant women to give birth rather than have an abortion (citation). They are frequently located right next to actual clinics and have misleading business names.

While a real clinic provides comprehensive medical services, and information on *all* of the various options available to pregnant women, CPCs do not provide information on abortion and often engage in deceptive practices. Vicki Saporta says in her post Targeting the Vulnerable:

Crisis Pregnancy Centers Deceive:

Many CPCs use deceptive advertising practices to fool women into thinking that they are legitimate medical clinics that provide a variety of reproductive health care services, including family planning and abortion care. In reality, most CPCs do not provide full options counseling and generally will not refer for abortion care or birth control.

These fake clinics use deceptive advertising practices such as intentionally placing advertisements under the "abortion services" heading of phone and Internet directories and choosing names that are similar to abortion clinics to confuse women about what types of services they provide. Many CPCs are connected with religious organizations, but few disclose that fact in their advertising. Additionally, CPCs often locate themselves in close proximity to legitimate reproductive health care facilities. We have heard from many patients who mistakenly visited a CPC because it was on the same street-or even next door-to the actual abortion provider where they had an appointment.

Vicki's post is part of a series of posts that appeared on RH Reality Check yesterday for April Fool's Day: Don't Be Fooled: Spreading the Truth about CPCs. All of the posts are must-reads (and there's a podcast from Amanda Marcotte), but my two favorite posts have to do with the personal experiences of college women:

Speaking Out: Manipulated By a CPC by Allyson Kirk

Georgetown's Guerilla Bathroom Campaign by Sam Demetriou

Of course, what really gets me angry is that these centers - these religion-based centers - often receive government funding in the United States. How this happens in America - a country founded on the separation of church and state - I have no comprehension. It is truly shameful and infuriating to this American.

Further, the newest trend is for these CPCs to offer ultrasound services to increase the perception, no matter how tenuous, that the CPC is a clinic, as opposed to a propaganda-pushing counseling center. I'll pull from Allyson Kirk's post linked above to give you a taste of what makes me so angry:

When I walked in the front door of the clinic, an older man sitting behind the counter welcomed me. I quickly gave my name and said that I had a two o'clock appointment. He acted like they were expecting me and asked me to have a seat in the empty waiting room while they prepared for my appointment...

She brought me into a different room and gave me a form to fill out. The form asked for basic contact information, but also asked for the personal information of my partner or spouse. The form asked about my medical history, including how many times I had been pregnant, obtained an abortion, and if I had children. As I was filling out the form, the woman began asking me questions, too. She asked why I was seeking an abortion, if I was sure that I was pregnant, and how many weeks I was into the pregnancy. She then began asking questions about my partner, such as did he know I was pregnant, did he want me to terminate the pregnancy, and why he wasn't there with me. I answered her questions, but began to feel guarded.

...I decided that this was not the kind of place I felt comfortable seeking medical care so I asked her to complete the free pregnancy test and then I would be on my way. I gave her a urine sample and she agreed to run the test, but only if I watched an educational video while the results were processing.

She goes on to describe the video.

Allyson thought she was in a medical facility, which by its nature provides protections in regards to the personal information you give. A CPC is not a medical facility and is not staffed by medical professionals, therefore, your information is not protected - and you're sitting there giving your name, address, medical information! Horrible.

And legal???

And

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Liz Rizzo 5 pts

This really spoke to me:

“Good counselling asks the client what her values are, and tries to create a plan so that she can live out those values,” says Bev Muendel-Atherstone, a chartered psychologist and family counsellor.
“But it does not try to impose; it is open-ended. Bad counselling doesn’t ask you what your beliefs are—it tries to impose its values on the client by pressuring, blaming or shaming. It’s not counselling, really; it’s coercion.”

Liz Rizzo ( http://blogher.org/blog/liz-rizzo )

I blog at Everyday Goddess ( http://everydaygoddess.typepad.com/ ).

( http://blogher.org/blog/liz-rizzo )

Liz Rizzo 5 pts

Hi Shannon,

The difference to me is that abortion is a legal medical procedure in the United States. So while certainly individuals can be against it, and protest it in all legal ways, the government has no business funding religious centers in their fight against a legal medical procedure.

I'm certainly glad to hear that you know of some CPCs that are as you describe (thank you for sharing your experiences), but I don't think that anything religious should be funded by the government.

Finally, I'm not sure I accept the phrasing "abortion counseling." Medical facilities I've been to offer counseling on all available options.  

Liz Rizzo ( http://blogher.org/blog/liz-rizzo )

I blog at Everyday Goddess ( http://everydaygoddess.typepad.com/ ).

Kuri 5 pts

It absolutely appalls me to think that these deceptive centres get taxpayer funding. I don't believe that many of them in my country are publically funded, but there was a really good expose of the their deceptive techniques in my city's independent weekly ( http://www.vueweekly.com/article.php?id=3826 ).  

- Kuri - Thought, Interrupted By Typos http://www.thoughtinterrupted.ca/

artpax 5 pts

CPCs get Federal Funds but do not cover all options.   Medical facilities such as Planned Parenthood clinics cover all options, including birthing options.  

No one, at least I don't think anyone, is talking about individual personsonalities but rather about deception in medical care which is illegal in any form.   

Build Peace ( http://buildpeace.blogspot.com )
Virtuality ( http://www.virtualknowledgegroup.com )
My Life As An Avatar ( http://www.blogher.com/http/secondana.blogspot.com )

( http://buildpeace.blogspot.com )

rocksinmydryer 5 pts

Pro-lifers feel exactly the same frustration at the thought of their tax dollars funding abortion or abortion counseling.

I think it's wrong for any organization to manipulate its patrons, particular those who are feeling vulnerable any way.  But I have to speak up and say that I've volunteered for two different CPCs.  They weren't exactly as you described--not next door to abortion clinics, and we werent offering medical care--but they were staffed with some of the most gentle, selfless, compassionate, non-judgmental people I've ever met.  Many of these workers had made it their life's work to reach out to women in crisis pregnancies--NOT out of a political agenda, but out of pure compassion. 

Shannon @ Rocks In My Dryer ( http://www.rocksinmydryer.typepad.com/ )
BlogHer Contributing Editor, Mommy and Family

alyssaroyse 5 pts

Deception is a huge problem, as they do historically "lure" women in under false pretenses. The other major issue is that they are generally religious based organizations acting out a religious directive with public funding.  And that just isn't okay.

If a church wants to set up a shop that clearly says, "Christian Church Abortion Alternative Center," that's fine and dandy. But not with public money. And not using language that makes it sound like a healthcare with all the same regulations and protections of a medical facility. This is scary stuff. 

___________
Alyssa Royse
JUST CAUSE: ( http://www.justcauseit.com ) A Web Site To Save The World

Start Her Up ( http://blog.seattlepi.nwsource.com/startherup/ ): A blog for Women Entrepreneu

DanaFiles 5 pts

This is interesting.  If these organizations are being deceptive with their motives, then I can see why so many people would be angry.  I clicked through some of the links, to try the find the names of these clinics -- to do some research as to what services they are offering.  I'm curious to know how they go about this. 

I don't think there's anything wrong with pregnancy counselling, even if they are sponsored by church organizations.  However, deception is not the right way to go about this.