On a Listserv that I subscribe to a member discussed the lack of musical artists who were publicly discussing the upcoming election. A debate ensued about whether people were actually interested in what their favorite artist had to say. After all, does their opinion really matter?
I couldn’t help but think that perhaps artists were afraid of getting Dixie-Chicked – the music industry is on a rapid decline and based on the bevy of summer festivals – apparently there was an over saturation of musical festivals this year that forced organizers to lower ticket prices – musical artists are having to shuck n’ jive a bit more just to make a buck. Musicians cannot afford to annoy their fans, so perhaps they are trying to avoid controversy? Plus, artists / politicians like Bono are getting ridiculed for their passion for politics and humanitarian efforts. People want their artists to ‘shut up and sing.’
However, it is undeniable that the younger generation not only looks up to their favorite musical artists as role models, they also value their opinion which is why there was such a backlash after the recent joke by MTV Award host Russell Brand after he derided the Jonas Brothers for wearing purity rings, symbolizing their abstinence from sex until marriage. People were outraged – well, mostly middle aged fathers who probably manipulated their pubescent, nubile daughters into ‘saving themselves’ – so much that within the next couple of days after the awards show, the brouhaha was a national news item.
Despite the bevy of artists that performed at the Democratic and Republican National Conventions, there has been a bit of a lag this election year. However, some musicians / rock legends, mostly those whose spotlight has dimmed a bit, such as Ted Nugent, Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen and Guns n’ Roses / Velvet Revolver’s Slash, have officially supported the candidates.
Surprisingly, some metal hans have also gotten involved. Decibel Magazine had a recent post on T-shirts supporting Obama but because the design was a clear rip-off of artwork originally designed for black punk legends Bad Brains, they suggested that people donate money to the campaign and skip the shirt. Disturbed's David Drainman has also supported Obama. the most popular and prominent band, the recently re-grouped Rage Against the Machine held a concert at a DNC Protest in Denver, the same week as the Convention.
Instead, musical artists have decided to throw fundraising concerts and parties instead. Earlier in the year, Bruce Springsteen and Billy Joel threw a concert, as well as Fall Out Boy’s Pete Wentz. In the last month I have been getting a few notices via email about fundraiser's for Barak Obama. One, which happened in early September, I considered maxing out my credit card to travel to NYC to check out. Living Color, Earl Greyhound and one of my favorite bands of all time The Family Stand put on a fundraiser in Brooklyn. The wonderful Brown Girls Burlesque rocked the crowd at the Women Rock the Vote 11 in August and The Roots’ Questlove hosted a show in September, also in NYC. Last night, a bevy of Jazz greats came out for the Jazz for Obama concert.
On October 13th, The Grateful Dead will play at Penn State’s Bryce Jordan Center, with The Allman Brothers. Why haven’t I mentioned John McCain? Because he accepted public funds for his campaign and because of the restrictions that accompany that decision, he can no longer raise public finds. I assume that if he was still able to raise funds, many of the acts would probably fall on the Country side of things..........
Comments
I think there's the a great
I think there's the a great potential and risk when people begin to identify presidential candidates with rock bands. It's transmits a subliminal message that teh candiate is somehow like the rock stars... I'd rather voters inform themselves about the positions the candidates hold.
Interesting that you identify McCain with country music. Thank you for proving my point.
Rock Bands and Political Meetings
Sorry - I think that such as in Germany and in Oregon - this rockband craze to get the younger "voters" on board for a free concert with food or drinks to PROP up the attendance reporting to the Main Stream Media is unacceptable.
If you are going to give a concert such as Elton John did for Hillary Clinton as a fundraiser event - different story - but to do it all for publicity sake is disgusting - and of course the media jumps all over it expressing how many loving voters are there for their man.
Rock the vote
I am very happy to see artist encourage the youth to vote.
I just wish it were a little more educational when it comes to issues and fair too.
Seems to me most artist have a hard time explaining why they support a candidate, most recently you have artist tearing the other candidate down rather than building up the candidate that they support .
What in the heck is wrong
What is wrong with people who look to Famous musicians and Hollywood elite to guide their important political decisions ? It is not like the majority of these Stars are going to be up for A Nobel prize anytime soon ! I mean , P Diddy , and Ludacris are telling people how to vote and people are freaking listening !!! Don't get me wrong , they are incredibly talented , musically , but if I have a serious health problem , I am not going to call up my Hair dresser to get a diagnosis - nor will I base my political decisions on what some rock star thinks !!!
Rock for What?
I question how many go to these rock concerts to hear Bo or to hear the band, I'm pretty sure its to hear the band.
But thisleads me to another point, if Bo cared so much about the US economy, and we know he has an in with these rock bands both home and abroad. Why didn't he pull together a few concerts and publically inform the people of the US what was happening, educate them, give them a chance to have a say on the bailout. People would have shown up for the concert and would have gotten educated at the same time. Instead he chose to sit on his duff and correspond by telephone. lol guess he's practicing for that 3 am call. Sad truth is he's doing a dress rehearsal with your jobs, lives and money.
Rock Stars
I believe that all youths want to identify themselves to a Rock star. Unfortunately, some people never grow up. It's hard for me to understand how people can still identify themselves to a rock group or otherwise.
Movie stars and rock stars are known liberals that just "need" attention. Yes, many have talent,but many are seeking approvement from an ever-loving audience. It's said that BHO has to identify with bands to gain popularity. How many people would be at his debates or campaign rallies without all the hype about a band? Geez
Sorry, I'm a bit confused
Who is BO and BHO?
Trish from Canada writes:
But this leads me to another point, if Bo cared so much about the US economy, and we know he has an in with these rock bands both home and abroad. Why didn't he pull together a few concerts and publically inform the people of the US what was happening, educate them, give them a chance to have a say on the bailout. People would have shown up for the concert and would have gotten educated at the same time. Instead he chose to sit on his duff and correspond by telephone. lol guess he's practicing for that 3 am call. Sad truth is he's doing a dress rehearsal with your jobs, lives and money.
How do you know that he has an 'in' with musicians? And if he did, so what? What do you say to the musicians that played at the RNC? Many of the concerts I listed happened before the most major economy fallout that happened just over a week ago. Plus, did you ever think that perhaps that he couldn't be in several places at the same time? Just askin'.
I think that people, especially the younger generation does look up to musical artists and while they might not agree with everything they say or do, they do have an audience that does pay attention. If musicians want to throw a party to support a candidate and I assume volunteer their time to raise money, what is the offence? I think some are seeing a great conspiracy theory here from the Obama Camp where there isn't one. If you don't support the man and are not going to vote for him, fine, but it seems like people are trying to find anyway possible to find holes in his campagin.
Contributing Editor - Race, Ethnicity & Culture
Writing is Fighting: www.lainad.typepad.com
In this case I think it's
In this case I think it's giving an unfair slant. Anyone who is against Obama is intimidated, called a racist, maybe gets their tires slashed. So the performers who happened to favor Obama's opponent would be afraid to speak publically. So it may look like all the musicians are for Obama, just because the others are afraid to speak out.
Editor
My position is that it is a shame that our Nation's youth take their lead from musicians AT ALL - not simply dependant upon whom the musician supports . Should the Entertainment Community really attempt to position them sselves as the moral athority in this Country ?
Are we , as a Nation ,so lacking in educated and politically astute persons that a young person's only exposure to the political experience is via MTV or BET or VH1 ?? That is disgraceful .
Look at the character and the life experience of those who would guide you . It is inappropriate to lure the young people of this Country into making an ill informed decision based on a concert - regardless of your party affiliation .
We should be encouraging them to research and educate themselves in this process - to never follow blindly , and to make an INFORMED vote based on the results of their in depth discovery .
People loved Castro , they followed him , he held concerts , he was the face of 'change' in Cuba . If more people had researched his 'plan'. Maybe Cuba would be a different place today . Don't believe the hype .
Music has always been a venue for political
expression
Four years ago I made a pilgrimage to one of the Vote for Change concerts, which were held in critical swing states. It was a phenomenal experience--Springsteen, R.E.M. and Tracey Chapman played movingly and powerfully at the one I attended, and the crowd had revival energy. It didn't affect the election, but it did charge up the hopeful dems in the audience.
One suggested correction to your article from the fangirl in me. Springsteen's limelight can NEVER dim. It will burn brightly forever.
Deb
www.debontherocks.com
blog
www.3smartgirlz.com
consulting
Your are right, Deb
Springsteen's light will never be dimmed! In fact, one of my favourite metal bands, Mastodon recently professed their love for Springsteen. So I apologize!
Fsteele, I understand that you are entitled to your opinion, but In my opinion it's comments like, Anyone who is against Obama is intimidated, called a racist, maybe gets their tires slashed. So the performers who happened to favor Obama's opponent would be afraid to speak publically Which is why some look sideways at people who denounce Obama.
If you don't like his politics, fine. But there always seem to be these common insinuations against Obama and his supporters, especially in the blogosphere -insinuations that are commonly used against black folks of being 'oversenstitive' (i.e. defending and / or calling out prejudice and bigotry against themselves, which apparently is a No-No) and prone to violence - in your case, vandalism that make people wary. Plus, do you watch Fox News? Them folks aren't afraid to critisize Obama. I could say that everyone who is supporting Sarah Palin resent progressive thinking,pro-choice, non-religious, non-hypocritical liberal women, and feel that if a woman isn't married and does not have multiple children is a freak...but I won't go there. that would be ignorant, wouldn't it?
As for people looking up to musicians, I dunno. I certianly did as a kid and I still do today - I was in love with Judas Priest's Rob Halford and guess what? I actually interviewed him about a month ago and I still had the same admiration for him as I did when I was 11. I think it depends on a lot of factors as to what fans can get so enraptured with musical artists and how far they want to take their admiration. Some do so quite literally and some, like myself, admire the freedom and the fact that these people have been able to make a succesful living doing what millions of people would give their left arm to do.
Contributing Editor - Race, Ethnicity & Culture
Writing is Fighting: www.lainad.typepad.com