Bio
Hi, I'm Karen Ballum, but I'm better know around the web as Sassymonkey. I live in Ottawa, Ontario -- Canada's national capital. (No, I do not li...

Penguin
Bookmarks

Top Picks


The Next Always

Nora Roberts

The Weird Sisters

Eleanor Brown

The Ideal Man

Julie Garwood
 
 
 

Book Club in Your Inbox


Sign up for our email newsletter!

Reading Next!

A savvy, page-turning novel about a woman torn between her husband and the man she thought she'd marry. Stay tuned for The First Husband!

Recent Comments on Book Club

 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

The Rules of Inheritance: Grief Is Not Linear

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 21
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Relationships don't end when we say goodbye. The impact of important relationships stays with us all our lives, shaping who we are and who we will become. How do we continue when a loved one dies? How does that change who we are? These questions are the topic of Claire Bidwell Smith's memoir, The Rules of Inheritance.

angel of grief

Credit Image: tkksummers on Flickr

Framed around the five stages of grief, the story that Bidwell Smith tells is not linear. In one section she's 24. In another she's 15 and then yet another 22. At first I wanted to flip back and forth between the sections, to arrange it linearly, but I stopped myself. I'm learning to be a better reader and to take the path that the author wants me to take. While there may be stages to grief, it does not follow that we progress between them in a linear fashion. We can go back and forth between them. If grieving is not a linear process, so why should Claire's story have to be?

The Rules of Inheritance is a book about moments rather than a story -- the moments that shape us and change us. Sometimes they are beautiful moments and other times they are dark and gritty. None of us are all darkness or light, but a combination of both. In her memoir, we see a lot of the darkness in Claire's personal narrative but in her blog, we see more the lightness.

In her darkest times, there is an edge to Bidwell Smith's voice -- a rawness. There is an element in it I recognize from few other books, most notably Amanda Boyden's Pretty Little Dirty and Stephanie Kuehnart's I Wanna Be Your Joey Ramone. While Bidwell Smith has written a memoir and the other two are fiction, there are times when the writing shares a gritty, truthful edge that will resonate with readers.

The Rules of Inheritance is a book for anyone who has dealt with grief. If you've lost a parent, been in a bad relationship in your 20s or felt you've lost that person you call when something bad happens, you'll recognize a shade of yourself in Bidwell Smith's writing.

We'll be discussing Claire Bidwell Smith's powerful memoir for the next month in BlogHer Book Club. Join the conversation!

BlogHer Book Club Host Karen Ballum also blogs at Sassymonkey and Sassymonkey Reads.

  • 21
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Mothering4Money 6 pts

I think the nonlinear fashion kept the book interesting without feeling too heavy, but it does have the possiblity of making it hard to sit the book down and come back to it later knowing where you left off and/or what was currently going on.

kateri27 11 pts

It was so hard for me to not read it linearly. I know that I found myself flipping through the book to revisit parts. Not that this is a bad thing.

AlishaF 7 pts

I never even thought about the fact that Bidwell Smith's book is not linear. Thanks for pointing out the concept of reading the book the way the author has written it. It's so true, our grief is never linear. It happens in spurts here and there, and somehow we make it through. Loved Bidwell Smith's memoir! 

leiasmommy 5 pts

This book was recommend to me by my grief councilor. I still haven't started it. I really want to, but my grief is so fresh when I read I want to just get away from it all.  I am glad others are liking it though. Maybe I will pick it back up next week.

Denise 1203 pts moderator

I just started the book a couple of days ago and I will admit that I was hesitant about it, after seeing this post and the comments that came in about the non-linear storytelling.

 

But, I'm about half way through it (and would be further if life wasn't so hectic right now) and I think it's brilliant. I don't think I'd be enjoying it as much if it was told chronologically.

jwarrender 9 pts

I didn't have trouble with the non-linear story telling. I found it an interesting enhancement to the story, weaving our way through the journey. I imagine Smith found herself feeling very grown up and like a little girl, often a the same time, which came out in telling the tale.

Not_Supermom 9 pts

Life really is a series of moments, strung together to form a collection.  Grief isn't linear as life isn't linear; so often it comes around in circles, particularly for me.  Often times things I don't expect to come back up years later do, and I find myself looking at how life circles around. 

lynnbraz 8 pts

I love your description of Claire Bidwell Smith's memoir as a book about moments. Like you, when I began reading the book I wanted it to progress chronologically as a story. But I became swept up in her moments. I've lost a sister, a father and beloved friends. Grief does indeed hit in waves. I find myself moving in and out of acceptance, depression and anger even years later. The healing journey from grief is lifelong but plays out in profound moments. This book helped me realize that.

KateEschbach 5 pts

Grief is such a very hard subject for so many of us ~ so private and personal.  I appreciate how open Claire was with her experiences.  

Mile Posts 5 pts

Like some of the other women who commented I had a hard time at first understanding why it wasn't written how it happened but as the book went on - I loved it. My mind is all over the place - quickly jumping from an idea, to a memory, to a moment. The more I read it the more I loved it and the more I realized that it wouldn't have been as good of a book if she had written it linearly! I don't typically read books like this but I found myself unable to put it down - I couldn't wait to hear the rest of Claire's story!

sassymonkey 828 pts moderator

Mile Posts It really wouldn't have been as good. Life is lived linearly but I don't think most of us really reflect or remember it in a linear way.

jpcross 7 pts

I'm not one to normally read memoirs or biographies but I loved every bit of this! I will admit that at first it was a bit hard to read given that it wasn't linear but I quickly adapted to the style and finished the book quickly.

sassymonkey 828 pts moderator

jpcross I think it always take a bit to adjust to a story that isn't told in a standard way. I'm glad you were able to work with it. :)

lauralohr 5 pts

I found this book to be so honest, so raw, so inspiring, and so real.

When I first picked up the book, I was a bit confused by the format---jumping back in forth in time. As I began to discover, however, grief is *not* linear and this story is not either.

sassymonkey 828 pts moderator

lauralohr The format took a few chapters to get used to for me. But once I was there, I was there.

It was much more raw than I was expecting.

anandi 6 pts

 lauralohr

 I totally see *why* she wrote it this way, but it was really hard for me to focus.  Though I did appreciate that toward the end we saw glimpses of a happier life.

GoodGriefGuru 26 pts

As someone whose husband died almost one year ago, it is great to see some other grief resources out there. Thank you for sharing. I started a blog about grief, if any others are also looking for more resources. www.GoodGriefGuru.com I will be sure to check out Claire's blog too. Sounds like an excellent read.

sassymonkey 828 pts moderator

GoodGriefGuru I really liked it. I didn't think I would just because I've read a lot of fiction about grief lately (coincidence really, not intentionally) and I was feeling a bit burned out on grief. But it was good.

Conversation from Twitter

kellybergin
kellybergin

clairebidwell blogherbooks Mine's coming up tomorrow.

Conversation from Facebook

Angela Amman
Angela Amman

That was the amazing part of the book for me, too! (you can read about it tomorrow, wink wink) :)