Bio
I am a College Instructor at a local community college, teaching English Composition and Literature. I am a mom of two, a feminist, and a writer who...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Why My Seven-Year-Old Doesn't Make a List for Santa

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

high angle view of a girl writing letter to Santa

It's that time, again. Christmas time. It's the time of the year when other parents and kids start introducing my children to the proverbial Santa's gift list. Of course, my kids don't know what anyone is talking about, because my kids do not write out a wish list for Santa. Once or twice my son asked me about it, and I just told him that he does not need to ask Santa for gifts -- Santa is all-knowing and aware of what all kids like.

And it's not because I'm a curmudgeon or a Scrooge. I love Christmas. It is the warmest and loveliest holiday for me -- but I don't like what Christmas has come to represent. It's all about consumption, greed, and wastefulness among children. People storm through the doors of the mall and smaller chain stores with scroll-long lists of gifts to purchase for teachers, their kids and spouses, in-laws, nephews and nieces, neighborhood kids, kids of friends -- the list is endless, and no one really has such deep pockets -- at least not anyone I know. Yet, they spend their money on gift cards and toys and scented baskets, their money expenditure fading out what's really important about Christmas -- being with your family, surrounded by love and deeply felt connections.

Christmas today is all about the kids -- as it should be -- but it's all about breeding greed in them. Spending hundreds of dollars on individual children is wasteful -- take that money and put it away for college or buy them bonds for the future, especially now when none of us really knows what the future will hold. I don't see the point on spending all my money on toys that will be forgotten after a few weeks or months, only to be replaced by new toys.

Don't get me wrong, I love buying presents for others. Just not everyone and everyone's kids I know. Among those who know me, I have a reputation for being a very thoughtful shopper/gift giver. When I buy for kids or loved ones, I think carefully about what they need or what their interests are in. And I do this because when you give a gift, it should be a personal one.

I suppose this is why Christmas gift-giving has lost its appeal for me -- because it's done for the masses. When you have a long list of kids and family to shop for, you don't have time to make each gift personal -- so they get what's on sale or what is age appropriate -- or what really kills me -- a gift card. There's nothing personal or thoughtful about that. I don't believe that kids should be given money, but that's just me.

Which brings me to Santa's list of "Gimme, Gimme." I don't have my kids ask Santa for gifts. I don't want them to ask for gifts. Period. I don't want them to grow up feeling entitled. Not even when their aunts call them from New York to ask what they want for their birthdays or from Kris Kringle. I never ask kids what they want. I listen to their conversations, I keep up to date with what kids their age are into, and when I need to shop for them, I shop for each individual child in mind. I'm old school. Kids get what they get, and they should be thankful they are getting what they are getting. There are kids out there that get nothing. And they should be aware of these realities. They should feel the glow of the advantages their lives are wrapped in. In this way, the gifts they receive will have more value to them.

I don't use Santa's name to get my kids to behave; I use God's influence for that. But they do know that Santa comes to our house Christmas Eve and delivers one or two presents for each of them -- because he is kindly and thoughtful. And my children know that what they do want for Christmas, they may or may not get from Santa, but it's not polite to ask him for anything. Therefore, Santa does not receive any letters from our house, the way that he never received letters from me when I was little. And because I didn't ask

  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
ModaMama 5 pts

I'm Jewish so I can't be outraged by the commercialization of the holiday and its gift giving but I can say thoughtful giving is a big deal around our home for holidays or birthdays or the just because gifts that seem to pop up.

I am in a constant battle between the grandparents who want to give give give and the need to explain that the kids don't want more stuff they want more of their loved ones, stuff to our kids has a single day appeal. If my kids need a gift, I like it to be something I can make them, they see the effort built into their gift (even the ubiquitous un-fun clothing gift) and are proud that "my mom made this!" If I can't make it, I like to at least be able to identify the person that did and not "Inspector 6" off the assembly line.

Funny story: we haven't got a TV and only at the age of 4 did my child see a commercial for a toy marketed to her. She didn't understand the cues the advertisers were pushing at her and I had to explain it was a toy. She was puzzled and said it looked like something we didn't need. Thank goodness.

www.SaraInAkko.blogspot.com ( http://www.SaraInAkko.blogspot.com )

Life in the Middle East, with craft and spice

Marina DelVecchio 5 pts

Your crew sounds amazing. Kids really are beautiful and pure -- and I love that. You struck me with the comment about making mistakes, because I make so many of them each and every day, and I hope to God my kids see only the best parts of me.

Thanks for sharing your family's story with me.

Regards,

Marina DelVecchio

Email:marinagraphy@gmail.com

Blog:http://Marinagraphy.com ( http://marinagraphy.com )

Web site:http://Marinadelvecchio.com ( http://www.marinadelvecchio.com/ )

FB:

Momofacrew 5 pts

My sons decided on their own one year to start writing 'letters to Santa'. I assumed this would mean a list, but didn't offer an opinion one way or another, figuring that I would roll with the letters as a learning opportunity, etc, when I saw them, if need be.
My oldest started his letter by asking how Santa and Mrs. Claus were doing and hoping they were in good health. He then proceeded to talk about a friend of his in poor health who could use some 'Christmas cheer'. He wrapped it up with saying he was not writing to ask for a gift, he just wanted to say hi, tell Santa about his friend, and hope that the North Pole had a good holiday. He was 6 and I was in tears. He helped his younger brother to craft a similar note, though shorter given his age and attention span.
Every year since, my boys have written these letters without prompting, sometimes with drawings or handmade crafts included.
The 'educational' experience was mine...kids are sponges, they see life how it is presented to them and for all of my mistakes as a parent, they must be absorbing some good things.
Kuddos to you for showing your children what Christmas is really all about...I would venture a guess that they see this in your day-to-day life, not just at Christmas, but sometimes the holidays are just the right time to exemplify positive morals and values! ...life is about the experiences, not the 'stuff'!

Marina DelVecchio 5 pts

Ditto, Sprogblogger! My sister-in-law just called asking what my son wants for Christmas, and I ignored her call. They all know how I am. He's a seven-year-old boy -- what do they all want? I feel that she should know -- after all, I know what her daughters are into...I can't change the way that I think, you know?

Thank you for adding a comment and for reading. Happy Holidays.

Regards,

Marina DelVecchio

Email:marinagraphy@gmail.com

Blog:http://Marinagraphy.com ( http://marinagraphy.com )

Web site:http://Marinadelvecchio.com ( http://www.marinadelvecchio.com/ )

FB:

Marina DelVecchio 5 pts

Jenna, the lack of greed among your children is nice to hear about. I think a lot of it has to do with the type of conversations people have with their kids. They're such sponges for information and so willing to please, it's incredible. Enjoy the holidays with your loved ones. And thank you for adding to the conversation.

Regards,

Marina DelVecchio

Email:marinagraphy@gmail.com

Blog:http://Marinagraphy.com ( http://marinagraphy.com )

Web site:http://Marinadelvecchio.com ( http://www.marinadelvecchio.com/ )

FB:

Marina DelVecchio 5 pts

I like the thoughtful list idea.

I think it helps to let kids know the real reason we celebrate Christmas, which is very often lost with all the gift-giving hoopla.

Thank you for getting in on the discussion and sharing your family rituals.

Regards,

Marina DelVecchio

Email:marinagraphy@gmail.com

Blog:http://Marinagraphy.com ( http://marinagraphy.com )

Web site:http://Marinadelvecchio.com ( http://www.marinadelvecchio.com/ )

FB:

Marina DelVecchio 5 pts

Elizabeth, probably because he's six and what the others have becomes very obvious. Schools are microcosms in which the little people play "look what I have -- you don;t have it?" My neighbors son used to come over our house to show off whatever his parents gave him for Christmas or his birthday -- it was a lot of pressure because our son doesn't even have a wii or DS or any of that crap.

Thank you for reading and commenting.

Regards,

Marina DelVecchio

Email:marinagraphy@gmail.com

Blog:http://Marinagraphy.com ( http://marinagraphy.com )

Web site:http://Marinadelvecchio.com ( http://www.marinadelvecchio.com/ )

FB:

Marina DelVecchio 5 pts

Thanks, Heather. I'm getting desensitized as well -- the commercialization of this holiday is very bothersome to me as well. It all becomes about dishing out money.

Thanks for taking the time to comment.

Regards,

Marina DelVecchio

Email:marinagraphy@gmail.com

Blog:http://Marinagraphy.com ( http://marinagraphy.com )

Web site:http://Marinadelvecchio.com ( http://www.marinadelvecchio.com/ )

FB:

sprogblogger 5 pts

This is something that I battle with my husband's family over. I come from a thoughtful gift-giving tradition, where the recipient is as grateful that you took the time to find something that they'd love as they are that they now HAVE that something. My husband's family is of the 'tell me what you want & I'll go buy it' persuasion & it drives me nuts!

http://www.sprogblogger.com

JennaHatfield 9 pts

I appreciate how you handle it. I think it's a great way to approach it.

And, of course, it works differently for all families.

I was caught off guard by the total lack of greed my own kids showed this year when they wrote their letters. My youngest son (3) asked for 2 things which total under 40 dollars. My older son (5) asked for one thing which came in under 20. (He added puzzles when sitting on Santa's lap. I can do puzzles!) I think next year I will help the lack of greed along by reminding them that we ask Santa for one or two things, not an outrageously long list. They get more than enough between parents and grandparents and the whole shebang of our large family, so limiting gifts seems to be a good idea.

That said, our friend group switched to only buying a gift for one friend (Secret Santa style without the secret) which made it much easier for me to pick out a meaningful, personal gift. We also removed the kids doing an exchange and are instead giving the "kids" a gift card to their family's favorite restaurant. As none of us eat out very often due to budgets and liking to cook at home for various reasons, a trip to our favorite restaurant is something moms, dads and kids all appreciate!

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

lisanoel03 5 pts

we have tried to teach our boys to create thoughtful lists. it helps us know what to get them and ideas for grandparents. but we've taught them that cray lists, are greedy and there for would get them on the naughty list. of course this is also tempered with our religious beliefs about the real reason for the season.

texasebeth 6 pts

My son is almost 6 with an early Jan. birthday. We are battling the Gimme's over here although I should be thankful it didn't happen previous years. Why it has popped up suddenly I'm not sure.

We have had many conversations over the years about thankfulness and gifts. I try to talk about it all year long, especially every time there is a birthday party or holiday. Charlie has been "writing" thank you notes since he could hold a crayon and scribble.

It is an ongoing struggle in today's society but one I think is well worth it. You have summed up my thoughts perfectly!

Elizabeth

@texasebeth ( http://twitter.com/texasebeth )  and My Life, such as it is.... ( http://texasebeth.blogspot.com )

theoutcast 5 pts

You've taught me how to handle this. My son is 3 1/2 this xmas so Santa is in the picture. My thing is, I don't want to give Santa credit for giving my kid things. He's not in my house doing things for my kid. It's my rational mind that has grown cynical with the commercialism of the event.

I realize there is a magic about Santa and I don't want him deprived of that. I like how you place Santa in their lives. I'll do the same.

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.