Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Schedules: Life-saver or Crazy-maker?

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

When my four-year-old daughter was a baby, her schedule ruled our lives. She ate every two-and-a-half hours. She napped twice a day. In her crib. In our house. When the time changed, we meticulously moved her bedtime by ten minutes a day for a week before the switch. We lived by that schedule, and I don't regret it one bit. Babies thrive on schedules.

Parents do not.

Parents have to figure out how to shower, exercise, eat, clean, pay bills, see friends, attend family functions and care for other children within the structure of that baby schedule. Parents have to deal with the sighs of friends and family members when the family leaves the barely-started party at 7:39 p.m. so the kids can get to bed. Parents have to stare at each other or the television from 8 p.m. on pretty much every night for several years, housebound in the name of the almighty schedule. It's a drag.

Once my daughter dropped her nap shortly before her third birthday, I thought I might die. I relied on that naptime to get a chance to shower/exercise/eat/clean/pay bills/have sex/nap. I lived in fear of the nap leaving for months beforehand, and when I realized that yes, she really shouldn't nap anymore, because if she napped she was up until 11 p.m. rocking the house, I admit that I cried a little bit. But I quickly realized I wanted my 8:30-11 p.m. back more than I wanted my 1-2 p.m. back. And really? Having to be home from 1-2 p.m. was starting to hold us back.

She's been nap-free now for almost two years, and now I love it. I know other four-year-olds who still nap, and I can't imagine having to be back at home at a certain time on the weekends. I feel sorry for those parents even as they are feeling sorry for me. Fortunately, parenting is a job that can be done in myriad ways, and I prefer to do my parenting somewhere other than in my house. I love Chateau Travolta, especially its new library, but I feel confined if I spend more than five daylight weekend hours there. I want to be out! In the sunshine! At the park! Downtown! Anywhere! For one thing, my daughter is more easy-going when she's not bored, and she gets bored a lot faster in the house than she does poking around somewhere she hasn't seen in a while. Her toys take on new interest in Union Station than they do in her bedroom. Dropping the nap and bending the bedtime schedule has reintroduced our friends to us -- we can eat dinner past 5 p.m. now. We can stay at parties until 10 or later (if we can induce her to lay down on someone's couch and sleep). We can take her to shows (we did Annie on New Year's Eve). We can stay at the zoo as long as she wants without worrying she'll self-destruct. We can have adventures in a bigger and better way, and I really like it better this way.

I can tell the structure of her preschool helps her a lot at home, too. She gets that time is divided into sections, some for work and some for play and some for rest. She gets the zero-sum game, in that if she wants 10 books instead of five at night, she can't play in the bathtub. We do let her negotiate within these parameters, because really, what do I care if she plays in the bathtub for twenty minutes or I read her extra books? We let her negotiate within the boundaries of her schedule, and that usually makes everyone happy ... there's an illusion of control there for everyone involved.

Some parts of the schedule are non-negotiable. My husband and I have to go to work five days a week at a certain time, and she has to go to school. It's important she learn that, since she's going to be in school for, oh, at least twelve more years. Some parts are totally negotiable -- do we want to eat lunch on Saturday now, or play for a while and then eat lunch? I guess after four years, a lot of blogging, great talks with friends and family and at least 8,643 parenting books, that's my parenting philosophy:

  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Distractions 5 pts

We are the opposite as well.  We've never scheduled our lives our baby's naptimes, meals, or bedtimes.  Instead, we've taken our children everywhere and anywhere.  They never had a problem with napping on the go, eating on the go, etc.

The result of this has been wonderful.  We have always been able to take our kids anywhere without worrying about whether or not they would behave appropriately.  Having grown up visiting a variety of places, they learned early on to behave and enjoy so much of what the world has to offer. We've taken infants, toddlers, preschoolers, and early elementary children to concerts (including the symphony), live theater, museums, fancy restaurants, and just about anywhere else you can imagine without any issues at all.  In fact, their behavior often elicits complements everywhere we take them.

JoAnn ( http://www.mylivesignature.com/ ) @ HomeschoolDistractions.com

Colormepink 5 pts

When my children were little (they're almost three years apart), I never had a schedule. They were very easy babies and we went everywhere.  They would nap in a car seat, a stroller, someone's couch, whatever and I never regretted it.  When my oldest started school we had to stick to a schedule - the kids adjusted, I didn't.  When we started homeschooling almost three years later, I threw the schedule out the window again. This year we're easing into more of a schedule only because I know that my oldest (who's in 8th grade now) will need to be familiar and comfortable with strict schedules when he starts college, or if he decides he wants to try traditional highschool.  

I've never once regretted our decisions and we've been able to do so many things because of it. Just further proof that there are many different paths.  I guess that's what makes the world go 'round.

Christine
It's My World.  Welcome To It.
Blog: http://www.colormepink.com
Jewelry Blog: http://www.starbrightjewels.com/blog

gabriellek 5 pts

Awesome, funny and I loved it. Although I prefer to be spontaneous, my four children do like a schedule! Things run more smoothly if I keep them prepared for what the day may hold!

Carrie Blankenship 5 pts

...especially when their kids get older, there are three of them going to three different school!

But still, very important and I would not survive without one!

Now, if I could promise that MY personal obligations were met on the schedule everyday, it would be a perfect situation all around.  But then again, that's what we do, as parents, put our kids first, right?

Carrie at Stop Screaming I'm Driving ( http://stopscreamingimdriving.com

stanle17y 5 pts

I can completely relate... I go through the same stuff now, having a four year old and a 1.5 YO.  We are still working around his naps... having relatives roll their eyes because we have to leave for an early bedtime because we came over and missed a nap.

But it certainly pays off. My kids are good sleepers, they're well rested, and generally good kids.  They know what to expect and that makes everyone happy!

I can't wait until he's old enough to have the freedom you have with your 4YO!

I have to say it's completey worth it.  Besides, they're only this age once so it certainly doesn't last forever!  And studies show that well rested kids learn faster, have less tantrums, and have longer attention spans.  I don't see why anyone would willingly deprive their children (and themselves) of any of those things!

*****************

I guess you're not having another one then?!

MommyWizdom ( http://blog.mommywizdom.com )

Dorotheaa 5 pts

Beautifully said and everything you mention creates great habits as they are older.  Commitments obligations all of the things they will need in order to succeed in life as they become adults.

So nice to hear about parents who are willing to work hard and adjust their lives for the future of their children.

 Dorothy from grammology

grammology.com

Kathy333 5 pts

Ah yes! We've found that having a schedule but being flexible is key for our family.  We always go to bed around the same time, and we do have quiet time during the day even if we don't nap-which means reading books, coloring, or doing something else that is relaxing.  We eat dinner around the same time each night and take our bath after and read books before bed.

But being flexible is so important-things always come up, and I know that if you are not flexible it can really dampen a great day! I tried to be too rigid when my first daughter was born and then would get frustrated when something came up. As a work at home mom, too, I've learned that you have to kind of go with the flow a lot of the times. The kids don't always sleep, they get sick, people visit . . . 

Kathy

Aniza Marketing ( http://www.anizamarketing.com )

Allbusiness:Working Mothers ( http://www.allbusiness.com/specialty-businesses/wo... )

Mama Marathoner ( http://www.mamamarathoner.com )

AmberS 5 pts

We've never been strict schedule followers.  And now that I have my second child, there's just no way.  He naps on the go - in the car, in the sling, wherever.  My preschooler and I can't be cooped up at home all the time because the baby needs to nap.

Both of my kids have sort of adopted their own routine.  But I don't plan my life around it.  And they're pretty easy-going.  I think at least in part because they're used to variations in the day-to-day routine.

~ Amber

www.strocel.com ( http://www.strocel.com )

shoalswriter 5 pts

 My 24-year-old daughter is a new mom of a 9-month-old, and I've been so impressed at the way she insists on sticking to a schedule. Her consistency has contributed to Nolan's easy-going demeanor and flexible nature. I think, because he knows what to expect and when to expect it, that frees him up to embrace other new things in his life. I so wish I had been that wise when I was a young mom -- but then, my kids seem to have turned out pretty well, after all!

Cathy

cathylwood.wordpress.com

vodkamom 5 pts

Schedules are great, here at home and even more at school! The kids definitely love the "routine".  

mochadad 5 pts

Although our kids' schedules sometime interfere with our plans, we would have it no other way. We are familiar with other kids who have no schedules and their lives are chaotic and have no structure. Things are a lot more predictable in our household.

Mocha Dad

www.mochadad.com ( http://www.mochadad.com/ )