In Search of Blogging Ethics – Starting Points
by Gena Haskett

Low life scumbags have been stealing blog posts it seems like years. I remember finding one of my videos surrounded by ads for a violent movie. Thing was I think I had recorded a peace march. You think that advertiser got his money’s worth?

When I e-mailed the person asking him to take down my video he replied that since he was outside of the U.S. American laws didn’t apply to him. It was on the Internet and it was free so why should I be upset? Since he had ripped off a number of people eventually he was convinced of the error of his ways.

By the way, if you are reading this entire post inside of another blog that isn’t on BlogHer or Out On The Stoop and there are advertisements around the post you should know that it is straight up theft.  What got me started on this post was that I can’t stop thinking about J.D.’s post over at Get Rich Slowly on How Much Money Would It Take for You to Compromise Your Principles? What is fascinating to me is that there were people who honestly did not see a problem of posting without disclosure of a post being an advertorial. They would have taken the money and not blinked an eye.

When I use a term like low life scumbags it is because some foul lump of meat is ripping off posts from the blog Mother’s with Cancer and presenting it as their own work. There are other words I would like to use. 

Ethics, people! We have to have ethics or as Crosby Stills & Nash taught us, “You, who are on the road, must have a code that you can live by. And so, become yourself, because the past, is just a goodbye.” If you don’t want you visitors leave you in the dust you need to brush up on matter of ethics.

What Are Ethics?

I started out looking for a definition of ethics. There isn’t just one. It does depend on who you ask. I started with Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

The field of ethics, also called moral philosophy, involves systematizing, defending, and recommending concepts of right and wrong behavior.

I tried the dictionary approach: the philosophical study of moral values and rules. Ok so ethics is the study of morals? What are morals? Motivation based on ideas of right and wrong. I swing back over to another philosophy encyclopedia at Stanford University and they have over 601 sub-sections on every kind of ethics imaginable.

Thank goodness for the BBC. They actually have a very clear understandable seven page section on What Is Ethics? for their Religion and Ethics portal site:

Ethics is a branch of philosophy that covers a whole family of things that have a real importance in everyday life.

  • Ethics is about right and wrong
  • Ethics is about rights and duties
  • Ethics is about good and bad
  • Ethics is about what goodness itself is…

My understanding of ethics is the instructional code that is placed inside of you by your parents, culture, environment and dozens of other societal reference points that help you make good or bad decisions. As an added bonus your emotions, wants and needs play a substantial part in creating your code.

As we get older and join different communities and cultures, that code of right and wrong gets tested, altered and sometimes quietly smashed for the sake of a greater payoff/reward. However if there is core foundation of “ethics” of what is or isn’t the right thing to do then you might not be swayed so quickly to the dark side.

Ethics in Blogging Past and Present

In 2002 Rebecca Blood of Rebecca’s Pocket wrote one of the first posts on blogger ethics. Although others certainly have written about blogging ethics and have attempted to set up a blogging code of honor this was a thoughtful attempt to help bloggers do the right thing.

Later in 2003 CyberJounalists.net also tried to quantify ethical blogging behavior:

Bloggers should be honest and fair in gathering, reporting and interpreting information. Bloggers should:

• Never plagiarize.

• Identify and link to sources whenever feasible. The public is entitled to as much information as possible on sources' reliability.

• Make certain that Weblog entries, quotations, headlines, photos and all other content do not misrepresent. They should not oversimplify or highlight incidents out of context.

I am not a journalist, I am a writer and blogger. But there is some overlap in terms of being responsible, honest and transparent. The Society of Professional Journalists (SPJ) has its own Code of Ethics that I learned about in a seminar held by the SPJ in June of 2008. It was a bridge and an opportunity for journalists to share what works and what bloggers should be aware of when blogging in public:

Never plagiarize. (You really can’t say that one enough, don’t steal other people’s work.)

— Tell the story of the diversity and magnitude of the human experience boldly, even when it is unpopular to do so.

— Examine their own cultural values and avoid imposing those values on others.

— Avoid stereotyping by race, gender, age, religion, ethnicity, geography, sexual orientation, disability, physical appearance or social status.

— Support the open exchange of views, even views they find repugnant.

— Give voice to the voiceless; official and unofficial sources of information can be equally valid.

Kate Trgovac at My Name is Kate clearly states what she will do and what she expects from visitors. Kate does tell you that she is a marketer and understands the needs of both sides but that does not mean you get to run a game on her:

This is my blog.  I write about stuff that interests me.  Sometimes that includes my clients.  And sometimes that includes stuff that has been sent to me for free as a review or evaluation copy. 

I will ALWAYS disclose if I am blogging about a client.

I will ALWAYS disclose if I have received a product for free.

Some bloggers like Karen at Good Dog Owners vs. Bad Dog Laws keeps her ethics simple, she will not disrespect people, period.

So, in conclusion, I would suggest that you start thinking about what you would ethically do and would not do in regards to your blog. There is no one answer but there are things that are flat out wrong. If you have questions drop them in the comment section.

Gena Haskett is a Contributing Editor and has been known to fish logs out of her eyes at Out On The Stoop and PCC LibTech.

Comments

 

Bloggers should also Copyright

Thank you for this post.  It is good to see blog ethics talked about in open forums.  New bloggers should know that there are free resources out there to check the web for duplicate content and to provide copyright protection for blog posts. 

I have had several recipes from my blog ripped of completely -- including the stories of how I made this dish with my mother or grandmother.  It is disturbing to think that someone else would just copy my content, even when it contains a personal story, without permission or acknowledgment.  But it happens.

I perform a check at least every few weeks, searching text unique to my blogs, to find out whether content has been stolen.  Other ways to check are to use CopyScape or MyFreeCopyright.

Thanks again for your post. 

Julia at Midwest Moms

 

You Can Also Use Google Alerts To Find Your
Stolen Work

Copyright is established the moment your work is in a fixed form. Now one of the things you can do is have a notice in your blog that defines your rights status, Copyright, Copyleft or whatever.

You could make a screen shot with a time stamp and the copyright symbol to demonstrate that this is your stuff and it was created at this point in time.

Copyright registration is different. You submit your work and pay a fee to register it. I have over 500 blog posts so that is a large chunk of money to turn over to the Uncle Sam each time I write.

The slime balls do not care, they have ripped off anyone that has a pulse and some that don't. You do have rights including the DCMA pull down.

Gena - Out On The Stoop

 

Thanks, Gena.

I've occasionally included entire blog posts on political topics on a commercial message board.  It never occurred to me that it might be unethical.  I figured that the idea was to spread the poster's political message and I always acknowledged the author and the site. 

Were my actions unethical?

 

Well, There Are Ways To Share or Refer To A
Post

You have options. One thing you can do is mention that you read Janie's blog about Star Chasing and provide the direct link to her blog post. You might also what to mention why you felt that post was relevant to the discussion.

Another is just to use a brief quote with attribution to the original blogger or name of blog. Link if you can directly to the source. Brief as in no more that 10 to 15% of the total words in the post. If it is a short post I think it is better to link to it directly and explain why you think it is relevant.

Now sometimes it happens that you are referring to a news article. Some newspapers have open archives and some stories go behind a paid wall after 7 days. You can search Google News to see if another paper has the article on their web site or if another blogger mentioned the article.

The main thing is to cite your source, use attribution to the original creator and check the terms of use on the blogger's site. Some folks really don't want you to copy their content without permission. Some just want you to show link love. Most are cool with you mentioning their work, link love and why you thought it was worthy of sharing.

Gena - Out On The Stoop

 

Thanks for the info

I am new to blogging so this information is very helpful. Thanks!  

 

Coach Jenn

My Goal is to Help YOU Reach YOURS!

http://personalfitcoach.blogspot.com 

 

Thank you

 Thank you for the info, I just happened up on this post and read it I thought for fun. It never occured to me people would steal blogs, but I don't kow why it wouldn't. Over on he message boards they steal your posts all the time and represent them as theirs.

 Again, thank you for the warning.

ItsAngel

BlogHer: Starting Over

Blogger: Starting Over: Life goes on

 .http//startingover.blogspot.com

 

Loads of Good Information

That's heaps of good information and how to details. Well done.

I know with my newsletter readers that the ethical focused articles have always had a great response so I think there's more good about than bad, it's just that the bad seems to get more attention sometimes.

So it's good to see your ethical discussion here.

All the best,

Belinda

Great Earring Holders - great presents and no more messy jewelry tangles!

 

Ethics

  This is an excellent post and a very important issue.

I started with a professional blog on blogger. My second post was about the rules of play. I have learned a lot in the six months I started and I now have a new blog on hats that has a new set of issues.

I find this site on bloggers rights very helpful. It covers a lot of issues -www.eff.org/

 Please also check out my site at http://ifrsexorcist for another set of "rules". I am obliged to you for this article. I need to get back at it and revisit the rules. 

Hat Revivalist

Many Hatty Returns

http://www.manyhattyreturns.com

 

Thanks for pulling all this info together!

Hi, Gena

Wonderfully written and information post - thank you!  There are so many facets to blogger ethics; you've captured them beautifully.  And I appreciate you including a reference to my personal blogging policies and ethics.

Cheers .. Kate

MyNameIsKate.ca

 

Unethical

Ethics are sorely lacking out in cyberspace. I hope this posts helps bloggers big and small. 

The Moxie Report. Giggles. Gaffes. Girl Talk. From television producer, writer and mom Tracy Evans. http://themoxiereport.blogspot.com

 

Folks Really Don't Know Blogging Ethical
Guidelines

Getting bloggers to agree on anything is harder than herding cats. I really feel there are more good people than bad. There are more ethical people than unethical ones both on and off the Net.

You do have folks that are nothing but opportunists. There are others that might have been told by a flim flam "instructor" that you can make $$$ by doing x, y and z.

I had an acquaintance who was interested in blogging. The person wanted to know how fast a blogger could make money. I explained it doesn't work that way. There is a lot of work involved. It is not an instant money machine.

Months later this person sent me a link to the blog. It was nothing but ads and links to other get rich quick schemes. The person didn't believe me but he believed the guy who suckered him out of a $100 bucks that told the dofus this is the sure fire way to go.

Each one teach one. Keep it clean and you'll get the green.

Gena - Out On The Stoop

 

Important and Not Discussed Often Enough

Thank you for this.  As a new blogger but an avid blogger reader, I have ruminating over personal ethics when it comes to my writing and using friends and family for fodder.  It's good to also take a look at the larger ethical issues facing bloggers.

 Dede 

 

http://deedledeedee.blogspot.com 

 

It's not just blogs

I really enjoyed your blog. I am a professional photographer and I've had other photogs copy my website design and copy... word for word. I read once that stealing a poster out of a store is the same as stealing off the interent. If you wouldn't steal from a store don't steal off the internet. It's not FREE. If people would just email and ask for permission to use the material, they might find that people are agreeable to it. For example: I asked permission to use a newsletter about Paris on one of my websites. The author was happy to do it in exchange for a link back to her site.  It's just a matter of being respectful of other people's work.

www.travelingwithtricia.com  my new blog.

Tricia