I am a feminist. I have been a feminist for as long as I can remember. If there is anything that I want in this world, it is equality for all (i.e. - feminism = equality.) When I say equality, I mean that every person has the opportunity to become the best person he/she can possibly be. That gender, race, class, and the other human-erected barriers we place on people are eradicated.
For example, if a woman is qualified to be president, I do not believe that her gender should prevent that from happening.
That said, I did not vote for Hillary Rodham Clinton in my state primary. The reason I did not do so is because I did not feel she was the best qualified candidate, and I will be damned if I vote for her merely because she is a woman. In fact, voting for a person solely on her sex would be in direct violation of my belief that you should not pick someone just based on genital status alone. (Meaning: if I don't like people who say they would never vote for a woman, I sure as hell better not vote against someone because he happens to be male.) Yet, supporters of HRC seemed to believe that is exactly what I should do. Worse, as a feminist, I was told I owed it to Clinton to vote for her. This is about the most insulting message that could be sent to me.
Now people are insisting that she lost the Democratic nomination because the media is sexist. Yes, the media is very sexist. For example, every time I read an article in the newspaper or see something on TV about infertility, it is ALWAYS about women and why they waited too long to try to have a baby, or are too uptight, or ate the wrong thing for breakfast on Dec. 22, 1982 and thus it is her fault for fucking up her chances to fulfill her feminine need for biological children. Only once did I see a tiny article noting that when treating fertility problems, 40% of issues are in females, 40% are in males, and in 20% of the cases, both have issues. And only once did I see something noting that men's sperm degrades in quality over time, leading to as many birth defects and problems as older women have. That is sexist coverage.
On the other hand, Clinton ran a terrible campaign. Sometimes, she absolutely was covered unfairly by the media, such as when they commented on her cleavage, said she "cackled," or described her as resembling a spurned first wife outside of probate court. However, these incidents, as bad as they are, did not cause HRC to lose the nomination. No, HRC lost the nomination because she alienated voters like me. Voters she should have had locked up, but instead drove away with things like the campaign's offhand slurs against Obama's ethnicity, her stupid moves to pander to every group in the world so that they would like her, and her refusal to acknowledge that she was wrong when she voted for Iraq.
Sadly, her supporters are refusing to acknowledge how poorly she campaigned. They can blame the media all they want. Sometimes, commentary did inflame her mistakes. However, the media was also all over the Wright "issue" and other Obama "flubs." If HRC lost, it is absolutely not because the media "robbed her of any shot" as supporter Allida M. Black of the Eleanor Roosevelt Papers at GW University told the New York Times on Friday. It is because she refused to stand up for anything, refused to take responsibility for her campaign's errors, and refused to be above the board. It is because she could not convince me - a committed, lifelong feminist and progressive who is essentially the spitting image of a stereotypical feminist protesting for reproductive rights with short hair, unshaved legs, and no make up - that she was the best candidate. And this is why she lost. If you can't convince those who should be your core supporters that you are the best candidate, you have a serious problem.
Clinton supporters who are angry about how women are portrayed in the news should be angry. Women generally get the very short end of the stick. But Clinton's coverage is absolutely the wrong issue to go ballistic about. (And really, if we want to look at sexism in the media, let's focus our outrage for Fox's horrifying most recent slur against Michelle Obama.) Let's raise the issue of sexism, work to alleviate the problems that arose, and move on.
Like every feminist, I do very much want to see a woman in the White House soon, and not as the First Lady. Learning from the Clinton campaign mistakes will only make the next female candidate even stronger. I'm looking forward to that.
Suzanne also blogs about life at Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants and about creating positive social change at Just Cause.
Comments
Sexist media ...
... didn't cause Clinton to lose the race, but they certainly didn't help. Who will ever really be able to know how many people were swayed by subtle and not-so-subtle suggestions that she was a bitch and a nag and like certain people's ex-wives?
The bigger issue is this -- when will it stop? Now that the media doesn't have Hillary to kick around in this way, they've moved on to Michelle Obama and I am sure if there is a woman VP candidate, she will be next -- brace yourself, Kathleen Sebelius.
PunditMom, Contributing Editor, Politics & News
Also at MOMocrats, Huffington Post, DC Metro Moms
No, the media didn't help but neither
does the type of harping that I am reading. Yes, there are problems in the media. This is because we still live in a horrifically sexist society, and our media reflects that. I understand that people are disappointed, but I think instead of playing into the media's hands and coming across as bitter feminists who can't face the fact that their candidate lost (which is exactly how the "Times" article read), we need to channel our energies into concrete solutions. I love that The White House Project (the last link in the post) and other groups are training female leaders to deal with these situations. I love that Clinton's treatment is inspiring other women to be more vocal about sexism as a whole and respecting feminist accomplishments, as Ester said in the comment below. We all face sexist media and general misogyny every day in many ways. Instead of giving the media more opportunities to mock feminists and make us look bad, let's get better messengers (like Morra Aarons and you, PunditMom!) and messages out there.
Suzanne Reisman, Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants
I voted Obama
accidentally posted twice...
I voted Obama
But in every possible venue I make a point to stop and contextualize Hillary's loss. As a liberal democrat under the age of 30, I'm used to voting for the losing candidate. Call me Generation Y, whatever, I'm a skeptic. I don't believe that America votes on the issues. And that's why I don't believe that Hillary lost for being the lesser candidate, or for the mistakes in her campaign. I believe that she lost because she's a middle-aged woman. Not young, not sexy AND not male. Not a chance.
I don't blame sexism in the media. I blame sexism in our country. I'm also thrilled that the DNC establishment candidate got taken by an idealist, risk-taking, youthful, outsider candidate that I greatly admire. I'm on the winning side for a change, and that feels great. But it also reminds me to be vocal about sexism. It reminds me to actively give value to the second-wave feminists to whom I owe my egalitarian marriage and my career. It reminds me to demand that Obama stand up for the women who got him this far. Because when America spoke--I don't know about the politicians and the pundits--but my dogs said, "Hillary isn't sexy. She isn't desirable. In fact, she's totally lame. I'm going for the cool one." And by that, we meant the guy.
Sexism in society is exactly the problem
My friend and I (both of whom voted for Obama) were just talking about this yesterday. She said that as the campaign wore on, she was horrified at how much sexism it revealed. Everything from nasty media remarks to jerks showing up and demanding that Clinton iron their shirts. My hope is that this campaign gives the next viable female candidates the tools that they need to fight back the insidious forms of sexism that are out there. And I love that it reminds us to be vocal about sexism and honor those who blazed the trail for future women leaders. That is exactly what the best outcome can be.
Suzanne Reisman, Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants
My instincts confirmed
I'm also a dyed-in-the-wool feminist who did not vote for Clinton. Throughout the primary season, I was baffled by the charges of sexism in the media. The oft-repeated "Iron my shirt" comment was made by a bystander, for example, not the press. I'm a media junky and I certainly didn't see any evidence of institutionalized sexism. And as a women, the incessant whining from some Clinton supporters really embarrassed me. Talk about providing fodder ...