Should The Drinking Age Be Lowered To 18?
by Catherine Morgan

I won't presume to know better than a bunch of college and university presidents...But, I'm just not sure I believe that lowering the drinking age to 18 will reduce teen binge drinking. However, I imagine, it might take some of the responsibility off of the colleges to reduce underage drinking on their campuses.

The problem is, underage drinking isn't beginning at age 18, and lowering the drinking age isn't going to stop the 12 to 17 year olds from binge drinking. If anything, it will just make it easier for the 12 to 17 year olds to obtain the alcohol, because now they would only have to know someone 18 willing to buy them the stuff.

And...Is there really a "sham" of not talking about drinking because it's illegal?

"Kids are going to drink whether it's legal or illegal," said Johns Hopkins President William R. Brody, who supports lowering the drinking age to 18. "We'd at least be able to have a more open dialogue with students about drinking as opposed to this sham where people don't want to talk about it because it's a violation of the law."

I don't think the problem of binge drinking is that 18 year olds are too afraid to talk about it. The problem is, that alcohol is too easily available to the underage already.

Teen Drinking, Facts, Help & Support...

Stress, depression, boredom, peer pressure, or just the classic stages of teen rebellion play a big part in teenage alcohol abuse.

Due to the ready availability of alcohol, it remains the drug of choice among teenagers. The highest rates of underage drinking occur in rural areas, where teens outside the big cities may turn to alcohol as a main source of recreation and entertainment. Urban teens, on other hand, are more apt to succumb to peer pressure in an attempt to increase their neighborhood "cool" quotient. By the time they reach college drinking age, teens face yet another round of proving themselves in all-night jello shot contests or in bouts of binge drinking.

82.8 percent of adults who drink today admit to having their first drink of alcohol before age 21, a none-too-surprising fact. However, the problem for teenagers, their teachers and parents becomes clearer when the more shocking statistic is brought to light: that the three leading causes of fatalities among teenagers — drunk driving, suicides and homicides — are all strongly connected to alcohol consumption.

If you or someone you know has a drinking problem, there is plenty of help available online, where you can stop by a friendly forum or chat to talk with parents or teens about beating the alcohol blues, find related facts, stats and research, or get expert advice and tips on avoiding the very real dangers of teen alcohol abuse...

The Cool Spot - Cool, interactive Flash presentation geared to teens with facts on alcohol, how to resist peer pressure, polls and quizzes, related links.

MADD Online - Under 21 - Clear, straightforward facts for teenage guys and girls, how alcohol affects the brain and body, common myths about alcohol, plus special sections for parents, teachers and college students, related links.

Teen Alcohol and Drug Abuse - Geared to parents, with an overview and basic facts, prevention strategies, when to see a health professional, finding the right treatment, and related links and resources from WebMD.

Teenshealth - Alcohol - Good discussion on alcohol's effects, dangers of alcohol poisoning, how to avoid drinking, where to get help for problem drinking, plus resources for coping with parents who drink, related links.

Alateen - Part of the Al-Anon program for helping teens cope with the pressures and emotions of dealing with alcoholism in parents, relatives, friends or other teens, and offering tips, advice, online newsletter, meeting information.

I was shocked to find out how easy it is for these teens to find people willing to buy them alcohol. Just to give you an example...My son (age 17) goes to parties where teens as young as 15 are drinking. But, that's not the shocking part...The parents are home! The parents are drinking with the kids! The parents are the ones providing the alcohol (after the teens pay them). Of course, my son says he's not drinking at these parties, and until recently, I actually was stupid enough to believe him.

This is the kind of kid I thought my son was...

Teen Skepchick

Personally, I do not find drinking parties to be that much fun. I have also had too many friends get themselves into trouble and they have caused me to fear for their safety. If you decide to attend one of these functions, at least go with trusted friends and make sure you have a safe way of getting home. If you can, try to see that your friends don’t do anything they might regret while drinking. But most of all, keep yourself safe.

Obviously, I don't have the answers. I can't even keep my honor student son (who actually won first prize in an essay contest for DARE back in elementary school), from being stupid enough to risk his life and his future, because he wants to drink with his friends.

I know that underage and binge drinking is a serious problem, and we need to address it. I just don't think lowering the drinking age is the place to start. What do you think?

Here is more information on underage drinking...

Teens Say School Pressure Is Main Reason For Drug Use

A new study reveals a troubling new insight into the reasons why teens use drugs.The study conducted by the Partnership for a Drug-free America shows that of 6,511 teens, 73% report that school stress and pressure is the main reason for drug use.

Second on the list was to “feel cool” (73%), which was previously ranked in the first position. Another popular reason teens said they use drugs was to “feel better about themselves”(65%).Over the past decade, studies have indicated a steady changing trend in what teens perceive as the motivations for using drugs. The “to have fun” rationales are declining, while motivations to use drugs to solve problems are increasing.

From Mir Kamin...

Telling your daughter that underage drinking is illegal is unlikely to stop her. Telling your daughter that she could drink too much and get sick will not impress her. Telling your daughter that underage drinking is dangerous will probably result in eye-rolling.

Getting the message through to your daughter that drinking may result in social embarrassment may, in fact, be the best way to encourage her not to drink while she's not yet of age.

Teen Health - Binge Drinking...

Many people don't think about the negative side of drinking. Although they think about the possibility of getting drunk, they may not give much consideration to being hung-over or throwing up.

You may know from experience that excessive drinking can lead to difficulty concentrating, memory lapses, mood changes, and other problems that affect your day-to-day life. But binge drinking carries more serious and longer-lasting risks as well.

Alcohol poisoning is the most life-threatening consequence of binge drinking. When someone drinks too much and gets alcohol poisoning, it affects the body's involuntary reflexes — including breathing and the gag reflex. If the gag reflex isn't working properly, a person can choke to death on his or her vomit.

Other signs someone may have alcohol poisoning include:

  • extreme confusion
  • inability to be awakened
  • vomiting
  • seizures
  • slow or irregular breathing
  • low body temperature
  • bluish or pale skin

If you think someone has alcohol poisoning, call 911 immediately

Also See:

iVillagers Debate Drinking Age Change

Pop Daily

StopAlcoholAbuse.gov

New Bill Would Lower Drinking Age For US Troops

Parents Get Jail time For Serving Alcohol at Teenage Son's Birthday Party

 

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
at catherine-morgan.com, The Political Voices of Women, Care2 Election

 

Comments

 

No Way!

We all know how easy it is to get alcohol. Kids can pay someone five bucks to go in the store and pick up alcohol for them. Lowering the drinking age, as you said, will just make it much easier for people who are younger to get it, because their friends will be old enough to buy.

Instead, let's open the dialogue anyway. The kids don't have to be legally doing it in order to learn the detrimental effects. I think too often we tend to ignore things we aren't comfortable with, and that becomes the  problem. Letting kids drink younger, I believe, will just lead to younger people who have issues with alcohol.

 

Kathy

Mama Marathoner

Allbusiness:Working Mothers

 

Absolutely

I've always thought that the drinking age is absurd and encourages the mystique of drinking in our society. I don't think there should be a drinking age at all, but it should ABSOLUTELY be 18 instead of 21. If you are legally an adult, it is absurd and insulting that you can't drink alcohol.

Of course, I started smoking on my 18th birthday just because it was illegal to me before, so I'm contrary like that. I quit in my 20s.

Liz Rizzo

I blog at Everyday Goddess.

 

The European Model

I asked a bunch of questions about this in my expat life. Where I lived, the drinking age was 16. Binge drinking was no more or less a problem where I lived than it was in the US. It was easy for kids to obtain alchohol, it was also not a forbidden thing.My husband told me this story about how when he was old enough to go to the bars, the parents sent the big sister along to make sure he didn't do anything stupid/crazy/toxic. Essentially, they taught him How To Drink Responsibly rather than locked the liquor cabinet. 

I do think it's absurd that you can go off to war but can't buy a beer in this country. That's just ridiculous. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Nerd's Eye View

 

I agree...

Hi Pam. I agree that kids shouldn't be able to go off to die in a war, when their not even old enough to drink. As far as I'm concerned, 18 is too young to drink, and too young to go off to war.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
at catherine-morgan.com, The Political Voices of Women, Care2 Election

 

For the record

Just about any age is too young to go off and die in a war. 80, 90, 100 even. I digress, but I just wanted to be clear. It's the absurdity of it that bugs me. 

 

Nerd's Eye View

 

I know...I totally agree.

I know what you mean Pam. 

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
at catherine-morgan.com, The Political Voices of Women, Care2 Election

 

Other consequences of drinking at 18

Sometime within the last few months, stats came out about how female drivers ages 16-20something are for the first time in a long time losing their status as the safest driving cohort.  Something to do with distractions, phones, texting etc.

I think we need to debate/discuss the impact of changing the drinking age on other societal responsibilities and environs, like driving.  Many readers probably recall that the age was rasied in the late 70s and early 80s because the federal government wouldn't fund state highway projects unless the states raised the age to 21 - this was in reaction to MADD and other realities about drinking and driving at early ages.

I agree with the reasons stated already about lowering the age and the emotional argument I know I feel for keeping it at 21 but I would urge us to think about, search out, the other places in which this change could affect us.

Jill
Writes Like She Talks

 

learn to drink responsibly at home

I think a good argument for lowering the drinking age even down to 16 or lower would be to give people a chance to learn to drink responsibly at home under parental supervision, rather than learning to drink like a frat boy at a keg party while at college.

PhD in Parenting - http://phdinparenting.wordpress.com

 

Another affirmative...

Getting alcohol is easy, teaching responsibility with alcohol is hard.

We approach the problem from the wrong direction, like saying no is sufficient to end the issue. It isn't.

We take this rather draconian approach, all or nothing, demarcation line 21 years of age. We let young adults drive at 16, and it is far easier to stop a kid from driving than it is to stop a kid from drinking. The combination is all too often lethal.

Making it worse are parents who toss parties and half the teen world shows up to get smashed. How do we deal with that? Why... go after any parent who gives a drink to their kid. All or nothing.

When our eldest was winding her way through her teen years (she is 24 now) I approached this by allowing her to have a drink in our home, subject to these rules: one, no friends would ever be allowed to drink with her in our home, no matter if the parent gave me expressed consent. Secondly, if she had a drink, she was not allowed to leave the home the rest of the night.

She learned to drink responsibly, and in point of fact rarely did drink.

We need to stop this nonsense of extremes and start finding middle ground. No one should be allowed to die in defence of our nation yet be denied a drink - there is something very perverse about that circumstance.  

 

nelle

&

llhaesa

 

Yes.

For all the reasons stated above and more.

Look at other examples from around the world... (or even us just north of the border, though I think our age should be lowered as well).

I don't think it's the government's place to worry about when our children drink.  

 

WCPN hour on the issue

It's on right now but you can hear it anytime after they post the audio (usually within an hour or so of the broadcast).

Here's the link for live streaming now.

Here's the link for later.

Jill
Writes Like She Talks

 

Possibly

I think that 21 is an absurd age because drinking is the only adult legal right that does not come at the age of 18.

Do I think that lowering the drinking age will stop binged drinking of those under the legal age? No.

I do think lowering it to 18 might have an interesting effect on college campuses, given that most people are 18 by the time they attend college and it would level the field and simplify across the board drinking rooms. At the university I attended, if you lived in the dorms and were over 21, you could only drink in your dorm room by yourself or with others who were over 21. You can see the problems if your roommate wasn't over 21 yet or how we used to joke that it encouraged the alcoholic to drink by himself/herself.

What I think would help underage and overagers too from binge drinking would be being raised to understand how to drink responsibly. Which is, by and large, the responsibility of parents. And, unfortunately, I think that's what's lacking in a lot of the US. I know my quite younger and underage brother got his drinking habits and attitudes from our alcoholic father, not his peers.

Erica

 

One thing about the "young enough to die in a
war"

I enlisted in the US Army when I was 17. While I didn't deploy at that age, I know many that have so 18 just seems like an arbitrary number.

I've also lived in Europe and I know that binge drinking was never as much of an issue as it was when I got to the USA. 

 -Kat

Tough Girl 101No one likes a Sissy! Read about the Life of a skydiving, gun toting, fast driving part time soldier and full time student living life after Divorce.

 

LOWERING THE DRINKING AGE

no the drinking age should not be lowered because then that allows more alcohol access to high school students which isnt good. plus teen pregnancy rate will go up in my opinion....